← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CR/66/2017dismissed

Punjab State Co-Op. Supply & Marketing Fed. Ltd. v. M/S S.S.Gumber Rice Mills And ANR.

2026-01-29Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri10 pages



 !"# $   % 



   %&%  '( (  ) * +,-./ 0-*..12 3/4

5/ 6( 0/*      37-(-( *8,/ 3 11  )/  



 

    ) * +,-./ 0-*..12 3/4

5/ 6( 9/*    373(6( 3 11!11,:;<=) 1!11,:;<=% /  />.*/  )/  



3' ?"6 3(!- !-  

-

  

     

   

    



 



  !

" ##### !-  

-

 !(:/1<

( $

     

 % 

 %



&

 

 



 

      

 %



   ( '



 %







 

  ( ))(**+,"-'./0+)+,,1 @(

    &    

    

%  &

3%   ")",+,"/

  (

 $ 

(   0    

   %    



    '56     

&

        

 



 "78

% &

 



  

& 9  % :+"8;



  





&& %



  

  

 

%  &

3%  

 (

 $ 

(  &

 



     <-

   (    =



 

> ?@&  

 /   % 

  



   '56

  (

!

)=@

%

 &  

 

  

 ?    & 

  

   

:+"8





 9  B

 B 2



 '56 %%6 



  )  

 

      

@

  



%

   &



 



   

   

:+"8





&

 

% 

:"78

&   

   

  2

   

&



  - .

  

 % 



  !

"     %    

  &



 

 &

  

 C '56 

 

  

 

&



 &



 

  &  2

 

 & 

:"78 ;

&  

 &     

% 



:+"8 



  



 



&  

 D E    %  F          

 



%%6

 '56





A



%%6  

 



 &

   



  

   & 

 (

 "7 

 

  %

  &    

   2 &



    

% 

:+"8

%

 

   * %

  % !

)

&&

 &

    2   



 3    

& % 

:+"8 

3  

 2&





%D E  %  F2



   & 

 

     7 I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. 1

 % 

    

 

    &        % 

 



"78

  

 &

    % 

%  



+"8 



!

)* & %   



 

&   

   

%

 * & 

  

 

%

  %

   

(

)=@"7     C  

   

 

    

  

    

  

 

   

  !" #$$%&

   



 

   

  '

(  )* 

!+ , 

!+

- 

!+ "

!.+ /      



      

  

       0!+     

            

) 

 ) & 



 ,     

  &1 2.& 345/43/(*'6  3

      

       

   7

             7

          



  

  



  ,  

     & /

       

   

  348"9,      

 



  

  

  348"9, 7





  

   &



 





    

  

&/   

  



 

 



    

  

 &,&  

  #     

  







 &: 



          

   

 & ;

        



 

 



 



    

    

&/ 

  



                 

 

  ,&,

  

 

 

  

 

&1 ",   (

)=@

%

  





 

  

 & 

  *  



    

  

   & 

   

   

:+"8





 9  B

 B





%%6

 '56



  

  

(

"7& 

&    



%

     

 

 

 



 %  

     %   %

%

 &

 = E    



&  

E

   



  @



 

  

6  

    

 *

&    & 

   



E  %  

   3      * 

  

    &

   E

   

  



 

 



3  

   

  

(

)=@     & 

&  & %



:+"8  

  



%%6

 '56&

2

   





:+"8& 

     %    &  

 D E    %  F    % &      

 

  



% 



:+"8 !

)

&

         C   '        





  '

/     



      

  

       0!+     

            

) 

 ) & 



 ,     

  &1 /   

 

!+ 

               )      & < # 



   

   &=.&!)                        

 

   

   

&/  

     



          &,& 

         7  3 



&

 



     >     ,  

           &    

       



  

7  #5  # 



  

 

0 

   

 &      

    

     &     #  

            6         &   5  ?7    #             @







 

&1 "" .

 

&  %

   

   %   % 

 

3% '56G!G

 %H  

&

& 

I (

 $ 

( 

  &       & %

    '56    

 &   %   G!G   



     

  !

 "# $#%&''()(*)*&+,%   &



3  &     

& 

 %  

> E 

?2

3%   



 -  

=@

    

 4      %  &  

 

;

?  (  2

 

  



3%   

. !/! #      $#)"/01++,2&''+%###&,'3&'34*%1     

   $#)"/01,(5,2&''5% ###    3'33&''4*% 6

    #        



      $# )"/0  1&  2  &''5%  ###   ''7&''4*%  # 6  $

8  0   #  $#       9   !  )1+32&'3(%###&5'&&'37*

   

3%  

  (  



 -  )  *   ## # :

  # 

 # /   

   

     A

%  A

. 

 

   &,&

 

  





 &/ #3 

 

   



    & #  

 3  ,    -   6 

    

  

 

 6   A

% 

A

.

   #   3 

  B&&$$.  1& "+

   

  

 

  %%

% 



 



+"8

   2

    



%

  

     & 

   %  

         &   

3% 

  (

 $ 

(   "< (  

     

   &   

9   

 

  

  :!-  

-

 <  !%

( ( 

  A

%B

J

B!

 A

  

J

B!