← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2479/2017dismissed

Municipal Council Kharar Through Its Executive Officer v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2019-10-18Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia22 pages

  



     

  

 

   !"##$%&%'($")#*+, 

-'%$%.!/-'$%/,01!*!*..#//!'" 2& "!"#-'3!)*&#&.'4#'"&    

 ! "#$ * !*-/!,45$!"#*"1#..#//!'" *!'4##.0-6!*,#'%* -'3!)* #&.'4#'"& !'4 *2%7!&!1/,45$!"#8%"1 *!*5%'4#*%'91&2#4%7! !'41%,45$!"#& *#&.'4#'" :    %       1%&..#!/1!&)##'.*##**#4!9!%'&""1#-496#'"!'4 #$*##.!&&#4);"1#<444/%&"*%$"-49#, !9!*,1!/%%' %5%/..#!/ 

 =4!"#4  >,5%4#81%$1,"1# *%9%'!/-496#'"#$*##.!&&#4);"1#<4%5%/-49#-'%* %5%&%'01!*!*%'%5%/-%"   =4!"#4    %'!5-*"1#.*#&#'"#&.'4#'"&?##'4!'"&8#*#-.1#/4 

1#*%9%'!/-%"8!&%/#4);"1#..#//!'"*!#$/!*!"%' "1!"%"%&"1#8'#*"1#4%&.-"#4/!'44#&$*%)#4%'"1#/!%'","1!" "1#*#5#'-#*#$*4 5%//!9#01!'.-*&18%'9"1#&!%4/!'4!&

5!$-##*.#*";%&%//#9!/,'-//5%4,"1!""1#/!'4'")#%'9 $6.&%"#,-&"4%!'?"!"# 5#*'6#'"1!&'5!/%4 %"/#5#*"1# &!6#,!'4"1!"%"&!//"6#'"6!4#%'!5-*'#&&!%'91%&'-// !'45%4'!44%"%',!#$*##*#*6!'#'"'3-'$"%'"*#&"*!%'

 "1#.*%5!"##&.'4#'"&*6!/%#'!"%'9"1#&!%4/!'4*$*#!"%'9!'; $1!*9#5#*"1#&!6#8!&!/&.*!;#4*%'"1#/!%'""6!;!/&)# 6#'"%'#4"1!""1#/!%'"%%'%"&/!%'"1!4'!**!"#4"1#!$"-!/ )!$79*-'4%"&$!&#%'9*#!"4#"!%/!'4"1#<4<8#*..#//!"# -*"1!&*##**#4""1#&!6#%'!*!&=">%"&%6.-9'#4 -496#'");'"%'9"1!"@ &'        





   

         

           



    

!                    "

      "



 #   $  "

% !&"

  

' ()* 

+ ' % ! & % +  (,*  

& -

   

  #   $             

     

 

   

 "



 #  $    



  

  #                 



    



 #  $   

     



 





#  $  - % !./



0$ 1

=          "     

,2 ) 



    3   $     3  +   + - 4 $

 5&

  6   4  "

   

 7) ('



     $  & #8 +   -   

   09: :1      "    0$

-1                 

    :  5   (*'

 -   

  

% !    $  3   ;+  <  4 

(*        

   

 "

 % ! &"

             

 

 &   %     

  &  %   "



 !               & % 



 

    

  

 

   % ! $ 3 ;+  <4  (*  





   

    -8    #    



  = 

   



  

  



   



"

 &   %   

% !    $  3   ;+  <  4 



(*

 

 4  (,   

      % !    $  3  ;+  <4  (,      

 

  



    "

    4                 "    

    2     

"

 "

    5

"

 >     % !    $  3   ;+  <  (* = 

 

  

   "   





       





     " 



!             &       

 

  





 "     



     ?" 

%



   "

 6

%

  ;$     +  <  4   (*'  

   

 



          ?" 

%

" 

"



 

$  >-  &"

  

    "        =     

:    

  "   " 

$  >-  &"

         

$  >- &"

  

        "  6

 

           "

     

  

$  >- &"

 "  "

   -     4     



        "     



$  >- "

      "  

"

      ?" 

 

  

   -

  

 "      

 



  -8  > 

 "

 

              



      

        

 

 

  



" 

 

   

    

 



    

" 



   

 "

 "

    



 "  $  >- &"

   

 " 4 -   ->    -   ;  

 

 < #  $  - % !.

