Tej Kumar Goyal v. State Of Punjab
!"#$"%&'&#()*+&, -
.
)/ 0 12
! "
# !
$
% $
&'
!
$!
$
! !
!
!()(*+(,-
# .
"
/
"!
!! 0$ 1 !
! 2 !
-
! ,*)) 4
5 !67
2
-(((8$
2
!
,94+7 !
2
-(((8$
2
% !" !
!
+ $
3$9:,+$+(,- ;
! !" !!$
# ! ;
!
9 <! !
= !
!
"
" !
"
>( (((8$&
. +(()
!
?
& " ,-,++(() ?
!
@
@ ! "
!
!
3
"
" 3
;
" 3
# !
"
3 !
3
3 !
! !
! ' !
! "
";
4
7 $ AB
' ! ,:()+(,( ,, ' ,:()+(,( "; +:()+(,(
!
C
! !!!
;
%
!!
(-(*+(,( )09( !! !
%
, (( (((8$ !
>( (((8$ !!
! D ()(*+(,(
E ' ()(*+(,( !
!
?
!% 4% 7? % ;
!
!% #
!
! B
" 3
!
" !!
! % #
!?% ;
!% '()(*+(,( ?% !
"
%
!
!%
"
??.
,,(-(*+(,( !
! ! >(! !
,(((
!
"
" ;
!
! "
"
"
"
"
?'3 ? ?'"
')*+(,( E0E( "
"
% ! !!>0+( % FG$+H! ! !!
! !! ! !
" !
!;
& " !!
" ! !
2 ! !;
!!"
" !
" " ! " %
!!" " " "
!
" !
; !
"
;!
" " 3 !
" !
#
" !
!;
!!
" !
!
; ! ;!
"
" " ;
!! 3 " "
&3 !
! !
" 3 > ? 3
" !
! !
!
!! !
-,94+7 !
D ,:"
! ! !!$
"
D !
9,93 32! !!D ,+ "
! ! !
! ! !
3 !!
!
!
!
! !
-,94+7 ! !
()(*+(,-
.
, : !
!
!
3 " .
3$$99,:$%$+(,-3 $
3$9:,+$+(,-;
! !"
!!$
# -
!
!
!
!
!
$ !
& !
!
!
!
" B !! 4,7 ? 4+7!!! 97!
) !!$
!
!
! "
!
! . & " !
! ? 3
!; !
!
!
33
3
B
"
"
""
;
#
! G ? < !
" ,:()+(,("
"
/ ! ,:()+(,( AD?G$-8 !
D ! " D+:)+(,('
/ "
"
0$ 5DD
,**-$*) " ! 6 * AD ?G$-83 "
+:()+(,( ,:)+(,(
?
!G ' ! !
!
!
" B
! ,:)+(,(
,:)+(,(+:)+(,( " "
& 3
!!
" ! !!
" !
!
3!
&
!
? 3
!
2 " ! "
"
!! ?
!AD?G$-8 "
"
,:()+(,( +:()+(,(
"
! ! !
/ "
"!
3 "!
!
" B
'
!" ! !
D3 ,3 +&(456"+'7'! !"#$7(8 9-
:;< ;+&=&( ,< ,( !!!
!
; !
!
" !
! >(! !
,(((8$
!
"
!
G$9
AD! A G$E ? ?'47& " "
! " !
"
!
!! ! ,, C
!
!
!!!
! ! !
-,94+7 !"
! ,+ !
!
!
!!$
!
! !
-,94+7 !
! # !
!"
!
,9
!
!
%
-*+(,(
!
/
'
!
! ?G$ , % "
!!
!
/
AD?G$,83?G$+ ? "
!!
!!$
?G$+83 !"
!
-*+(,(
!! !"
?G$9
"
" #
! ? G 3
?G$> ?
! .
%$:><$-E9>
,E C
!
!
!
!
+:)+(,( ! " " B
!!!
# !
!"
!
!
!
$ ,> C 3 "
!
8
!
!
G$, / G$+% ""
"
"
"
"
!
! "!
3!
! B
" "
< , (( (((8$ " >( (((8$ / -*+(,(
! ""
% 4G$+7
" )*+(,( !
$!! ! ""
! !
" !
!!
! ,: ! ; !!$
"
!
" !
!
!!$
!! !
