High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/53382/2023allowed

Barinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2023-12-08Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta12 pages

#$%&&'

()*+, -

&')').*&$

0$)*1&$ ()*+, -

&')').*&$

0$2)3,0* ()*+, -

&')').*&$

60$07 &&'

()*+, -

&')').*&$

&3&$8&1 * $.*.#*9&1 * / :;

( 6

#! "

"!$% &''

"!!

() *+,-./0/01%*,/0/20/01 "!$ "! "!$

"!!

()!

*,11300/01%*,.0310/01

# 4 !"

4! " '4!

6 <

6"! "44! /+!!

!4 !

44 "'

+13* * !!

7 ! ! 7!4!

89 .0./3..0/00! 4! !

"! #!! : "!

+,3 1-;

++;

1+0 +0;

0-,

.0/< "9 * !

0,=0; ' ( ,+ .-,-)> !

+..9 *4

0 89 4 "' : "@:

7= "! "! "

" ! '!&!

" (#) 4 #!! : "! "4 $

7" ' <& 4!

":$"

4A49 44"

" !"!

;=3..0/00 0'

" 4!

" '

" ' <&!

" "" '' !

! ' '!

:" ""!44 "+/,/

' !

' " !

' !"!

4!$ "4"4 ,; "' $" '!

<&! " $!

" ! !4 ' < '!!

"&! "( '4!

")$ "!! !7 "7!44$ 4 7 7

6"7 $!

"!' ! 4 " " < '!&! " ' !7 " "!

!'! 4"!' "!"!" ' $6"7$"!' "$7 !'

$ " &! $6"7!

"!'

$" ' <&!

!47 $"!'!

! 4 <&!

" 44 "'" $444'!"!

" ' <&! 4 $

$ "B !! 46"7 !47 "..=0 ₹ 4 '4'!"

"! "" "!

<& 4&!

0/ "

9 ! 7 ! 7 7 .0.,B ! " "!4 4 " 4' !4"

!.0.,' !4"

"! 4 7" '4!

""4 4 " 4' !4"

"!! 7C "!

'' 44

44!

" " "!""7" " (#) ":$"

4 ""7"$ 4 B !! 4 44< <" !

"&!""7 7!

< '!&! "44 ' $ '4!

" $ ""7 !44 44!

" "!4 ""(" "! " 44) '4 !" <" !

"&! $ 4 "#9

"7" '4!

" "!

4 < '!!

"&!

"7 4!D!

" ' "#

! $# '"

! $7

# !""' ' " E !B !9 "' !'

" "# " 4! "!

44"!

4 7 '" !

"!"! 4 "7 4!

7 ' "#

! !

! ' "'0$3&7 ()*+, = ,)>>.* %(0'?)$ ()*+, * '4!

"" 4! !

7 "!

"!' :4 ! 4 " "

" "" < "&! .;/.0/00 " = "!'4

"7! $":! '" !

< '! !

"&!: # 4 : "! :"

#<<" !

#: " "4 &4 "

"7 !"" !

' < '!!

"&!: "#:$"

4 "!!

! "" "" 0?0 ,0+@0* ()*+,4 !" 3,@0$ ()*+, = !

)10$ ()*+, = !

44 " '"" " ! 7 $ !4 !

"#9 4 44""!

"4 ! "'7 ( ') !

' 4' (!$"4!!

) "43/7 "

"4!!

!' 7 ' $ 7 !

4! !

4 "894" !

" !" !

" !# & 4 !

!44:$"

4 4! "" "'

: " " !"4 '

: " 4 !

!7 !!

"= F!

7" 9 + 4! !4 "4 .!

44"

4" !49 !!

6' ! !

! "' , (!) .,..0/00 4' 7' '7" ' 4!

"! "6'!

"@#"!44 " '4 !"#$7#2, ()*+,<0$07%)'

()*+, (0$*%)'

()*+, = (,0$0*%)'

()*+, = (,0$0*%&&'

()*+,

!" # 4 "!"!" " $ "$$!

"!' " &! "!

$=4 '

$"!

'!!

" " !

47 '!

!## 12.,..0/00 ! "! (!!) '

$"!

" .2..0/00 "@" "@" !

" 1/..0/00 "! 4

7"!'

6'!

"@#"!44 #1+& " "!' 4 /1..0/00 !"! !

!" (#) 4 ""( ")4 !"

.>1A"" "" ! 7 '" 7!

4! !

! "' G '*!!4: !4 '$' !

" 9

"! 4 " 47!

4! !

! "!'( ") " "!'4 '!*!!4 : !4 : "! "G ! $ 7 !

4 ! 4 " " !" ;=3..0/00 ""$

"! 7!

! !

" 4 !"(#2,8)$ =

0*+0 = .>1A< 0$3,0*< #$B$&&'

()*+,< 6#>@)*1&$ ()*+, 0*1 0@0*

"7$ ""7 !

$!444 !

":$"

4 "4 ! 4 " 44776'

" 4 !"./.0!" !$"" "

" ""!" " 4 "# "**6 'C " ! ! 4 !

#" !

$"!!

"@ "@ 47

!## 0.

