← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/49824/2024allowed

Utsav Singal v. State Of Punjab

2024-11-29Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry16 pages



   

   





  

  ! 

  !"#$ %& !$'()(%* +,,  ,

- .

- / ,,,

$#(#(%*$0 .$0)1) - 





,,, $)2%*3$*# ,

4

 5 /

,,,

$#(#(%*$0 .$0)1) - 





,,, $)2%*3$*#  +  6/ ,

- -  .

 , 



 

    

        

  ! "

    # 

$$$$$ -  .

 7

,

 / 8  (* %

&

 '()*+

   #, %- %'

(

.



/ &

, %- %' "", 

-

! 

"(* '")$) %

&            # 

 #01

 (

*22    -)(  *2+  3*+

4(5(/   201   %, !"#$3 -$'#(%*)

%9('$ -#"#(%* %(6 %) (5(- /%)3-4/(73/48(/'%3(4  *+ !! 9 /

12 2

 

     2# 2#  #  2  #57 5) (5(( #  .  : 2#!

;# 2          #      #     #   .       2 

  #%(   # <2 ;# 2  . # #2 # %5 5) (5(-! 2   !



 =2# 57 (5(- 3, '4       1 22 # #2# #  .>

 !755 %) (5(-#  =2    2  !

  !         57 (5(-    .> # 201 75' #  !

!2=2 # &2#

  # #3 4    2                        #    2#            1     #  #201

 #2 1 2  #  5- %5 (5(- 2;

2" .   5- %5 (5(-2

   #   # #             2     #         #      #       2     #      

#                   #  2   # 

-

9               # # 2



# !

! .> ! 2  "## 

      //83(4  //)  //83/4  /-53(4    8%3(4    *+  01 2,,  "#  !2+ /8/5 (5(- . #  #

2

2 ,,      !2 

,,   2 2##2    

 1     2    #              # 2  ?, 1192 @ 2##

 # ##

?, 1192 @ .  2  #"  12  A&# B5% (5(/B3, %'4, # 2 ?@#  ? # 2@  ""! #9# ?2@ ?, 11  92 @ ,     ""! #9#  #?, 1192 @



,,  2#2         "  "  ! #  9#  ?, 1192 @  # # =2 

'

1  2  #57 5) (5((   ?, 1@ 22?, 11 92 @  # . 

# = =          2    # 2    #     # #  #2

# 2 . 2,   

              #   =     2 #

,#2%(          #                2#01 # 2## #!

! . # # 2 ₹

# =# ( ' (/ %( (5((                A 2# 

2B##(8 %( (5(( =            :        !     ;# 2      #       ;##      

8

, - ?, 1192 @  "#  #2

   #2=  

 +2  2/'2  )# 2 2#  22##  .  ! ;# 22#  ?, 1192 @ 1#  2#  ## 2# !

! .> !   1   !?&# 5% (5(/3, %'4@ ,# 2 AB "" ! #9#A2B# A # 2B 5% (5(/?, 1192 @,    2               #         ""! #9# 1#  #2 ",, 2 2

,?&# @2   2    ""! #



9#

. A&# B , %'

9 #  +             #     2   # 2 !

!#  (5(-# 2  #  .> ! 01     #/5 (5(- !2 + /8  ?, 11 92 @ 2 "# 2  >  #    "# 2 # !2+ /83, (42# 2# 01  #  !

! &  #  2     #  1  2#  ,,  "#2

  # 2#  2 !2+ /8/5 (5(-3, (4 



)

 1 2" #  5- %5 (5(-() %5 (5(-



 22#  # 2  

 2  #  1 #   ! 1>

 #

    C !

!  

 &  #    !

    1  >

          

" = .   2 =

 2 #   + #  !  ;# 2# " 2 #  

"# ?, 1192 @ #  #   = #=2 "# ==2 

%5

  : 2 

=

 #    "## # , #  #2# # 2 = 2 2 "###2# >



 2# #  %%

9 # #2

 

2# !

