High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5992/2023dismissed

Sanjay Gupta v. Ashwani Kumar And Another

2025-02-06Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji11 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*++

!"# $%& (!&

(' ) ,-

+ .- )& *

& + !%

!, '-(.,

#-+ , '-(.

!&(0!

1 & (' 22222

- /+ -

& &5#&#( 1(.###( .,

!&#/& &/&&'

76 .8

'& .!0 #%0'

'0% (&'& 9 , , '

''##( :# &#. 9'0, 1!'#0&!, . <&'

.( &#0 5!/ 5%# /(&0'

/5&#.'

&#. . .'

!&(

= 5%# !& &-#( '

>, , &5#& 3&#5 .( # #0 /#- %%5&

1!0#0 "&', . !&#

1(&, /& !&#0

., '# %# '

1!0#0 (&'&

&.!

;, , .#-# &-# #( /#'

.#-# &-# #( '# %# '

3!&/&, &-#"

##( /#', "!#.!

/# .(-&'

#( >; ? (&'& 5&& , 6,

1((&'# ?.!

!# #' '

& , #. % #0'

&5#&(&

#. &# ! %& &/&&'

#'' &5#&(&, 1((&'# ?.!

(#'

#'' &5#&(&, "!( ''#.'

'# 5" &# ; &# 5%#'

&# '#.#( ( &(.'#0 .%#'

#( %5& 6, 4 #'

.!0'

5/(& ''##( :# &#. 9'0, 1!'#0&!, &5#&#( 1 @(; 4

#' '0% (&'& 9 , , ''##( :# &#. 9'0, 1!'#0&!, '# %# '

., 5#0 '-(#'

%&# 1!0#0 #%0'

'0% 9 , , & <&'

.( /&!& .('

!& &.##( -#'. ! /#'

+ #( .( #'&#( > A'#

-#'. ., >4B.#( 4 ?!&# + ! 5!#,

!(& 7?8

A &0'

!& .(&. 5" &# !&/(&, /#'#0 &-&

#( !# '&" '.# #(

.0+ A 5%#'

"! &5#& 3&#5 + #( .( #'&#( (%!#0 #&&- '.# #( &&#-'

, ! .!

'.# #( //&

&-& # !('

#' 6 <&'

.( &#0 5!/ & (' 5%# (5.#( &0&'#0 &# '#.#( &5#& 3&#5 + !&#

& (' &(.'#0 &!&%(&, &&.##( -#'. . '( ''#.#0 .

/& &.##0 -#'. .% /#'#0 (% 50 (( (&'

.('

(&0 % &/.'

5((+ &# %##'

&!&%(&, %( # ' 5 .#% .('

-#'.'

5((+ &#

= /&!& 5%# &0% &0&'#0 #.5## > %# .'

1!#/ 9'#.#

0# & !'

&(& ='"&##0

C&, 9& , , &0&'#0 #0& 5#0 /(&0'

/5&#.', 5#-5

#0& + !(( .( .(%&'

/& 0 5( &

3!&/(&, &0% . &# '

( 4 3!# !&'

5%# #( .( &# & '

%&# &.(&' > &(% & %5& 6, 4, # & !&# 5#0 ("& .('

(&0 '

(& '#//& +#'

0&#.& &('. 0&'

& '%#'

&#(' 6;

50 (( (&'

.#% "#!

& (' & - #'

50 ((

,,B (( (&'

@(-%5&, , 5 #.

% &&'

.#%, '# '#//&. &( 5" &#

A 5 0'

' !#0!

%&+ & , & (' ('

% "#!

##( A (&'& & (- '# '#//&. 5" &# , &'

#( &# 4,

.#%8 . !'

&.#. &.(&'#0 '# 0(('

&.#-'

.('

(&0 !#& 5((+ &#

&('.'

(&#0# 5((+ .(##0 0 :&#0 &5#& &(.'#0 !'

& , % ..'

&5#&(&

'#'

.!0 &# &#0 (&0 (( )0 @( 5((+

!((.( (&#0# 5((+ &# &.(&'

&-#( &(.'#0 C'

% .#% A &0'

5!/ 0(('

-& (&'

"#!

!#%

3!&/(&, (!#0 !'

&&'

.#% '# &/&&'

&5#&(&

>, /-(& .#%

.(% #(

,,B (0 "#!

#& >E & % "&''

C.#( .#% :.%5& >, % .( '

. .(5& ,

/& '# %# (5.#( #.#(, &-# #( &/&&'

"!#.!

'# %# '

1((&'# ?.!

!# =(85 =#0!

.(5& ,

&-#"

##( &.#0 (&'& .(5& ,

#' (&'& 5&& , 6, % ("'

.(-&'

#( >; %& &/&&'

( &5#&(&

A 8 . (#. &.#-'

=("-&, ( .(%#0 +("

5( C.#( C.#0

>, , . '

F#& .% +("

/(&0'

.#%

A%%'#, .(%# ('0'

-#' ::

@(4

&.!

, , &0&'#0 ( '(.% && .('

(&0 ( .(%# "#!

#(& &#' )(#., 9'!&

: 5%# #( /(&0'

'(.% .#%

.(%&# ( #0& &#0 /+ 0&%

#. (#. '#'

+ .#(, .(%# 6

1&)1 0# .#% %&# , '%#'

! !('

.('

(&0 /.% /5&#.'

(('

&(-'

&(& ='"&##0

C&, "!( '

#0& '#'

%.!

"#!

