← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CW/386/2017dismissed

Santra Devi v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-05-21Mr. Justice Amit Rawal,Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia8 pages

 

     

 

 !"

!#!$%&!' ('!'!" ))) *'((+!,!"-*.  ,'/)   0*"'&*(#!

11$!+*"'21('!'!"(& 3(&,4, 0'*'(*&.*"* '5(&, "2*11$!+*"'6&(,1"7("',  $ %&'() *+,-. )/.,% +.

%&'() *+,-. )0+ ))-,.0%,1%!(. %&'() *+,-. ) .-!(

&(,("'- 11$!+*"'21('!'!"(&,0*"'&*(#!!"1(&," &"84&!''*$/77!'!"*$7#+*'(("(&*$/*&.*"* 99999  .-!(3* 5(1&*.(&!"'5(1&(,("' (#!(:*11$!+*'!"/*''5(!",'*"+( '5(*11$!+*"' 1('!'!"(&!"% ))) /!,&&(#!(:'5( &7(&  7*'(7  )/  *++;1*"!(7  <.  *"  *11$!+*'!"  ,((8!"= +"7"*'!"7($*. 7*.,/!"!$!"='5(,*;( ,  1(&  '5(  *#(&;("',/  !"  14&,4*"+(  '  '5(  *7#(&'!,(;("' <(*&!"=6)>7*'(7))> ""(?4&(

2) /@1,',A(+'4&(&,!"

0*",8&!'("(&*$*'(=&.&(;*$(/:(&(*7#(&'!,(7/<4''5(&(:*," 1,'&(,(&#(7&*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&.  5(*11$!+*"'61('!'!"(&/ <(!"=*,1!&*"'*"7<($"=!"='*+8:*&7$*,,/,4<;!''(7*"*11$!+*'!" *"7!"$!(4'5(&(/&(+(!#(7!"'(&#!(:$(''(&7*'(7)))> ""(?4&(

   <(*&!"=  $$  )  '  *11(*&  "  ))>  (&(  '5(  7*'(   !"'(&#!(:/  *"'5(&  *7#(&'!,(;("'  <(*&!"=   6)>  7*'(7  ))>

""(?4&( 2 &!$$!"=41>1,', A(+'4&(&,0*",8&!':(&( *7#(&'!,(7/4':5!+51,',:(&(&(,(&#(7&*+8:*&7$*,,

(;*$( *'(=&. :!'5*,'!14$*'!"'5*''5(1(&,",/:55*7*$&(*7.*11$!(7!" 14&,4*"+(''5(!&,'*7#(&'!,(;("'/"((7"'*11$.*=*!" 0!"+('5(&(:*,"1,'&(,(&#(7&*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&. !"14&,4*"+(''5(!&,'*7#(&'!,(;("'/'5(*11$!+*"':*,!"*B4*"7*&.*"7 *,*"*<4"7*"'1&(+*4'!"/*$,,4<;!''(7*"*11$!+*'!"7*'(7)))>

""(?4&( 2 *"7  *$$(=(7  '  5*#( &(+(!#(7 *  +;;4"!+*'!"  7*'(7 ))> ""(?4&( 2 <.*,,!="!"= $$>>05(:*,7!&(+'(7' <&!"=+(&'!!+*'(5(&+*'(=&."'5(7*'('5(!"'(&#!(:*,,5(5*7 *$&(*7.*11(*&(7!"'5(!&,'!"'(&#!(:5(,(+"7!"'(&#!(::*,'<(5($7 "))>:(#(&/'5(0($(+'!";;!''((&(4,(7'!"'(&#!(:'5( *11$!+*"'"'5(1&(;!,('5*',5(:*,/*$&(*7.!"'(&#!(:(7/!"'5(!&,' *7#(&'!,(;("'*"7:*,;*7('<($!(#('5*''5(&(:*,*+;;",($(+'!"/ *,'5(,($(+'!"1&+(,,:*,4'+;(+$4<<!"='5(*7#(&'!,(;("', " )) ""(?4&( 2@ /'5(&(,4$':*,7(+$*&(7/<4''5(*11$!+*"'C,

$$"4;<(&:*,"'!"+$47(7 "*,+(&'*!"!"='5(1*&'!+4$*&,'5(&(,4$'/ !''&*",1!&(7'5*'&*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&./+4';*&8,:(&( ;*&8,/  :5(&(*,  &  ("(&*$  *'(=&./    ;*&8,/  :5(&(*,  '5( *11$!+*"'6&(#!(:1('!'!"(&*=*!",' $$)/<'*!"(7;*&8,4' ;*&8,*"7,!"+('5(+4';*&8,&*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&.:*,/ ,5(:*,$!*<$('<((&(7*11!"';("' 5(*11$!+*"'*"7;*".'5(&*,1!&*"',*,,*!$(7'5(,($(+'!" 1&+(,,% ))):*,"<(5*$'5(*11$!+*"'*"7<4"+5