;# 2 #  .#  ,#57 5) (5((                     #     # . #    0"# 2(5%' (5%8 

#   

  , 112  2#  # .2 #    .=2#  #%(2,2 

 #  # %(

       #    2            ;

-7)(- (5(-5- %5 (5(-



 

  

              

!"#$%&' (%  %, !"#$3 -$'#(%*)

%9('$ -#"#(%* %(6 %) (5(- /%)3-4/(73/48(/'%3(4

*+ !! 9

 

)*        +    !"#$%&'),   -  ..+ /0)/)/     1   ),   + .+1

 +2 $2 -  /0)/0)/!"#$%3'.       1),          -    +1 

      ,4      0)//  $)5)    &)/0)/ +. -  .

 2      $  2     ,4 + .   /0)/3$)5) +       .          2 $2  1 .  - .+  1),  .+3             + .  &    1   . 1+  . )  ,        +  1       1 +  .  ),  +      +    ..  - + .

+++ .  .+), .  ) 6)+) )4 .75)" $.



+++      ) ;)* +               +             + .+ +       +   .+) <)=     . + 1+    +  1 .+- ) )* /;)&&)/)

0)      +  .    1    +  +  +

  .   +-+  1 .+ 

91 . 1 +  1      +        .   >         " .4>1 ..4),   

  1 . !' /6)?

%/

0    ;

'/7-5 (5(-() %5 (5(-



)            

              +  ), .  63   1 ..  +  .), 



 +  ! '.  &)/0)/   +.     8)2))/6;6/)/0)/!"#$%'   . ),  .+.1    1   ++ +1

+2$2 !"#$%6') , +   +1  ++),  2$.-  + 1 !"#$%'  /0)/0)/+  1 +) 6)*    -.+ + + 1+&)/0)/

 . ),  .  .+ /0)/)/!"#$%3'      . .+)   .+# @"#%( *   $A      .+      89  $9 21+*++   @+. A . +    .+/&)/;)/6)= +  +  "#@"A),          .    .+ /0)/)/    

     .       +      .    8)2))/6; .

 1++

), 

.1 .. 1. +   91 .)



)+) 3)4 .75)" $.""8 $9  7  %   +  >  +) ;)5)$."1   + ++    +  1 + 9),   +  +22 !"# $%'    . !"#' ++. ) <)"9/;)&&)/) )  #1    ) 0)B.1 1 +    +                    1 ..  

 91 . /3)&&)/1     +  .

 >                " . 4>1 ..4)   

  1 .!'  .

 /6!

')?

%-

#2 " #   %'

&  #!

! 1>

  ;  #22   "# 2(5%' (5%8



 #       2 #  2    2 ##2  

?, 112 @  22#     = %8

&    # 2       #2 #57 5) (5((2 :  #  #2 +2 # 1  



%(2,   #  2  # %6

9          #     1>

!

! ;

# 2,, 

"#?, 112 @2 #    & 

2# "# #2 ## 

## "# #57 5) (5((   #



 2 # 2 2# %)

   ?, 112 @     2 A&#

B 5% (5(/,   # 2AB ""! #9#A2B # ? # 2@2  ?, 112 @, #  #  #     A2B ""! #9# 1 22       ?, 112 @, A&# B5% (5(/  2?

   ""! #9#"# 

  & 2   #  2 

 ; D  # ?, 112  @# #57 5) (5((  #  A, 1B#

?, 112 @ 0   A&# B  ?, 112 @, 2

2  2 2   =

8

2 & ,     2              =           %7

&  # ### #

 #)":

-(*;"9 "*3 (#(<"

;;"0="9      5- %5 (5(-() %5 (5(-    2 2 #" -)(3(4 *+

02#   E =E 2  # ;

(5

* 

(%

2#   ;# 

((

;



 2 

(/

 2   

-  .

 

! (7 %% (5(-  4 F GH IG+ 4 F H IG+