High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/260/2017disposed of

Tek Chand Etc v. St Of Hry & ORS

2018-07-20Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

# $%&" &' ( !) * &+ ,$!-.&+$/-&'&$(&-%,012,3($!-%,&0( 445 '$!%( 6&0(1( 7%$%&"$08$!$$!-$!%,&0 &(4!-&!%(

) 9 3 7

3 0&(&!%) 0(,:$! $5:$0;-<'$%& "0%,&$445 '$!%( 0!+10 %%$5;--5;$08$!$: %, 0$!= ,$!+,$0;;$08$!$

8" 5 !2 %,& 40&(&!% $445 '$% !; 0&< &:" %,& 0-&0 4$((&->8%, ( 10%! * ?

*,$(>&&!(12,%!%,&201!- %,$% " !$558 "0 %,& ($/& $'@1 ( % ! " 5$!-; '/4&!($% ! :$( -&%&0/ !&-. ;

A4&0$'0&< -&0-&0-$%&- ? #

4$((&- !

* !B B"

#% %5&-$(

9 5!2 : %, %,& 0&< &:

$445 '$% !;$445 '$% !(&&+ !2'!-!$% !"-&5$8"B; -$8( !" 5 !2%,&0&",$($5(>&&!" 5&-

3&$0!&-'1!(&5"0%,&$445 '$!%("$ 058(1>/ %%&-%,$% %,&$445 '$!%(: 55!%'5$ / !%&0&(%"0%,&4&0 -"-&5$8 !" 5 !2 %,& 0&< &: $445 '$% ! :&<&0; % /$ !%$ ! 4$0 %8 " '/4&!($% ! "0 %,& ($/& $'@1 ( % !; %,& $445 '$!%( (,15- >& $:$0-&-($/&$/1!%"'/4&!($% !$(,$(>&&!20$!%&-%%,& %,&05$!-:!&0( , ( ( $! $445 '$% ! "0 /45&$- !2 %,& 5&2$5 0&40&(&!%$% <&("-&'&$(&-$44&55$!%&+ ,$!-.&+$/;

:, - &- !

# % ( (%$%&- ! %,& $445 '$% ! %,$% %,& -&'&$(&-5&"%>&, !-! !&%&&!5&2$5,& 0( 0 %,& 0&$(!( /&!% !&- ! %,& $445 '$% !; %,& $445 '$!%( $0& /45&$-&- $( 5&2$5 0&40&(&!%$% <&( " $"0&($ - -&'&$(&-$44&55$!%:&<&0; % (/$-&'5&$0%,$%%, (0-&0(,$55>& '!( -&0&- !58 "0 %,& 4104(& " 0&40&(&!%$% ! " $"0&($ - -&'&$(&->&"0&%, ( 10%

, ( ( $! $445 '$% ! ! %,& >$( ( " C 55 -$%&- ??? "0 /45&$- !2 %,& 5&2$5 0&40&(&!%$% <&( " -&'&$(&- $44&55$!% $/ ,$!-&0. ,$!-&0 7 !2,; :, - &-!

% ((%$%&- !%,&$445 '$% !%,$%%,&-&'&$(&-5&"%>&, !- %:5&2$5,& 0(

B (%,&40$8&0 !%,&$445 '$% ! ("0 /45&$-/&!%" 5&2$50&40&(&!%$% <&("%,&$"0&($ --&'&$(&-;%, ( 10%: %,1% 4 ! !2!%,& ((1&" !,&0 %$!'&!%,&>$( ("C 55;- 0&'%( /45&$-/&!%"%,&$445 '$!%($(5&2$50&40&(&!%$% <&("%,&$"0&($ - -&'&$(&-$44&55$!%;!58"0%,&4104(&"0&40&(&!%$% ! !%,& 40&(&!% 40'&&- !2( :&<&0; % ( /$-& '5&$0 %,$% /&0& /45&$-/&!%"%,&$445 '$!%(: 55!%&!% %5&%,&/%0&'& <&%,& '/4&!($% !,&($/&(,$55>&-&' -&->8%,&D&'1% !2 10%; "

%,&0& ($!8- (41%&

, ( ( $! $445 '$% ! "0 /45&$- !2 %,& 5&2$5 0&40&(&!%$% <&"-&'&$(&-$44&55$!%*71! %E1/$0;:,- &-!

