High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9276/2017disposed of

Ram Chander v. State Of Punjab

2023-12-15Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi21 pages

!"# $% &#'()($*

+,,

- . ,

/ /

! " #

$$$$$

/ /

, 1!2 + % & & " '&"( ) *+ *,&&( '

% '

+./

0" 123 45 /6 /78, 47, 4+

8/7*9 2 +/7 2 : & ; " &

&(' & &: ) *8;&"(

8<4

: ) *4;&& 0 " "

% " & "

123 45 /6 /78, 47, 4+ 8/7*92 +/7 2 : & ;

&(' &

&: ) *8; " % !

*! * !"# "

$$ % " &' ( ! ) *+,-.(+((,*'/ '

' ''

' ' & $ $ " 0!

!"" & 1'

'! & ** +*,2*,.3$ " '"

! )!& ! '! 4*,2*,.3! '& " !&5 " 5 " 5 ! #" 5* $

1' *

$'!" 5 ' ! *6 "& !

5 "'5! # 5 5 5& # "& '#

) *.

5 '' '! # 5!&5 " 5 '

' &'' '!#' $ '5

! *0! 5!' ! & ' ' ' ! 1 & '

& ) ' ' +,4

)' '

* ! '

(,"7 # 8 && 5

&' !* !" " 5 ' 9' " ''"7 " *:

55! & # &

' #!'5 '! 5!'

'5 " #' " "'*55!& ## ! !!&; '5' !'

"5*1 &' & ' &&" "5 # 5 ' #!

'5# #* '!! "''' '!

! !# "*% & " ! ' "' 5 <'# ! 5"

5 '

# " # 5 '

# ' 5 " #' ! " "' & '! &' "' ''$' !*9&" !'! &# '"' '! " #'! " "'*$ "

''!! # " !" &*9 "

'&! '

! 5"'' "

"*9" ! &# '"' * .-=,, &' 5'

&32/; # "# 5! "# ''

+*,2*,.3*> "

"'&= '! ..-,90

5! # " 5" 0 5 5# ?'' '! !& :)@*. 8& 5 '9 '

" $@ ' $@ # 5" $ 9$ 5 & 9$

' & -.,<1 &44,"9 & /-2'*' &2/

' &" "'

: ) *.9 ' # 5 # " & '' # ?'' '!5!& " #

5 5 5 ' 5" 5 '# " ' #

''' '!

'5 # " " ''

'!5" '"'

5 &#

"' # " # 5 " '

5" &5 ' " "' 5 <' 5

" '

5" 5 # " # & : '' : '55& ! '

9$ ' &-.,; ' & "

' 5 # & &5"5 ' !&

5"5 ' !*9# "'

" #' '*9# "' 1 & & ) '

& < ) *+,4 )' '

' 9' " '#&

0 ' !6 ;# &

0&% " 0' & ' A !$#" & "

# 6

# 6 A 6 9 B 9&C ## 6

'# " #' ''"& #

"' " (,3 (- -,$ ' '" !' & &<1 &44,;

& "* & " ! '* #" # ! '*@

" &'

& # $9$ &5" #

" !

& #

) *.5!

# * .2(,,? "'' & 9$32/ " 5! "# ''+*,2*,.3*

"'& " # # D") *2 D" " 5! "

" ' < ) * !

# "

) *, % " &' ( ! 0 ) * +,-.(+((,

9$ ' &32/ " 5!

# ''+*,2*,.3 & '&" #& '

'"' " ' < ) * ! # "

) , % " & 1 & & ) ' & < ) *+,,4)' '

' 9' " '#&

' !6 ; # &!

0& % " 0' & 0 A

$#" & "

# 6

# 6 A 6 9 B 9&C ## 5 " & & <1 &44, " ' ' !9$ ' & 32/ " 5! #

" (,3 (- .,$ ' 5 & ''"

& & < 1 & 44, 9$ 5' & 32/ " 5! # 5 # # 5 !

7 ! # * @ & ' "' 5 *

# ! '#" # ' #) *3''+*,2*,.3.4+@?" ">*

# " " : ) *5;(

* $ % A' ! "!&## 1 &'

& A ' ) ' # &<*) *+,4,)' ' &5 '

' " #

'! '# &

0 ' !

