High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/2870/2019disposed of

M.K.Trading Company v. Kawaljit Singh

2025-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+,($- . /0/1$&(2"34(, /////44+&%( 5!1'*' 06+7& 8&(29 /////!'4"($!( ' ) ) ) ) :;8/80; :;8/80;

:;8/80;

:;8/80; 1!'!( ) 1/'96(&0*310 !1-$<"% ! #"11/;//*+ &-$<"% ! #"1 9!44+&%( / 0;-/ 0;-/ 0;-/ 0;-/

/ 9! 44+&%( 9' #&+!$ 9! 41!'!( 44+&% &"( '!!=&(2 21( "#+!<! "44!+2&(' 9!7*$23!( "#%>*& +4''!$&( %"34+&( %'! &(' & * !$ *($!1 8!% &"( ? "# 9! !2" &@+! (' 1*3!( '% - 9!1!&(# !11!#!11!$ "'-A% B-69!1!@, 9! %"34+&( #&+!$ @, 9! 44+&%( 6' $&'3&''!$ ($ 9! %%*'!$ 6' %>*& !$/ / 9! +&3& !$ >*!' &"( 1&'&(2 #"1 %"('&$!1 &"( &( 9! 41!'!( 41"%!!$&(2'&'69! 9!1(44!+2&(' ("1$!1"#%>*& + 4''!$ &( %"34+&( %'! *($!1 8!% &"( ? "# 9! % %( @! !( !1 &(!$ *($!1 9! 41"<&'" " 8!% &"( ? "# 9! 1/// 9! &(' (%!"# 9!%"34+&(( C ?/ 9! &''*! &' (" +"(2!1 1!' &( !21/ ( AD' !+!' &*3 AD' !+!' &*3 AD' !+!' &*3 AD' !+!' &*3 &((%&+ 5'/ / (('!=1( %/ . 8 E) .

? &((%&+ 5'/ / (('!=1( %/ . 8 E) .

1&3&(+ B

1&3&(+ B- 9!"(:@+!8*41!3!"*1 * 9"1& &<!+,9!+$ 9

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

"1 %"34+&(( " 41!#!1 ( 44!+/ * 69!( & %"3!' " <&% &3:'1&29 "41!#!1(44!+- 9!&('&' !(%!"('!!=&(2 '4!%&++!<! "44!+#1"3 9!&29"*1 *($!18!% &"( ? E "# 9! 1 6"*+$ @! %"( 11, " 69 9' @!!( &( !($!$ @, 9! 1+&3!( @, &('!1 &"( "# 9! 41"<&'" " 8!% &"(? "# 9!1/// "*1 9+,- 9! 1+&3!( 9' (" 3!($!$ 8!% &"( ? " %&1%*3'%1&@! 9!<&% &3:'1&29 "41!#!1(44!+7*' '& 9' 6& 9 1!21$ " %"34+&(( "1 9! 8 !

? 44!+/( 9!" 9!19($- 9!1+&3!( 9'&('!1 !$ 9! 41"<&'" "8!% &"(? '"' "!(<&'2!'*4!1&"11&29 #"1 9!<&% &3"#("##!(%! "41!#!1(44!+"( 9!21"*($' 3!( &"(!$ 9!1!&('%"341!$ "%"34+&(( / &# 9+,- 9! &(<"+<!3!( "# 9! 8 ! &( 1!'4!% "# ( "##!(%!*($!18!% &"( ?"# 9!% &'%"('4&%*"*'@,& ' @'!(%!/ 9&' &' @!%*'! 9! %"34+&( #&+!$ *($!1 9 41"<&'&"( &' &( 9! ( *1! "# 41&< ! %"34+&( ' 4!1 8!% &"(

"# 9!1///($8!% &"( E?"# 9!% @,( !F41!''&( !( &"(&(%"14"1 !' 9!41"<&'&"('"# 9!1/// &( 9!3 !1"# 1&+"#'*%9$!!3!$"##!(%! 1&!$' %1&3&(+ "##!(%!/ 9!1!#"1!- 9! %"34+&(( - 69" &' 9! <&% &3"#$&'9"("*1"#%9!>*!3*' @!%"(' 1*!$ "@! <&% &3&( !13'"# 9!41"<&'" "8!% &"(? 1!$6& 9 9! $!#&(& &"("#<&% &3*($!18!% &"( 6"# 9!1/// FFFFFFFFF

/ ' +1!$, (" !$- 9! 41"<&'" " 8!% &"( ? "# 9! 1/// 6' &('!1 !$ &( 9! ' * ! @""= "(+, 6& 9 !##!% #1"3?

