M/S Autonation Pvt. Ltd. v. South Indian Bankltd. And ORS

2024:PHHC:058588-DB











 





 








 
 




!
"#$# % &'#(
)*

+


,-
   
./
0/







  .'$1$


- 

2
0/

 -


 
 3
 40
 -/
 -
0-
00


 40
-/
 -
  



  

  ! " # 


$ !#  ! " #  %%%% 0-
00*
/
& '  # (   " )  !  &&* +, &-  .,#) !) , $! &/ " $!,0  !,! " 1!2   3"!4 " $!,' 5 !  " # 6 7$ 1 3$5 !8  9 !,2 "  ,:4 #  6
4' (#!#   :, " 2 " 4!#' " 422 ,2 !  )  $ 3 , # ! $422  ,4 3 ; 24 !  1!2 "!2'  # + "   !
#
 24 (  2 " :'  "4  6 <=  2 & >#" #,) 2 ( 2 = :' ;! "  6 !4'  # , " && 2=#  ?&&-
#
 "!2' ( ( 22'  /&- '  2    " (  ( 4))  !, :# # 2 5 ( ,:4 # ,  4!2 :24 "  "42'

44: " # ;! "  ! ),2 ! 
#
 "!2' $,:.,2' ,  ,:= " 4!
@5;&? # ( ) "!2 !2  #  "  2)  !2 " !!,  A "4)  A   B/& C,) 2 !!, "  ( !2 A  *& A! , $! &B  "

$ 1 3$5 ! ( ,  &-*&  &&  !  #,) 2 
#
 "!2' ! 2' " !  " &-*?*-  &/-   -*&  ?& ! 2'  ,:4 :

! (#!# (  ! :'  6 := 2'   22)2 "#  !44,!  -&  B-& +, &  && ! 2'  #(  !# # := (# 2 "  >4 $24

>$  " ) " !) , $ 1 3$5 ! B

>$ (    " , " #   ! 2  -&& +, &B "  ,4 " * ! ) 2 ,) " B*B-*/*   :# ! 4, (  :    :" B&&& #:' "") 2'   " B '  #    ,4 " B&*/-BB  -&&  &/?/* ,,  ! "

>$ 4, (    '

!"! !!,  >$ !#4 (  !2  C(   6 := (#, ' 4    #  4,  #,) 2 !!,  !!, ( !2  : !2  -&&  #     >$ 4, :' 22) ' 4)) (# := :,  BB& "! , $!  " C' ; 24  ),2 " D:  ! &?* :' $ " C' >( 
,' 2) ;4 ( , (#   ., :) !2, #

>#"  ' !,2  :  " (#, A :

!
"! "4 # ;! " >( 
,' 2) ,  (#!# :,'  # :!= , ., " + " 4 ( 4 :'  (#2 ) ! 4 4,  2 !!,  2   & " (  5 ( ,:4 #  !  &&* ( 22)2 ,   :' 4
42 2 " 2!:2   " 2(  !) ,= , $ 1 3$5 !  22) :' #  5  ,:4 # ! !2 >$ !#4 ( ! :# !!, #,2 #  : !2,:: )#  4, :  ., :#   ' ! " #,) 2 !!, ( 2 !,4 " !,  #,2 #  : ,  ,:2 '4 # :  :'   4 "

>$ !   " ,  "  "

!42 4, #,2 #  : + :'  6 := !22' =)  ( # ""! " "!  BB& , :' ;4 " >( 
,' 2) / 9 !,2 "  2 ,:4 #  :)

$ 3  ( !,4: ,  6 <=  #  "  ! :" ;)
44   !2 "  !!, A  >#, ! !2 " !!,  : A  22)2 ",# !) #,2 : .,# 5 ( ,:4 :' 2 !,2 "  # "# 2 " >$ # 2 : ,:4 2)(# ," 4, "  2=# :, 4 #  : ! :'  6 <= 5 ( #, ' # #  : 22( * 9 !,2 "   := (#2 ) : ! ., :2' " (  2"

#42' ), # !) ,= )  , $ 1 3$5 !   !42 !!