#0& &'

0&% ; ( 5%#'

5/(& &# &/&&'

.#% ( /+ /(&0'

.#%8 . .( .( #'&'

5 # .!

/5&#.'

'(.%

&-#( &5#& 3&#5 .( # '

#& '

& ( &#. .('

/#& "&'

#5 .#% .#% &5#&(&, /& G#0 //#'-# -#'., &# 4, , .( 5((+ &# B (.+ '#& &.(&'

%##'

(!& &.(&'

&#0 &-#( &5#& &(.'#0 , .% /#'#0 6;

50 (( (&'

0('("

A &.(&''

'&#0 &(. .&( C%##(, !((.( &# 4, '%#'

&!&%(&, # '%#'

!((.( &- 0 5((+ &# C'

& % .#% 5/(& &-#( &5#&(& 6 .#% "#! (('

!# .&( C%##( '( '

&.# &0&'#0 (&0 (( .('

(&0 + !# .( #

.#% '#'

00 #( #'

(( (&'

( $ !%#& #0!

( @ #5 #0!

(#'

( % $ !%#& #0!

@ #5 #0!

!- 5 "&# '#//& !'

'#//& #+ 4 '%#'

5/(& ::

&0&'#0 ( 5((+ ..( (& '(.% !#%

= ( .(%# &0&'#0 /(&0#0 5((+ ..( 0&%

'%#', &(& 0#- &#- ='"&##0

C& %'

(-&%

C& > !'

C.#( &(- &# ( &/& %& '# #'' &5#&(& !'

(&'

(( !# .('

(&0 & !#&#0 .!&0 &/.'

5((+ &# 5%#'

& (' "#!

&-#( &5#&(&

3!& %&# &.(&'

00 %# #0 (& #0 (& /(&0#0 0&% 1(%# 6 1&)1, 9& 4, ;, -& 5'

0 @( -#'. 5&(0! &.(&'

!("

# '.&#( '.&#0 -(#'

/#' 3!&/(&, !# % 5/(& &5#& 3&#5

:&#0 .&( C%##(, !'

'%#'

50 (( (&'

$ !%#& #0!

@ #5 #0!, "!&5, ! !- '%#'

/.% (&0 ((

.('

.(&'#. %&# & -#'. &0&'#0 &# ( 5((+B (.+ '#&

3!&/(&, .% /#'#0 ' C.'

5" &# "&''

,,B (0 "#!

#& E & % "/ &# 4, # ' %5& 6, 4 .( &5#& &(.'#0 %(#0

,B ( 5(&

A -, /#'

"&''

%( "#!# &#('

/(& %(! , ! /& #& E !#0!& ! #& ..'

5 6, ., '#&.'

' # . &#G#( #. .( #&/&. . #%#', :9, 9'!&, &/ '

#&/& "#!

A !'

' "#!

.(&. #0! #& '(.% .'

5/(& !#% /& //(&'#0 ' ((&## &#

A !'

" & ('

!& &&(& /. /. &.(&' @#!& %# .('.'

&(.'#0 #0(&#0 %&# '(.% (& '#'

//& &&(&

3!&/(&, -#' #%0'

'0% (&'& 9 , , ., '# %# ' 3!# &.#'

%5& 6, 4 #%0'

'0% 9 ,

'%#', 6 ., 5

> &5#& &(.'#0 !-#0 5 .('.'

&5#&(&, .( ("

&# # !-#0 &# '#.#( ''#. '# 5" &#

5 (#.'

&#&, 5/(& 1((&'# ?.!

>; , &# ! '# !('

&/&&'

''#.#( #'' &5#&(& @( (5.#( &# '

5/(& 1((&'# ?.!

&0&'#0 C# . &5#& 0&% '#'

# 5 !&#5(-, !("

&.#'

-#'.

3!&/(&, !& 5 . &0% -#'. 5 '&'

&# (& .( #'&'

&5#&(&

&!&%(&, #. /('

.!&0 & &.(&''

5((+ &# B (.+ '#& %##'

!#% /, !& F #( .(&. 5#0 !# 1(&. ., >4

&(% (&'& '

''##( :# &#. 9'0, 9'!&, # & (##( ='"&##0

C& ..'

!#% &-# #( ##( (&'& 9 6, >, '

9'#.#

0# & 1 , #&/&'

"#!

3!&/(&, !# (##( -#(#( &(-# #( >

-#'. ., >4 5 .(%%#'

&5#&(&

A -, !# /#'

% & /. #% !(&# &.# -#'. -#5 5/(& !#%

A #!& ''#.#0 '# . (& !&#0 . &.# -#'.

- C&. '.# #( C ''"%& !

1&2$!3'4 . & 5#0 &&('.'

!&#/&*

"# $

& ' & '

5/#.# &/&. % '.# #( C

" . 5+ 3! &- C&. &&('.'

!&#/&* ( )

% *

% ##$

&'()*+ , - )./ & '

* *

- ! '

+(*

! 0120.3.*%%.

; 5/#.# &/&. % '.# #( C !26& ! 3" &2"37"3 &"(- $+8'+!26&&37"3 ! 3"

973!'' 3&: !-&;& !$/0 *.< &- C&. #'

'0% &&('.'

!&'&5("*

;

&4 5 6

' &!&%(&, .( #&/& C&% #%#'

. ''.'

-&#( '0% C 1(& ..(&'#0, & 5#0 '# %# ' 6 1(.'

, #/ , ( '

..(&'#0 $&';&''!$

*++ 7/ 8 &9 :97 8 :97