> /





 <



   .@

 A   

 "

   



   '  "

      

  

"

   2 =   

       

"    

    "   " 



   ' "



"

   

         $  >-

&"

    4  -                   "

   & %    

% !  $ 3 ;+  <4 

   

      4 -      "

   

     

 



        

               

    

 " 

$  >- &"

 



  

(,(  4- ->-   

 "    

 

  "    

 

  %8      " 4- 



 $  -    $

 % !  B   "



( @ ()*    

 

   *(

  ! 



 ()'2)*              &  % "



"



 

 

 $  -  $

  

 

  C2 D  "   

 

" 

"    

   

     

  



  

 5   

0& 8  1 0& 8  B 1  

      %   #   $  - % !./



    $

 5  % **      3

+              

= 

  #

"

 & #8  



 

    

 " 

   

       

:

  E   

4- 

  

     

           

"

@7,          -  -   

   



"

@7,@  

 "          

+ -  



  

 

    

      



  @7, 

 



      F  

         4  -  





 B - ->4!-  



  !   ()'2)* 





  " 4-    



     $   -  $

     "   4-   A 

  "  "

   



   '    "



 

"

   =   

        

      " 



    ' "

    A

 



   ' 

 



   

   4-     

4

$ -   $

% !B  "



( @ ()*



  "    4  +    



  

        "

 4 $

 @ &

#   $  - % !./







"              4  -     

     

 

B   ()(2 7  

!   1 $      =   #    $         &  %   

        



4-   3+           "

 3+ 4- "

  *)  

!   ( '2 *    A !   ( (2(7 

  (

 



 & +>-+

      !   & + A

   



"

  ,'@

  !   (('2(* 3+ & +"



 "



 

  







   ' 



 

 



  



               "   $  >-  &"

       A   " 4-   

"

   



  

    "   2 =   

   "





"

 

 $  >- &"

   

! -  





 " 

    - +3$ $"B  ;B  6" <

   

     

    ! 

    



            "

       

"   

     



 "

      



     

  "        

   "

          @*      #    $       -   % !./



 

  > 

'

>'@*   )'

;'2*<)* ;'2 ,< )*@  ;'2 ,<  )**  ;'2 ,<  )*,  ;,2*<      

    7    )     

   >  '7@>'

  )', ;*2 <)');*2(<      '

  

 8 >  ( >'@*   )(*;'2 ,<)(,;'2 ,<)((;'2 ,<     @  * '*>,7 

          @     

   >  '7*>'*   ),) ;'2 ,<), ;

<),(;'2 ,<')7;'2 ,<

7>))

;'2@<@7 (>),';2@<@7( >),*;@27< 

     (       (>(,  

   

    '    ,     

   >  '7'>''   ),, 

 

"     

  !   (('2(*

   



      

 "

    #  5 !  

 



   '

 , 

  

     "

 



               

 

" 



 "

  

  



         

   

      

/

+ 7$%$ "  "

    



    



 

$"$ 

  

"

 !     

G 

     "



  



 

  

   

"

/

,@77    



  

 G % !.  $     

,@77 $"+ "

@7*@@77  #  $ 

 - % !./



 G % !.

      $       



 $" + " 

 

C D6

     

"          #  $

    "E    







 

"

   

    



               



 

 

  =

     



"

           



      

  

        

"

 

         

   





 



    

8   

       



  



     

 

 772*7 

 



"

 

 

  

 "    

 

   

 

 



 "

 

    

       "

 

  #  $   



 

"

      

          8 

=       @72@*  "

  

    !   H      

   

 "  

   

 H5+ 



 



    $"$  

"

 

  %

  5 !   !  -     

         



  "

  

 ;



     

 < 

    



''@77 



           )'@77   "

  !      

         







   '8    

    & 

        #   $  - % !./



       

A 



   

              #  $  " 

 

 E =

1#-%"8!&18#5#*,$'"#&"#4'/;')#1!/*%9%'!/ ##'4!'"& &="+,81%'"1#%*A*%""#'"!"#6#'"$'"#'4#4  

2@ D  





?" 

%

    

   6

 %

  ;$   .  +  <  4   (*'  



      ?" 