5 ; # &

0 & % * 0' & ' A !*$#"

&' # 5

# 6 A 1 5 9& ## 55 '*1 &'

'!"7

&& 5 *("" '

" #!%* ' & " '

(,"7!& " #!5 !"7'

# # & 7 '' "& %%5 *( "'

" #!"

" * 5$'''!"71 & '! " #!'

'*<'' &'# # !'

1 & &5

'# ' "7' '!' '

* ' " ' "' !&& *& '&$ & " # &5! 5 % ) - # "

"'' ""# !##" ' '! *$' $ #*$ ! # #' # ! # # " # "!''* ' A' ! ' & & * 3,,,,'

.,*,/*,.2!5& " 5'

5 # & '# & '

* " & !!'' &"' 5'

5* 1 &' & " '

' # 5 $" &"'

" ' ' ' " '

5 "! 5'

' " & '5 #"

# & 0 ?# 5"55'&

5" ! & * 9'

&" ' ! 5" "

" * '!" ' '" *$"' !#

!5 !

5 ''& #

!'* # 5 5 "'

!'>*

# " " : )

*8%;3 &( *! ( &

* 0'$ ' '

'' "'!*0! '

5; !*<5 & ! "" "

' '"7 ! '* 0! '5 &

9"" ) *022,4.-4(33-*0! ''& (,"7 &&* $" '5'

5 !

' "''#! "'

* $!#"7'!# *@'!

# '!# 5 5"5 & "' !* 9 # "7" '

'*6 '&'" #5 ' & '& "7 1 &# ' "7 * .

/, ,,, * " * .

/, ,,, 5 "" "75 "'*655

" !

5 "7 5 1 & ) ' & <*) * ,+,4 )' '

* ! ' !

' 5 '" 1 & 5 1 &'

& ' 5# *6'1 & "7*9 1 &'& " ' *(A

" #!*65& "7 " #! " ! # ' !

"7 # !&'

"7* 5 ''

!# *1 & ' & 5"' " 1 & !'&

&& # # '' "

&&" '

;

A' #!9 #&!'! 5" ' * 55 1 & ! 5 & ! 5 " '* & & "7 !

'&"7 " #!%*6 5 " '

5 '" #&

*9 1 & !'

5' ' &' '! "7'!&' 5*$ '"& ! && "&"7*6 "

1 & ' & ' ' &

""'" "5

& '#& & E (2.( 16

<*) *23 < & !

0 0 # E-,)

1 # ; # & & E.,2-( ) A0D' 6;

5 E.3:* #)&

0& & E3.0

% # D

% *0'

& 15& E4.3 ;) *.

9')&

< # &

' 15 1 & & # '

'!*9 '& '# ! ' "&'

& ##' ! !*9 ! '

'!&' '# 6

8' !&&# # ' !1 &* && "'' 9' "*$#" &

# 6

# 6'A1 6 ' ## 6 5 ' " & * ' ! ' ' '!

'*6"' '! '

"' '' &

"" ' A ' ! 5

'& 0' 0 ) '

" 6" ''" '1 & ! ' ' ! " 5 & " #

"'5 $5*.A ! '! '5 ' A '! &

& *3, ,,,'

&*3, ,,,

! '

' A 5 &'.,,/.2' ! '" " # " '

"'5 ! :

'' &

"' " # 5 1 &' ' *3, ,,,* 6" #

5 '!#

*0!

' 5' *< '

##" 5 & '&

"7*9'

! ' " '

"' +2,.3 ' ! '

# *<"' ! & " * '# #!'

'# * 6 55 '&##!

"7* 1 & ' && #!'

' # < ?

" ! 5 ! * 1 &'

&5 5 ! '*@ "'"7"

' !1 & &9' "' * !#'&

# 5 '"& 5 "'&

0 0

'#& % *0' &

0& # #5 & "

"!' 5' #'! ! !

'1 & 5 & "7 * G ' " # 5 1 &* 6 5 5'

5"*$ '# ' &"

! ! '' '# *$ &&

&5 ! 5 # * '

# " #'! ' " "'* # # #!'

'# < '5*$ & "

''5! '

">.

%" '8. 12

% 8<4:/;

( /< 7< /78, ( & ' &&( 8.

/78<" =- " " " : ;

!& " ! !

