High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5448/2017disposed of

National Insurance Co Ltd v. Manjit Kaur & ORS

2026-03-10Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma18 pages

"#$ %& $ $'$( $)'*"'+ ,- ,

"#$ %& '%.%*./$0$.#(

! 1! ,

"#$ %& 23%"45.6(

! 1! ,

( 7 8 9!

9 9 9

! "

# $ % & !

' % ! % ! ' () **** 9 9

( + $ '

$, -

&,# " .)/(./(0' % (11'

(233$,

& + '

4+ 5" -

&," ' " $,, ' .6 0( ///7- &7 ()#" 809: & ! , # " # ! &'

&" '''#! " ;

$##

. < '' ' .9/1./() =# %# " " '+ +

<-.6>-19)9 " ##'

& " ?" !# + +

' ' & @$ 2 // '

',< +

<-(/AB-1.61" " $# ! , ##,C#-C#& $, ! %# '< %# '<", < A

& & "

# ' '

" #!#, #

# '+ +

<-.6>- 19)9 " " $# !$,=# %# &

$, %# ! '+

<-(/AB-1.61 =# %# ! &

" !'

/9/0./()> 9) .1/1./() % .02766076637).0' " # %& &'D

%# 6 E ' & & ' &' ) > &# ' '"#

" '

&$, + -

!"#$!# % &'(##)*+ ) ,,

+ -

/0& )1 #23 $!4$& *

)) !56 +7

+ +7 7 8)) 45

& ).

"5 0

7 /0& )1 #23 $!4$

$5 /0& )1 #23 $!4$

& ).

:5 6

+ /0& )1 #23 $!4$).

'5. ;

9 ' # # !

+ " & ()?"! -

&," $,

# ! , # -

&, ! &'

&" '''#! 9? 1 ' F

&, %# " #!'' ! !# &'

$& %# " " !#''#

$ # # <-.6->-19)9

, !# " !!,# ! 0 ?'

# " !' &

, ' +

# -

'," '

"$ , ! & '

& " ' ''# ! ? '

$"$,, #!$ ' , " '''#! 3 '

$& + &&

"$," # , 'G

&H " G

'!'' H? < #&' ?5$ % &

! "

, 9 , :

'!'' H &

$ & , !'

' &H 2 ?'

" # 9/:" '

')/: " (/ I #'

, $" ((

#' ()F

$& #$ ' & '

,#! $"F

&," ! '''#! ""

& ()! ?'

, # !"

$ # $ ' , + &

&, '," '

' ! & '

&" ! ' ''#!

(. ? '

& + #, " + '

# & # "

'' '

&,#' &, (6 I & , $#!'& ! $ &

() ! '

' (9 " $

! '" +

- # 4 7+ < < 7

+ +7 8 7

% /

7 7 -

7 0 7

7 . "+###= )* 7

+7 .4#+###= )*7

!=4 >7 7 !: / 7

& 7 8 -

/ 7

/ 7 & 7

6 +

4 % /

/ 7

& +

, /

8 -

2*? >

/ +

7 &8 )6 + & 8) 8) !% .4+ 9+%# = /

& -

+ -

& 0 7

+ 8 7

0 70& .:###= / 7 . +%%+###= A.:###B%###= "#C

5D !@

E E2 / ? +!##'A45. @ 8 - 494 >F& ? 6

+ 7 8 & A =%57&

7 @ =% 7 8 +

. +#:+###= /

7 7 -

7 4!

6 8) !:+ 4! @ + 0&4! 8 !:6 7 @+

$ &

70 7 4 4" @ +

+ 7 . 9+!:+###= A. +#:+###D $5

" 7

/ /+

+ 8 6$%&'

( )** +,-./.0( "

%1!"

(+,-+)+0) 0 22+( $

3" "

+,-4).0 -2+( &1 5"

$% 1 1 ( +,-4).0 467%

(( &"1 (+,-6)+0 6+4+>F& ? 6

."#+###= G . +##+### 8

.!"+###= .4+ 9+%# = 8 /

7 .!4+9#+%# = A. 9!:+###= .!"+###= . +##+###= .!+#####B4 9+%# = 5+ 7 .!4+9 +###=

$ 7< 7

.,? +@ !+6 ?

> *

G*E G >7 > *

7 6 0 & 7 &8+ >

6 ?

0 & 6 ?

6 ) 8.6+ 2G 8 .! 8.4

2 G *

8.%+ 8." 8 )$

.? )1 #23 $!4$ 8.9@

6 & !6 +

$ +,-4)+0) 0+-++ 7 7 &

2 + 0+ G*E >7

& +

& 7 & >F& ) & >

> ? 8%&""

$955:;

%1! "

( +,-.)-0 ) 0 --- "%"

3"$"

%1! "

) 0 --<

$ &"!

= ( +,,2)40 ) 0 >,++ 7 >7F& ? &

7 0 & 7 7 &8

> 6 ?

& +7

& / /0& )1 #23 $!4$

6 7 &

+ / & 7

& !6 ?

7 7 8.%+ G*EG*E?@1+*?H5* 0 & *

;

7 &8 >7

7 ! 0 *

& 6 7 && +& 7 !6 ?

: @ &+

7+7 /

.!4+9 +###A./7

5 7 9 =!C

#:#'!# %

/ &

& !+6 ?

+7 & 8 0 +

/ &

7 , A7 75A

!5 .

+9 +###= !@

45 .%+##+###= 4H

%5 .%+##+###= %* , A?

