Harish Rai Dhanda v. State Of Punjab And Others
!" #
$ #& '%
#
! "#
$ ! "%
& '&! "%
'&
! "%
()! "
! '!
&! "#
*&! "
) + , $ () #%
# & -(
# *&! "#
*&! "
& ! "
! '!
! "
( ! "
) +.
/ !& $ '%
#
&
*
! "
! '!
! "
( ! "
) +1
/ ! 2
* +,* --
-$ .
+,* - -- - * -
-$ .
/
" 22 # 56 56 2 "&&
7 "
2#!!& 2 "
"&& " ,
-&!""# 56 7 2 2
0"12$ #& '
%
#
$ # ! "#/ "
8+ ,8,05
9 .:6!& 222!
" :.
; "2 / "!4<:=5 "22 4<:="6!
&" " " 2&
> "2/ !4<<?!
!2"
"2@2" 2!4<<+5 "22 @2" 2!4<<+6
+
$ " ' & ! A"2 ' & 2 " 84 8;
,8,0 & ! 2 @9"22 "!' !& "" " ;
4<:="
"2: 2& >
"2 / ! 4<<?! # " B # &
C 2! # & 2" / "22 "2 / !A !& <?# ! #" ?=# ! 9" # # "(#2
# 2 #&
?
$! 2
#
"2/ # " &> ) 4> ) <?
=
$ 2 #& 2"
8;
8;
,8,0
) ,!0
+2 "& 2 " " 562
# 8+ 8;
,8,0 $ "& #2
) ,+! 2 #2 2
" 8< 8;
,8,0 $ " #&
) , /&& ! A
"2/ !A :
$ " 2
#
) ,! # "& ( #
) 4
, "22" / "22 "2/ !A !!2
/> ) ,,00;,8,0 # ! " # ! & " 8+ ,8,0 #
!! # #2 # 2  "
"" 2!# 56# & # # # 2
;
$! #2 # "22 " 8+ ,8,05
9
.:6
0"12 $ () # %
# <
$ # ! "#/ "
8+ ,8,05
9 .:6!& 222!
" :.
;4<:="! &" " " 2& > "2 / ! 4<<?!
! 2 " @2" 2!4<<+
$ ) 4 #22 &! 2 " 2&
> "2 / ! & $ /&& ! "2/ !&!#" " ! " ' & 2 "
$#29" 2& > #
#22# "
# .
"&
" "&
&#
0"12 $ '%
#
$ # ! "#/ "
8?
,8,05
9 .,6!& 222!
" :.
;4<:="! &" " " 2& > "2/ !4<<?
4,
$& " ! .2& # "2/ ! 2
!
#
) 0, 2(' 2/#!
208D/ 2 #
33 !435521670"!721681515
$2 " 2 56&! & .2& " 56222!
"2 2 "! "2
!&& " 56 &
4<:= "!
! 2 "" " .2& !9
2& > "2/ !4<<?
" " 9 @2" 2!4<<+ $22 2" ""
" :.
;4<:="!9"
! "
" !
! !
"
#
$ %# %
#
&
$'
#
(
%
# % %
%
(
(
"
)
#
*
%
( (
# $!
+
#
()
#
#
(
% , $ # %
&
$'
#
-
4+
$&
" " & 56 " & " 56! "& #22 " $ & !"" " :
; 2& >
"2/ !4<<?! #!9"
% !
&
) , .
#
% #
)
%#
$
# '&!
!
, $ )
$'
%
/
(
!
((
% 0
%
(
!
((
#
%# %
0 !
((
#
%
%
0 () *
"
&+
'"" '
'&!
' (,)- !!
.
!
!!
"
/'&!
0 !
1 12
#
$ # %#
(
#
(#
( !
((
(
(
(
%
3 "
(
!
((
#
$ %
%
(
.
4?
! "2 = 2& >
"2/ !4<<?! #9"
! "2" 2& # / $2 " 2 56&!
# 9" .2& " # " & "2 $!& & " 567
/! !
2 1
45 ) ,
(
%
.
%# % 6 "
# ( (
%
#
(
# (
%
0 3
# #
#
%#
(
%
%0
(
#
%# ( (
%
$ #
#
%
0 ,
. # %
$ #
. #
%
0 *
#
(
#
(
( 7 %
#
.
(
#
( (
(
%65 12
5 4=
C & !2 " 2 56 &
- "
/ "2 3 + 4'
0 5 % '
+ &
0 ! #" 6 # "& ! # ! .2& 9" "
# "2 222# " " 20;24<:, $2 !9
& 9" 7
(
#
%
( (
%
,
"
8$
7
!