% & & ( 12 >(

( && " &'( '

& " > " 12&"( & " 8,8

3 & '

"" ( " * 2 &

8,8

(&&'"( (- '&& " " > "0 * &'

" =- " !& " "& ' 0 ' % ( "

"0 (&&& 0

% & & (&

" &'

8/ /786 & '

& 1?

( " % && "" ( & ( " " 3 " &(

% && "( & 8,8

: *! @;( *3 &

0" 12: ) *8;

8<4

: ) *4;( >

(

" 0 * " =- " !& " " 0 '

2 & "

9 "

(& &

& &(

47, 2 *

$ ! # " "' 5 " ""'

#' 5 #

5"!8' !

' *H 87< 2 *

9# ' &

& 5 : *$&!# ' &I

" '!*&&5 #

# !" # "!

' & &

" & #"# "

" # "!

' ' ' & &I

'!*$ ! ' ! ! " & ' & &*H

( &

% >A& 3

"##$#%&'&$'

(%)*

( & ) "

B* H.(* & " " "

!""#'# " !

"' !'"'' " 7

'#" 21!

.++45 &' ## ' ' &&'' # '! ''"'? & ''?*:

" '

'"'

"' ' .+/( 5

# '! '"'

" & "

## '##'

'' '5 !5 '* "

'' '

"' ' .+/(8'

8 ( ##'& & & 5 ' ' '"'' '##'' ? & ''?* 5""## " !

##'''"'? & ''?

' " & '

?& ?* 5 '?&?' "

&& ' '

" ' " "*

" !" " & *$" 5'&5 ' '7

# " '5 *$ & ' *" '!

&' 5 ' ' ' '"'5 21!

.++4' !7

* '"' 5 ' && / 1!

.++4* 9& '"' ' && !

' & 5 ' "'

" '

&& 5"' ' ! ## 21!

.++4' ''"' " "'*"' !'"' /1!

.++4 # 8 && ' !

## 2 1!

.++4* " '"'" '"' /1!

.++45 '

" !# ' " 7

#" 21!

.++45&'

##'' &&'

''"' & ''* "'

"#' " " 5*H CD& E % >A& F+ ,

("/&#0$'%0*" & * H2* ! &'"' # ##'"'! 5!5! #

'!#!& ! '"'

)&*$

'"'5 !"' '55 & " ' 5 #"* ! "'

'"' .+++'

".3,*A* '

# ' 5 ! ' "' #" .3**,,.*$" ' # ## ' ! 5! &' '"' " "' 5 #

)&*9

"' " (,3$ 5 '' !

" "

* # H H '" .,/ $'

'*" .,/!# ' & & 5 &!# ' &I &&5 #

# !" # "!

' & &

" & #"# "

" # "!

# ' !

''!" & * 8# " .,/!!5 #

5 " " "5" '

'" ! " 5 "

H H* 3*$"' 8"#

& ##5 #" " !"

"'"5 !## &' " ' ! 5 "

!'' &''"'

)&" &" "'* "###!'!# ! !" # "!

5"!&' ' " "' !'"'

)&* /*9#

"' & ' !" ### !

5! &

)&* "

& '&##5 ! "

' * " &'"' '

! 5!

" & ##* # " ' & ##5 ' ! ##5 !

*$ # '&1'& !

' '& : $

# &##'" '

" &D

"* 5 ! & ' # "'&## *6 ' "5 8 ' !

# 5 ' " '

"' .+/( '*67"

# "'& ' & ## ' ""

'&! 5##*H CD& E % >A& F' 1 2

"#$3%&'&$'

(%* & * H3*$ 6& *@ 15 .++-B(C B C.43=B.++-C./( " '" ' 8 !" & "'" "" ""'

'"''"'

# #

'&5 "

!' "'

"'"' ' !" &"'*$

## " "" &"' 5!# ' !#" '"

"' " 7" "!

5" " &''"#" '"

"5 8#"' '" !

" ""'' '& "! " "' " "" " '

& '&""'" &'

" "' ' '&!* /* # *B; *

) %C,,+B-CB C.+3=,,+ B2C*9*1*/4=B,,+C.33,2 ' "" '5#" * '5 '" !& 5 'H& H'

H& '&H* #' ' # " " &' & " ! *"# ?"' !# '

*"# 5'

' #"*

# !' 5! "

'&5" "*"" '"'' 5 "'" ""* 4*9 # " && # !'&# ' & &*6 # " # ""' & '" &"' " " "

'* & '

"'"'' ! "

' " "# ' " (,3$ " "

"*$

7 " " ' " " 5" ' '"' " "'& # '" '' #'"' " # " '"'* +*$" '"'5' '!

