High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/49348/2025allowed

Sandeep Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-23Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

% &'

1/+ % &'

1/+

+/& * +/& * +/& * +/& * %#)$ %#)$ %#)$ %#)$ 5

!"# @6%/%/& 7$+"+

% &' "

( @6+ &

* * * * $+ %* $+ %* $+ %* $+ %* 3, 6 3, 6 3, 6 3, 6 , , , , $6 +0 . 0 <"$5 7&1 % '

'&$ %0 %/%/& $6 $6 2 $% / -05 "

(

)6 ===== ===== ===== ===== , , , ,5 6 9,4 5 6 9,4 5 6 9,4 5 6 9,4 $+ % %/%/& + ) '/.

$ 1%/& &' %0 Bharatiya Na agarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 9'&$ +0&$% > 34 '&$ -$

% &'

$-".

%& %0 %/%/& $ / + ) $/ - &6;A

68A6 5 $-/+%$ '& &$ %0 &''

1+ "

/+0 ). "

$ 1%/& + ?;B ?B; &' %0

$1&%/1 $"

"-+

+210&%$& /1 ")+%

+ 1%5 ?; 9'&$ +0&$% > 1%345 % &./ /1 % ++/

5 /+%$/1 1% %0- $0 0/)5 "

( )6

0 -$ &' %0 / :"

+%/& /+ %0 % %0 %/%/& $ /+

&' ) )/ - /

- %& 1% / 7&.7/ - ?8 -+ 1& - 8 <- & 2 0"+<

- 1& ; <- & 2 0"+< < 9%&% . :"/

; <-4 .2 $1&7$

'$&# %/%/&

0/+ 1&

#.25 .#

6 ,

1&"

+. '&$ %0 %/%/& $ 0 + /%$ % %0 %/%/& /+ / 1"+%& 2 +/

68A6 6 ,

1&"

+. 0 + '"$%0$ +")#/%% %0 #

%&$2 $&7/+/& + &' %0 1% 0 &% ) 1&# ./ C/%05

%0"+5 %0 $&+1"%/& + +"''$+ '$&# / 0$ '1%+6 ,

1&"

+ /%$ % %0 %$/ . /+

%0 ./ )/./%2 %0$&' 1

&% )

%0 %/%/& $6 ,

1&"

+. 0 + '"$%0$ /%$ % %0 $ 0 + +"''$ '&$ #&$ %0

$+6 0"+5 $-".

/. /+ $ '&$6 6 ,

% 1&"

+. 0 + & &+ % %/%/& )2

$-"/ - %0 % %0 + $

+% %0 %/%/& $ +$/&"+ /

%"$

5 %0"+5 0 &% +$7 %0 1& 1++/& &' %0 $-".

/.6 ,

% 1&"

+. 0 + '"$%0$ +")#/%% % %0 /

% ) /. .

/+ ) )2 %0 $/-&$+ &' 1%/& A &' %0 1%5

%0"+5 %0 + # &"-0% %& )

/+#/++ 6 ,

% 1&"

+. +<+ %& .

1 & $1&$ 1"+%& 2 1$%/'/1

686 ; / %0 &"$% %&

25 C0/10 /+ % < $1&$ ;6

7 0 1&"

+. '&$ %0 $/7 $%/+

7 -& %0$&"-0 ). $1&$ + &' %0 1

0 %/%/& $ C $$+%

68A6 C0$/

'%$ + 1 $$/ &"%

+ $+ ?;68?6 6 &% ?; $&+1"%/& C/% +++ 0 7 ) 1/% 5 &"% &' C0/105 8 0 7 )

8 0 7 ) -/7 " %/..

%6 0 $/7 . 1& + $

$ -/7 $/+ %& ). /++"+5 C0/10 +0 .. ) $ %/&1/

"$/ - %0 1&"$+ &' %$/ .6 0/+ &"$% &% # /% $& $/ % %& .7 %0+ $/7 . 1& +5 % %0/+ +% -5 .+% /% # 2 $("

/1 %0 %$/ &%0/

-/). 0 + ) )$&"-0% '&$C %& /

/1 % %0 ./<./0&& &' %0 %/%/&

)+1&

- '$&# %0 $&1++ &' ("+%/1 &$ / %$'$/ - C/%0 %0 $&+1"%/&

6?6 $"+ . &' %0 E/# / &$ $+ ++ )2 %0 %$/ . &"$%5 )$&"-0% '&$%0 )2 %0 %/%/& $5 /

/1 %+ %0 % %0 %$/ . /+ /

$&1$ +%/

'&..2 %0$&' 1

&% ) +

%0 %/%/& $6 + $ 1"+%& 1$%/'/1

686 ; '/.