/..00/006"!! 4 ' "4 4 " 7 "'$:6 ₹ ! 7 " , ///=9 " 4' 7! 4 " 4 ! 4 "(#2,@)*1&$ ()*+, 0*1 0%)*1&$ ()*+,"4 '

!"!' " " " " $!444 !

4 "! ! $"

" '!

"89!## +0/2.00/00 (!!!) $"

" /2.00/00 !4 "!! 4 C0$)*1&$ ()*+,

0$2$)3,0* ()*+,

%)'

()*+, 0*1,0@0 '!

" "! ! 4 $"

(!) # !

" !

6' !

" @ #"!44 .3.00/006"!! 4 "

" 7 9 ! * 7

₹ ₹ ;/ ///=H .,4 ! ! 7 !

$ !"!

,-' ,/'6"! 4 ' 6'!

"4 " 7 ! 7 !

₹ ₹

! !9 ! 7 ;, ///=H 14 ' 4 < '!!

"&! $

"< $ 9 ! < $ " () # !

" !"

! #$% #$ F!

!44*"$ 4 "!$"

4! !

< 4 #!! : "! "!'

.2.* * .;.00/00 !

"! ""! 4 " " !"!

/;=/3..0/00 " " ' " 4 : "! !"! $ !

6"!

! " "!"

& #$% #$

! !

!" "(47)I #$%&&'

()*+,

" " !

"" " 4! !

!7 C " ! "!' " !!

" '!

" !## .3.;.00/00

(!) 0+0*1&&B ()*+, = 0BBA '!

" "!

! 4 6'!

"@#"!44 !## 1- 01.00/00 (!!!) # !

#$@)*1&$ ()*+, = .>1A

.;/00/01 !

"! ! 4 '

0./00/01 " '!

60$07 &&'

()*+,

#$8)$ ()*+, = )*2# !""!'"!'

C "! "!! 4 !!

'&!

"@!

$ '!

!## 10./00/01

2 9! 74

4" ' !!

"" " !!'!

.2.* *

.;.00/00! ' " '

" '"

" " ' "!!

! '!

"! " "

B 1 7"! !

' "! " "" " $

7 !

! E !

2,< "J!

" "!

!4 !!

'!!4!

! "" " ! 4 7 A !!

"!' G

4 '!"!44"!!

!7 !

; 9! 74

4"" "

"! ! 4 !

" " 4! '!

7 " " "

"! 4 !

'!!4!

! !!

!44 7 !

#$ %

3 9! 74

4"!!!

! '!

"! ! 4 "@ 47 0./00/01! ' " /1'

" '" !"

" 4! "!'G

4 "!!

!!44 7 !

- C !

"!!

447 7 4 !

" = '4!

'!" "

"" 4! " !

" " 4 "# " **6 !

44 "!

" (!!

* +,-./0/01)!!!4!

" "(

B 1) 7!

"! "

" "" $ '" " "**6 !

44!

" !

# 4 ' "" !7 ''!7" ''G

" '!"' !!44

" !4!

"!!

() !E !!

"B 4477"' !

" 7 !

! 4 "! " $ 77" 4! 7! ' !'!4 "!!

./ 9" ! '!!

""! " "

.. 6"!* "4!4 !""!4!!

"@" "@" !

"I!!

"I6'!

@#"!44 % !

"! " ! ! ''

/0/20/01!"

&# #$ '<7 7 " "

""!!

4!47 ! !

6'!

"@#"!44 !'! ! ! 7!4 4 !

"@:7 !

""! ' " !

01.00/00!

! ! 4

6'!

"@#"!44 " ' !

' !

'" ! !"!

/;=/3..0/00!4401.00/00 .0 6" !!

:$!" !

"%'

"!4' "' !

"!!

:$!" !

"%<!

"" '!

"! ! 4 ' $"

" " 4!

7 " ! "! 4 ! 7!

"" "!

'6'!

"@" "@" !

./.0 "'"!' !" " !

:$!" !

"<!

""! "!' 47" !

4 "!

" !7 "$"!' $ !""!' 6"

" !

! 4 !

"! 4 !

!"!!

" 7

'!!

.1 JB "! 4 " "!

!'!

'!4"'!

"!!

:$!" !

" .+ !'!447 " ' !!

'&" "

!!' 0./00/01 "! ! 4

"@ 47 ! ' " /1'

" " !"

" 4477"!' .,

"! "" ' 7 ! '47 !!

" F!

" '

B 0 .;.00/00!' " '

" " "' "" " "

B 1

"' ! !

! !!

" 4! 4 "" !!

! 4 " "" "9! " !!'"G

4 " '4!

! 4 "! """ "" $

" '"**6 !

44!

" !

" "

"**6 44 """!'7 ! **6 $ !

!47!!4 !

"!9! 4 4

B 1 ""!" "!$ '" .2 :!

44" ! ! ' "!

! !

" ! ! ! 7!4 "!!

44"

9!! "!

7 "!!

"7"444 !4 "! !

" !

! =9 !!

! :

!!! ""! !

"44 !

" E !7"9 !!

! 6"7"44 7 ! !"" ! "!' '"!

" "444"

7 !"

! '!!

"* 6"7"44

" '47 !""

! 4!

+13(0)* *

" 7 "! 4 "

6 &9&7?&$ /< !$6 A""$!

= K= A"" 4 K=