 :&!'1('!'!",:*,">))*$$:(7*,1(&7('*!$(7&7(&!"% )@))/:5(&(<.'5(,($(+'!":*,B4*,5(7*"7'5(7!&(+'!", :(&(!,,4(7&5$7!"=&(,5,($(+'!"<.'5(!#!,!"("+50'*'( *&.*"**,,*!$(7'5(*&(;("'!"(7D47=;("'<(&("C<$('5(041&(;( 4&':(#(&/"01(+!*$A(*#( ('!'!"*=*!",''5(7(+!,!"!"%  ))):*,1&((&&(75(01(+!*$A(*#( ('!'!":*,7(+!7(7<.

"C<$('5(041&(;(4&'"/:5(&(!"/'5(7(+!,!"'5!, 4&'!"% )@:*,,('2*,!7(*"7'5(;*''(&:*,&(;!''(7 ''5!,4&'&&(,57(+!,!" 3!7(  &7(&  ,4=5'  '  <(  &(#!(:(7  7*'(7  )/  '5( ,($(+'!",:(&(415($7<.'5( 4$$("+5'5!,4&'11$!+*"'*$$(=(7' 5*#(,("'*$(=*$"'!+(7*'(7&+",!7(&!"=5(&+$*!;*=*!",' '5(*#*!$*<$(#*+*"+. (;*$(*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&."'5(1&(;!,( 5*#!"=<'*!"(7;!"!;4;+4';*&8,*"7/'54,/1&*.(7&7!&(+'!"' '5(&(,1"7("','(&*11!"';("'/<4'!'&(;*!"(74"7(+!7(7/+;1($$!"= 5(&  '  *11&*+5  '5!,  4&'  #!7(  %  >      +$*!;!"= '5*'

,($(+'!"5*7<(("415($7*"7,!"+(5(&:&!'5*7<(("*$$:(7/,5(,54$7 <(*11!"'(7 !#!$  %&!'  ('!'!"  >      :*,  1(&;!''(7  '  <( :!'57&*:"#!7(&7(&7*'(7>@:!'5$!<(&'.';#(*"*11&1&!*'( *11$!+*'!"!"% )))5(&7(&&(*7,'54,-2 E  

             

  

     



   

    

    

            

 



    

  !   "

  #$  %  "

     &     

     

4 '! ('' #

 





  ) '!,!"'5(,(+!&+4;,'*"+(,/'5(1&(,("'&(#!(:*11$!+*'!"5*, <(("!$(7<.'5(1('!'!"(&*"7$!,'(7<(&('5( 4$$("+5(?1$*!"!"= 7($*.*,5(&+4",($ :*,5,1!'*$!F(7 :!"=''5(+"'&*+'!",(&!4, 7!,(*,(*"74$'!;*'($.7!(7!"/<4'/!"*+'/5!,7*'(7(*'5+*;(' '5(  8":$(7=(  "$.  !"  '5(  ;"'5    4"(/   /  '5(&(&(/  &(#!(:

*11$!+*'!"+4$7"'<(!$(7:!'5!"1(&!7$!;!'*'!" 5!,4&':5!$(+",!7(&!"='5(*&(;("'!"(7,4<;!,,!",/ !,,4(7"'!+(!"'5(*11$!+*'!",&&(#!(:*"7*,:($$'5(*11$!+*'!" ,((8!"=+"7"*'!"7($*. 7*.,

(,1"7("'  ,  *"7    !$(7  '5(  &(1$./  *#(&&!"=/  '5*' &(B4!,!'!"  1,', &'5( ,($(+'!" A(+'4&(&0*",8&!' 