)2 %0 .

% 1&"

+.5 %0 %/%/& .$

2 +"''$ '&$ $/& &' 8 $+5 8? #&

2+5 F /+ &% +0&C %& ) /

2 &%0$ 9+46

%0/+ 7/C &' %0 %%$5 %0 $/-&$ /# &+

1% +%

/."%

./-0% &' %0 $%/1.

? &' %0 &

0/+ &"$% /

-# % %/%.

+ !".C/

$ 7$+"+ % % &'

!".C/

$ 7$+"+ % % &'

!".C/

$ 7$+"+ % % &'

!".C/

$ 7$+"+ % % &'

( "

( ++ 8A

9 ;**88

;4G '%$ $.2/ %0 $

/ &' %0 ("

-# %+ &' %0 & 3). " $# &"$% /

"++

!0 %&& 7+6 &# 1265 % % &' /0 $ 9?84 ? ?G ) ".

%".

2 7+ 66

< 9? 4 ?

;G ".

)/ 0 /<0 7+6 % % &' +0%$

&%0$5 94 9$/#/

.4 G &0 "+./# H "++ 7+6 % % 9 &' .0/4 $ &$%

??G $/#/

. &6 ;B

8A68 8 %/%.

+ I0/%%

/+C + ./ + ")0 + 7+6 0 % % &' J+% .KG I /%/+0 0/< $2 H

7+6 0 % % &' J+% .K5 1/ . , 7 %& . 9$.64

&6;;8

686

%/%.

+ I&0 ##

/' 0 /<0 7+6 0 % % &' "( %KG $/#/

. &6??

8;686

%/%.

+ & . !$/+0

%$ H & .$"+# 7+6 /&

<"$ 0 $2 7+6 % % &'

+05 94 9$/#/

.4 ?A G 0 + 0.

5 %0"+*

IA66 0 $/-0% %&

/%/&"+ %$/ . /+ &% & .2

7/% . + '-"

%& $7 % "

& $++/7 / G %& #/%/-

D/%2

11&#

2/ - %0

+ C..

+ %& 1"$%

/# /$# % / )/./%2 &'

0/#+.'5 )"% %0$ /+

&7$ $10/ - +&1/% . / %$+% 7/ - C 2 '&$ 2 %$/ .6 0/+ $/-0% 0 .2 1%"

%0 $1

%0 $

/ &' %0

)&7$'$$ %& " $# &"$%3+ ("

-# %+ 0 7 .

+$/+ &'

1/+/& + & - "

C 7/+% + &' '"

. $/-0%+6 0 1& 1 % &'

2 %$/ . /+ .- %& %0 $%/1.

++ $% &' %0 '"

. $/-0% %& ./'

./)$%25 -"

$+$7

$ &"$ & 6 0 $/-0% %& + 2 %$/ . )-/ + C/%0 %0 1%"

. $+%$ /# &+

% %0 %/# &' %0 $$+% &' %0

+:"

C0/10 1& "+ .. +% -+5

#.25 %0 +% - &'

5 / :"/$25 %$/ .5

$7/+/& +& %0

2 &++/).

$("

/1 %0 % # 2 $+".% " %& /# $#/++/).

7&/

2 +/ %0 %/# &' %0 1&##/++/& &' %0 &''

1 %/.. %0 1$/#/

. $&1 -+ +"## % / '/

./%25 1&".

7$% 6 0 + 2 %$/ .5 $.2 $/

:"/1< $ +/ :"

&' 1$/#/

. ("$/+ $"

16 0 &7$1$&C

&"$% &1<%+5 %0 0 72 7&."# &' C&$<

%0 $+".%

$++"$ & %0 $&+1"%/&

%0 &./15 /

")/% ).2 < + %0 %/$ 1$/#/

. ("$/+ $"

. #10

/+# "

$ +%$++

+%$ 6 &C7$5 %0/+

&% )

D1"+ '&$ < / - %0 +C&$ &' #&1.+ 0

-/ - &

'&$

'/ /% $/& &' %/#6 &% +$7

2 1$ /% %& %0 1$/#/

. ("+%/1 +2+%#5 $ %0$ /% # <+ '&$

% &'

/$+6 0 -"

% &'

2 %$/ . /+ /

7&/ & $++/&

2 )2 /# &+/ - & %0 &"$%

%0 $&+1"%/&

&)./- $&1 C/%0 %0 %$/ . C/%0

%106 0 -"

% +$7+

%0$'&.

