← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27625/2022dismissed

Umesh Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-12-02Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal5 pages



       

    !"#!$%&%'(  )!&*+,)'#' *!   ! % %'!&    -     !".''# *!&  !&/'#!' &  0(  120   +2

!&!' ( + !#*,3#4$ !3" *!/! % %'!& 056%07%83##73.'  9999999  +23:

2;

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

 

      

 %'<*%$*/! % %'3'6!%'5/,  ' %$!3 *! *!'#4$ !!'!73.'//!!#6!"! *%&, '#&  !# * *!  !3&,6@!$   *!/! % %'!&1)!#%$7"% '!&&'#4!%"%$ %'" *!% ' !$!#!' &3*# 8!'#!$%&%' ""! *!)//%' )!'  ' *!6&%&" *!"!&  !)!'  *!/! % %'!&1/! % %'<&#%&/&!#"<% *", *!

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

3/! % %'!)#!!/!&!'  %'  *!!&/'#!' &&  %'5 *!!%' * *!&*,7#6!5%4!'&!'%% .' ") *!# !"*%&//%' )!' 6, ") A<*%$*<& *!# !<*!'3$$#%'5 *%)3$'#%# !& <**#6!!'&!7!$ !#7'5<% **%)'#<!!7<!%')!% *#@%'!# &!4%$!'# *   *  %)!*!<&' ""!!#//%' )!' '$$,' " %)/&% %'" *!)#!7$#!"$'#,$ 6. *!7!$ %'))%&&%'"'#% "<*%$**!$,7#'#&*,7#' 6!",7 !#*!$7%)"/! % %'!<& !@!$ !#7!#%'5  *!&!4%'5"&!/ !7!57' %$!&# !#  '*%& 6!*7"&7&'6!*7""/! % %'!,/' *!!&/'#!' &'<*%$*' "4,67!#!<&/&&!#6. *!  !' *!5,'# *  *!/! % %'!&1/7! <&*%5*7.6!7 !#,$*$ %'" *!  !%&,'#!$*77!'5! *,5* *!

%'& ' /! % %' 2!'!#$,'&!7" *!/! % %'!&&,6)% & *  *!/! % %'!&1 /7!$,7#*4!' 6!!'!@!$ !#6. *!!&/'#!' &' *!5,'#"#!7.& '$$,' "<'5"%D %'" *!%&!'%% . *!/! % %'!&<!!5! %'5 7!&&!/. *' *!%6 $*) !&!4!.)' *'# *!!"!% <&!

BEC $,&!"$ %' 2!'!#$,'&!7" *!/! % %'!&*&6!!'*!#'#<% **%& 67!&&%& '$! *!!$#*&6!!'/!,&!# ' *!.!A *!  !".'#4! %&!# "%77,/A

/& &  "  7%$!  '& 67!&   *!  /! % %'!&  <!!  &!7!$ !#  5%'&  &,$* #4! %&!#  /& &   *,5*  &)!  "  *!  $'#%# !&  &!7!$ !#  7'5<% *  *! /! % %'!&<!!""!!#//%' )!' &'# *!.@%'!#' A6, ' ""!"//%' )!' <&)#!=, *!/! % %'!&'$$,' "%)/&% %'" *!)#!7$#!"$'#,$ 6. *!7!$ %'))%&&%'"'#%55%!4!#6. &,$*%'$ %'' *!/ " *!  ! *!/! % %'!&8'$8!# *!#&" *%& ,  *,5*    

 

     

 <*%$*/! % %'" *!%&<&#%&/&!#"'   *,5* *!

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

#") *!# !:&;!7%!  *!/! % %'!&3 *!/! % %'!& &*776! 7%6! . )8!!/!&!'  %'  *!!&/'#!' &&!!8%'5 $'&!=,!' %7!7%!""6!%'5//%' !#") *!# !:&;/!&'&7<!%' )!%   *!)<!!//%' !#'$&!&,$*!/!&!'  %'%&)#!<% *%' /!%#"'!)' *") #.3 *!!&/'#!' &&*77 8!#!$%&%' *!!'%'$$#'$!<% *7<3<% *%' <)' *& *!!" !6./&&%'5 &/!8%'5#!I /!,&7" *!"!=, !##!/&&!#6.%4%&%'!'$*" *%&, $7!7.!4!7& *  *!/! % %'!&1/! % %'<&#%&/&!#"' *! &  !)' )#!6. *! *!'#4$ !!'73.' *  *!  !*# #!$%#!# ""!//%' )!'   *!/! % %'!&3"$,&!3&,6@!$   *!

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

 *!3    %&!  &,$*    $7%)  *!.  &7!/  "    .!&     !D/7' %'

<* &!4!%&" *$)%'5!% *!") *!!$#") *!7!'!#$,'&!7 " *!/! % %'!&& <*. *!/! % %'!&&7!/ " .!& $7%)&!'%% . *!5,)!' %&!#6.7!'!#$,'&!7" *!/! % %'!& * &%'$! *!/! % %'!&4! *!.!&!5! %'57!&&!/. *' *!%@,'%&'# *!!"!% %&!$,%'5$,&!=, *!)%&!=,%!# 6!$'&%#!!#'7. 6! !@!$ !#/!,&7" *!!$#!4!7& *  *,5* *!/!&!' /! % %' *! /! % %'!&<*<!!//%' !#' > &!!8&!'%% .<!" A %! *!# !<*!'$$#%'5  *!)/!&'&*4%'57!&&!)!% <*<!! &!7!$ !#7'5<% * *!)*#6!!'//%' !# *,&3 *!%$,&!"$ %'3%" '.3$$,!#' > % &!7"' *!.! % &!7" *!.<!!<!"

*!"$  * $! %'/!&'&<**#6!!'&!7!$ !#7'5<% * *!)*#6!!' ""!!#//%' )!' ' A&'7." !$)%'5 8'<"&,$*"$

B C *#  *!. "%7!#  %' <*%$* '  *!/.! )#!6.  *!) %4%&%'!'$*" *%&, *#/!)% !# *!) $7%)&!'%% . *,5* !/!&!'  %' 6!"%7!#6. *!)<% *%''!)' *" *!#%&/&7" *!%<% /! % %'*!.#%#4%7" *!7%6! .6, '7." !','!D/7%'!##!7."

.!& ' *!7%5* " *!64!3 *!/! % %'!&1$7%)%&",'# 6!& 7!  &,""!&")#!7.'#7 $*!&'# *!!"!3 *%&, %&' %'$7%'!#  !' ! %' *!&)!%' *!!D!$%&!"% &#%&$! %'.@,%&#%$ %','#! %$7!  " *!'& % , %'"'#% %&)%&&!#  B +2C &*)&*!     *! *!&/!8%'5H!&'!# ( !&H *! *!!/ 67!

(!&H