High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47872/2019disposed of

Gurjeet Singh Johar v. State Of Punjab And Another

2019-11-08Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat20 pages

! " # $% & '

()*++$",-.%%/) +$,$,-+) &+)0(0 "$/$+ (-*/1 /-$%+) +02-3+-$0 # 45 " " 6

! " #

" 6' )/7! $ %# # !"!& # '()*'(+ ", "-.

/ $01 $'

1( )1$( 23 4)5 '16 ')1 7 $)148 . 4.9 / )6 1+ )1$:)6 1'

)1$:+1 )1$:$( 1;

)1$:7);

1( )1$: !& " # !, , ) " # ! " ! # # # # , -.

< ! !& # # # & ,

!& # -.

+ 9& " , -.

!& " # !!&

% ## !&

# " " " &" %" 3 # . 3" !& ! " !& =>!# " !"# # $"%&' (#)*"+, , -

" # & ## " " # ! " #" '$2$52!525" . " ! !& ! " &

? # & " # " %" " ?# & !"

? " # '

/ "

=!@ !# !" " A 8 # !""# / )4# . ! !& " # # " " 8 # ## !& "" " ! " < & & ! ## # " # !

# # # # " # " "" &## " " # % , &" " = & & # ;

8"# " !### " ! " #"

" # # " ? " # " ! !& # # " #*"4!!"" '$';'( 0(;1 ;+()(;7(:" #!

%/2$+)8& ))+0$ +)0-0 6%+- 27,9+ :/; /))+0$ <,$%($ </))/-$2$5 & # "" & "

&#4 B25 #"#"" ?!""< 2!5 ! # ! !" ! !#3 ?!""#! # " & ! &

&3 &

" " " "& 4 25 #"" ! ! " # "

# # ""< 25 #"" " &C 25 # #" &" ""< 2!5 "## " ""< 25 # #" " "" ## # & < 25 # #" & # & # , " " " " #""< 25 # # , ! #""

B #"" "# , # " !4 " D 2!5 ! " ! ?!"" #! # " &3 & " #"" ! !" " # ""<D

25 ! # "" !& " @ < 25 #& " & !& ! # ! ## &

& !& ! # " "" " < 25 ! #"" 3 " & # # #" " &< 2"5 !& # " ! "&" -" E< 5 ! ! # ! ! " ! ! # 3 " ! & &# ". " . !#! """ & 3 ! ! ## &.

< 25 ! !" &!4 205" +06< 25 " &, !" #"" # , #" # ! "" " ! ## " # "& !

!& "" , B2)5 ! # " ') # 4 ?! ""

# ! ! " ! ! # 3 " ! 3# " D ';

"+/)9% 27/9+ +-$+)+3 1; 2+)0- 0(.%$ $ 1+ /))+0$+3C2$5."&# " &#"" & ! # !

&#&# ! " # " # " # "" " "" ! " " 2)5." # !! !4 2$5 ! " & " # & & ! ! ! "" # ! ## &"#"# "" # "" # !#& "&# " # !

" & # " " " " & ## " & ! "&## #& " " 2 ! # ! 5 ## #! # # "" !" # " ! & "" & ! " & " & !

2+5 & # "" # & ! # &

"&# ! " & # "& " ##" ()0(,$+-3+)0,-$$%+)*(),03,9$,-0 C# ""&" ##" & # ## &#. = 7,9+$)+2)$/22)+%+-0,-0CF"" " # # 9 " !4 " # " # #! ! &

"" 5

>"(::-0 ???@???@???@ >6/))/-$/))+0$ ): </))/-$ /))+0$ /-3 3()/$,->2$5 G&

" !& !

!& # "" " ! " 2)5G& " !& 3 <+)$3,)+9$0+9(),$;$1+$/A+->2$5& " " & # & !& " # 3 ! "" " !" #" " !& ""

& #" & 2)5% >

25 !" < 2!5 & #"

! # &!< 25 !" 2+5H & "" " ! 6/))/-$0 $<%: 3,)+9$+3>2$5 " &! #""<! & " 3 & # "" & ! & ## ##3 2)5 H "" # &!3 !&!

&& " B6/))/-$:/;1+3,)+9$+3$/-;2+)0- C 2$5%"I " " & &# " " & # # "" " & # " 4!!

& ## & 2+5 H # ! # "" !

!" & ;$ > )97/:/$,-/-3/$$/9%:+-$ )97/:/$,-)2+)0-/109-3,-.>2$5."& !2 " 5 &# !!& ! " ! 3 & #! # , ## #"# #" &&" " #! # 2)5%# !#!" > 2525 !#!&# # " #&< 2!5 !

""3 ## " # & ##" < 25 #& " ! ""3 ## " 4< 25 &" " #&" # ! #! & ## # #& 2+5 !& # "" # & #! #" & #" 25"!4 2)5! , " !# # #!& B2'5 H # #!