(
9#
%
, :
; %
( #
#
#
! -
% (
,
< = .
*
%
>
= .
, (
!
%
%
%
*
(
(
(
7
(
?
@
% %
$
2!# >
= .
% (
)"
" (
,
%
%
'
(
4
A/
% "
#
(
%
7
#
(
A/
#
"
8$
7 "
(
# #
(
# "
#
- #
#
> . C# >
2 ( ( 32 /D4# /E BE/A
E
%
%
( ( (
A/ " #
-
( &
-
% ( ( (
%# 9
" #
/EE# 4EE EDEAE (
-!435521670-101!7 4:
!2 / 2&
2& # "2/ " " ! " # # 2 &# /!#" 7 & $ " 2& #
2& >
"2/ !4<<?! 222#
4;
& " 562 #" " #
2 " /&
" # "" 2(
$ " 56#
2E
" 22"
4< F&!@2" /&&
@2" &&!22 /&& ."&.
"@2"2" $!2"
""&& "
#2 & & "22" G"22 7 G!!" " 2 "2,+0.H'/
$ "2,+0.H'/ C
9"
! 7
&2 '
! !
) C
( %
(
# F
%
(
#
(
8"
9
%
%
% 9
-
%
%
% % %
=(
2"2165!1 ,8 $2 ! " 2" " "&& "
"& 2" &&!!"
" #
" 2" " 2! #2 " "22# &
9/ "2 96
'
5' * 3'
"
0 -
..
!
' 2
!
% !
(%)
"2 9: "
!!
5' * ;!
- 6 $! !
( #) %'/ ' $2 "" "569"
(6066<%:, 5;3%<% *=;
3;*<36,6
0>>,;3- 6:44?
06%*,*<;6@) D , 9
%
(#
% (
( % (
- % !
:
(
B
% !
( - % - #
%
%
7 %
#
%
2 GH
2
" #
# 7
#
%
(
(
%
(
(
(
% 7
#
% (
!
(
9
"
A
%
(
( #
(
%
9
( 7
% %
((
(
( %
# %
(
%
7
(
9
( #
%#
#
(
(
A
( "%
(
#
#
(
( % -) %
:
(
)
( ( %
#
%#
(
(
---- ---- E 7
(
2
"
!
#
!
:
(
B
,
(
%
% (
" (
A 7
((
4E
"
#
%
%
I
( %
(
I 7
9
-
!
:
(
%
%
( ----- ---- 7 %
A %
!
(
%
/ 4
(
A
!
(
(
(
, 9
(
%
!
!
:
( "
B
7 2
GH
%
# #
(
%
-
(
:
( #
(
! )
:
(
%
)
,
A I
I D ,
%
%
6)) () =
"
"
/
'
!" !
'
/
'
-
! 2 &
"
1 &
/
! '! & !'
!2
/ &!
"
'!
!!
!
!!
/'
"
' ! '! & // !!
!
- !
/ "
& '
'!2 / () ,
2 / /!- !
!
'
2
!!
;
"!
"
'! &
2 "
A! AB
"'!
!
/"
2 &! "
"2 !
- '
!
&2 !
" - '!
"
9 9!
&! /
!!
C' - 2 '! & &'" '/ &
/ !
&'
!
&2
!
/
&
'&+
/' &
' ! !
/" ---- ---- 9:0=,6$;3 %,6 =
,??
5;3%<% *=;
=,;> ;?;*,06 0::,%%,06;36; $;?=, A , #
#
( ,
(
(
,
#
9
#
(
2 #
)
*
I%
(
(J
(
:
(
( , 9
%
(
#
%
( 9
,
# #
(
J
J ( (
J (
9
J ,4 9"
2 " "2 "& # "56
I2 & / !9035: "0 ;!80<! 2
6 @2" 2 " "2 22 "" &" 2
22" 2&
22
2" 2 22 2" !2" " &
"
6 $2" 2# 2 / ! "& " "2 " #" "2"
2 "&& #2 !
##2 " 2" " "
!& "22 "2 2!
"2$ 2& 2" 2
%
"6 "" 2 "&& 2# 2"
& 2 /A# ,,
& "22 "22#!"
"56! " & 22!!
2 &" " "2 " .2& 9"!
& 2 2" !