"$ &+6 /$+%.25 /% $&%1%+ %0

+% & $++/7 $ . /# $/+& %G +1&

.25 /% $./7+ %0 &' %0

D/%2

")./1 +"+ /1/&

" %& "

$+&.7 1$/#/

. 10 $-+

+%.25 /% $&%1%+

+% %0 $/+< %0 % 7/

1 C/.. ) .&+% &$ ##&$/+ /## )2 %0

++ - &' %/#5 %0"+5 /# /$/ - %0 )/./%2 &' %0

0/#+.'6 % -&+ C/%0&"% + 2/ - %0 % %0 1& +:"

1+ &' $%$/

$ -$ 76 11"+ 5 $+"#

&1 %5 %/.. $&7 &%0$C/+5 +")(1% %& +210&.&-/1

02+/1 $/7 + &' ( /../'5 "+"

..2

$ & $&"+ 1&

+6 :"

..2 /# &$%

%5 %0 )"$

+"10

'$:"

%.2 '

..+ 0 7/.2 & %0 /

&1 % ##)$+ &' 0/+ #/.26 0$ /+ 2%

+ 1% &' %0 # %%$ C0/10 +$7+ +/

% %0/+ +% -6 0 + / % 1 + $.

% %&

)/ - /

- %& 1&##$1/ . :"

%/%2 &'

$ %0 1%5 ?;6 J0/. 1& +/ $/ /. %/%/&

+ / 7&.7/ - 1&##$1/ . :"

%/%25 %0 &"$% 0 + %& < / #/

$/-&"$+ "#$

A &'

1%5 ?; C0/10 #

%+ % &"$%+ 1

% ) /. %&

.2 '%$ 0 $/ - %0 ")./1 $&+1"%&$

'%$ 0 7/ - + %/+'/ /%+.' &' %C/

+ C0/10

). -$&"

+ '&$ )./7/ - %0 % %0 &% -"/.%2 &' %0 &''

1 10 $-

%5 0 /+ &% ./<.2 %& 1&##/%

2 &''

C0/. & /.6 0 +%$/ % $/-&"$+ &' 1%/& 1%5 ?;

#"+% ) #%/1".&"+.2 +1$"%/ /E

+% %0 ) 1< $& &'

3+ '"

. $/-0% %& 2 %$/ .6 0 $/-0% %& ./'

$+&

. ./)$%2

&% ) $

"- %&$2 )2 "

2+ / %0 ("

/1/ . $&1++5

$%/1".

$.2 C0$ +"10 29+4 /+ /%0$ %%$/)"% ). %& %0

("+%/'/

% %0

&' %0 $&+1"%/& )2 1&- % $ +6

/7/

&% ) < % )0/

$+ '&$

% $/& &' %/# )2 % </ $'"- / $/-&"$+ .

&C 1%/& 1%5 ?;6 0

.-/+.

%"$ / /%+ C/+ &#5 / $ %& +"$ +

%/#.2 . &'

%0 1 ++ "

$ %0 1%5 0 + $&7/

'&$ %0 1& &' + 1/ . &"$%+

&' %0 1%6 &C7$5 %0/+ &"$% 1

&% %"$

.+& 3+ 2 %& %0 $&%$ 1%

+2+%# %/1 / ''/1/ 12 %0 % '$"+%$ % %0/+ .-/+.

%/7 "$ &+6 &"$% &' .

C /+ "%2)&"

+"$ %0 % /%

&% )1&# 1&# ./1/% / 7/&.

/7/ .3+ '"

. $/-0%+5

&%C/%0+%

2%0/ - 1&

%"%6 J0/.

./ - C/%0 )

+ -&7$

)2 %0 $/-&"$+ &' 1%/& 1%5 ?;5 %0 &"$% #"+% +%$/< ("

/1/&"+ )

1 )%C %0 .-/+.

%/7 % %& 1"$) %0 #

1 &'

$"-+

%0 + 1$&+

1% $/-0% &' %0

/%/&"+ %$/ .6 $&.& 5 C/%0&"% ("+%/'/ ).