(;*$( '5&4=57!&(+'&(+&4!';("'/:*,,("'''5(04<&7!"*'(0(&#!+(0($(+'!" *&7/*&.*"*/":*&.*"*0'*0($(+'!";;!,,!"/ *"+584$**"7 !"&(,1",('5(&('/':*7#(&'!,(;("',/"(7*'(7))>*"7*"'5(& 7*'(7))>:(&(!,,4(75(&(*'(&/'5(04<&7!"*'(0(&#!+(0($(+'!" *&7"7(+$*&*'!"&(,4$'&(+;;("7(7'5("*;(,+*"7!7*'(," ))!"+$47!"=+*"7!7*'(,&  *"7  +*'(=&."#!(:

'5(,($(+'!"1&+(,,/+*"7!7*'(,*11(*&!"=*=*!",' $$,>/>> *"7> :(&(!,,4(7*11!"';("'$(''(&, (&  +$*!;  :*,  51($(,,$.  <*&&(7  *,  ,5(  +4$7  "' <'*!" B4*$!.!"=;*&8, 11$!+*"'21('!'!"(&!$(7&(D!"7(&''5(&(1$.&(!'(&*'!"='5( ,'*"7'*8("!"'5(&(#!(:*11$!+*'!"*"7'5*''5(&(+&7:*,"'<(!"= 1&74+(77(,1!'(7!&(+'!",!,,4(7!"% >"> 

5

(,1"7("'!$(7*,(1*&*'(&(1$.*$"=:!'5""(?4&(,

6  *"7  6/  !(/  +1.    :&!''("  ,'*'(;("'  *"7  *!7*#!'  7*'(7 *"7,411&'(7'5(!"7!"=,'5!,4&'!"D47=;("'7*'(7 )<.*#(&&!"='5*''5(&(!,"(&&&*11*&("'"&(+&75(1!'5 *"7 ,4<,'*"+('5(&(1$.&(#(*$(7 '5*' '5(&(#!(:1('!'!"(&7!7 "' 7!,+$,('5(;*&8,<'*!"(7<.'5($*,',($(+'(7+*"7!7*'(*"7!"'5(!&,' *7#(&'!,(;("'/'5(&(:*,"1,'&(,(&#(7&*+8:*&7$*,,+*'(=&.5( 1('!'!"(&5*7<(("!"'(&#!(:(7':!+(4"7(&<'5'5( $$"4;<(&, 11$!+*"'2&(#!(:1('!'!"(&/*11(*&!"=!"1(&,"/,4<;!''(7'5( $$:!"=,4<;!,,!",-2

!

&(7!+*;("''5(*11$!+*"'61('!'!"(&!,:&!'$*&=(*, B4*$!.!"=;*&8,&=("(&*$+*'(=&.:(&(/'5(&(&(/'5( +;;!,,!":*,$!*<$('(&*11!"';("''5(& "+('5( &(,1"7("',  +$4<<(7  '5(  ,($(+'!"    ':  *7#(&'!,(;("',/ *11$!+*"'21('!'!"(&  *,  *<4"7*"'  1&(+*4'!"  *11$!(7  !" 14&,4*"+(  '  '5(  ,(+"7  *7#(&'!,(;("'  !"  *+8:*&7  $*,, *'(=&.':*,"'1("&'5(&(,1"7("',"''+",!7(& 5(&"*;(!"'5(*+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&./'5(&(&(/'5(&(!,*" *<7!+*'!"!"1(&&;*"+('5(74'.G

!!

05(:*,"'!"'(&#!(:(7"))>:!"='&(4,*$ <.0($(+'!";;!''((*,,5(5*7*$&(*7.<(("!"'(&#!(:(7!" 14&,4*"+('!&,'7#(&'!,(;("'/!(/))>*"7&(+&7 !"'(&#!(::*,"'<(!"=1&74+(7G

!!!

"+('5( #*+*"+!(,  "'!!(7 #!7( <'5 *7#(&'!,(;("', :(&(  +$4<<(7/  5(&  +$*!;  ,54$7  5*#(  <(("  +",!7(&(7  !" *+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&.G

!# ,1(&&(,4$'/<'5&$$"4;<(&,7!7"'!"7;("'!"G

#

(&4,*$&(,4$'&(#(*$(7'5*'&*'(=&.*"7 ("(&*$*'(=&. ;*&8,:(&(+4'G

#!

