High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/319/2023dismissed

Bhagwan Balmiki Mandir Committee Village Batriana v. Gp Village Batriana And ORS.

2023-04-25Mr. Justice B.S. Walia10 pages

2023:PHHC:058779

!"#$ "*+,+-..#/ 0 ! 1"23"#"45.6."#$.7 55.**++ 8.44"2+"*7."#" 9::+44"#*

7"5"#-1";"*8.44"2+"*7."#""#$7 9+:#$+#*

7"5/

#<=4+7>*.-+%?"4." 7++#*/ 7 "@+1 >1"#A $B-"*+ 'C+2"4 .$ >#+4) ,7 *1+ "::4.-"#*D"::+44"#* EEE %?"4."A'7"4)

7*1+7+"#""7+5+#*.#+$.#*1+"::4.-"*.#A*1+ "5+."443+$+4";, $";.#4"*+,.4.#2,*1+"::+"4. -#$#+$

7*1+7+"#""7+5+#*.#+$.#*1+"::4.-"*.#A*1+ "5+."443+$+4";, $";.#4"*+7+ ,.4.#2,*1+"::+"4. -#$#+$

443+$":7";+$,7

1"44+#2+ .# *1+ +2>4"7 %+-#$ ::+"4 . * *1+ @>$25+#*"#$$+-7++$"*+$ 0 :"+$=;*1+4+"7#+$

$$.*.#"4 .*7.-* >$2+A %"#27>7 $.5..#2 -.B.4 "::+"4

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

#,4+"7#+$->#+4 :+7>"4,*1+:":+7 =67+B+"4*1"*>.*3",.4+$=; *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* ,7 :+75"#+#* :71.=.*7; .#@>#-*.# ,7 7+*7".#.#2 *1+ 7+:#$+#*D$+,+#$"#*A *1+.7 "2+#*A 7+:7++#*"*.B+ "#$"-."*+,75$.:+.#2A5"6.#2"#;6.#$,-#*7>-*.# "#$ .#*+7,+7.#2 .# "#; 5"##+7 .# *1+ :+"-+,>4 :+.# , *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* B+7 4"#$ 5+">7.#2 .3" -5:7.+$ .# F1+3"* 0&D A F"1*">#. &A F1"7" !0 '0 0)A!

)7+-7$+$" .*>"*+$.#*1+7+B+#>++*"*+, 8.44"2+ "*7."#"A +1.4 "#$ .*7.-* %"#27>7 " :+7 "5"="#$.,7

! *1+ ;+"7 13# " "76 .# *1+ .*+ :4"# 1+ 7+:#$+#*D$+,+#$"#*3+7+:7-++$+$+G:"7*+ 0 C+"7#+$ *7."4 >7* *6 .#* "-->#* *1"* *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*1"$+G"5.#+$1.5+4,"? "#$7+.*+7"*+$*1+ "B+75+#*5"$+.#*1+:4".#*#"*1"#$1"$"4:7B+$-:;, +2.*7"*.# +7*.,.-"*+, 55.**++" G A-:;,+4>*.# $"*+$ 0& " G A -:; , +7*.,.-"*+ .>+$ =; 7"5 "#-1";"*B.44"2+"*7."#"7+2"7$.#22.B.#2 .3",4"#$**1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 55.**++ " G !A 4.* , 5+5=+7 " G

!DA -:; , "5"="#$. ,7 *1+ ;+"7 " G

A .*+ :4"#

G 0A-:;,"::4.-"*.#5B+$**1+ 1.+,.#.*+7A>#@"="

G A -:; , "::4.-"*.# 5B+$ * *1+ .7+-*7A "#-1";"* +:"7*5+#*A>#@"=" G

A:*"47+-+.:*" G * G A -:; , "::4.-"*.# $"*+$ & 5B+$ * *1+ % A 4.-+ %*"*.# 1"3"#.2"71 " G "#$ :1*27":1 " G *

A =+.$+A 1"$ +G"5.#+$ C"61" %.#21A 5+5=+7 , *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 55.**++ " ?

31 :7B+$ -:; , +2.*7"*.# +7*.,.-"*+, 55.**++" G A-:;,+4>*.# $"*+$ 0& " G "#$.$+#*.,.+$1..2#"*>7+#*1+"5+A =+.$+A :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 1"$ +G"5.#+$

>7@"#* %.#21A 1*27":1+7"?

!31:7B+$*1+:1*27":1,>.*4"#$"

G * G

"#$7.*"5%.#213"+G"5.#+$"?