/ /

/9!"@7!% ($1!'"(#"1'*%9&('!1 &"( 3*' @!1!+&'!$($3*' @!2&<!(& '#*++!##!% "@, %"*1 /(<&!6"# 9!#"1!'&$$&'%*''&"(-6!9"+$ 9 9! <&% &3"#("##!(%!9' 9!1&29 "41!#!1(44!+*($!1 9! 41"<&'" " 8!% &"( ? "# 9! 1///- &11!'4!% &<! "# 69! 9!19!&'%"34+&(( "1(" /<!(&# 9!<&% &3"#( "##!(%! &' %"34+&(( - 9! %( ' &++ 41"%!!$ *($!1 9! 41"<&'" "8!% &"(? ($(!!$(" $<!1 "'*@'!% &"(

E"#8!% &"(? "# 9!1///H ./ 9*'-69 #+"6'#1"3 9!@"<!"@'!1< &"('&' 9 9! "(:@+!8*41!3!"*1 -# !1(!F9*' &<!!F3&( &"("# 9!' * "1, #13!6"1= ($ 41!<&"*' 7*$&%&+ 41"("*(%!3!( ' &(%+*$&(2 A++&=17*(0"$2+&5'/8 !"#01( =" 9!1'B

8 A++&=17*(0"$2+&5'/8 !"#01( =" 9!1'B

8 . . . .-%+1&#&!$ 9 9!1&29 "#44!+%"(#!11!$*4"( 9!A<&% &3B*($!1 9!41"<&'" "8!% &"(? "# 9!1///&'&($!4!($!( ($'*@' ( &<! &( ( *1!- (" %"( 1"++!$ @, 9! 41"%!$*1+ 1!2&' 1 &"( *($!1 8!% &"( ? E"# 9!1///

/ $"4 &(2 4123 &% ($ 7*' &%!"1&!( !$ 441"%9 ($ 2*&$!$@, 9!41&(%&4+! 9 41"%!$*1+1*+!3*' '!1<!($(" "@' 1*% 9!%"*1'!"#7*' &%!- 9&'"*1 $!!3'& 441"41& ! "$&1!% 9 9! 41!'!( 44!+ @! 1! !$ ' "(! * 9"1& &<!+, &(' & * !$ *($!1 9! 41"<&'" "8!% &"(? "# 9!1/// / ( <&!6 "# 9! * 9"1& &<! 41"("*(%!3!( &( D'!+!' &*3&((%&+:'%'! '*41 D'!+!' &*3&((%&+:'%'! '*41 D'!+!' &*3&((%&+:'%'! '*41 D'!+!' &*3&((%&+:'%'! '*41($ 9!<&!6 =!(@, 9&'"*1 +'"&(8 4+8&(29</8 !"#*(7@(1/ ??

$&'4"'!$"##"( / / .- 9!41!'!( 44+&% &"(&'$&'4"'!$"#6& 9 $&1!% &"( 9 9! +!1(!$ 8!''&"(' *$2! %"(%!1(!$ '9++ 1! 9! 41!'!( 44!+'(44!+#&+!$*($!1 9!41"<&'" "8!% &"(? "# 9! 1/// ($ ''&2( 9! '3! " ( 441"41& ! "*1 #"1 $&'4"'+ "( 3!1& '-&(%%"1$(%!6& 9+6/ / 9!%"(%!1(!$44!++ !"*1 '9++41"%!!$ "$!%&$! 9! 44!+!F4!$& &"*'+,-6& 9"* @!&(2&34!$!$@,(,$!+,&(#&+&(2 9! 44!+- &( <&!6 "# 9! +!2+ 4"'& &"( ("6 %+1&#&!$ @, 9! "(:@+! 4!F"*1 /

/ 9!!2&' 1,&'$&1!% !$ " 1('3& 9&'"1$!1+"(26& 9 %"4, "# 9! %"34+! ! 44!1 @""= ($ 1! *1( 9! 1&+ "*1 1!%"1$- &#1!%!&<!$- " 9!+!1(!$8!''&"('*$2!/ *+, *+, *+, *+,($ ($ ($ ($- .

- .

0; *(!! I9! 9!1'4!=&(2D1!'"(!$ )

!'D" I9! 9!11!4"1 @+! )

!'D"