Commissioner Of Central Excise And Service Tax, Panchkula v. M/S Lone Star Engineers, 146, Adarsh Nagar, Yamuna Nagar




   
  

 !"#"$%&%'() **%&&%'"+"'!+ ,-$%&" '#"+.%$" -/ '$012,  3344",, '! 5&

6&7'"! +'8%'""+&  3 "&4'#"'!   ( 97

 
:


7    97

 
 


: 7 





























 















; <:2* + %!! ,/ !

"






 #



"


 




  $%



&'



!())
* 

+
,-


 .

 
 
  
/$


0 
!(()

  

 


!$ #2!3
'

$

.

 
&'


4
 
"'

" .



 


5
. 
6 

5
+ -
7

&"

"








  
.


 

.




.


 
.


5

 5




 

 

 


'
.

 

 8

-
7

&"

"








.


 


 

.
8
$

5
 



 











.

"

5
 




'.
 

 
 


 


0 
!(()
"





5 

 
 


 

#1 #22(

+ 
 

 
 ,


 


95




 


 

#( #22(

 




5 

 


  


:

 

' 

!# #22(
;
9
<
 



=



.



5 
 
  
 

.



>

6 

5




5



'.
 

+ 
0 
 

 

 
  

? 
 ,


 
#2212/

#2!!!#

5

 
 
'

"


5


5

 
 

 
'
 


!$(##!2(;

= '
 



 
@

  
1%



  
13
11

1/



5




"
A

 
 


## ( #2!)
'

#
 





 
5

 


 

 


!$(##!2(;
  


.




 


.

" .
:




!$ #2!3

'

$

5




5



 
  





5
 
'


 
95

5
 


 

 
'
.


 

.




.


 
.

@
5




 5

  
(1


0 
#2!#



5

 
'


  

 

 




 

 
 
5



 

" .
 


. =


A  

  

5


 
'






 



 
5


.
 



.
 .
 

9 



.

 ) 7






  % @

.
  
 
.

" .

'






5
 


  

 
 
 


"

5
 .


  


 

 
 
'


.   

 
.


 


.

.



5


 
.



0

 5

  
(1


0 
#2!#

5
 



5

 
'


  

 

 


 

 
 
5








5
 
. =


A
 

  

5


 
'






 "

 
 
.

" 
 
 


+3
>

  


.

 

.
.





 
5
 




 


  

 
 
 



7

 




 '
.


  




 

  

.



7

 



5
 
.


 

.
 
 

.




 


.
 
" 




 


*-

.



@



 
.


5
.





. =





 
5 
.



 
. 

 


5

 =
.=

 
 
'

.


..=



 

 

..=


'





 
 




..= 



5
.
5

 0
5
 









   
*-




  
'
5 

   
5
6 

 
"B


 




 ;


 
 

 

"B
.

 ;
 

  
'

@


   

9C.
'


.









  
D
#1%;#2!;(% @"* -

#( 2!

!((1

.





B  
"'


 
 







"
 
 
+
 
  E

  #2!*!-


@  
"'


.
 


'
 

  

    

"B

'


.
 
.

 
95
 
5 



 .



 

  #2!*!

-



 



 

'
.

 


 .





  
#1!


@  
"'
,
/ ?


.

 
5






.

 


  
 
.



 

  

 
'
 .


.


0
5
 


 
.



 


.

.
?
@


   
5



 


 

.




.


 
.

 ( 7










  
(1



#2!#




 

  

 
4
 




 
 




"


 
. =


A 
 

  

5


 
'






 
'

@

 


.
 

 

.
 .
 

 ,
F











 .
" 


   


   !"#$ 
#2!)
*$3-
 "

?

)2/
*"
 . -



 
.

 
 

 


 


 " 


  





5
.


 
 
 F







.
.

 




  


 
 
.

" .
5  
.
 

D
. 
6 

5
  6






; <:2* + %!! , 2#8"

"=+2 +</) 

'; +%"0+2: 2, >8&9  2#8" 7
= ;
G;D



7
.
G;D