!# ' ! #" '"

' '

"5"## '! '! *< ! " ' ' '

* %

# # '

! * (,*65" !"

D'"

"!8 " "& '& # " " "

" " " &!'5 !"

' '" "

'&##*

&" &' " (,3$'

'&#### !

' *$5 ' ! " " ### ""

5 !

' 5 * 7!

&" &' " (,3$' ' &##7''# "'& #'&& '*H CD& E 1 >A& 45 ! "#$%&'&$'

(%)*" & * H*$

" "' !!#

# '"&8" 8 5 5 &# #&" " *

"& ' # "'''

* " ' ""' '

&" "'# *9!

" " ! " 5 '

& '"* "# " ' ""' "D"'5 ' 5

" "# ' " (,3 $* ** &!

" !

"# ! ' " #"! '" "

" " '" * " (,3 $* ** "

"'* +*& "!

' ' !

& # " @ 15 B# C

" 8 !" & " ' " "" " " " 5 "

!' ' "'

''"'# '

!" &"' 5" " " & "' ## !#

' !#" '"

'''

"' "

7" "! 5"

&''" " 5 8#"' '" !" ""'' ' "#

""'" &'5 " ' '

&!* 55 '9' J 1 * 6 & ,., B.C B C 3-( = ,., B.C " 9#8 1'& B*9*1*C.4-=B,.,C./,/* (,* & ' " "# ' " (,3$* ** " "

"' & " ' ""'&'"'

" "' & 5 # ' # # '' ! ** * F!

0,.,B-CB C33=,.,B-C "9#81'&B*9*1*C3+=B,.,C. .+,*H % 3

2 6

"777$% &'&$'

(%00)* & * H-* '#5# # 5 # # '' ! ' " &"

' &#" ' "& ## ' 7 '

" ' ' # &!## "'&

&" ' " (,3$'

'* 9 # " (,3 5

" "' ! !5 "'5& ' " *9 " 8# ' " ' " #'

" # 8! 5&' '

"* # 5# ! *$ & '

' ' "" '

! # ! ## "' & "'

&*$ ! 5 # & !# ! ' &"

'* '" "

'# " && # & ''

&' 8"''"'

& * 0

"'#" # ,'!* #&

& 5 '#'" '"'

" " "'

5# *$" "" '

5 '

&" && # ' " (,3$' '*$ & '

" " #"' ; '# & * < ! .++4B(CB C33*H CD& E % 4 2 8( 6

"#)$3%&'& $'

(%37*0 & * H.2*)' !

5" " ( '! 5 3 9# .++( ' '

" ** (,*-*.++(* $ '"' ' '" " "' #

" & " '' 5' &

&*) 5 "' 5 ' ! # " " " ' " (,3

$' '* ""' 5 &!

" "' "

!' '"''

" '"& ' !

" &"'*<5 &!

"5!# ' !'"

"' " * $ & ' ''"'5"

!* #

' " ' " " " " "'* # " &&# !'& # ' & &*" .,/ $'

'' &*

# ''"

"*9# ' & &5BC&!# ' &I BC&&5

# !" # "!

' & &I BC !' !" & ' & &* & " # "

* 5 '

?&?

! # " &

& !

# ' ! &* 9 ! !

& " # "! '

# '' (" " .,/ '*" .,+ $'

'# ' " '" ' " 7" ' #

# "

#'5#

5" # " &' 5 ! ' 5 # '

"* K *

< ! K,,4BCB C4.,=,,4BC91 /L*H K###'L 8/

( " "& 46 !

###$#%&'&$'

(%* & *

G.3* 5 ! &'"' 5 ' ! & ""' & '

" ' *$# "

&"' !"

" & ' "

5"#

" # "'>*

2 &'

12 D 8,8

& (

" 0 * &'

" =- " !& " "& '0 %

& (&

'&&(" " " ( &&

8+ 2 ( 123 45 /6 /78, 47, 4+ 8/7*92 +/72 : & ;

" &

&(' & &: )

*8;&"( 8<4

: ) *4;

&& 0 " " 0 0

/ /

#'#45#1

- H -" I 3 H & I 3