Atul Gupta v. State Of Haryana And Another




   

  



  

  !

"!  #$!%&!      

 

! !&#'"!&! &()& #* '#! '$!% !# !&+ (!+ &,'"! !&!("!#&!('"!!-






   

  .&!& & !# /0 1&!%-*!,# !,&#&'

0,**! !*

 34-  

!*! !

#

' 50 6
71&!%-%%#&'

0   ##!

'

!

*!(
 1!&!&  

'&"( (( & 8&&

*&&%!


'&(8&

6&!!7 %(& %'8&! &(  !3%(% *"! &!!92&(%"  !&!

!&8&&!:% * ;#(2!'

'&!



&!&& &!<,*!"8!&!92' 8&!&!2 %2 &&% ! 8&&!=&&

"

!!%*'&!*"4

&! !&!!

92$ &!&!&&8

!!&(!%'

&8

"! &!292  !&%&( &!!.&!!'&  !%!'&!"  &% ! 8&&!(%( &!&!  2 &(%2%=&"!&! 2 & &% ! 8&&('&*"2*&!:&2& ( '&348!*! 0 >!    !  &  !   2(  &  & !&2  %( &!   $   2(  &  &  !    &  (   8!   ! &!(&%!

! 

! 

'&% 2& 2 **(!! * '

&!

"&( ?& ,*!(!(&!!!

(!!*8&&  &!&( '8& 29    &  (!!*'  !

!

%  2   &  !     "!3

8*&!'&( ?!

 & &!8!!&348 !*!  4   !    &  '  !    !  & !& !!&*!&6< ! 
7&8 &  &  ! &  28  &  !    (   8  $ !&! 2(&

&( !*&"2 !("28&!(! (@!*
 6< ! 07&2!28&! &2&:@' /


6



% A#$!%&!7&2 2%&!

,*B &*&34&2(!(;:@
 .&( !&!*2!& ! 0 &

8*!!
 

    

           !"

#  $% & '! ("     ) "! 

!" *# + ", 

-

    " 

    -     .

    " - - /0-

-    1 

    

2  %(

3 )* &  4 5

"

 " -

         .5  "

"    -     "      

" -

6   



   " -

  6

 6 

          -

-



- 

-





6 

 "     

   " - -  7

" 

  .-    "

5 "  5

" - - 

. "     " -  

  9   0 )

 6

!

+(, :

"" " .      

 +

-4 !

- (4 "

  "" " .      

 4 

- 6"  "

 7

" 

     

   "- " - - ".6 

  7

! " 



     3   3    "     .   

9   ;; 



 < - - 5.

"

 

     . 4 . 



 "



. "

"

 /+50 







5    

9  . 6- " 3  "

  - 6  

"

   "4  -  6  

      

/"

"

 " - - 

  " - -           

5  

 

-

 

             6     

 6  .4  .   ""  % &-       

""  





  4 4

"

 " -  

5  "

-

"

  0 

/+50 

      

!

="

"



.  3.  9   (> 

 ;    (     

  " 

      



. 5 - 4

"

  

   ""



"6 6? 9  

 "  

 "     "

   . . 5     

-5 ""



"6 6@ >! !&! !&!!!!& (    &  (   !!  2!  &  &  C 

*!//

'8&&! !
!   -" -

           !"

#  $% & '!

) "  !   !" *#  , 

-      "

 

" - - 

. ".6 -

 "" 

-5(, 6"    4 

5

 

$  -"  "

   "  6



   "  

 "" 

 "

 4  .>"  .

 - 4  -  -5 6 6" 5 081

.  

-

*(A

$ !&! 2(&&!2&&2!   

" "%&!$  2( &  "*    &  !      ( D  &

   !'&8"!'&!*!%2!(.&!  , % ,!2 (

&!!'!



! 8

2!"2%*&!2&&2!

!!' !# &"&( % &!%!!*!!*

&!&*! & &

**&!!!  !$8"!'& 

! & &&

&2!'

&8"!'&!*!%2!(#&&   % !
/

& !8&&,!! !& %!'&!2&&2!(! &  (&&" "%&!

4&"&! ! !&!!

& !! / +*"8& %!&!8&&  (&
%&&&(!(&2   28  &  !    &    2!*  - /


&2 2%&!!B &*&34 &  2    &  (!(;:@    8&&'  "  !!  

0 '  &  !  8!  !    !  2!  &  4

B *!; %  *!  !  !!  &!  (  B (!(D&

&2!D&!*!%2!(D &!" "%&!&! (%, !2 (

'&!!'&!!!2 ! !*

 !*! & !&*2 2; !% 2&4

B*!;.!  !

.&!* %  $8"!'  %&*  2!"  &!2"  &

   2 !<!&(!& (!& !*&! % #&# "#"$  
 

 5    =&&!,*;! );- =&&!!2  );-