← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CW/369/2017dismissed

Pb. & Hry. High Court Chandigarh Thro Its Registrar General & ORS v. State Information Commission, Pb. & ANR

2017-09-08Mr. Justice S.D.Anand4 pages

  

    



  

!!

" #$%%&' ()%*$%+,%-!.

/ 0#,# 1#-2# #34/-$4# 13#-4$4$' %3'$-#-% %-#56-' 7 #**5&# $8*%$$ %- 9' )$#$% -+#$ ++'' . / 0#,# 1# - 7 %'* 1% $'  :(  ;<:

 )::)  

-%'% $( :-=# #-3.**5&# $-%'* 1% $ *%-'    

 91% -1%- 1#$%1 :#2 . 

 $4% =-$ *%$$  4#1 ,%%  #55=%1 4-/34 $4%  '$# $ -%>%= #**5&#$ . -%'* 1% $ 8 #**5&# $*-#2'$4#$$4%-1%-1#$%1:#2.

,%-%>%=%1# 1$4%=-$ *%$$ ,%-%#10/1&#$%1# 1'4/51,%1'+''%1 4%3-%># &%$4%#**5&# $'$4#$>5:'&#**5&#$ ' ,%#- 3: """ 

".:

 

".: "  

.:  

# 1:



4#>% $,%%  & '1%-%1# 1$4#$$4%'#1+'&#**5&#$ ''4/51,%#55=%1 %-% & '1%- 3 $4% +# $# #,5$2  $4% -%>%= #**5&#$ .$' $/$*5#&%$+% $ 4%-%$4#$=4% $4%*%$$ =#'

   $#?% /*-& '1%-#$ .$4%#**5&#$ -%'* 1% $4#1%@*-%''%1 & 1% &% $4%/-$# 11%'-%1$4%/-$$-%&/'%-+4%#- 3$4% =-$*%$$ %4#1#5'+#1%#-%A/%'$$4#$4%4#15%>%55%1#55%3#$ ' #3# '$ $4% 4% /'$&% # 1 -#'%1 3-%># &% -%3#-1 3 $4% '2'$%+  =-? 3$4'/-$#'=%55#'/ &$  3$4'/-$#'$4%*-&%%1 3' '4/51,%$#?%  &#+%-#'3-%># &% =-$ 34#1,%% & '1%-%1  $4%0/13+% $ %,-/#-2 .

.4%4#1+#1%# $4%-'$#$%+% $$4#$4% '4/51 ,% *%-+$$%1 $ 5%#>% $4% /-$ #' 4% 4#1 +>%1 #  #**5&#$  ,%#- 3:



-4%#- 3$4%+#$$%-,2)/*-%+%/-$ 4'/-$4#1-%0%&$%1$4%-%A/%'$-%'* 1% $$-%&/'%-+$4% &#'%.& '1%- 3$4%'#+%$,%>5#$ $4%& '$$/$ #5#$4$4' /-$$#10/1&#$%$4%+#$$%-=$4/$%#-.#>/--,#'4%=-$*%$$  =#' #55=%1 # 1 $4% +*/3 %1 -1%- # %@/-%   1#$%1 *-5 . 

" -%A/- 3$4%34/-$$*->1% -+#$ $-%'* 1% $=#''%$ #'1% 4%-%>%=#**5&#$ 4#' =,%% 5%1#3# ,2-%'* 1% $  :- =#  #-3 ,2 #**%#- 3   $4% /-$  %'* 1% $  #**5&# $#**%#- 3 $4%/-$4#'& $% 1%1$4#$$4%5#==4&44#',%%  -%%--%1$ +20/13+% $4#',%% =- 352#**-%&#$%1,2$4'/-$4% #**5&# $-%'* 1% $4#'3>% 4'=  $%-*-%$#$ $4%&#'%5#=  $4%-%>%=#**5&#$ 2#**%#- 3 *%-' .$4%#**5&# $4#'/-3%1 $4#$ $4% -1%- *#''%1 ,2 $4' /-$ ' =- 3 # 1   +'-%#1 3  $4% 0/13+% $'$4%)/*-%+%/-$

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

"(  $-# '%- $4%   $ 4%/'$&%-$4%#-$4%  &#+%-#C B :

 

"( $ $#?%   -%&-1 -%*52  -%'* 1% $.=# #-3$$4%=-$*%$$ C B : "  

(  1-%&$ *%$$ %- 34 /-$$/- '4&%-$&#$%&5#-2 3=4%$4%-$4%2 4#>%-3 #5-%&-1&+*5# $8 >%'$3#$ C >B :  

(  $#?%   -%&-1 -%0 1%- -%'* 1% $ $$4%-%*5&#$ *%$$ %-C

   >B :



(  *5#&%   -%&-1 &%-$#  %@$-#&$'1%&1%1&#'%'# 1$'% 1$4% $ )/*-%+%/-$-4%#- 3D 4% #**5&#$ ' #$ )-   $ " 4#1 ,%%  $#?%   $ & '1%-#$  #$ $4% $+%  1%&'   $4% =-$ *%$$   4/34 / 1%- '%*#-#$% /+,%-'+'&#**5&#$ '.'%*#-#$%-1%-'4#1 $,%% *#''%1. $4%=-$*%$$ 4#1,%% #55=%14%*-#2%--$-# '%-=-$*%$$ $ 4% /'$&% =#' 1'+''%1  ) #- #' +'& #**5&#$  #$ )-  ' & &%- %1.$4%-%*52-%'* 1% $4#1,%% $#?%  $& '1%-#$  :'&#**5&#$ #$)- =#',% 3--%5%># $-$4%#10/1&#$ $4% =-$*%$$ .4#1,%% 1'+''%1)#-#'$4%+'&#**5&#$ #$)-E '& &%- %1.$4%'#+%,% 3 $*%-+'',5%/ 1%- -1%-! /5% .

 =#' $#55=%1)#-#'+'&#**5&#$ #$)-"'& &%- %1.$4% '#1 #**5&#$  & $# %1 $4% '+5#- *-#2%- -%A/- 3 $4' /-$ $ '% 1  $)/*-%+%/-$=#'+*5%1521%&5 %1=4% $4%=-$*%$$ 4#1 ,%% 1%&1%1,2$4'/-$ 3-/ 1'+#1%/$--%>%= 3$4%-1%-1#$%1:#2.

*#''%1,2$4'/-$.#''/&4$4%-%>%=#**5&#$ '1'+''%1 )%*$%+,%-!.

 F::)B '# 0#2   4%$4%-'*%#? 38-%#' %1( %'8 4%$4%--%*-$#,5%( %'8