Surinder Pal Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
"
# " "
$ "%% & '('
! " )*+( #
! ,& -!. , '
/ /
/
0
-!. , /'
/ / " / ,
$ %&'()(**+(,,- !.)* /( #0 1"234"1"3"5 %6 !+( (*,7*,- !.)* /( #0 1"89:1"3"5 %%*!+(-
- &;*< /
/
0
'
)<((7 .,.*)66=&/,*7 *7,,*)66,/(*.<&+((-*&)(-<((7 **6*<,<)6!)!!(&+(*)66.!) "
(*'/<.>-(/*)**'/6#0 1"234"1 "3"5
: (&+((*7 -( *'/( =&*(+/6 &+!/)*!*!"839"3"5 ?& 1"-* <)*6&!<> ! "-+*!+7*!<*!/*6 *)(*>* '**- ,)' *&>*- )(* &-<!6 &+! ,)*, ,,1"3": ?& 18/*6 *)(*>*'**- ,)' *&>*-
) (* & &( ( (*. &+( * 6*!*6& !)+ ( ! )) & !* ( ,)*, ,,1"3":
?& 18 / *6 *)(*>* '**- ,)' *&>*- ) (* &* ( ./@( &;*<* ,)#66
)-995A(*//!*( )/995-*7,,*@(
&;*< *)(*>* ,)&,-995A(*//!*(&, /995-*6**(*)>/ ,)*,,, 5 ( *.(* ! "&!*/)* /"839"3"5 ?& 1"+*!+7*!<*!/*6 *)(*>* ,)' *&>*- )(* &*!.*/ *)((7*! 7.-7(+*!*6 *)(*>*'**- ,)' *&>*- ) (* &-(7*!(*.<!.!!&.,>(<*/ ,)*, )!* 8 (*,*-,) +*6!*!"B39"3"5 ?& 1: 7*&!.!/)*<> ! :*!(6*7 )(!&,!)66)(*6!*>"B39"3"5& ,,353"3"5 7.-(.,76*!*.*,*<,( &<,)*!*,> *! !6*! &! ( & / 6!* (* ( //) / ! "6*!(.,/*6 *)(*>*'**- &<,) "B39"3"5
/345%% $ 6 3 6 $ 7%% 2 (,*!)&,/( &<6(*/6( &*,/( ,)*,,, ?& 18 *7,, *(6 &+!
/)*/"839"3"5 ?& 1"-( /&!(*( *6*>,,+*,( ,)*,,,*7,,*(/)*/ 7*!<*!*!&,*,>((,!+/,)*6 *)(*>* '***((<*/(*/*! & !!/). ,)*, ,,*!(<*/(6 &+!/)* ?& 1"-(& 7&,!<,,+*,*!.,*./( ./( )/995-<! /(&,/995 B (> /&( &<6 (* . (7 ( 7*! / ( (*<)(*+!/6*(</(,)-<& ( )*6'7*<&(*6**,**+-7(*-( *6*+*( ./( &;*< *)(*>**; )-995 (*//!*( *)(*>**; ) 4 (,*!)&,/( 7(,6*'+(*! &<6,>& *;&!+6!,.!<>(#&)*<*+ #0 14"931"3:-,!*@3
9 55% :'
/ $ 3
A(*!;&!+6*)(*,,+7*6*! ()*/7*!*/( **/,)*,,,*!*,*/( &<,)*/(,))(!&,(&*(6,*( &*(*)* 9 7.-7(,!*++7(()(*,,+*!(- <>(,*!)&,/( -(#&*,,&!!)*
+&!,7()())& **+* (:/(;&!+6& *- **+* ( 7(/<)6?*)!(*/
!
! !
!
"
! #
$#
%
! !&
'
( ) (
' '
*
+ $ '
& , +
- !
).* $/$$$/! $0$$$#
1
2
1
2 ,!
'
*
3
3
'
' '
, + !
+ $ + $' ' '
!
!
! + $ $' ' ' 4 ) + *
.
! 4*53 60/66*
60$3 $0$#$'
&
73 % , * 1
8
9 9
!
$:); '
5!
5!
!
<%
<' !
4 )
=
2 & 4 !
* (
4 4 !
* (
, * 2
!
& 0 <% 4 )
$ <'
= <%
& $$ > %
&
+
)* !6
! > !
!
+
#$#$ $$
!
? + * * @'
##:' '
A $;
!
! * :. ; , * ! 73
:; % *
! + ) ! + )
:
;, *
+ )
, * + :; 3
! 3 :;
! + ) :; 3 :
! + ) ;
:
; !
, *
! . :;( *
! 2 & ) , *
2 & ) , +
, + :9;% 4 )
! * !
=
3 :3); + $' !
4 ) B ! $$ ! 6 * 73 .
+ ) !
! * :. ; 1 8
!
9 $C
+ 9
! , * 6 ! & . + ) . + ) . . .
. ,
9. 9,
&
$C ! !
& &
' ! + ) + ) ..2 & ) :
! $C;
, . ! DE 3 ( ) , *! ( ,*- ( ++* ()*, )+&>/(7*!-(*+6/!//*,&6<( (6*!%.-(<)6? !()>=&*( &,*/*)(/(7*!<+*/** <,<+*6 6,* &(6-(*,))&*!)&=&*()*/* .*/* ,)*(/-.1*1.-(.!)*+ ))!-<&<*+6!( ) ,/ *,>/ &,* / ( .! )*+- (& ( *, &,* / ( *6
*)(*>***))! *!!-(* )*/<&!*-(&( (* + / !1,6* / ( 7*! *, <)6 *! ( <)6 )!! <> * )&C <)6+ )!&)! <> ( #&
*6))!(/-(* !1,6*(**' ,*)6/()*!D/( &,*(7*!))!- 7(<>(**)>/77*!<+)*!*(/ &+((* +/<!., 6*,7'-(&**6),., " 7.-.(&,*+(*,,6/(& &6< ( (6*! ( .,,*+- <)*6 !7, & ( !) )/(*<.*)*! **+* (52/(;&!+6 & *- **+* ( 7(/ <)6 ?*)! (*/- 7(<> *
6*!*6&<)66*!& (+.6*,,(&&6< *,,((&(.,,*+))! "!
&
73 % ,!
& 8
!
+ * % * +
, *
&
F 8
% 8
, * * + G *
&
8
%
68
!
! !
% 4 ) ) '
6
9. H + *
0
4 ) #$
8
E
: 7.-(*,,6/(&&6<((6*! (.,,*+))!-!**,,)*>*/&()*-(*/( D/(!7,,+&,*+-(<>*)>*+.1*1.* * /((&=&+/*,,+7((<&!*/(( )*!7*!6/(!1,6*?)-*<)6*' &&*)()&C<)6+)!&)!/-(/&()=&) (/-(*-(66</(!7,,+&-6*> )./(& &6<<)6+*,,!*>(6*!-*(<)6,!* .((7*!))!)(<>( *)(+/(+(/?)+//*)(<>*>/(66<* !7,,+&&,*,>-./((66</*>!7,,+ &*,!*.((7*!))!-(<>( *!,6!&///6*>+,,+*,>6 > 5 (/-(6(7 *!(*6 *(<>!6!
;/
/
0
<
" '(' ;/ " / , < 6
" 7 =% 9> &
#> 7 46&
#>