High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/407/2017dismissed

Sushila And ORS v. Sahid And ORS

2019-04-30Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

!"! #$%$&'

#(#)$&*$#!(&+,-*./0'$ #

#%,(%,12'0-*./0'$ #',$022$330&'% "##$%$&'(%) * ,$ 040#* *0'$* 5

6 20%%$* 78 ',$ '# //(*$&'

30(9%#(71&03- $40':

#%,#'-',$#(71&03;,0%7$$&0%%0(3$*78',$ 3$+03#$2#$%$&'0'(.$% "()08<190#%$$=(&+$&,0&/$9$&' /92$&%0'(& 040#*$*1&*$#!$/'(& 66 ',$ '#"$,(/3$%/'- >??:

#%,#'-',$ /'; ,$#$%2&*$&'%0#$',$*#(.$# .$,(/3$7$0#(&+#$+(%'#0'(& @AA@ ?6:,$#$(&0 '$##$ $##$*'0%',$

$&*(&+.$,(/3$;-4&$# 0&*',$(&%1#$#($ 970#*$&$#03&%1#0&/$920&8 (9('$*

',$

$&*(&+.$,(/3$ ,$ 0/'%&$/$%%0#8 #0*)1*(/0'(& ',$2#$%$&'022$030#$ ',0'& 55

5-"()08<190#40%'#0.$33(&+(&,(%/0#7$0#(&+#$+(%'#0'(& @ 6@"@>?

& ',$408- ,(% /0# 40% %'#1/= 78 ',$

$&*(&+ .$,(/3$ % 0 #$%13' ',$ (920/'- ,$ #$/$(.$* %$#(1% (&)1#($% 0&* %1//197$*'',$(&)1#($%*1#(&+'#$0'9$&' ?6*0'$* 5

40%#$+(%'$#$* &',$/30(92$'('(& (3$*-('40%23$0*$*',0'',$*$/$0%$*40% 8$0#% 0+$0&*40%09$*(/032#0/'('(&$#(%$0#&(&+40%/30(9$*0% - B@2$#9&',,$/30(90&'% 0(3$*'2#.$',$9&',38$0#&(&+

',$*$/$0%$*71'/&%(*$#(&+',0'',$*$/$0%$*,0*/923$'$* ?9&',%

/991&('8 $*(/03%$#.(/$0&*$%%$&'(03*#1+ C#(90#8$03', 0#$ ',$!$%%(& #90&10#8- A'138- 60' 1D9(0#09$*(/03 &%'('1'$-!,&0-',$#(71&03 /&%(*$#(&+ ,(9'7$0%=(33$*3071#$# 0%%$%%$* ',$ 9&',38 $0#&(&+ 0% 6- B@ 5 E 1'1#$ 2#%2$/'% 4$#$ 040#*$*- B',*$*1/'(& #%$3 @$D2$&%$%40%90*$0%',$*$/$0%$*40% %1#.(.$*78 1#*$2$&*$&'%0&*913'(23($# A40%0223($*(&/&%&0&/$ 4(',',$*$/(%(& ',$!12#$9$1#'(&

" +

, - ( ) * . --

,$ #(71&03040#*$*0%19

- ?- B@03&+4(',(&'$#$%'F AE2$# 0&&19,$091&'040#*$*(&/31*$* - - B@ #3%% /&%#'(19 0&* #3%% 3.$0&*0

$/'(&'',$/,(3*#$& ',$*$/$0%$*0&* A- B@ # 1&$#03$D2$&%$% ,$ #(71&03 /&%(*$#(&+ ',$ 0/'% 0&* 022#$/(0'(&+ ',$ $.(*$&/$0**1/$*,$3*',0'',$0//(*$&'40%/01%$**1$'',$#0%,0&* &$+3(+$&'*#(.(&+ ',$

$&*(&+.$,(/3$'40%,$3*',0'',$*#(.$# ',$

$&*(&+.$,(/3$40%&',3*(&+0.03(**#(.(&+3(/$&/$&',$*0'$

0//(*$&'%0#$%13'-',$(&%1#$#40%,$3*3(073$'208',$/92$&%0'(&' ',$/30(90&'%71'40%+(.$&#(+,'%'#$/.$#',$/92$&%0'(& #9',$ *#(.$#0&*4&$# ',$

