High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1907/2017dismissed

Mandip Kumar & ANR v. Surinder Ram & ANR

2023-12-08Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh6 pages

!" #$%

'$ ($ % " )*$ +, ! - .& / ) ! !0 .& / )

! -0& (*&/ )

.& "

& + 2 +,

3 $ )

4/ 0* 5$&* 6)7$ 8 " +, 2 9$* 6( 8/ :$&/ ;&+, ""2 2 +, "

$ < = $2

& + 22; 2 $

2 ($ % ' 9; #$ > #$2;

#$ & .& +

& "$ & $ , $ '22* !$ #2/ .&2

:$&/ *%

22 % ?&@ #$ 4 % & 9$,/

;

%, "

- " - 0; +$

% & &, % 2 " * +0 2 &% " 7 "* &% +0 2

0 * $ - % +20 "" 2$* %" "" +$ $ & 2 ; * " & & 5$ &% $ & +20 * $% / ;&

&, & %$ & $% * &% .& $* " , / "

" -/ 0 +2 "

& $ , / & $

% , @$

0* "

.& $ +,

" - &, 2 ;

/ $ ;

2 +,

2 $

/ "

2 ""2

;& %% ; $*&

& *$ & *2 "2

22 ;& & ; +, ?&@ #$ & $/ ; ;

$ 0 .& ""2 & %%

.& 2 2 $ 22;

& ""2 $+@

/3 ?* **/

& 2 & "

4 & & = .& & "

$+% +, ;,

- 0 "2

22 +, ?&@ #$ ; & + "2 & *2 "2 .&

& $+% %2 %"2 2* +, - " 2*

*% ;

.& & "

& & *$

& "2 2 @$

2 +$

& * $+ 2 4

& + & 2*&

& " < = $2 / & ""2

; % +2

& +2

2 4 & + & *$

& *%

5$ ; 2 $" +,

& ; $22, ; +$

7 % & , +** +$ % , $ & ""2

22*

2 % 0

& 2 .&

&$/ "

2 +2& "

& $2 & %

+ %%

2 4

"" %% ** $ &

& "@$ & 2, 0 +, & "

& $+%

& %"$* +* 22*2 + 4 $"" &

& "2 2 $" A+2 ($"% $

! " $% & '

! # () ;& ; &2 " "" < = $2

& ";

"$ %+* 7

.& A+2 ($"% $ & & +

$ A @$

& $ 2%

*2,/ ""2 ; 22; ""2 0* %% ;

+2 * ; % & * 2 %

& $ @ (*2 ' !@ (*& & &* - = == ;& 2 ; &2 " " < = $2 ""2 &$2 + 22;

2 $2

2$ "

$2 & & %% + %%

2 < & & &/

;&2 $"" * & %"$* &

"" %% ** $

, % 4 & + $ 2 0

22 ; % "2 "2 ;& & 2 % 0

-/ %% 2,

/ & ""2 "2 2 & % & + *& 2, 22; +, & 2 2 $ & %% "" @$ , %

& "

+ % +* % 4 & & $+% % +, " 4 & *2 "2 - ""$

22 7 +, ?&@ #$ $

- ;

& * $ , .& " 2 0* %% "2 & *$ $

0 & *2 "2 ; ;

22 ; 7 / ;& &

& *% ; B% & "$2

22/ % & % +$

"" + ," %" "" ?

%,/

2 2;

& %

& %% $*&

" +, ;,

+ @$*

22;* ", & + + +, & A+2 ($"% $ $ &* '

* $++ .& *%

22 % 2 $%

"" @$

4 ""

& "" %% %* & 2 5$ , &;

% + 22; ;22 %$2 "2

" * B$ &/ +, & "" %%

- 0 ;

&; , 2 % % +, , ;& *& & & B$ &%/ & "" %% ;22

;22 $2

* $" 2, ;

.& "

& +@

& "" %% %2, & *$

& % & + $*&

& +2 * ;

7 - ; $22, ; +$

&$/ & "" %% & +, " < = $2 )%

2,/ & ""2 2 +, "

0 ;

& *

22 ;& & " &% ; ;*2, ," "2 4

& "2

0; +$

0 $* & " ,

%% 2,/

/ & 2 , ""2 0* %%

.& $

& ;

2 0 +

, % + "*

2 @$*% +* %* & 2 , + ; ; 22;

; + 7 , " */

% 5$ & @$

.& "$" 22;* $ & 20 %%C 2 * 5$

"" @$ $+@

"$ .& A+2 )"7 $ 2 )""2 - ,-

* #-# # # #-.

& &2 2* ;

& ", "2*/ &$2 &," & 2 "" 2, 5$ + 2+2 " 22, ;& & "" " ,

+ %" +, 4 ;

2 " 2; + +/ *$ % $

& %"$* ;&+, 2 +, "

& "2 22; $+@

5$ 2,/ & "

&+, % +* %

"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./