* % ((%$%&- !%,&$445 '$% !%,$% %,&-&'&$(&-:$( 1!/$00 &-$!-,&5&"%>&, !-!58!&5&2$5,& 0;>& !2/%,&0 0 %,& 0&$(!( /&!% !&- ! %,& $445 '$% !; %,& $445 '$!% ( /45&$-&-$(5&2$50&40&(&!%$% <&"$"0&($ --&'&$(&- :&<&0; % (/$-&'5&$0%,$%%, (0-&0(,$55>&'!( -&0&-!58"0 %,&4104(&"0&40&(&!%$% !"$"0&($ --&'&$(&->&"0&%, ( 10%

, ( ( $! $445 '$% ! ! %,& >$( ( " C 55 -$%&- # "0 /45&$- !2 %,& 5&2$5 0&40&(&!%$% <&( " -&'&$(&-

$44&55$!% 71>&7 !2,;:,- &-!? B % ((%$%&- !

%,& $445 '$% ! %,$% %,& -&'&$(&- 5&"% >&, !- "10 5&2$5 ,& 0(; !'51- !2%,&$445 '$!% (%,&40$8&0 !%,&$445 '$% ! ("0 /45&$-/&!%" 5&2$50&40&(&!%$% <&("%,&$"0&($ --&'&$(&-;%, ( 10%: %,1% 4 ! !2!%,& ((1&" !,&0 %$!'&!%,&>$( ("C 55;- 0&'%( /45&$-/&!%"%,&$445 '$!%($(5&2$50&40&(&!%$% <&("%,&$"0&($ - -&'&$(&-$44&55$!%;!58"0%,&4104(&"0&40&(&!%$% ! !%,& 40&(&!% 40'&&- !2( :&<&0; % ( /$-& '5&$0 %,$% /&0& /45&$-/&!%"%,&$445 '$!%(: 55!%&!% %5&%,&/%0&'& <&%,& '/4&!($% !,&($/&(,$55>&-&' -&->8%,&D&'1% !2 10%; "

%,&0& ($!8- (41%&

" # "%&0 ,&$0 !2 5&$0!&- '1!(&5 "0 %,& 4$0% &( $!- '!( -&0 !2%,&=1-2/&!%("!9>5&%,&7140&/& 10% !

!"#$! %&'9 $!-9(

) (*

!"#$! $"';-&5$8"B;

-$8( !" 5 !2%,& &< &:445 '$% ! ('!-!&-

$ % !

" # 3&$0!&-'1!(&5"0%,&7%$%&- -!%- (41%&%,&"$'%%,$%

# "0%,&($/&$'@1 ( % ! !$/ ,$!-$5 $($/ ,$!-&09('$(& (140$;%, ( 10%,$--&%&0/ !&-%,&'/4&!($% !$%%,&0$%&" ;

A4&0$'0& ("0%,&($/&$'@1 ( % !;%, ( 10%,$--&%&0/ !&-%,& '/4&!($% !$%%,&0$%&" ;

A4&0$'0& !

, %/$ !%$ !4$0 %8;%,&$445 '$!%( -&(&0<&%>&$:$0-&-%,&($/&'/4&!($% ! ''0- !258; %,& 0-&0 4$((&- >8 %, ( 10% !

* ?

* ( /- " &- $!- %,& $445 '$!%( $0& ,&5- &!% %5&- % '/4&!($% !$% %,&0$%&" ;

A 4&0 $'0&$( $2$ !(% #;

;

A4&0$'0&$:$0-&-&$05 &0;$5!2: %,$55(%$%1%08>&!&" %( :&<&0;"0%,&4&0 -"-&5$8 !" 5 !2%,&&< &:445 '$% !; %,& $445 '$!%( (,$55 !%>&&!% %5&-% !%&0&(%!%,&&!,$!'&- '/4&!($% !; "$!8 ,&0&< &:445 '$% !(%$!-(- (4(&-" 7

C,&%,&0(4&$+ !2A0&$(!&-) &(A C,&%,&00&40%$>5&) &(A