.%+##+###= / <

! 45 &

8 7

I1 0+

7 , A

;

(1 ?!# !

' ' &,'#

$, +

'$, (0

' ! F

$ # %#" #, # " !!,#

! ;

$ "" "+ !"$,?5$% &

# # $ ' , &

, $"

$ $ &' #& &' - ,! & $!

(3 + + ' #, # ! $!' & '

, &

$# - ,! & $' &

&, ;

'," '

' ! & '

&" ! ' ''#! (2 +

$, + #F

&,, & & '

"$ , ! &'

&" '''#!

" # #! #&

& ./ ;

, '# $, + ' # & ,$, F

&, '," " &

,# # ! , # # " '''#

! " ' &, " ' , ' $,

.( %' $, ' F

&, + &&

" $, " # , 'G

' &H " G

'!'' H

.. +?5$% &

$ "% ""

" *;

(+,+7 -.- ,

'# " # ! +J

# ,G

'!'' H ' &

& "$ ' & "

' & ;

, '

!'' & &

$+ !J ' &

!! 6 .

A 5+ ? ; +

& >7+? 1 )

A 58

A 5 7

& + + + 8

& +)

A 5 ( "! @ +7 7 78 .

+A!# 45' ??"%K6 .!"+###7

8 +. +##+###7 . +##+###

7 / 8 /.

+A!# 45' ??"%K

2 J

2 6 ?G+A!# !5 $ ??%!

K+ 7 /

+ &

& & 7 & & L 0 +

&< @ < & / & 8+ & 0 +

& /

& / & & 7 + 7 & 8 &

+ &

0 0

<7 +

& &

0 & /+ 7 0 & 6 & + + + 8 &. "+###+.%#+### . "+### /

1 & < 0 7 & 7 < & & & #C

& 7

& !4/ &< 7 & )

A 5 -

? 1

1 @ + ?

7 7 !%/

+ 8 / ;

8 6 7

+ 7 & 7

& +

D66@

.9+ J

" & , ' , >7+ + & + & 7

& ;/

& !$6 8 &< ? * H 6 ? G .

9 / ?8

& ;

07 &

0 A!# :5 : ?? 4# / 8

&7 ; ;

& & / 1 7( !

@? 1 ? )

6 ?G)

+A!# 95 $ ??$:#K 7 7 &

+ ; 7

; / 7

+ + + + + +7

+ 7 8

7 (J.

+A!# 45'

??"%K !

& 7 7 7

+ + +

;J1 0F 7 2 A" + '9'5K !

! )

+ + + +

; !

4 M

? + +

!!?

& 7

* 7 F 8 *

+ +

!4 / * E @ &

6 7

+ +

)

@@7> ? J.

> ? -

+!# 9 ??G .

4:%:NL 0 > ?

) , +!# 4 ??G L!%4"N

, > ? G 0 ? ? +

''$ ??G , 9%K>7+7 7

7 &

!%/ & 7 & &

;

7 )

6 +7

+ .%#+###

!9 6 +7

!" * H

6 A 5

.:#+###=

+ ? . +##+###= !:* + L 6

6 ?G

, :+ -1 ?

7 )

A 5 * H

6 A 5 . & )

A 5+ ? + + + 8 @ + * H 6 A 5+ ?

&7 &

/ ? 7( A!#!

?9:# 4%@ +7 7 +

/ & > ? & &

/ ? 1 )

6 ? G )

+ A!# 95 $ ?? $:#K+

, 7 & I +

8 6* H J* H 6 ?G .

+A!# :5 : ?? 4#K+ ?

+ 7

G 4" / / & > ? + 7 / 7

!'? 7

&7 + ? && 7 &

? 1 )

A 5+7 ; @&<

, A 5+ & )

A 5 * H

6 A 5+

7 &

;?< +

7 ;

.6 !"'' ! &'?5$ % &

" ' # $, +

'!'' H $

#, & " $,+ $ $

& .) %' $,F

&, +

#9/:" '

)/:

.9 +?5$% &

%1!

! ""

(@)+,-<0-772,A # ,"

" " $"#')/,

" & &,& &

$" '

)/:' $ & " " #

" # & ! #' &'

" 6.,

.1 !"'""

! "B " '

" $ )/: ' $ &9/: $, + + ' J "

$, + ;

&' .0 ;

, " $, +

;

- %1 '

( , & 3///7- .

8)/:

6.//7-)/:'3/// A

(7) .3//7-((.//K(7) ) + & 3)//7-((.//-.3// ) (1 A , (1 (. 3//7-3)//K(.K(1 LJ

6 (0 )/(7-

'L (9 ///7- > LJ

(9 ///7-

' & ( 1/ ///7- %

)/ ///7-J( > )/ ///7-J(

)/ ///7-J.

%#"3 %02$. "#5%.

! - - <

.3 %' $,?5$% &

3"C " 5 $"!%3"$ % ;

, $"

$% 1 1 )+,++06 1

% -,<- & () # 82: &$!&& '

&''#'

&' C .2 '

! '

& '! /6(/./(0 - < '

,,&$, ./ // ///7- 6/ ;

, ()F & ₹ ' .( ./ ./(7-#" 82: &'

& ''#' & C 6(

#, F

&, & ' " $,

#& '

, , ()- & $' + " '"& '

&' ' ' ,'

#&E

+ &

()F & " .)/(./(0 + & 7 () '

+ 6.

#, ,"" .)/(./(0 &'$!J 66

# ', '

9 9

! 1! , D

! @ #7- # %# @ $ M