(# 2!:2   5 ( ! # >$ ( ! ., :# # !!, "  ,4 " *E  :    :" B&&& #(  2'  ,4 " * 2=# ( 4   & <= (#2 =)  2 ( + >$ 22 &*B   !44,!  * +, & #2 ")  ( 4 "2  :#2" "  A &   2 !,2 ,:4 #  '4 ( 4 :'  " &  + :) ) 22 &*B #" ),4 # #2' ' 4 ( ""  4= #   !! 5   # >$  B-& ( !  # : " !) 2 " !,  5 ( ",# ,:4 # $!  " C' ; 24  ),2 " D:  ! &?*  2!:2 

! 2   !, (# 8 2   !  #,       !#  6 := (# ' :,' "  2 < #   4'  ( ! #  ),   ' !  ,""! " 22) !) , $ 1 3$5 ! 9  >4 $24 "" " &/? ! ,:4 :'   &/ ( !2  # 4  2" =)  ! # :2! ,)   &&/ ( &B 2=#  2, " !,  ( #)# # >$ 4, "" :'  $  ! 2 ( ,2' !  :'   &/ 2" #!' "  ! 2 ",# 
, (# !' #"  2 !,2 "  ( =  ! ,:

!  , +! 5 ( " :  42 " (  ( ,)#   # 2 !,2 "   2)#  #  , # "2 C(  (   " ' ), (#   "  # (   +! "

,! , !2  "
, " 5

>#   " #  # $ 1 3$5 !   !42 !  2"  ) " !"! 4 " ' ) ! (#!# 4'   !  !) = #, "!  # ) ! : 4  ,)4 " C8:2 # $,4
,  %# %
 %5
!
%6#
7/
-

#
 %6 %

%6
:'$*
;<
-
;;=
.

'#> 61?1
@#
668
7/
/
-'%#7 $1(1

%6
:'$*
A;

// /#7#(
A+*,$
- 1 :
%6# %
@ %5
0 6/
%6
:'$
7/
 7%


:9
:#(#&
%6
% :'*
A

#7#(
;/

CF:2 # $,4
,  # ! " ,$
- 1 :
%6# %
 %5 , #2  , G&B   4' #(   # 2  " 2(  # "! " # C)#
,  =) !2  " #
, " 5  !44!2 4 (#  ""!   ""!!, 2  ",4 # : !, #,)#  , +++ +++ +++ &/ ( " !   : ,    ! (# #
, " # # !   !"4  # 2(  , 5 # ( !,   +!  ,:, #42  (# # !4=) ,#' (#2 ") ",2 (# # ! 2) (# #  ) $,!#  (   +!  : ,  4' 22 2 +++ +++ +++ +++ &* ># :

!   :# # ! */ "   '

!2  :  :' #
,   '6#
:>#"

($
0 6/
7/

%# %
!
%6# *
+
+
-
A;; #2  "!2  "  4# 4 " ! '  ' "! "4 #
,      " 4!#4  # "4 " # >:,2 :) 4 :'  2)22'  4 ># >:,2  !2# (#  ( )  (     22)2   #" ) !.,2 2" !2,)   '4 " !4  ! $! & & " # $ 1 3$5 ! )   +  4)  # + G' H (# !,2 !# # >:,2 +++ +++ +++ &- #2 )  (  !!, " # "! # # ( !" , !2  " #
, " 5  # ( :,  .,  : +! 2'  +' !!,4!  4 )  !)   ,!'

!#4 .,  , 4   !44!2 4  2 )  2   :( (# # 2)2, #   "  !"! 4!#4 "  2H  9 !,2 "   ,:2   , ' +'  +!2 !!,4! (#!# !22 " "! :' #

, 22 2   :" ,  ' (22 (# # 24 "

! :' 2 >:,2 - 5 !  ),4  ., 22)2  ! " 8 ., " >$ ( )   " ' ), " "! 5   2  # :(  ),   #    )# " >$ 5 # : #2 :' C8:2 # $,4
,  ,)4 " :
#B% '
'@ %
 &'

#7
 %5
0#># 6*
#B% '
%6
:'$
7$/
% (
??