 %

  4     

!   $"$ 

 

   





     &   %      



   

% !

$ 3 ;+  <4  (*

  



 



     !      $

 

 





 



         

       

   

  

2!     

   

! - 



 



  

  G $    



     

       

    5    

   !  -  38"

 -   +"

    

8  -  - -  



 









 "  

   "



  "

  









    "



    #  $      -    % !  . /

 

   

   

 

%



:  

5





   

 "

 "  

  A   



    & % >   "

    2      - 



  

#   $   

6 

   





   

 %  @     

 "   

      

    

 8   "



 

   

 G$  G6 

   

 $ 4$5&

 "



7) ('



 

>$  G& #8 +  

- 

G :G "

G$  G   8      "

  :   

5 

 & % 



 

   

  !     (*(2,7  (,2,'     

 

  

   "          

  ?" 

 

       "

  6

%

 ;$  .+  <  (*'    





   ?" 

> 

  "   

 "



   $  >-

&"



    "    =         "

  "   " $  >- &"



 $  >- &"





  " 6



  

 5

"

$"$   !    ! 

      



   ?" 

 %

 

   



   :

   

 4- 



   





  

      4- 6 

 

 

 

    B  

         



   $  -  $

 

6 

    



     "

   4$  55  &

   4  -     

 

 

#  $      &   %      

 

         

          



 3    (



  





&" +->-+   &" +"



   &" +   

 



 



 



 



  

 





  

       

      "      

  %

  4       

      "

  

   



    

  

      

  



   

 

        

 

"



        





 $"$ 

 " 

 ''@77 



 

 $  !      !     "            

 

''@77    

 



 



          

          

 

)

@77 "  6   

 

"

 

  

  

E

 "#*$6./#"%' *%!/,-%""1#..#//!'"8!&4%&6%&&#4 );"1#<4 *%!/-*",&%'$#%"$!6#""1#%'4%'9%'*#&.#$"&&-# +*!6#4);%","1!""1#%5%/-*"1!4'3-*%&4%$"%'""*;"1# -%"  '  !$$-'"    "1#  "!"-"*;  !*  -'4#*  #$"%'  >    "1#

+ 46%'%&"*!"%' 5!$-##*.#*";$",!'4$'&#B-#'"/;"1#*#/%# &-91"*);"1#..#//!'"?/!%'"%$-/4'")#9*!'"#4%&6%&&!/ "1#-%");"1# *%!/-*"8!&"1#*#!"#*-.1#/4);"1#<4<8#* ..#//!"#-*" :

1#!*9-6#'"&!45!'$#4')#1!/..#//!'"%'!&&!%/%'9"1# -496#'"&)"1"1#-*"&)#/8!*##&&#'"%!//;-*@/4,"1-91 %'"#*@$''#$"#4  8%"1  #!$1  "1#* 1#  -'4#*/;%'9  !&&#*"%'   "1# ..#//!'"C&&%4#%&"1!""1#4%&.-"#4/!'4%'B-#&"%'%&'".*5#4" 1!5#)##'4#$/!*#4!'4'"%%#4!& 5!$-##*.#*";,!'4&%"$-/4 '"  1!5#  )##'  $'&%4#*#4  !&  &-$1  -'4#*  #$"%'     "1# 46%'%&"*!"%' 5!$-##*.#*";$", : ,!'4$'&#B-#'"/;

$-/4'"1!5#)##'4##6#4"1!5#5#&"#4%'"1#-&"4%!'&!&" )#4#!/"8%"1!'4!//""#4"!';4%&./!$#4.#*&' #'$#,!$$*4%'9 ""1#..#//!'","1#5%#8"1#<4-*"&)#/8"1!""1#%5%/ -*"1!4'3-*%&4%$"%'"#'"#*"!%'"1#4%&.-"#'!$$-'""1# !*-'4#*#$"%' >"1#46%'%&"*!"%' 5!$-##*.#*";$", : 8!&6%&$'$#%5#4,&%'$#"1#/!'4%'B-#&"%'%"&#/8!&'" .*5#4"1!5#)##'4#$/!*#4!& 5!$-##*.#*";,*5#&"#4%'"1# -&"4%!'-'4#*#$"%' ,'*!';&-$14#$/!*!"%'8!&&18'" 1!5#)##''"%%#4);-)/%$!"%'%'"1#%$%!/ !D#""#*%'!';

