← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/56909/2023dismissed

Bhupinder Singh Bedi v. Ashok Chaudhary And Others

2024-12-02Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat14 pages

      



!"#"

$% & &

'



 

 



    



   

 %()&*&*&*+, 





 !

" !

#





 $ % &!

"

#



 ' !

!

!

(

) &*&*+, -&./  *



 #&



    

+

, + 

-.). / 0

123 

$ 

 #

 &  

  !

4  !

5

$!



  &  

 1



++  



)..) / 0

13 

$ 

 #

 "&

 

 &!

4   

"  & #





" 

  



 & 6&#





"+&

 "   *



5  

$

77  +!

 



 





&



+  "

 

 +



5

 8

   

 & &

+

 9&+ &!

  



5 "  

 

 

 #

  .-. :5

!



  $+

$ 



5  ""



$

77 +



 +

"

 # +





"+& & #&

"

 + & "

  *





#&

"+&  $ #



 #

 "&

 

 &!

4   



.   

##"&!

+

 + !

   







 # 



 +   

&

&



+ + +



.. 

"  & #





# 

" 

 



 '   ;!

&& # "$&





# 



!

+  &

+

& 



+ *



 '   ;







# 



#

 ""

 



# *

&  "





# 



&& &&

"  & # 

" 

  





"



 # 

  "



 +

"

 

<= '  

).2. 

"  ;!

2>!

(!

;.>

( # =



  



&"



& *5 !

4  

"  & # 

" 

  





& ++

$ 

&  $ 

 &  "+& & +

"



  " 

" -) 

"  & # 

" 

  

 &   &  &

 

""

" 



##"&   $

    



# 



= #"!

  

* 

&

 



!

    



?

 + # + "    "

 

" 



 &&!



##"& # 

 + & 5 &"& &"







# 



"++



"

+ ( @ 



 !

&

"  &    $ &# # 



 

 + & 

 

+

, +  

$ 

  &  5 &&





##"& # 

 +

# +  

  

&5 *

 " 



" -)     " 

 $&

$&"



    

  # $&

" "

+ & "

  #



## "

&& 

 

$

"++

$  + 5&

 

" 

     "  $&"



 



&" # 

& &

5  ##

6

 "  " $&"



  



  

 "

#

  

$  + 

" 

# 

##"&

  5

 $&

" ; = 





& $+  +

$ &

"  & #



  





"

> " -) # 



# + &  "





"

$ &5 #



#"& #

#

"



   

  

      

             

      



     

'    

     

  

 

    ! 



" 

 #   

   

               

    

   

$    %  

   

               

    

   

 &  &   '(    

 



      (   

    )*+      &    

  "

, &   ,

    "

,   ,   - .  /           !       

       1  $ 

 

 

" 

     - )2&   

       

  # .  

  

 



1          

             

    # 

  "

,   ,

   "

,&   ,   3-

 ) *

: B$&



+

 

"



&5

&   

&"$& # 

  # " -)  

+

#  



 



!"#"#$%& '

 ( ) *+""

 &

 #&&5 4)-2

  5 

 

   

"    



  67         (      67) 8 &79 :

  (0 6+)-; 

"        

      



  <;

       

 

- ).-  2  5    

  

 67   ( 

67)  &79 :

  (0



   8 

  

       

  

  

 

   

  

 -    =   ,    - )./$%&01  ( ) 22'

,---(    





 

   

!    > 

 ------2  >      

      

        

   

   -/   

  

---,

 ))-  ;  3/        & /   $ / '+*"))#  '

,.---   

  



    



-  2             



 



 

-2

                 

 

     "  

        -/

       

  

  

  - & 

     

   

   

  - 2

     "    

 "  -2 

  

    

                          

    "    - 2

          

  

 "

       "   -/    

 

  

   

 

  -  

  

  

   

   

  -; 

     

     - ?"

  @   

2

A @ 

A @

"  



A  



  

   -0          

"   ---, )B-  ; $(3  /        

 $%&  00

 ( ) +#  

5 1   &(/4(   $%&+5 ) 2+6  .74(   $%&25 )  5 ( 

  .7&$%&28-) "8 '

,---2         '

; 

   

> 

 67

  (  67)% 

      

       

    %                         

      >        

   

%   

 



 

 

           

                

 

 

---, )*-&67   (  67) C6C    

           (         5 D 

 (  5

 0  &



3   

          67        

   (   67)-  2       (  67)       (  - )+-;&  



7

/)/

'

*!

  '

,7-2

 &67 



                 

  "      

  

    

    -2 

        

 > 



     



  

                            "      

-2

                 



         5  -;

 

 

 "



      

  

 

"



 

   

-2>      

    

   

   

 

     

     

           

   -= &67       

  

          

            

  

  -; 

 > "        

   





     -2         

    -; >       

              



  -,  

 )7-;   

7

/)/

'

*   

  "

,

   ,    

     

        -  67   (  67)  "

 

  

             -  2     

 &    



                 

  - )C- ; /

3/&(-- ,     . (- $%&  00   (  )   "8!    "

    5 &67 

 (       

  

          67        

 (  67)-2  '

,C-/    67 

 (  67)  

 

    

 

 

  

 A   

   - =   "        

   

 

     - 2         - 

 # @   --     

    

 

  --A        

            @

A- 6-/ 

   -;               

     -;

         

     @ A  8  @A%          8  @  

 A%     @

A% 

        

    @  A-  /        8    

  

  >      

    

   

 

     -  2          

 



  

  -;

    

  %

       

  

              

       

  

  

   

    

    

%  -E         

            

  

 



  

  

 

      -2   

    

 

      

   > 

 

 



 '    

   



  -, )6-2   &67    (       ;$

(

, $%&1  ( ) 1    '

,---; >         

     

  

   67   (   67)  -,;

    

 

   

-;      

  "

 

   ---, B9-;./ / ,9 /'*2))   '

,C-;  > 

  

         

           



 

   

     

     

 -, B-;   :

9(    ,- '

*   -(

   =     " &+

= (0 6*   & 79 :

  (0 

 

,   , ,      

    ,- B.- ; F "

 F

 :    

   

   ,

, A G G" B?-

 '

,

, ,   5      

   

 

    -, B)-2    

  ,

& A  D

) ?   ' ',

,  

  



           

  

 

   

  

         F

H

  -=@  

A @   

   

  

-, BB-  0 

      G   G"

      ',;

                  -+        



      - 

 

   (           "     



     A D

  -2          ,   ,- 2 = 

 "

&!

= 

5 

#  

"

$ 

  &   



 '   (

"  



"  # 



##"

!

 !



 ' >

)





 



# 



 

" 



!

5" 

5  ""

  $ 5 #

&

+

?

 !



"+&  

"





+ + + "

#& +



  

 "

#  "

 7



  , &!

 & *!

5

&& 





# +  

##"&  !

 5 +     

 " 

" -)  = 

 " !

  

$  





# +  

##"&  

#   

"

0"

 # 

 !

$ 

5

6

" " $ 5



"



# + "

# ##"&  !



0"

 5&&  $

##"  





$&"



  # 

 "  :5

!



 " !





"  6 "

#

   

"

#& +

 

 !

!



 " 

" -)  5&

$

&$&

 





' - *!

#   +

 

    !



+



 $

+

& &

'

 .&*&*+,1 +

    C 



?  

?'

C 

 $&

?'