"+5 $/+<+ %$

+'&$#/ - $%$/ %& "

/%/7 /# $/+& %5

&"%1&#

%/%0%/1 . %& %0 $/ 1/ . &' ("+%/1

:"/%26 $-&5 %0 "

:"/7&1 . / '$ 1 /+ %0 % C0$ %0 %$/ . 0 %& 1& 1."

C/%0/

). %/#5 $+".%/ - / $&.&

5 /% #/./% %+ +% %0 $1/&"+ '"

. $/-0%+ &' ./'

./)$%2 -$

$ %0 .

+ +"105 1&

. ./)$%2 &7$$/ - %0 +% %"%&$2 #) $-& 1$

1%5 ?; &"-0% %& ) 1& +/

+ $ '

1%+ &'

-/7

C&$ +5 -$

% &' ) /. /

+ $% - %& 1&##$1/ . :"

%/%25 & -$&"

&' "

2 / .5 1

&% ) + %& ) '%%$ )2 1%/& A &' %0 1%5 ?;6K "''/1 %& + 25 '"$%0$ &' %0 %/%/&

$%$/ . /+ &% C

%0 '

1%+

1/$1"#+%

1+ &' %0 1 A6

7/C &'

)&75 %0 $+ % %/%/& ..&C 6 %/%/& $ /+ %& ) $.

$-".

/. & 0/+ '"$ /+0/ - ) /.B+"$%2 )&

+ %& %0 + %/+'

1%/& &' %0 , 6 1&

. &"$%B"%2 -/+%$ %6 &C7$5

%& 1&

+ %0 % # 2 ) /# &+ )2 %0 1&

&"$%B"%2 -/+%$ %5 %0 %/%/& $ +0 .. $# )&"

)2 %0 '&..&C/

+* 9/4 0 %/%/& $ +0 &% #/+"+ %0 ./)$%2 -$

9//4 0 %/%/& $ +0 &% % # $ C/%0

2 7/

15 &$ . &$

&1"# $25 "$/ - %0 %$/ 9///4 0 %/%/& $ +0 &% )+ % 0/#+.' &

% )'&$ %0 %$/ 9/74 0 %/%/& $ +0 &% 1&##/%

2 &''

1 C0/. &

/.6 0 %/%/& $ +0 &+/% 0/+ ++ &$%5 /'

25 C/%0 %0 . &"$%6 97/4 0 %/%/& $ +0 .. -/7 0/+ 1.. 0&

"#)$ %& %0

- ''/1$B &' 1&

&./1 %

+0 &% 10

- 0/+ 1.. 0&

"#)$ C/%0&"% $/&$ $#/++/& &' %0 %$/ . &"$%B :

-/+%$ %6 97//4 0 %/%/& $ +0 &% /

2 #

$ %$2 %& 2 %0 97///4 0 %/%/& $ +0 .. +")#/%5 & %0 '/$+% C&$</

2 &'

7$2 #& %05

''/

7/%5 )'&$ %0 1&

&"$%5 %& %0 ''1% %0 % 0 0 &% )

1&##/++/&

2 &''

'%$ )/ - $.

/.6

+ %0 %/%/& $ /+ '&"

%& ) /

&''

'%$ 0/+ )/ $- /. / 5 & %0 ) +/+ &' 0/+ ''/

7/% &$ &%0$C/+5 %0 % % /+

%& #&75 '&$%0C/%05 '&$ 1

1..

&' 0/+ ) C0/10 .

5 )"% &' 1&"$+5 +0 .. ) $ %/&1/

#$/%+ %0$&'6 6

+ &' )$ 10 &'

2 &' %0 '&$+

%0&+ C0/10 # 2 ) /# &+ )2 1&

. &"$%B"%2 -/+%$ /$1%

0$/

)&7

+0&C/

+"''/1/ "+5 %B1&# .

% +0 .. ) % ./)$%2 %& #&7 1

1..

&' ) /. &' %0 $6 6 $

11&$ -.26 ?86

&%0/ - + 0$/

)&7 +0 .. ) 1& +%$"

D $++/& & / /& %0 #$/%+ &' %0 1 ??6 / 1 %0 # + 0 + )

- #/+1..

&"+

./1 5 /'

25 +0 .+& +%

&''6 9 , , , ,4 %#)$ %#)$ %#)$ %#)$ 5 7/$ J0%0$ + </ -B$

* +B J0%0$ $ &$% ).* +B