31 :7B+$*1+7.2.#"4.*+:4"#" G0"#$.$+#*.,.+$1..2#"*>7+# *1+"5+ 1+4+"7#+$*7."4 >7*#*1+=".,+B.$+#-+4+$=;*1+

:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 1+4$ *1"* *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 1"$ -4".5+$ *1"* *1+ 7"5"#-1";"*1"$"44**+$>.*4"#$*1.5,7-#*7>-*.#, "#$.7 ,7 31.-1 1+ 1"$ :7$>-+$ -+7*.,.-"*+ .>+$ =; *1+ 7"5 "#-1";"*" G! 3+B+7A*1+4+"7#+$*7."4 >7*-"5+**1+ -#-4>.#*1"**1+".$-+7*.,.-"*+$.$#*=+"7*1+.2#"*>7+,"44 *1+5+5=+7,*1+ 7"5"#-1";"*A=+.$+A*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 1"$"4,".4+$*:7B+*1+$->5+#*":+7*1+#$."# B.$+#-+-* " # 3.*#+ , *1+ $->5+#* 1"$ =++# +G"5.#+$ =; *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*>7*1+7*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*1"$:7$>-+$-:; ,"5"="#$.,7*1+;+"7 =>**1+$->5+#*-4+"74;13+$ *1"* .* 3" *1+ 7"5 "#-1";"* 31.-1 3" *1+ 3#+7 "#$ .# :+.#,*1+>.*4"#$C+"7#+$*7."

4 >7*,>7*1+71+4$*1"**1+ *1+7$->5+#*:7$>-+$=;*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*$.$#*13*1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#**=+*1+3#+7"#$.#:+.#,*1+>.*4"#$ #7"#;*1+7$->5+#*1"$=++#:7$>-+$=;*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* *13*1+"44*5+#*,*1+>.*4"#$=;*1+ 7"5"#-1";"*A*1+ .*+:4"#"#$*1+:1*27":1:7$>-+$=;*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*$.$ #*:7B+*1+3#+71.:,*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*B+7*1+>.*4"#$A =+.$+A+B+#":+7*1+"5"="#$.,7*1+;+"7 A*1+ 7"5 "#-1";"*,*1+B.44"2+3"3#+7.#:+.#,*1+>.*4"#$"#$ *1+7+3"#*1.#2#7+-7$*13*1"**1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*1"$ "#;7.21*7*.*4+B+7*1+".$>.*4"#$"#$#*1+=".,*1+"5+ 1+4$ *1"* .* 3" +**4+$ 4"3 *1"* # .#@>#-*.# ->4$ =+ 27"#*+$ "2".#**1+*7>+3#+7"#$.

0 .+ 7+:#$+#*D$+,+#$"#* 3" 7+-7$+$ " 3#+7 , *1+ >.* 4"#$A *1+7+,7+A # .#@>#-*.# ->4$ =+ 27"#*+$ "2".#* *1+ 7"5 "#-1";"* +.$+A .#-+A *1+ "::+44"#*D:4".#*.,, 1"$ ,".4+$ * :7$>-+"#;$->5+#**:7B+*1"**1+ 7"5"#-1";"*1"$"44**+$ *1+>.*4"#$*.*"#$.*3"*1+3#+7.#:+.#,*1+"5+A *1+7+,7+A :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* 1"$ ,".4+$ * :7B+ 1. -"+ --7$.#24;A.#*1+4.21*,*1+:.*.##*+$"=B+A*1+4+"7#+$*7."4

>7*$.5.+$*1+>.* ::+"4,.4+$=;*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*5+*3.*1*1+"5+ ,"*+ " *1+ 4+"7#+$ ::+44"*+

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

B+7#5+#* +:"7*5+#*D>*17.*; 1+4+"7#+$::+44"*+ >7*,>7*1+71+4$*1"* .#*1+7+B+#>+7+-7$*1+7+3"#+#*7;7+2"7$.#2:+.#,*1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* B+7 "#; :"7* , *1+ >.* 4"#$ "#$ *1+ +B.$+#-+

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

#*1+-77+-*5"##+7-#*+#$+$*1"**1+*7."4 >7*1"$#* ,7"5+$ .>+A *1+7+,7+A *1+ .5:>2#+$ @>$25+#*') "#$ $+-7++') 3+7+4."=4+*=++*".$+"#$*1+5"**+77+5"#$+$**1+4+"7#+$ *7."4 >7*,7,7+1$+-..#",*+7,7"5.#2.>+ 1"B+-#.$+7+$*1+>=5..#,4+"7#+$->#+4"#$ 3.*11."=4+".*"#-+1"B+:+7>+$*1+7+-7$=>*"5",7".$*1"* *1+ >=5..# , 4+"7#+$ ->#+4 ,7 *1+ "::+44"#* "7+ $+B.$ , 5+7.* .# B.+3 , *1+ $+-..# , #<=4+ *1+ %>:7+5+ >7* .

