Sukhwinder Pal Singh And Others v. Punjab School Education Board And ANR.
!"
& $'( %()!*!"+ , -./01!"%(2 $3-!"40$"%'0(2*
."5$6-)03%.)$'!"$2%$"%$"'0(2 + 78 - - +
999 :
!"
! # $ %&'(
)
* %(+
"
, $
* %(+
"
-
! ..'
/ ! 0
1 2+ ! % / / ! %&34 ""
%3%%.3%'
/6 7%&+'% .3%#
0 $
*
!
! $ $!
"
"
"
$ $ $
*
(
.
"
)"
) 8
!$/ ) $ * - $
"
!$*
%3%%.3%'
$ 89-
!"#$!# "
!
! ;
<24
*
- / !
!$-"!! *
%&% & 8"
!"
*
"
)
' () )&
*
$ " $)"
!
##
0 !
!
$
$
* ! -! * ""
)
$
!
- /*
!
-
$" ) * !
!$
"* *
$
)
"
!* 8
$*
"*
*
"* ,
)
! $$ *
" *
*"
" $
$* ! ! $ $""
!
$"
= !- *
!
$ !* !-5!" #+
!-
>?!
?!
)@
-
$ * * + , -) , ' .%
"!* ""
$ *
"
#4
0
!
""
"
"
$ * *
-!
"
* A
* B :
*
"
C 7
!
!
!-$ $
-!"
$
/
B
"
(
.
"
! !-$
* - "
! !-$ ! $ !$ $ $* !
/6 7%#'42 .33(
"
"
!- ?!*
7.2'
.3%#
"!
-
%#%..3%'
$
$
$
: *"
"
! 7
*
A
B
! *
!
!-$
"
*
"
(
.
"
! !-$
"
-
89- /!
" *
!
!
"!
$ !
%3%%.3%' 0 !
!
!
*
) 0% 1
%+3#.3%+
2 *
) ,
3 1
323&.3%+ 8
"!$
!
!
%3%%.3%'
/6 7%&+'% .3%#
$ *
/6 7%&+'% .3%#
"
!
$ $ $
" *
(
.
"
"!
)"
%#
:
*
!
*"
*
"!
?!*
89-
/
B
"
(
.
"
$
- $ 89- 7 +' 4.
4(
/
B !
! ;
<0
! - !
! -
8"
"
!5- 1 A/6 %2+&'
.33(B
%%%%.3%% -
-*
-
8"
!5- 1 5 "
1 A ((+ .33(
+%.33&B -
-* 6 $
!5- 1
5 !$ A %3.2 .33&
(34.3%3B
$
*
* "*
-"
$ ::
::
::
::
8"
"
$
E?!
?!
)9 $ * * * " *
*
! - ! *
)B ?! !
$
* A- /!B
"
$
!
-
"
*
"
$ "
:
?!
$
E?!
?!
)9 !$$F
!
"
2.
- 8 $
! !
!
6 -!
* ) "
! "
!5- $ * *
-!
"
- - $ 0
!"
! *$
$ * *
$*
!
"
!
-
$
$
"
* ) *
"
!-
"
)
"
$ * * $ $ $
$ *
!-
!
-
"
$ * *
"
* 0
$ *
?!
-
$ - ,! $ * $ * *
* *
!$$F
!
"
2.
-
!-
E?!
?!
)9
-
$ * * "
$
"
* "!* ""
$ *
"
0
!
""
"
"
$ * *
-!
"
* A
* B :
*
"
C
! 89-
/
B
"
" ! $ !
7.2'
.3%#
/6 7%#'42 .33(
"
;
< "
! !
!
)"
! - !"
%+%..3%2 !
! *
= *
-
*
!
!$
= * 5!
)
$
:
- ! $-"!*
$ $"
0
-
! !
4
!
!* "
89- !
$
/
B
1
%+%..3%2 $
$
: *"
"
!
*
A
B
! *
6
-
- $
C 0
-
"!
""
"
!
"
*$
(
.
"
$ !
- 5 6
7 , ' 8 + &- - $-) &.9 .
!#$*
$
7 (3
(% !
! ;
<(3 !
"
"
!
$ $ " * !$$
$
"" G$ H =
""
!
- !
- $ 8 "
! ,!*
! $*
" -* $
"
*
I *
"
!) -
*
-
"
"
$
) ?!
"
"
-!
$
" $) "
$
?!
?!
) : *
$"!$ !
!-5 J"5 "
"
$
!
$ ! $ $*
$!! *
!
$ $ "$ "$* $ $
!
*$
! !
$
"*
*
=/ "! !
"! .3%3
$ $
! !
= *
*
- "
$ - !
$"
?!
)
I
* !
!
$ J"5 "
1- .' .3%'
*"
"
"
,!
"
B
+ 0 .
!4#:0 **; !"# $44
$"
< + 0 1,< .:3 "
) +3 4.
$
*
"*
-"
$
"
*
" *
%3 -
"
$! " "
J"5 "
B
"
$
$ * !
$ (% / ?!*
!
% .
"
+ -
!
* *
?!
>%#'33 (&%33
*
!
! * >'333
>.%'33
=
>.#'33
!!
J$-
= *
$
* $ -
?!
! !
$ * * = * "
J"5 "
"
* ! 8 !
"
* *$ !
! *
"$ !
! 8"!
*
" =
$ !
*
!
!
$$ *
! ?! !$-
0
! * $ E $ "9
!-5
- ! : !$ -"
%2 %'
! / !
!
"! =/
*
)
!
* -
-*
!* 0 !
$ -
!
$!
$ !
"
$ $$
"
"
!* $
! " "
*
"
$
!
* $
"
/!C 0
!$ $
-
"
$
)"
! -
$
/
B
!
"
/
B
!
"
"!
%3%%.3%' "*
%3%%.3%'
$
$
:
"
! 7
*
A
B
! *
6
- $
*
* ""
( .
,
; <
)"
;
K
7
-
;
K
7