"
/
1057=/160558!15140>51014=160>>5/4!1 7=02116"70015216!71/07=42167"15 54!07"" ,0
72! # 92 2#& "56!"22# 92 2#56
- " G2&/! 2 E .. - " #" 2 " 56!#"&2! " #& ! ""& ! ! " " 2 .2& 9" ! #( " 2 2" ! & ! 2 2 2"
@2" $ 2" "
/ 7 2!
92 2# 7 &
,+
F&! "2 56
!9035: "0 ;!80< "& "
9/ +*65-5>6577:"0;!80< / 7 2! " "56 "22# 9
9/ !9035:"0;!80</ ! "2!2 2# 22"! "!# " #& "
(
" 2" " 2! "
,?
! " "! 2"
" "22 "2/ " " 9 !
!# "2,+0J/ C
! #9" !"" 2&
" " ! &(.& "
" " !"& #! #
2" " 2 2 2 2" && #
" !2 !
!#7 2E & # < $'
:'
/ ! - *%
%#
%
(
#
%
( (6 2
% (
(
C
%
(
(
% %
#
( %
#
-
"
% #)
-
%
0
-
-
6 2
-
#
%
%
(
"
%
%
-
%
@ ,= -&!"
& 2"2 22! 2 & " ! 22 !#"722! "& &# 9" " $"!#2 &"""#2 22"
! " &! "& " &2 "2,+0$/ C
! !
" 2&
27 222 E
$ 2 E 56 " 2 &
!
#2 "" 2# "" "" " 2 G # " " !"& & "& " " !
7 2 #22 & # " " !
#"& " 2(2"# && "
# &"E# # ! ! .
2& # 2" "& " ,:
$
" " ! "2 &( 2#2 .2& # " " !" "
" ! & &" " # " " ! " &( 9" 2& # C ! 2"& #""&
#" # 56 $ 2 ""2 "
! &9"
,;
-&!##2 7 " & 2
6 ># "2 2"! "2 /20; 2& > "2 / ! 4<<?
# & " ;" 4<:=!"& &
" .2&
9"
6 >" !"& 56 # " " &
" 56
"6 ># 29"2
2! "" .2& "
,<
!
2!# " " ! & " 56 "& ! 9" .
2& # " 256 C 72!
( #22&( .2& 9"!
( "" &" " # " " ! " "& 2 & "& # ! # ! 2 "
)222!&"! 9"2 2! "&2 .2&
9"!"22!# 2 " "2 9"2 " @ " " !!# 2
2# "
2@2" $ 2" " !# " " & !# & ! "" 9"2 22 !& 2!& "
"22" !& &22"
# ! " @2" $ 2" " ! 2"
"!
"
@2" $ 2 2 2!"&2
.2& 9"! ! " !
"" .2& # ( 2"! # 222"& "
# "56!
#2 E C 72! .2& 9"!
( "
2 "!"22!#
2" &&
" !2" &&#!
. 2 &92 2#& "56 C& 22!# "
" .2& 9"!
9" " .. !!2 .2& 9""
2
!# &2
! #!
"! & &"E!
# #" # $! 2 " 2!/ & ! &
"" 2 &" E "56!
C 72! 2 !" " #" "& &
! #2 " .2&
9" " !& 2 /&( "#2" && 0,
# !# "&! ! " & &"E "
#& # " " !
& 2 #
2! "2256 "" " #2#! & " & 2 2" !# && "! " & "256 C
!
2# &2 E
"! & & #
!
# & 7 #
/ 7 2! 2!&2 " .. "! & " E2 # " " ! 2 #22 &
!
" "
" ! 2"
& " 56 0+
$ 2 " 2 56 & 2 &
- " / 0?6 .!30+ "0 ;!80</ 2 # 9" !# !/ ! "22 "" .. 2B" 2 .2& 9"!!
" " & >/!
" 2" &&" " " 2 "2,+0.H'/
! " & #
" 2"
&& 0?
# ! "2
"
& G2&/! 2 )
48!40
4+ "!#9"
! & ""22
2 "292 " &
- " /
,
( (
(
$ #
% (
# %
%
" ( #
(
%
(
:
#
K (
%
)
% (
-
( % (#
!
%
%
%
*
%
(
(
(
#
( DDDD DDDD , 9
9 % %
%
(
EE4E EDEE
#
"
8$
7 % (
'
(
EE4E EDEE (
%
, %
%
-
, :
;
< * 2 ?
.
('/ )
6) ? ,
( %
'
(
#
!