"1#*6!''#*!&.*#&$*%)#4-'4#*#$"%' ="1#46%'%&"*!"%'

 5!$-##*.#*";$", : -*"1#*!$$*4%'9""1#..#//!'",%"

8!&!/&'".*5#4"1!""1#.*.#*";1!4)##'4#$/!*#4#5!$-##.*%* "  : :

*"1!"!"/#!&""1#.*$##4%'9&*4#$/!*!"%'8#*# .#'4%'9'"1#&!%44!"#%'"#*6&#$"%' @"1#$" >

1%&  -*"  %&  18#5#*,  '"  $'5%'$#4  8%"1  "1#  !)5#



$'"#'"%'&*!%&#4')#1!/"1#..#//!'" 1%&%&&)#$!-&# !46%""#4/;"1#*%9%'!/!//"6#'"""1#<#9!/ #%*&&&!%'91);

&"#'&%)/;$'&%4#*%'9"1#4%&.-"#4.*.#*";!& 5!$-##8!&4'# 8!;)!$7%'"1#;#!* > ,81%$18!&= ;#!*&)#*#%/%'9"1# -%");"1#..#//!'"%' ='"1#%'"#**#9'-6,#5#'"1#!//"6#'" %'!5-*<&&&!%'918!&$!'$#//#4);"1#1%##""/#6#'" 66%&&%'#*,81%$1*4#*8!&"1#'$1!//#'9#4);8!;A >>    

:,  !'4  "1#  &!%4  A*%"  #"%"%'  8!&  !//8#4  '   +=%#6*#"1!' ;#!*&.*%*"%/%'9"1#-%" 1%& )!$79*-'48-/49"-'!6)%9--&/;&-99#&""1!""1# %91-*"

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



1#'#G"$'"#'"%'"1#..#//!'"%&"1!"'$#"1#!//"6#'"

 %'!5-*<&&&!%'911!4!/*#!4;)##'$!'$#//#4%'"1#;#!*

:,  "1#  /!'4  %'  B-#&"%'  %&  .*#&-6#4  "  1!5#  5#&"#4  %'  "1# /!%'"%?,  01!*!*  5%4#  "%%$!"%'  4!"#4  =

:   GA, &%'$#"1#/!'4)#%'9*%9%'!//;1!6/!"#15%//!9#01!'.-*,

#1&%/01!*!*!-"6!"%$!//;&"45#&"#4%'"1#/!%'"%);.#*!"%' /!8 1%&$'"#'"%'!9!%'%&-'$'5%'$%'9,&%'$#!46%""#4/;"1# $!'$#//!"%'!//"6#'"8!&&-)&#B-#'"/;&#"!&%4#%'A >>

  

:  !'4  "1#*#*#,  "1#  .*%*  .&%"%'  &"4  *#&"*#4 '&#B-#'"/;,"1#*#%&'B-#&"%'"1#/!'4%'B-#&"%'1!5%'9 5#&"#4%'"1#01!*!*6#*#/;'!$$-'""#6.*!*;$!'$#//!"%' "1#*%9%'!/!//"6#'"%'!5-*"1#!//""##& + "1!&'#5#*"1#/#&&)##'$'"#'4#4')#1!/"1#..#//!'" "1!"#5#'"1#4#$%&%'"1%&-*"%'A >> 

:%&'"

1#/.-/""1##&.'4#'"&,81!*#"1# *!'&#*##&"1#*%9%'!/ !//""##& 1%&1!&)##'#G./!%'#4);$'"#'4%'9"1!""1#-496#'"%' "1#!*#&!%4A*%"#"%"%'8!&.!&&#4);*#/;%'9-.'!%5%&%' #'$1  -496#'"    "1%&  -*"  %'  C()*  )+,)  )"-  ()*

)".,)/)# )+)0!,1  ##2 * "#**1!!1" )"-#, !

