Randhir Singh And Others v. State Election Commissioner, Haryana And Others




































  
        
  



  !

"# $ %$ &

   '

   '




 )!*!

'

  +

,, ''

-     '





,#

 .+ ,'$ '

 + ' ++  .+ ,'$ '

 



  
 
  
 
 




 


! "#
$!
% "  &&&& + ' ++- $




 "
 


## 

'
 
 ( #

(

 

##
) * 
$ 
 

 
 

#

+,,+,, , -
 .(

#


 

##
) * 
/ #
 
$ 
 


#

.
#

+,,+,,
 
 

. 

#
1 
 "
 (  $

.(

(
 
.
2+,+,,
 3+,+,,
-
 .(

'
.(





(

# 
(





#

.

 
##
)
* 

%

(
 
 


 

# 
##


#

##(
 (


# 



.

.(

(
 
'
  


3+,+,,

,  '
##



(
#( 


#

.



  
 (

(
 


. .(



  
(

4++

5 
'


## 

#"
#(


#

.


 
  
  # "
(




/ 

. 
 










# #(


.  
."
'
-




'


#"



#


 



#
1 
 "

4 6



#




.(

 

  
 .(
."

 


# 
 


##

,++,+,,7+4,+,,
.


#
-
 
 
 "


'
 #
.
( 

(

 




.(

# 


# 


(

(



.(
."




(
. 


#
(

4++









#
#  2 / 

( 
 




 
  #



#


 








"
 
  
# 8
9

 
#



#


  

  

#






  



 "


 




(
:

) ,,;

- 





.
  ; -

 



 #  
.




."

#
(


 #
,24 <

- 

 #
4,3

- 
#



.



4 ."
1 #
(


1

0 



 
-=


- 
>4 

( ( 
33,
 (
 

 
,2+2334

% " 


"
)
 
332



332  
 (#
 



 
,,+2332
1
,+


332  
#

 

# 

#


>

>+


332




.

(


    $ 
1#
1 ##

) ?



 
) 
 "
0
 "



 #


 (


#


#
 

@

.

0

##"
"

A


."


 "



B#
1 ((





  
(

 "


# 
'

>;


332
 
 

 




1#
1 
 "
)

 


 
#

.  #

.
#

>;


332


  /$


-

#"
"
#

((.

!

( 

"


"
(

C#
 


!

( 

"
1 (
D 1 ( 
 
D  



"
(

C#
 
 #"

.




0
."
 "




#
."
 "


0# 

 


#




0 # 



("

 "
(
 "
"



#

 


 
#


 "
)

 

 
#

.  #

.
#



2 


0 

,

 ##

)  




:



##  


?


 




##  

#"

##
"



 #( 

#


( # "
 

.

#"
# 
##






  


# #(
##






@

.
 "
 



 (
##

 "


 
(



4
##
#



. 

 
 #"

((.


 

(
# #  
##
.
 
."

(
#



2

-

 #


 0 "

#





 


 ((


 


( . 8

##

 
 
 


 0# 





#
("
.
# E 
-
 #


 0 "

1#
1







 



 0# 

.
# @


 "


.
(  #"
) @



#










.
( ##"



."
( 



"

."
 "




((


 



."


 



#
 

."

( 

 

#
) "
 


"
 
 

 

."
 "

 (#




 #

 

- 

 
"

(

#






##
.

 
 

8
("
.
#@F

.
- 
 "


 
,E 
F
 


#"

#"

 
.


( 
 



##



"


(

 


 



 








  (.
#
 
  


.
"


  



( 
 "
0#"

 



: 
. "

 




 
##
 #
 "


.
  

 #
 
##
.



 #
(.

#
 




. 
 


 
 
("
.
# 
."

# 
 




)



(

 ("
 

8



##
.
(


((



 







 

 





 

 
  "


 "
( "

#.#

 

 #

 "
 #



 #

 "
 
) "
 "


@

.
 




 
 "



 




 


 

(
. 







 "
( "

#.#



 #

 "
 #




 #

 "
 

) "

 "


@






"(
  
 "

 #



#

"

"
 
 

( # 

((.

 (#"


 



"
 ##  B:#
G



 ##
.
(


.

;

((
."





. ((

 #



."






 #

 #
 "







# B:#
,G
/
:

H #H
(

"
 #


.#

. 


 





##
."
(  #
 
  
 
 

 


   3
/
% I.#
(
1 


#"
#

  )

%
1 #
,,;

- 




(

# 

#



 #


 ."
 %
1 
#
:

# 
 #




(   ##"


 
.