$&*(&+.$,(/3$ $0#&$*/1&%$3 #',$022$330&'%0#+1$%',0'&091&',0% 7$$&040#*$* #3%% $%'0'$

5 ,$/&'$&'(&#0(%$*783$0#&$*/1&%$3 #',$022$330&'% *$%$#.$%#$)$/'(& &.($4 ',$*$/(%(& ',$!12#$9$1#'(&

& -+/0+ 1 / (&!

- -',$/30(90&'%0#$$&'('3$*' - B@1&*$#/&.$&'(&03,$0*%($ - B@ #3%% /&%#'(190&* A- B@$0/, # 1&$#03$D2$&%$% 0&* #3%% $%'0'$0&*&091&'(%'7$040#*$* #3%% 3.$0&*

$/'(&-4,$#$0%(&',$2#$%$&'/0%$0%19 - A- B@,0%03#$0*87$$& 040#*$*1&*$#.0#(1%,$0*%(&/31*(&+3%% 3.$0&*0

$/'(& ,$!12#$9$1#'(&3( & -0 4/5(&!

-. ,$3*',0'4,$#$/92$&%0'(&1&*$# &$,$0*(%)1%'0&*&',(&+,0%7$$&040#*$*(&0&',$#0&*$.$&'103

(+1#$022$0#%)1%'0&*2#2$#-('413*&'7$2#2$#'(&'$# $#$(&%1/, 040#*,$#$3$.0&'20#0(%#$2#*1/$*7$34

GC,$&4$ (&*',0'1&*$#&$,$0*-#$0%&073$091&'

,0%7$$&040#*$*0&*1&*$#0&',$#,$0*-&',(&+,0% 7$$&040#*$*',1+,('%,13*,0.$7$$&%040#*$*0&* 0'',$%09$'(9$-4$&'(/$',0'$.$&'103 (+1#$ ',$ 040#* /92$&%0'(&208073$'',$/30(90&'%022$0#%' 7$)1%'0&*#$0%&073$',$&(&%1/,$.$&'103('8-4$*&' /&%(*$#('2#2$#'(&'$# $#$(&%1/,040#*0&*(&1# 022$330'$ )1#(%*(/'(& 1&*$# #'(/3$ 56 ',$ &%'('1'(&&',$#4#*%-( 7802238(&+',$'$%'%0&* +1(*$3(&$%-4$ (&*',0'.$#033040#* /92$&%0'(&(% )1%'0&* 0(#-',$&-(&1#.($4-%1/,040#**$%$#.$%'7$ 12,$3*(&/30(90&'% 0.1#C$ (&*(''7$%(&',$ 0/'%

',(%/0%$,0.(&+'0=$&&'$ 033#$3$.0&' 0/'%0&* /(#/19%'0&/$% ',$/0%$H ,$#$(%0&',$#0%2$/' ',$90''$#,$*$/$0%$*40% 8$0#% 0+$0'',$'(9$ 0//(*$&'0&* $33(&',$0+$+#12 'A 8$0#%0.(&+*1$#$+0#*'',$*$/(%(&% ',$!12#$9$1#'(&1 / 6) *0&*$+!7 & -+/0(

8) * 10! 8 ( AE 1'1#$ 2#%2$/'% %,13* ,0.$ 7$$& 040#*$*- 4,$#$0%(&',$2#$%$&'/0%$5 E 1'1#$2#%2$/'%,0.$7$$&040#*$* ,$#$(%&%/2$ #$&,0&/$9$&'(&/92$&%0'(& ,$022$03(%*(%9(%%$*!(&/$',$022$03,0%7$$&*$/(*$*& 9$#('%('%$3 -',$I1$%'(& 3(9('0'(&(%3$ '2$& )"##$%$&'* %9'# 5

> 9= C,$',$#%2$0=(&+B#$0%&$*

$%B C,$',$##$2#'073$

$%B