3

'4 '

5-""1!"%5%&%'#'$1-496#'"%"&#/1!4)##' '#9!"#4);!<!*9#*#'$1-.*#6#-*"%'&()* )".,)/)#  )*)2670!)281"- 1"9,% 5:'

,81%$18!& "1#*#!"#*//8#4);!%'9/##'$1"1%&-*"%'A 

 +E()* )".,)/)# ;122)9 <, 10!#)#  )/)")= !&!$'&#B-#'$#81%$1,"1#1!6%/!"#1/!'4/#");-&/%6&%& "5#&"%'"1# *!6!'$1!;!",!'4"1#-&"4%!'"1#*#*#,1!&' .8#*"4#!/8%"1"1#&!6#%'!';6!''#*



 "$!''")#4%&.-"#4"1!"'!$$-'"4#$%&%'.#G-*" %'()* )".,)/)# 0122)9 )*)2673!76)4,"1#.*5%&%'& -'3!)2%//!9#66'<!'4&#9-/!"%'$", :=8-/4.*#5!%/ 5#*  "1#  46%'%&"*!"%'    5!$-##  *.#*";  $",   : ,  81%$1 "1#*#*#,8-/41!5#"1###$"#'&-*%'9"1!"/!'4&*#&#*5#4* $66'.-*.&#&?1!6%/!"#1$-/4'"5#&"%'"1#-&"4%!',!'4 8-/4!//-'4#*"1#8'#*&1%. *!6!'$1!;!" 8#5#*,!&!

$'&#B-#'$#"1#!*#&!%4-496#'","1#4#%'%"%'E1!6%/!" #1F8!&%"&#/#G"#'4#4);8!;!'!6#'46#'"""1#-'3!) 2%//!9#66'<!'4&#9-/!"%'$", >,81%$1&-91"" #G$/-4#  $#*"!%'  $!"#9*%#&    /!'4&  4#%'#4  !&  1!6%/!"  #1  %' #$"%'9;8!;"1#-'3!)6#'46#'"$" +

:, %"8!&.*5%4#4"1!"1!6%/!"#1C4#&'"%'$/-4#/!'481%$1CH D;2<     

      

 

  A2

  



  



   

 

     









4    

( B ( *E   '4-)"#4/;,  "1#  .-*.&#  )#1%'4  &-$1  !6#'46#'"  8!&  " .*"#$""1#!//"6#'"&6!4#%'*#&.#$"&-$1/!'4&,81%$1*%9%'!//; )#%'9  1!6%/!"  #1,  1!4  '#5#*"1#/#&&  )##'  !//""#4 "  4%&./!$#4 .#*&'&*"1#*8%&#"*!'&#**#4"!';.#*&');&!/#*%'!';"1#* 6!''#*)#*#"1# "14!;-/;, +:46%""#4/;,"1#!//"6#'"%'

"1#.*#&#'"$!&#%'!5-*4#$#!&#4&&!%'918!&8!;)!$7%' "1#;#!* > ,!'4!$1!//#'9#""1#2%*#&"1#

:6#'46#'"

1!4)##'4%&6%&&#4);"1#%5%&%'#'$1"1%&-*"%'$!&#

 ()* )".,)/)# ;122)9 <7*+,<)2)"0!#)#  7">)+ ,

1#%'#&$!.!)/#$'&#B-#'$#"1#*#*#,%&"1!""1#!//"6#'"%' !5-*<&4#$#!&#4&&!%'91*#6!%'&&"!"-"*%/;.*"#$"#4 '!$$-'""1#!$""1!"%"8!&6!4#/'9)#*#"1#4!"# !6#'46#'"%#  

:,#5#'!&&-6%'9"1!"%"8!&!1!6%/!"#1 '!$$-'""1%&&.#$%%$/#9%&/!"%'".*"#$"!//&-$1!//"6#'"& .*#@4!"%'9  

:,"1#*#%&'8!;"1!""1#!//"6#'"4%&.-"#4 /!'4  ); "1#  -&"4%!'  $!'  )#  !&&!%/#4  '  "1#  9*-'4  "1!"  %"  %& 1!6%/!"#1  *"1#!*#&!%4*#!&'&,"1%&-*"%'4&'3-&"%%$!"%'" %'"#*#*#8%"1"1#4#$%&%'&)"1"1#<4-*"&)#/8,"1#..#!/ %&"1#*#*#,4%&6%&&#4 3   4  ( $")#*+, 

  A1#"1#*&.#!7%'9?*#!&'#4I #&?  A1#"1#**#.*"!)/#I  #&?