J ## I  
 " 
 
  (#



#

  


.
#


.


.
 

# !

#


.
(

)(

% I.#

(
1 


 

          

         !"#$%


&  '

  (  ) 

* 


 +

   ,-.

/&%0  *   

   #

   "

 1

      !000"# .&2 /!, 3

 
  !0!0 "#.&/666 + % I.#
(
1 

"

1

7


#




 #
)(

#
  H,'
B#
 
 
) 
 
#
  .

  
/ 
 #


> #

"

 
.



1 
.

A



"


 #

 #
9 
"


#
 







"
 
K

 ##"



 
 





#



"


 

(

"
 ##






 .# 
"






 





#

     
 #
 
/ 
: (


.
 

# 

#

 4+
/

: 
 #
4,3 .



 


 #
,,;


1


/

1

L



#

 

 #
  38
 

#"
("@

("
. 
."




.
 

 ("
 

 "
 (

/

.

 


 
 #
4,3



  #
,,;
 

 
A

(
## 


0


 
,8

  
!##M


/
 






 


 ##"
:

#


K
  

1






 ( ."
  A 

) #

(@
 #


#



#  (  "






 
 


# 
### 


A





  
 
/ 


 A
" 
 

#

 

.
 


  




  




 


 


 A

## 
 #
#"

.




(

"

4
/





1



'

#"
(# "



M ##
.

##
 M


. "

4,3 .
 
 
 

 
 

  # .#"
#
4,3 .
-

 

 
M ##

0

# M

. 4,3 .

 
B# 

   % I.#
(
1 

3

7



"


 

 
#

N<


#


(  "
 
."


 




 
) 

 
("
-
 




.
:


."

%
1 



(


  ##"

 #


.

#
 


("

(#
."

O , 5##
L


%
1 




) 01 )2 (!$ 3  "

44 !!

"

"5 -  6&7 
 6
1 37 8-
#
 # 
 :



) #



.
0

# A

.

) 

#
  N,;
/


( 
)( 
 









1 
##

 


H ## 


0 H

H# H



H# H

.  ,>

H# H


 #
 
((





."


! 

( 

4 ,


 #
 
/
# 
#
."



B#
1 ((


/
M# M

# 
 



( 
 "
  





#
/ 



H ## 
0 H

H# H 

  


H# H
 #

.
  

 #
,,;

- 



 "

 


 #




 (

3
#
 #
.

."
# 

 



B#
1 ((


/


( 

#


  
##

.




 )

%
1 
#
,,;

- 

%
1 M
 
) #


( #"

 


(
 





#
 

#


) #
 #
"
)(


("
.



."

B#
/ .

#
#"



>4

B#
1 ((

O :
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
::
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
,3
% 

%
1 M
)





   




 #
.



 "
(


 




  ##
 0 

 
A 

:

#


#


.) # 



 #

.


## 
 
0 



) 

 #

.
 # 
."
# 
  



("
# 

 / 

 
 

 #
,24
C!

.




# #"
 #


# #
 
:

  
 #
(
 
 #"
 




# 
 



## 
0 :
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
::
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
44

 #


 

 #
,,;




 

)(

% M.#
(
1 



 
. 


 
 
# #"
 # 



# #


((









 #
 
 "
 


  
H# H
 #
.
) .#
#"
."
"

 
-


."
1

#
(





((

(


 #

.


.# :




#(
: 
 
. O 4 /
1 

& 1

 ) & * 

+ 

8    9:!$! :!0!!
 

+2,+,4 #
##  




 
#


%
1 




 #

(
:


) #
,,;

- 

  2 

(



# 
.

 #
.

(











)



.
 

:

) #
,,;

- 
 (

.
## 
."
A





(
#.#






#
!

#

.
(
 )(
$
L

1 

19,''>

,+,
 

 ;

1  

 & * 

;

5    

+3+,,+, !0!

.6/. /%6-
 ( 

.#






 "
(

.
A

.


 

(#

#


  
/




# #"
A

##

# '
 
 
  .

A




 


 


  

##

#

#(
 # #"


 




.
 "7/ .

#
 
.

#"
:# 
."

% I.#
(
1 



 &  '

7 

 8 -


 




#



#

 

 .#

  

 "



  
 ##


."

1 

:

) #
,,;

- 

  ; 
 ( 

.


 > /
 


#"




 ' -
 


:



( 


##


 ( 


 






6+ ' ++7



6



7 

$ %$ &

# 9 A 7 

 P 7 9  .#
P 7