"&(+(!1'!"'!;*'!"#!7($(''(&""(?4&( 2>:!'5 %&!' ('!'!", )))*"7""(?4&( >

 /*=*!",'&$$"4;<(&)/,5(<'*!"(7;*&8,G

#!! '(&  7(+!,!"    4$$  ("+5  7*'(7  )/  "

&(;*"7  :5(&(<.  ,($(+'!"  :*,  415($7/  *11$!+*"'21('!'!"(&/ '5&4=5  +4",($/  ,("'  $(=*$  "'!+(  7*'(7    & +",!7(&*'!"5(&+$*!;*=*!",'*#*!$*<$(#*+*"+. (;*$( *+8:*&7$*,,*'(=&./<4',*;(&(;*!"(74"7(+!7(7

(&+"'&*/&"84&!''*$/$(*&"(7 77!'!"*$ 7#+*'( ("(&*$/  *&.*"*  ,4<;!''(7  '5*'  '5(  &(,1"7("',  5*7  +"74+'(7  '5( +;<!"(7  &(+&4!';("'    <'5  '5(  *7#(&'!,(;("',  11$!+*"'21('!'!"(& ,4<;!''(7*"*11$!+*'!"!"'5("*;(0*"'&*(#!7*4=5'(&  *;

!:*,:5!$(*11(*&!"=!"!"'(&#!(:*=*!",' $$)!"=("(&*$+*'(=&.

*"7*=*!"!"'5("*;(0*"'&*(#!:!(3!&("7(&0!"=5*=*!",' $$ >>"'5(!&,'!"'(&#!(:!"=("(&*$+*'(=&./,5(<'*!"(7;*&8, *"7!",(+"7;*&8,!"2+*'(=&.*=*!",'$*,',($(+'(7+*"7!7*'( ;*&8,/!(/!"=("(&*$*"7!"2+*'(=&.(&+*"7!7*'4&(:*, +",!7(&(7*=*!",'<'5'5(+*'(=&!(,*"7,5(:*,!"'(&#!(:(7':!+(/<4' ,5(+4$7"';*8('5(=&*7(!"'5(,($(+'!"$!,' %(5*#(5(*&7'5(*11$!+*"'21('!'!"(&!"1(&,"/$(*&"(70'*'( 4",($/1(&4,(7'5(&(+&7% )))/&(#!(:*11$!+*'!"

*"7*,:($$*,*#(&;("',!"% > "('5(=&4"7,*"7,4<;!,,!",*&(;("'!"(77<&!"= '5(+*,(:!'5!"&(*$;(&&&*11*&("'"&(+&7&,!;1$(&(*,"'5*''5( &(#!(:1('!'!"(&/*,1(&*#(&;("',!" *&*,>*"7% > /  (?'&*+'(7  <($:/  *11$!(7  4"7(&  <'5  *7#(&'!,(;("',  #!7(  $$ ,)*"7>>&(,1(+'!#($.(&;*&8,<'*!"(7/!(/!"&(,1",(' !&,'  *7#(&'!,(;("'  +4$7  "'  <(  +",!7(&(7  *=*!",'  *+8:*&7  $*,, *'(=&./&(,(&#(7!",(+"7*7#(&'!,(;("'*,'5(&(:*,"1,'&(,(&#(7

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

2*'(=&./:5(&(*,$*,',($(+'(7+*"7!7*'(!"<'5+*'(=&!(,<'*!"(7/ !(/!"("(&*$*"7!"2(&($.<(+*4,('5(&(,1"7("',*&("' *<$('1&74+('5(&(+&7!"'(&#!(:))>5*#!"=7(,'&.(7'5(,*;( " !"#!(:'5(7(+!,!"7*'(7)*,1(&1&*+'!+(*"7 !"#!(:!',&(,$4'!"/'5(1('!'!"(&+*""'/'54,/'*8(<("(!''5( ,*;(5(,*;(,'*"75*7*$,<(("'*8("<.'5(&(,1"7("',!"% > ""(?4&( 26  5(&(!,",+1(!"'(&(&("+(!"&(#!(:!"='5(&7(&1*,,(7

 <.'5( 4$$("+5/:5(&(<.'5(,($(+'!"!"#!(:'5(*7#(&'!,(;("' *&(;("'!"(75*,<(("415($7 (,4$'*"'$./'5(&(#!(:*11$!+*'!"*"7 *11$!+*'!",((8!"=+"7"*'!"7($*.*&(7!,;!,,(7 &7(&<(+;;4"!+*'(7''5(1('!'!"(&*,,5(!,*11(*&!"=!" 1(&," /.,% +.

  %.)6*+,-. ) 0+ ))-,.0%,1%!(.

*+10)  .-!(   *+10)

78 3# :8;

!; ;98 <=>9 ?

@8> !; ;9

A $ @8>