High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/9/2019dismissed

National Insurance Compancy Ltd. v. Ranjna And Others

2019-01-11Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

%&'( )($$"

*"

+ ',"

))"

%&'( )(($$"

*"

-%". ',"

)(("

"#$% $&! "

/ 0 (*(# 1 $2'.!"3 ,"$$ ! 4$$"

( 555

$&!'"( !) ," "

" 6."

," $$ ! 3 " '" 3 '" ' #

6 $$" '"3 2 ," $$ !

1"'(0 $$" "

"' 6 #-" (

**+( ) 78

" '

3 ,"$$"

(

,- 798 , '" 1

'"!'" (:3 9: "'

%&#"'.( + ',"

'(39: "'

%&#"'.(-%". ',"

1,!, #"

,;# '< ,;# '"

3# !%!

"(=>= ?:? '"' "

3 + "

"' !!'"

1, 33"

.",!

"("(+" -" 6 "6 (*=@A( 7B8 ," "

"#"

"'-"

12' 3 ' %#" ," $$" ( ,"

% $ 6"' -% "' !

3 ," $$"

,,"33"

6.",!

"("(+" -" 6(*=@A,' -""

3

% . ."' ," !!'"

"' 6 ," '", 3 ' ." $

'" 3# !%!

"(=>=?:?( 7?8 $"

3$ 6 $,(3,"1 ' "."

, '" $ ."," ! "2," "

4!

# "C# "'D=9<,""

2 "%"=1

3,"!! "

1"

, 3,"1,"

'" "' ".'"

!" , '

% 1 33'. C(D=94 6 1, '!#"

("( !$%3 C( '!$%30& C(:3'"!" #"

,;# 1," " ," "

3"' ," #

" 1,!, ," !!'"

E $ !" # 6 -" '( "3 ," "

3"', B(F(9A- (9 $(#( '"!" #"

, ;# 6 1, < , ;# 1 " 6 .

6" + 3 # .

6" ,"'$ 2 ", <# # !%!

" (=>=?:? ' 1,"

,"% "!,"' ,"' 3 .

6" # 6 1 '

-" 2,"

33"

6+" (*@A!#"3 # $$ " '"1, "-" 6' ."

-% "

(@ , "6 6"

#

" ." %,6, $""' !E6

,"# !%!

"3,"'"!" "

31,!,'"!" #"

,;# '< ,;# 3"

' '1" " ,3"'+ ' $ 2 1," " #"

,;# '"'( D=9 <,""

3 ," "

3"' , ," 33"

6 .",!

" 3"

,- , 6 ," # !%!

" 3 ," '"!" "'

!E 6

" # !%!

" ' ." "' ," 3"

'

1," "3" "

(@ 3 1%3 #," $ ". 6,".",!

"," $(D=93 ," "

3"' , ," !!'"

E $ !" !! 3 , "6 6"

' . 6 3 33"

6.",!

"(*=@A ',,",'1

"',"!! "

, C( 1 '6"' , "#"

!" < <# ( 6 !

="C# 2 D=9 <,""

"' , ," ,' !"' ," 33"

6.",!

"1,"

!E6

# !%!

" ',"#"3," !!'"

2,"'' E 1 %, 6-,"1," "- $ !

3 ,"' ." 3,"33"

6.",!

"-.

% "',,",' ""

33"

6 .",!

" ," #" 3 ," !!'"

' 3 ," , ," !#" 1-," #" '$ !

3,"' ." " 3 #,"$ !" 1,"

,"1"

," !"< '"

3%,"' ." ( "

"', ,",' "'," #-" 3,"33"

6.",!

"," $ *=@A- 3!1 *=@A ',",'1 % "'," #-" -"! ","

#-" $ ",'- E"

$"!"

,"#"3!!'"

("

$"-" !

="C# "' 6,-%

3 ," "

,"

%2 #" ' ! "$ !%! $$"'$ , ."

! "" %'- "6 ' 6,"6"

3, ."

("

'"

2 (@ 3! 6 ! # $ "! "

$"! 3 ," 3 "#"

"'!!'"

1,!,

%'"!" #"

,;# -

< ,;# 1,1" " ' 6 # !%!

"-" 6(=>=?:?

," ."

' 3" , 6 # !%!

" (=>=?:?2 33"

+" .",!

"(*=@A

!E6

," # !%!

"-" (=*=999 "

6 + "

0 + '" < 6,("(,"' ." 3," '# !%!

" "

$"!31,!, !"3# , -""

%G,"$ 31 '3 "#- "#"

3#"'! "C$"

,.- 6 ',," #"1 ,6"# ',' -""

$ ."'-%," # '! "( 7F8 G" %2

3 ,"$$"

3 %! !"'"' , G"

,'-""

$-%,"!

3 ,"

% ,""%"=1

D=9<,""

( ," - !" 3 % G"

,. 6 -""

$ ," "%"= 1

("(D=9<,""

1,1

"',"!! "

' 1, "

"#"

2 ," 1 '6"'2 3 3 #% 1, "." 1, ," 1 '$

"'-%," "'0 !!'"

# - ( 7@8 ," $ , -""

6"'( 7A8 !! ' %23 3 #%1,,"1 '$

"'-%,"

"'0 !!'"

# - 2 2 (: '3 9: "' #

"' # "( (<(D '6" ((9: # D,"," $"E 64 " / "

4 D,"," "$ - " / "

4