Khushi Ahuja & ORS v. Dharam Dev & ORS




   
 

! "#  $%%&'(' ) * + ,-.(-'-./

$-%0( 122%33

4%0(.( - 5%6

$-%0(  1 %(2 
  


 
 

0%(% $) (.

/

%0 76& $%0$-%

$( 0 ,8'

77 0:

00%(2 $ 0(85(-%0, .076& $%00%(2 $*; (.0

&%52

: <<<  
 

 

 


 

0$-%0% ( 0%5% %'

$-% 223'& 7$-%( 5%'(

33=%%3 :> :('

'3'

9$-% 3'(&  %(.?/%&$$ 33 /.($%@&%2$' ( 


!
 
AB 22% 3 - ( ?%%  '3% ?: $-%

$( '% ='=7 .9-$%0

 $-%0%&% (%

-./ =-'%'

5$06%-'&.3 0 &&'%   > C720 :'

90% -

&%5% $&52% 
C7>7> D

0% ?: $-% 3% % $0 &&'% $( 3 '5( 0'?.

37

$'

!-%0%'

$%00%%00%$ (E$-%0'?.

3F#

AB AB G% %&.

(%30$-%

$(& $% ($- $$-% 3'( 3'

?3% $ ?% 33=%7 0 5''%7 &52%  2 :

?3% % -

&% ?: $ H'

9 '

$ &&.

$ %($ ?3'(-% '

&5%  $-% %&% (% $= 0( 0  .$.0% 20(2%&$( 3( ?: 0  &52%   &&.

$  3((  %($ $% '

&&0

&% ='$- $-% %&'('    F?3% $-% 8.20%5% .0$ '

"#$%"&
%'()"%*+
,-"%.
$,$#+/
0'
1)"%".
+#2$
"%/
#2+)'



$0$&
3 A*B

%0 & $0 7 3% % &.

(%3 0 0%(2 $ *
(.0

&% 52

:=-'3% $22('

9$-%&3 '5'

3& $% %$- 3$-.9- (.5
C

D- ?%% 0% &&.

$3((& (0$'.57 3:
 

D = ( 2 :

?3% '

 $%05(  $-% %&'('  '

: 8%$-'F( & (% !8.20 #G'H%='(%7
C7

0% &&.

$.

3%@2%

$0

09%(= (3'

?3%$?%(& 3%= $
C7

D &&.

.

3%@2% (%( 3:7?%('%(7
7

0% &&.

$3((  36%

 = $ 2 :

?3% '

 6'%=  $-% %&'('  '

: 8%$-'F(& (%!8.20 # AB
 - 6% & ('%0% $-% (.?5'((' (  3% % &.

(%3 0 $-% 0$'%( ACB 5'$$%3:7 $-% %&% (% = (** :% 0(  9%7(%3%523:%

- 6'

9'

&5%
* 7 D2%05 $- $%0%.&$' '

&5%$ @ &&0'

93:7 ( 2%0 2 2- > !'6#  $-% %&'('    F?3% $-% 8.20%5%.0$'

:8%$-'F(& (%!8.20 #7$-%

0%% $'$3%$ $ H'

9 '

$ &&.

$  I  $-% 0%5% % %($ ?3'(-% '

&5%  $-% %&% (% $= 0( .$.0% 20(2%&$( =-'3% &52.$'

9 $-% &52% :

?3%G'H%='(%7 (2%02 2->!6'''#$-%%&'(' '

: 8%$-'F(& (%!8.20 #7='=$-%%&% (%=.3?%% $'$3%$


A*B  &&.

$  3((  & (0$'.5 '

($
 C

0% ?: $-% 3% %0'?.

3%('%(7
C7

D'(2 :

?3%$= 0(.

3%@2%

'

($
 C7

0%?:$-%3% %0'?.

3 &&.

$.

3 %@2%

$0

09%( .0$-%0 (.5
C7

D'(2 :

?3%  &&.

$3((%($ $%=-'&-= $ 0%?:$-%3% %0'?.

3 
7

0% &&.

$3((36%

'( $2 :

?3% '

$%05(2 2-C$-%%&'(' '

:8%$-'F(& (%!8.20 # A>B $-%3'9-$$-%2('$' $% ?6%7$-%

0% -%3% $'$3%$$-%33='

9&52% ) ) +"/'
,(%#
"''+''+/
,(%#
"''+''+/
4.
 4.
#2+
)$4(%"&
#2+
()#
 &5%!

$%0%.&$'
* 7 D
* 7 D '

&5%$ @ $(.0&%# !2%05 $-# !2%05 $-# 

.$.0% 0(2%&$( '3  I
* 7 DJ
C7C*> !0.

%$
C7C*D# * $ 3
&5%((%((%
* 7 D 
* 7 D 
C7C*D# 
C7*+D  .3$'23'%0 223'% > > D*0  D*0
C7*+D C %.&$' !$= 0(
* 7 D 2%0(

3 %@2% (%(  J 
+D
 7>D %&% (%# > %2% &: 
* 7 D !
C7*+D
7+D
 7>D#J J
C7 +CD!?.$
*>7C*D!2%05 $-#

((%((% (





5!36 #!2%0
*>7C*D@J
7*C7 *>D 5 $-#


AB 
C7 +D@J
*7 7 D
*7 7 D@>
7*C7 *>D@>J  52% 0%
>+7> 7C>D ?: 223:'

95.3$'23'%0 J
+77> D  G((& (0$'.5
C



C7

C7

D!0.

3 +

.

3 @2%

0

09%( %@2% (%( 3:#   G((($ $% '3
C7

 G6%

7


G 

$%'

$%0%($ >I2%0

.5 >I2%0

.5















#"&

5 77!6



 8 576 AB &&0'

93:7 '

($&52% 
C7>7> D 0% ?: $-% 0'?.

37 $-%

0% -%3 % $'$3% $ &52%   



 8 576

3 9='$-'

$%0%($K>I2%0

.5='$-%%&$05$-% $% &3 '52%$'$' $'33 $%2 :5% $73%((2 :5% $7'

:7 30% :5 % 220$' 5% $&52% (- 33?%5 %'

&&0

&%='$-$-%0 $' ($'2.3 $%'

$-% 02 ((%?:$-%3% %0'?.

3 A B &&0'

93:7 3 '( 33=% ?: 5':'

9 = 0 $% *  * > 2 ((% ?: $-% 3% % 0'?.

37

$'

 $ $-% %@$% $%

?6% !8LG
#    * + 5'$ 
L-%$-%0(2% H'

9D0% ( % ) %(D 2.
L-%$-%00%20$ ?3% ) %(D