Dinesh Kumar v. Haryana State Federation Of Consumers Co-Operative Wholesale Stores Ltd. (Confed) & ORS.










 






 
 








  !

"#

$ % &'

(
)*



 "

!+
,-&(













  .

(!-!

(/"
$

( "

 "!-& (!
  % ( 1
+ !2
$ !
304
"0
+ (!














 5#
 63
5 $4
 $
3$
33


 63
5 $4
 $
5,$
4
5


   
     
 
    


   
 3$
33*
4
!
    "   

   #$%



"             &   ' ( ( 

(  )*
)!
+)+, -.  /!$

 0

1
!" 0  00         ,)2         (   1%3 4     0     +56+)57/ 0 (  4           ( (8 4     0    (    

9
3  & :

8  0  :0& ; 

(   

( 0  <   != !6-!$-($ & % 

"

     (     (      :

 ; 0$%

"    

"    

   (

 "   

      0       0  (   +)
)*
+)!,   +)
)>
+)!,   ( 

 ?=!6+)57/ -   3  4  9  1 3  3"  .8$ 3 

 @ ("     <   0 :0& ; $    .       %

(  8  )*
)!
+)+,  (     

A ;

$ 

  

         0   ( 

  ( 

 (0 (        (         %

( 8 )*
)!
+)+,; $B.

   (    . / ! .  /!,               7

/           <  '; 7  $

    7    

0

:0&   

      < C'
D  +
 @          "         ((   0 

   

    (     

 

        "  0    (

 
 3      

    (  

 (  
   ( "   4&%7   (       4      



" "   0 

E  4  

& &/  A   9

-   E&814B$ 

   

( )!
)*
+)!,  ?!
)?
+)!5
   

+!   "

     "     "  '    0  7    

 .   

         !)  (  +)
)*
+)+,
& !)(   

  / #!)
 3 "0    

.          

         

         (     (     

 7   "   0     4&4   

   

  :

  ( " 0   
D  ?
  "  "     

  (    4&%7   ( "  1%34    



     ?!
)?
+)!5
%      0 



.  

 &  ,  (     

   < F    

  (      
& ,(   

  / #,
  1
+  (      4&%74& 0  
3 

   "     

   " (     (  "  F  % (
D  =
  <F  "  G 0   (0 (

      0"  

 (  (      " 
 % 

   

  .

     0  

0    

          < F 
 ' 

 7    " 0   0        "   " 
 ,
  ( 0        4%  1
 ++   =)6=5*=5>=!* !+)@%&*B

&

     !?     &   !6>> "  (     &   "

   (  &    4( '  4     0      09"B  (  ( ("     (   "  

       
    (   (    0  

      4&% ( "    (      "  &814B ( "  4   "  0(

  (  

    F < H        G    
4% "  (   ( -!)$  ( 
   ("  -6$  " 

 (  4%
%    " ' 0   &  < ++
)6
+)++"<F  

 

  0             F    "  
 5
 %   (  (   +)
)*
+)!,   +)
)>
+)!,   ?!
)?
+)!5
      0  "    (     

,!>)))7/"

      (   
%   ( 0 0 "    0     (    "

     (
     " 0("  (           (   4%  1
 ++
   0    +*
)5
+)!6 0      4  & 

 

     ' (        

  (   ( ( 1%3 4     (    (   '    ( 4  (  0        (   " (    ( (  
 &     "      .       



)?
)*
+)!6
 " ' 4% 1
++ !5
)!
+)!5   <  ++
)6
+)++

 0 

 

I (""<F    0(
0 ' '   /  ++
!)
+)++ '  

     ' 4  " 1%34  ( 
 1" "   !5
!!
+)++"

0


 4  

 "      0   0  &   J 0 A "+!
!!
+)++
 *
 %       "          "     +!
)6
+)+? -.  !+$ "  

  (  

  "  ( (  !5 +)

     
 % "  (      0     < F        +)  

    3 

   
%   "  +!
)6
+)+?       

(  <  ++
)6
+)++
   "   "  "0   0   4 0
 >


  )+
!)
+)+? " 0   0   -.  !?$
  (" 
%    ( '

 /  !=
!!
+)+?     ("

"

 (0
A" &A/>=?6/+)+=

"    ((     (  "    +!
)6
+)+?
 &A/>=?6/+)+? "

   !>
)=
+)+=   0  

      

   0 G 

  0      " 0    "" " 0<(       ( 

  (
   ( "     ++
)>
+)+=   "   +?
!+
+)+=
   "   +*
)>
+)+=" 0  0   (  
%  "  (  

 

(  )*
)!
+)+," (

  (  ,)2    (   3 

      0   1%3 4     "  0 (    
((        "    0 
 6
 9            (   

(     0 (

 

       

 <F  

(      
  .

     0  

0    

     <F 
   0   0   +)!,
3    "     (     +)  

      
 3  .    .

    ( "         ,)2      "   0 ( 


 K        <      

 

   "  (
3 0  0     0  0 

     0 (  (   "        

       
  (   "      
 3      0            (  
 %

(    )*
)!
+)+,     /

(  " (    0( 0(   
&'  4% 1
++ !5
)!
+)!5 0 

 (
     (   "   "  0  <    


% 0  (

 (=+
=6'" 

56+)57/ 0  (     
%"     0 "
 !)
 9        (  
 9       

0        0 (( 

 



 <F     
%  . (      ( "         

0   < F    '    +)

  (     (   ( "  ( (
9        0    "      ,)2    !))2" 0 
  (  ( (' ( "       (  "

 
  "   (         < ++
)6
+)++
%"      "  0

 !!
 A        ( (  


!+
 "  7"    

 4  1%3    0       
 9            (   

<F  0(

  (        ""   0  0   
  (   0      (  

  

   0               ?!? &

&
  (   (4% 1
1
++ !5
)!
+)!5
 

   

   L8 !5
)!
+)!5 %        0   0    &814B   
 "  (     0  (

  4
&
%
 "    
 % 

      !,/!5     &814B 4 
3 (   0   "      
 %     0  +)!, %     %  G  <"   
-!

0
$"7/
2!

- 0
"


01 
"
944

+


+
+  (*
+
:

-20
'

( !% "! '2

(
"/
:

(;
0 "

'/
+ &
!
"( (4
+
%/

! 0


01 
+!
2( 0/
'

"
%2 0
"

-



$
%  %0  

   
L !?
 %   

   0       &     

  <F  " 0 

0 "  0      0  

0   <0 7    "  "  

  <F  "

  (       


!=
 %            ( 

  
       00 ("   

0<F              "   

(    0(   "

 0 0 +)

    
& +)

  (   

  / L3   0    

(      
 %      (     &  0         "                    00 

  ("&

  '   (   (  
    0  "00 
L !,
 %  (    

   0      "             (  (  ( 


 %     .   <  !5
)!
+)!5        (      
 "    "  

   +!
)6
+)+?  (( 
 !5
 9         "  0    

    (        (     0     (  ,)2   0 ( 
3       !=   !6-!$-($  &   %    "   (
 %

(  )*
)!
+)+,0 0/

(    < 
 !*
 1  ( "



!>
 9           0     (  "  "    .  < 

    ++5& % 
 !6
 A    (

 <3$
33=











 
<5,$
4
5=
$ % &'

(

)*






 

 A 

(7   M 71 A    0M 71