I!
!
!
:>$% A !!'
!" ! & J D3 (> +6 6'1 '5""+ (?
#!5"+'
:;@<0 A"+ ,?:@@B;< ,- C !
"
!
8
!
" ""
!
" I ! !
! ? "!
!"
!!"! $ C !
"
!
!
!
D
!
/ "@
@ !
"
"3
" !
3" !
3! ! +:()+(,( ADG$-8 !
"
!
3! !
!
! !
'
!" ! & J D3
#5 == ? ?&C7" 6"+'7' +9 + &(45 7+7- &>&, **" , #:B
#$
@ !
+*(E+(,: 1 (7 6"+'7'
5 &+= (- %+7!&(D #==&!!"" $#+ 6"+&$&% !&#( #$ #==7(&!D "+!&$&% !"-&>&,**" ,#
@#$
B!
+:(++(,> ,)
!
/ 4G$ ,7% 4G$+7 "
!
!
+( ! !!!
!!
! '
!" ! & J D 3 ! !" #$ (?5+ + ?"'5 6"+'7' 6"(3 !"'5A +,7-
@;< ;+&=&( ,< '
!" ! 3 $ %!
1 = ,8&!17= + ,& '1 = ,8&!&(45;?" ?<!5+#7455&'0' 6"+'7'! !"#$7(8 9-
@;<;+&=&( ,< : ,* C !
"
!
!
!
!
!
!!!
" ! !
"
!!!
"
$!! '
! " ! & J D 3 6 1 (( ( 6"+'7' ! !"
"*+"'"(!"?9D5" ('*"%!#+#$#,&%"-
.;:<;+&=&( ,<
!
" ! G$,:
"
!!
" ! !
!;
! !;
!!" +( C !
"
!
!
!!!
!!$
! ! !
!
!! !"
+, & !
!
!
!
3 "
!
!!
! !
-,94+7 ! !
/ 4G$,7 "
"
% 4G$+7"
"
4G$973 ?4G$E7
!
++ 2 ! 7,6'",5&?=&(&'!+ !&#( .
;+,<
& J 3 "
"
! "
!! B
"
% " !
!
"
! "
"
"
!
!! " 3
"
"
"
! " +9
""; 3 $ %!
3
=+&3&(456"+'7'! !"#$7(8 9-
@;:<;+&=&( ,< 2
"; & J D3 3 $ %!
3 ! !
3 "
;
!
! ! !
!
G$,G$+ "
"
" ! B !
;! 0$ 4,7 ? = 4+7 !!! = 497 !
3 "
; "
! "= (?#$9+&9"=#("D +E 2 !
;
!!! !
" & J D3
6 8 ** 6' ! !" D #,&%" ('*"%!#+ 0#3 D73! - 5&!+ ?7+4 -
;
<;+&=&( ,<B "
" & J D3 0$ 5,)2 "
!!!!
2
"
!!!
!
!!
!
!
!!
"
!
+(
3
!6 5+(& " !! !
D
" B
"
!
!
"
! "
!!
! " "
! !
;
!
!
! !! 6 +> ! "
!
2
!; !
/ " $ ! ! !
!
3"!
? 3
,-,++(() AD ?$,, ? 3
"@
@ !
. ! "
"
2 ! ! < /
!
3 !
33
3 *E+((* 3
; B
"
" !
! ?
! G ' ! ',,>+(,(
!3
" "
" ?
! /2
4G$:7 " ! I
3 4
5 3 67
;
!
+: ' ,:)+(,( 3
; ! "
!
/ ;
!
?
!G ' !
!3
"
AD ?G$-8 ?G$-8% ! " +:)+(,( AD ?G$-83
3 ; !
!
3 !
!
; +:()+(,( " B
!!$
-*+(,(
" % G
#
?
! G
?
!
; +:,(+(,( '-*+(,( % G
"
+- !
; 3 +:()+(,( " B
!
!"
#
! +) 2 ! " 3 $ %!
3
,3 +&(45/'% '";'7*+ <"
!" ! ,:,,,***
3 " !!
!!$
!! ++,,,***K ! ! ! "; & J D3 ,3 +&(45/'% '";'7*+ < D ! 0$ 5,> !
,:,,,*** !
! " B 3
3 "
!!
!! ++,,,***
2 " ! !