'9 (
%6

:'$*


-
C  , "? 3  #(  :  #:   :( !   4 " )# ' " ) " :" "  >4 $24 $!#4 5  )  !  4' # #   (,2 :(  #,) 4, " +42 & ! "  2) # 2 # 4' 2:2'  ' ' 4, ( 224 #,)# :2  4= # '4 C (,2 ( " # >$ $!#4  # ' " ) " :" , # >$ $!#4 , (#!# 2('  2 4, # # 4, ,  ':2 , # 2 !!, (22 #   :  >#  # :) 22 :2' " ! ' " #  2 4, (#!# ! : 2 :' 22) # 4))E!,  5"   #2 # # :( ! 22   4 " )# ' " :" , # >$ $!

#4  # !  (,2 : ) )  4,4   # :( (#  # "! # #  :2  4= # '4  # "! # # <=  :2  !  #  2 4,   :' 22) # 4))E!,  # "4 # :( E ), >#  :!, , # >$ $!#4  : #  '  2 4, # # !,2 4, ,  ':2 , # 2 !!, $,!# ! : #  " # <= (#2 "") >$ $!#4  # ! : , " # $!#4 (#!

!,) ,!#  #' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ && ># ,4  ,:! " # " !, (,2 : #  ( " 44, ! : , :' # C)#
,  +! " ( , !2  " #
, " 5 !)  "!2 ,E<=   2' ) # :" "

>$   :( ># ) " :" , # >$  2(' ,:

!  # 2):2' ! 4 , #

>$ $!#4  # ),2 , "4 4  4 5" # <=E"!2 ,  " #  # # 2 # # !!'  4= # '4 E # # <=E"!2 ,  :2  !  #  2 4,   :'

,!) # 4)) 'E!, ' # "4 # 2 E ), # <= (,2 : ,"  ",)  ) # :" , # >$ $!#4 D242'

,!#  ! #,2 : 2"  # !44!2 (4 " # <= (# 4,   2     2('  : ,4 # # "!2 ,E<= #22 =  , ! (##  ) # :"   , # >$ $!#4 # ) )  # ,:2!   2   # ) )  # "! (#!#   #: H ? 5 # ! " -


 %5
!
%6#
.$/
'7#%6'

("

' %#"$
/
6/*
A;

-
C+ C8:2 # $,4
, # !)!22' #2 # ),E:(   2  = + "  " >$   4 " )# 5 #  ! + " >$ # : ) ! :'

 6 :=  8 ,:., "" "  ,4 "  &/? 2=# ., ,) 4, "  * 2=# # :  ! 5  ,:2 #    ! " + "  "

>$  "  "# >$    : , #,)#   2('        ' 4,,22' !!:2 24  '  " 4 & # ),4  :' 2 !,2 "  ( #  ( $ 3 #"  ! #,2 #  : 2! :" ;)
44 :" !2 "  !!,  A  ># !  .,2' !  )   4 "   &-&B    ;C
,$
":%#"
- '#&$
%6
1@$
/
0 6/
%6
% :'
7$/
1 $":
 %5

%6
% :'

 !! (  &&

)  ( # "!  !!,4!  :  # (   4 (# 2:'     2 ,' 4'

  2:2    !!! (# 2( C(  =)  ( # "! #

4   " , "  ( )  &  # + # # (,2 : ' "  "  "4 !,  4 #22 !, " "" &* (=) '  :2    2 4'  4' :  2:2   I, " !,!  #( " 4   8 " , #22 !2' : (# # 24 " ! :' #  1,4 (#!# (22 : !  !!! (# 2( (#, :) "2,! :' '  (#!# 4' #  :   # (  & 5  !2" # 4 ! ""   #22 ,4!22'  !  # :! " '  :' #  ,#' &B ) 2!  " '    "







0-
00












 
  

&'#(


)*
+








 
 ## =)E JEA ## :2 JEA