High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4721/2017allowed

Punjab Roadways Through Its General Manger And Others v. Jatinder Singh And Another

2023-05-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!" # $ % & ' ( )(* + ,

)-"* ( ..,, /

*1*)( ( .

+ "* 2 -+- $ %

..,,

013(

(-!

. 4

5 1*)(

$* (* -!

. 4 7* ,'

- (

( !

. 0

*1*)(( % )( !, *". * 1!

*##8 /(*!,!

-9:: (*

) * . *4 *1*)(; *- $ % & ' ( )(* + ,

)-"* &,, $ %1

7 1

)" 3".

'< -1!

-3( *) (;& % 47 79: (*

(

*)% %* .

) . 4- % !!*

3, *" =*% ,- 11 4 )

( ,* - ( "

9 ". & )*) "2( .

**)(*" !'!,% *))*

*47#>99 (*" (1"

,%*2 & .*,,***)

" !'!,?&( ('

!( %( ( "- *"

"* " !'!, &(*!((,&* &?* (" &(*,

*)% *%'. 4;4 *1*)(* ( ),*) "

" (* (" !'!,

)*) (&) * )) (!, 8. * !* %,*

!?* .!-% ( (,) ) ! (?(& *""*

@ +A-3( *) (-&((& .

. "

* "*

" 9 ? (

- ( & (*

*5.*

,- ( ,* %

" &((**)( ,) ".

?(& *!( ) ?(* *,,

" ( . " , @( (?

* (**)( ,)-(*"

,,* ( %

?(&

%*,,* ) % ' "

**))( , (%

-(( %!"%* * %, . " '&@?( )( .. , "

7!@5 , (!

<*"* - &(*!(B ! *!* ,,*"% -# - 8 "

,A&* () ( %)* *!- ( *,&*

" '*)

( % 47 79: ( !

, *)**$ * *=(' (!

(A& ) )*

C.*' *" (

(* &*). )- (C '

* -4& ,)%'!, (*",

&(*(

. 4 *1*)(* (% &

(

@., !&( (!, ,

! , ! *"

, * " !'!, =(. . ' *"* , (!, *". * A "* & " .

* &

.. * * , *!* .. (*.!

* !, *"

( *) ) " - ,&(*, ,,&*) !, *". **

: -) !".

-#-: 8 -#:- 8&* (*

(

#D . " " (

*,*) (!, *". *,, ,*E

(!, .

%,%' $* ,' ,,' =(* ,

. 4 ))* ('

.. !( (*3 %'& ' *,*) (. , # 4 *! ,& )* -&(( .

* ! ( )(! , A( ( , ! , (.

*%*)*)

( )( (! : =(=*% ,!**)

!*! "

! *!% )( !%' (.

*-( )* !,

**)

*&(*!( !**$ *-

@., ! ( ),*) **) (

*) % %'. 44 *1*)(F(*,!"*) (*!!, *

,( !* (

( !, *)

F* "

* * >CF8-*&(*!((( .

( (* !

)* * ( !, *" . * =( )( ( & ! C "*

,) ( %( , ( . % ( "

* (

3 .,&* (

* "

,A4#

(

! 1!

*9-:-A3 , ( )(4 *1*)(. *) F( *( *)!

%'(* ( ),*) **)

*)% % (*(*!C "*

*-( "*

!*) * ,* (3 30 - . )

(!( ,, & *,

) * (*"* (3 5

(( .. !( '(*)(

(* ') *)(* ,,)

,*".,*!

*=(=*% ,( , !* (

" * ( %"

%'.

% (.,*! >CF83 >CF87&(* (( ,,),'

*B *(

@., !

,!"*)* (*" !'!, % *

, =( !, *) F * (*

* *

>CF8( %"*

(**)

*%' (.,*! %, @.

. (% * &(*!(&

((( "

!"., * ( .,*!

(* * (

A & )* 3**) (

- (, ' " (*,)*)

,'=( =*% , %' )**) ,* *) ( %,* ( * !, &* () ( ..*) -&( **) * ,

%' % & (' !!.

!A %*)

- & , !, *"!".

9 F(*, *) (B " !".

%,- =*% ,( .

" , *.,*" ( "*)

(!,

"*)( ( $% *) - 8." (( ( "

&* ( 5* ,*!"&

@ - - 8 =( . & (

:D * %*,* '1*!(( , (**)( ,) *$ *

* ( % ) ".

=( )( !

*,' . &*,, % %, ,*,*

,. ".

* (**)( ,)

*)*$ *(* .% ((!

% "

,,'!*.., %, '

&@. " *,'!(5( B ! *!* ,,*"%-

" %' *) *!* ,*)( ,)- (* %*,* '

%'(*")

$C A

& '-(* !

* ,* %*,* '!

(" !

@ % D =(=*% ,( &),'"

* * D &

..!

. ($ )"

!"## $"

%- D* %

&( .8*!

*"*%,& ' *)

(" (,'

*!"* (*!

*&@ - - G:

-#:- 8 =(, *)!

!* ( !" : 8 #: ;

: 3**) )

*" % ' - " , *.,* :& *)( ,' ..,***& (, &, * & *

& '

# (

% )"## $" =( - "

8 : C:

=( =*% , ( ( "

& (( .

*)-

"* * ,* -

!( )-

& .!* ,* .

*A"'!*.**- !(

" !

* ! @.

=( =*% , ( ( " !"#$

& . *!,*"% %!"#$ ., !*) (,*"% ' ' , ( )(* *

%,*(!

!(. *!,*"% B *., !*)

'' % (* " !

,,& "

* !(!**)

!*! "

! ( ,( " !"#$ &

,..!

- !"#$ ,

$'" ,*

"*!

,C.-&(*!( .. ...*

'* ! =(

,!".

( !" #-- 8 # =( =*% , ( &),' !".

-#:- 8=( "* ! #-- 8=(!, & ,% , ) * H#D. " " (

*,*) ( !, *" . * *,,

, ,*E

* ( "

#-- 8 ( " !* ** (*)* , ( ,, "

* ( "=(C! " * !*%'!, % %'(*" (&* ( ,

&* (*"

(&* ( ,,% , !* %' *,*) C!

..,*!

*% , F* ( !("* *!

*- ,* ,,&.

,'&* ! 1*! ( "

* ,

,,& .

,'- "*!,, ..,*!

* -* '

*. !!*),' # &'

7*$ ($)*$)++)",-)./)"#0-1 ), ($)*$)++)/,+*"2!) ),