!6 +* 2 6 (87(?& 56'! !";",5&?=&(&'!+ !&#(<- .BB +,0@ ;< & @ 3 !
!"
"A "!
!!
!
! "
;
!
!
"
"AD! A " ;
, !
"
"! " !
2"
"
"
;D!
; AD! A $ !!
!
!
!!
D "
;
+ >((8$"
"
!!AD! A 9(,(,*-9 "
!!" 2! ! !!" ! ! !!
!! !!
!" "
! % !! AD! A ! "
" "
" D +> (((8$
, )E (((8$ !!
D "
; 9( 2 !
!! " & @ 3
!
; D ! ! B "
; !
2 !! " B
!
!! !
"
!
!! "
" B
"
"
"
" !
" !!
"
"
!
!!"
!" A "
"
!! !
! 9, 2 ! "; 3
%!
3 =+&3&(45/'% '";'7*+ < !
;
" B
!!! !
!
! !
!! 9+
"
3 7+&(?"+&(45 6"+'7'! !"#$7(8 9-
;:<;+&=&( ,<
"
!! ""
;
"
-((8$ ;
!
!
!
" ! !
" !
"
"
4
!;!
7"
! "
!
!!
3
" ! !! B !
; 99 D
! "
" !! "!!
!
"!
9E !!$
;
-*+(,(
% "
!
!
?G$, % ! AD?G$,83AD?G$,8
"
% "
,(E+
# #
:(( "
< !
AD?G$+83?G$ +8
-*+(,( )9( "
! ,* 3 2 !
!
!
9> C !
"
!
!
! 1 5 '5""+/'
% '" ;'7*+ <
"
!
! !
:>$% A !! 9: & "
" !
& J D ! 5 $5& #5 == ?6"+'7' !
!"#$ &= %5 ,+ ?"'5-
B;<;+&=&( ,<BB-"
" & J D 5,E
!
! B !
:>%4E7 A !!
! !
"
!
! ! ! !
"
!!
! !
!
! 2 !"
! ! ! ! "
!
!
!
:9 :> A !!! D!
2!
! ! !
! !
;2
"
!
"
! !8"
!!
!
! ;
!
! ! ! !
:>%4E7 A !! "
!
!
! B ! ! !
:>%4 7 "
6 9- "; & J D3
!! !
!
!
"
!
!
AD?G$,83?G$,8
#" ; " !!
! " %
-*+(,( "
!
! %%"*! (%" (?"%#>"+D#$9+&9"=#("D 9)
! !!$
!!
!>,> )*+(,(%
!
/ ""
%
!
!
!! EE( " >,> ""
& " ! "
!
! !'
G$,:
! !
AD?G$,8< AD?G$,8
" ! )>(( ! *
>+( ?G$9
"
""
;
!
!!
"
>((
?G$> ?
"
>((
! 9* !
G$9
G$E3 ? !
"
"
"
2 ' !
"
!
! !
!! ! !
"
!
"
" ! !
!
!
! !
"
!
A ! !! " !
" !! !! !
" ; ! !
/ -*+(,(
)*+(,( !
; +:)+(,(
" & J D3 970 , 8* &6"+'7'! !"#$- ..:;<;+&=&( ,<
"
" !!
" ! !
" !! !! & J D3 !!" !B E(
?G$- ? # 4AD?G$-8,7 ""
%
4G$+7" "
!AD G$,8-"
??.
,,-*+(,(4ADG$ ,:8,7 "
ADG$,8 ADG$,:8, "
)*+(,( AD G$,8% "
! ! ADG$,8% !
!
)*+(,( ! $ "
% 3? G$,: 2 ' !
! "
"
@@ @; @
!
!
""
"
! !
!
"
!!!
E, 2 "
3 "
7 " " !!
-*+(,()*+(,( !
; 3 +:()+(,(
7
!!$
"
%
-*+(,("
"=
7 !
"!
! !
! ; !
! ! !
"
! !
!
!!$
!!
!
!!$
!!!
E+ & " # !
!"
!
!
!
! )*+(,- E9
!
!
!)*+(,-
# .
$
!B 3$$99,:$%$+(,-
"
! "
"
"
EE 2 "
3$9:,+
+(,- ! ! ;12< *+&, -
.
;
8 L 0 M L M