% %
( %
(
-
#
!
% 7
#
,
#
#
9
% , (
%:
L # M
M
#
%
M(#
&
3&
"
>! D
$/'2 %/ .- '
!
?" !
&!2- ( ) # %
(
, + .
+
2 "
""& ""!#"22# I2&/ <
* 2 ?
.
('/ )- .
4'
('/ )
%
5 >'1 2
, .
( ) # % # " !#2 & 2
0= $! "& "
" 22" .. 256!#""
/! 2 & & 6
'
('/ )- >/&( " #
" 2" &&! &
/! "56 7 2 "
2" &&" ! #"&9" ! &"
" 2" "2 / "! 2"&2 .2&
9"!# " @2" /&& ! " "2 B 2E 2"222 / 7 2! # 22& !"& 22 "
# 9 %# 32 C /D4# /E BE/A
E
(
6
, *
-
(
-
/EE# 4EE EDEAE
(
%
$
EE4E EDEE
"
( %
#
'
% ,
#
*
K
'
(
% ( (
# (
(
#
%
( 0:
"&( "!2"
&& "2/ !/ "2!
!)
"
"
$! " "
" 2"
&& "56 2 " 0;
"! "&2 & 56 "& 2 &92 2#!9 # .2& 9"2#
"" " & !!> /&# #2" && 0< $ & #" 2 - "/!#" " " 0?6 .!30+"0;!80</ "2 2& 9"222!
# ( " " 2 " "& ! #! .2& 9" "& ! 7 2 22 & " "&
C! "! 2 " !&( 7 .
2& 9"
"" 7
" ! "
""& " 0?6 .!30+"0;!80<
222! " 2(
" 0?6.!30+"0;!80</# !#2
&256 / 2! "56! 56 2 &256
C& 2 2 ! " & "2 56 C &&! &
- "/"&22 2"2 "
+8 )# # ! 2! & " 0?6.!30+"0;!80<# 7 & " !# "22 &
& ! G2&/ 2 "22 &2 "" "& 9 /!
& / 7 2!# & & 0?6.!30+"0;!80< &
2#
!"" "56
## #9/ 2 2!2 "22 +4
&! "2 2# "2 56
6
'
9 ('/ )
: "
!!9 ('/ )/"& !#! 2 "& # /! ! 9" # " ! " " & 56! "22 # 2" " 2 "&
" !&( "56
" 2"
&& +,
)#! &
!92 2# "2 9/ "2 4
"
*
:'
/ !
/
2 &
- (
) # %
"2 %' :
+
% :
2
-
( ) % - # !
2 ! # 9"
! "& 2 2 !
& 2#! " .2& & # ! & 2 "
" 2" &&@2" /&& !
"2" 2"2 !
# 2" "& &"2
4
"
*
9 ('/ )F ? 7
"
L "
8"
*
*
7 "
,
,
# J #
J
J
J
I
I %
( 6 C
EE EE 4 /
( $ J A/4 ED
9
9%
*
@ G%' :
+
% :
2
F ? 7 % #
(
(
(
(
% %
%
*
)
(
(
(
(
%
-
%
%
(
( % 7
)
-
%
% )
(
) )
%
%
(
%
(
%
(
$
# %
7
#
(
(
(
(
D 3 (
K
# -#
(
%
%
-
%
(
( % 3 #
( % %
(
(
-
# -
%
%
,
#
( %
*
#
# (
%
E 3 (
%
$
"
"
E
9
?
@
(
&. ( %#
*
(
(
K %
-
3
(
% 2 *
K
% 2 0
*
K
#
EEDE#
K<
,
*
%
@ +0
!# 2 / 222"
" " 8;
4, ,8,+!& @2" /&& ! !#!" 22" "2/ !/ "2!
) "!
!
"
$!"!
!256"& 2 &( .2& # 2"
"
2" && ++
2
"&2 " " / "2 01.!300750 01.5>@-1012 !?040 16!#"$ ,%
2
"& ! # ! 9"
! " &2 !"22!# & 2 9/ 44 ,8,+!& ! "2 6-1012 !?040 16@01.!30016! #"-, ;557< & &A% & &'2
"&
,
(
(
*
# 2!#
2!
%
(
%
(
(
9
D %
(
-
507 2165!1 +?
&!/
& # 56 56
# 56 !& &
+=
"& "2 " !!22
2" 56! ! " ;-
-$ .
< ;- - *< #
( $61680B5>C0 C $61681047 C