!4 2$5 # " # " "" #!

+:'+:0+:6+:;+:(+::'11'1)'+6'':'0:'61 " .2'0"$(615#" ## #" # , !& # &" ,& " ##"" "" 205 % # " !4 2)5 2+5 ##& !& !4 2'5 & ##& # #! !4 2$5 D 9>F # 00(+ </))/-$ ,- 7,+( ' ) ,- /33,$,- $' 0(::-0> & & # !

& " ##"&#" " > 25 " !" "" " ! !" "3 " ## ! ! !& < 2!5 " " ## # !& " ## ! 3"""" ))+0$-1)+/9%1-3)/22+/)/-9+>H& # !!&&! ##!" ## ""# & # ! #!

" ( !#" !# # " # "" # # = # # # ?!

#"", " #, " , & " , "" % , & 3 " " "

&!, ="#"" # # #

! = &" 4# " # ! ## " "#"" / & # "" # #" &? G " & ! & 3# ! " #"" "! " #" "" " #"" #!& &# ?

%"" ##" # "#""## , & " % & " !& , " , ! , " # ?!

"" 3 ""3"# ." 3 #43

&"#"" && #! " "" ?! = , " ## :

. " ! # J.. "

. " # & " < # "" , " # # !& ! # &, # , "# ! # !& # G # ! " # " & !!& # . # #" " !& " ?

""" " &! " >! & # " & ! !& # & %" $6; , " " )' # ! # !

#! "# # &" $0 & G" ? & # & !&$0& , "

" & !3 :1&61& &! $1 G# . !"

# " " !& # % # 3#& # # # ## !" K > % !& # ?" "" $:1" " # " E )1' 2$52!5 " ? " ##"!" ? - ## # ! # . # # " F , K##>"!" & # 9 "

" # & &# 3"# !& # " %" &

" !!& & # "" & # !& <##!" # $$ ;+" "# # " I " -

&# K > #

! 3 ## " # "

"# # & " # "# K# ""> % ! K&#> # "#

"3 4&# # "" & " # " , ! " " % " # " < " E " # 4 25H# 2!5"" 25 " K4!!> "" K > = #" " # " - 252!5! &

& ?"""& # % & 25 # # # % & " # #

& 25 ;+ ! 43

% # &# # !&

K ?!>"" H &25! & "" K4!!> F!& K ?!> K4!!> ! #""" " # % &"" " "< K ?!>! K!!> K4 ?!>! K4!!> F " #"&

"" ! ?!4 ?! !!!4!! & ! #

" # ;+ " %

& ! ? < # # F & & ! ?

# ? # %" &25! ! " "# &25 2!5! = ! ;+ # &" # , ##!" # #< (; (: +:1" < "" ? % # ! & " """ ###!" "" "

K4!!> "& # ! " "" & '$ # " = ! & & " " " ! & #" # !&&#"#" & ! !"" # $;+ # " # & #" " # ! ##"" !

&" # () " < & ! # # # # # $) & " # # " "! " " # ! # " '$" , ?!"" !&# #"#""# "" & !" # # "" ."# ?! "" #! " # !

% "" " # . " *) $" # '

-!" " " . =>!# ,& !" ?!4 !! "" #! # # & #"" , " " #&" ## && " # # !& "" " # " & # & ! , " # "" %"&" # " ? " # & ! !& # !&

" !# " # = ##&# "" " ,, " # F&" """ # !& # ! ? !# " &" "" $+ " " " %&' (#)*"+"/ # " ;+ " 3#

" !! ! " ,#4 <" " !& & # ! # !& # . !!& #

# 3 " &" ##" " #"" $'

% " " # # " " & #! & & < & " ## " #"" % &&# !& # " #! &"# # !" , " # # " # # ""< " !& # " =!! " !

" * ? " & "" # " " " & # " ## " # "" ! !& / & "# < #" " # # # !&" # &#. %" &" #< # ,& = " # !" ! & #" & !

& 9 < " #" " ! !

#!" # "

" " & # " #, #"& ! !& !" ! ! &" #< E &#"! <!" # ! < !!& # " " " " !& & " # ! & 3 !&" " "" !!& !!

& # "%&' (#)*"+"/ $0 " " # # & # ! !& # # # %" " # # < "" ", , " # ! % # &## !& #"" !" < " # %## ,& , " " # % ## #"& !

/ & !# ## , , " '$ "& " # 3# & # . # ## #

" ! #

$6 8&# !& , & "" " #, < " " % & & " , # !&& & ! , & "

" "

, 3# " % #!& " !! "& 3!& $;

& " # !& ! = # # # & %# " , # # # , $( = # # "# "

L #&" ! 3 " !=& E% & $% & '

" 6!