! "#$ !%&"'(") * + ,*- ./0$+-.$+$#00 !":+731.-1.#"-"+31+7+ *1+$+,+#$"#*3+7+:7-++$+$+G:"7*+A*1+ >7*.#*=>#$* ,7"5+.>+>#$+77$+7 "#$$+4.B+7*1+@>$25+#*#+B+7;

.>+"7+H>.7+$=;7$+7 >4+0 "4*1>21*1+*7."4 >7*. 7+H>.7+$ * -7>*.#.I+ *1+ "B".4"=4+ :4+"$.#2 "#$ $->5+#*A -#.$+7*1++B.$+#-+"$$>-+$"#$$3+44*,7"5+*1+:.#*,7 $+*+75.#"*.#"#$:7-++$*-#*7>-**1++G:"7*+@>$25+#*$+"4.#2 3.*1*1+:.#*"*.>+#+=;#++7+4;=+-">+*1+$+,+#$"#*. "=+#**1+ >7*1"44#*"$5.*+B.$+#-+A*1+"$5..=.4.*;31+7+, . +G-4>$+$ =; 4"3 #7 :+75.* .* $+-..# =+.#2 .#,4>+#-+$ =; .77+4+B"#*7.#"$5..=4++B.$+#-++4+B"#*+G*7"-*,*1+$+-..# , #<=4+*1+%>:7+5+ >7*.#"5+1 1"#$7$"3"*.;"<-"+ '%>:7").7+:7$>-+$">#$+7/

! " #!

$ %&&&' ()

*+* *

* &

& #! *

$ -&%

. $ --' / 0

* 1

1 #! 2 *

# 3 =+.$+A 7$.#"*++#-1+,*1. >7*.#12$ %##( # 3 4 #'(") * + ,*-

'1 5 )+, (# 6 * 7%5 #' (" ) * + ,* - !% /8 # !$/8 #' (" ) * +, - $+-.$+$# A "#$&! 7+:+-*.B+4;1"B+"41+4$*1"*.#"-"+31+7+*1+$+,+#$"#*3"+G :"7*+A*1+ >7*3"#*=>#$*,7"5+.>+A=>*#4;*-#.$+7 *1+ :4+"$.#2 "#$ *1+ +B.$+#-+ :7$>-+$ # 7+-7$ =+.$+ *1+ -#*+#*.#7".+$.#$+*".4"#$*1"*+G:"7*+@>$25+#*"#$$+-7++, *1+*7."4 >7*->4$#*=+".$*=+>,,+7.#2,75"#;.#,.75.*;

& 5+7+4;=+-">+.>+3+7+#*,7"5+$=+-">+$+,+#$"#*1"$=++# :7-++$+$"2".#*+G:"7*+ & $5.**+$4;A*1+$+,+#$"#*3+7++G:"7*+A*1+7+,7+A*1+7+ 3"##+-+.*;*,7"5+.>+ 1+:.#*.#.>+.3.*17+2"7$* *1+-4".5.#>.*,7:+75"#+#*:71.=.*7;.#@>#-*.#,77+*7".#.#2 *1+ $+,+#$"#*A *1+.7 "2+#*A 7+:7++#*"*.B+ "#$ "-."*+ ,75 $.:+.#2A5"6.#2"#;6.#$,-#*7>-*.#"#$.#*+7,+7.#2.#"#; 5"##+7 .# *1+ :+"-+,>4 :+.# , *1+ :4".#*.,, B+7 *1+ 4"#$ 5+">7.#2 .3" " :+7 $+*".4 2.B+# .# *1+ 1+"$ #*+ , *1+ :4".#*D@>$25+#* "#$ $+-7++ , *1+ 4+"7#+$ *7."4 >7* *1 *1+

>7* =+43 1"B+ 1+4$ *1"* *1+ -+7*.,.-"*+ .>+$ =; *1+ 7"5 "#-1";"* G ! "#$ " :7$>-+$ =; *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* .# >::7*,*1+:4+",1"B.#2=++#2.B+#*1+4"#$.#H>+*.#=;*1+

7"5"#-1";"*$.$#*=+"7*1+.2#"*>7+,"44*1+5+5=+7,*1+

7"5"#-1";"*#71"$*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*:7B+$*1+",7+".$ -+7*.,.-"*+ " :+7 *1+ :7B..# , *1+ #$."# B.$+#-+ -* " # 3.*#+ , *1+ $->5+#* .# H>+*.# 1"$ =++# +G"5.#+$ =; *1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*=+.$+*1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*1"$:7$>-+$-:; ,"5"="#$.,7*1+;+"7 31.-1-4+"74;7+B+"4+$*1"*.*3" *1+ 7"5"#-1";"*31.-13"*1+3#+7"#$.#:+.#,*1+ >.*4"#$7+B+7A*1+.*+:4"#"#$:1*27":1:7$>-+$=;*1+ :4".#*.,,D"::+44"#* $.$ #* +*"=4.1 *1+ 3#+71.: , *1+ :4".#*.,, B+7*1+>.*4"#$"#$#*1+77+-7$1"$=++#:7$>-+$*13 *1"**1+:4".#*.,,D"::+44"#*1"$.#7.21*7*.*4+,*1+>.*4"#$

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