High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5931/2024dismissed

Vishu Midda v. Shree Gurdwara Singh Sabha (Regd.)

2025-07-28Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal20 pages

!"#$#%#&## ##% #

()* +,

!-, . /

01-)1 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7

()*

-+468 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7

()* 91:8 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7

()* 21;2121 !11 0- 2 -321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7 .

()* 01<;01<# !11 0- 2 -321425'4*#5-41!1 6

()* +1=3 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7

()* :-<> !11 0- 2 -321425'4*#5-41!1 6 7 /

()* %)214>8 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6

()* 11=3 !11 0- 2 -321425'4*#5-41!1 6

()* 9-91 !11 0- 2 --321425'4*#5-41!1 6

7 .

()* -81-41: !11'* 0- 2 -321425'4*#5-41!1 6 #), ?$:

)"2 09#)#

#=#:

#4-$>

!"#!$$

#!$"%$%& '

((

#$!$#!)!

#"%%$%& *

" #)#!%)

%%%$%& - .

/#"0"/%$%& 1- + .

2+ 2 / 09#)#

#=#:@" /""

4+ .

+ ( +

(5 5 (

(

, (

,, +

,, 6

, ( ( ,, *(, %

/ !"/%$%& 4

1 + .

+ ( + 4 (5 8.

, ! + .

+ ( + 4 (5 4

+ "! ;

' *

" & 4

9 :5 2 ( <

:5,

("":=%:4

5 "

. , + .

+ ( +

(5 & ; .

( .( > ,

( ?

$$$</ , , "&"$%$"" .

$"$&%$"0 @.

. . 2

. ( , (

( ,

$$!%$"0 ( .

2.2 ( .

,@.

. , , .

(. ,, ,

@ . , ,

( (

, ( .

(

. (

(

, (

. A ,

,8..

"&"$%$"" B@.

, ( !""$%$"0@.

, , .

(

@ .

. , ,

, 2 (, * , @.

, * ( .

(

( ( .

# 7, ( . (

. , /

=6115 18>A-1611A-1@ 884B !!

=661111158116 B

! 81 0 '

) $&"%%$%$ . (

. .

"#$0%$%& ( (

. "$ @.

(

(, .

45 ( + "!4!54 545 (

, D45

(

. (

D45 ( ,

+ "% ' * ( ',

5 " 0 4' * & " )5

9" ):5 "" ; (

(

+ "!4!54 545 . .

, .

(

, "% (

, .

. , .

2 .

, , , .

, , .

. .

. . .

( ( "!

(

" ).

(

+ %45

%45

+ !

+ "% .

(

, "& 3 (,

*(,

)-<024@

* '1+18*/ @9<266102 #-1@

' *'1+18*/

@$8CC02-18)@

'* '1+18* .@ 1 '!1+* : 02 !-C5@ 7/'7*!:/.

@1214 0)181>

1@ / "@"1<)- -14 6>0:1 -61 1@ .

*"@ #<)<14:0!-C518$<@ #'2-6 -*.@5C214 02 !-C5@# '2-6-*7 @$0-

'.7*#:..

@$8+214022% 25@

/' *!:7 "1!< >8021

--3 214 25 215 01C --4 215@ 9-<C@

'*'1+18*7. " ( , .

( / .

"# @.

( + "!4!54 545. 8 ,

. ,

* .

( . , "0 (

, .

*( .

, . , .

, , .

, .

, 2 6 2 ( 2.

(

( ") (

" )

(, . .

" ). B ((

2 *

. ,

$8+214022%25 @1D ..D

/,!,

@"1!<

>8021 --32142521501C --4

215@9-<C@

'*'1+18*7.@"4C1214 98101>)11618@

*'* @ 28#-C011-6>:@ .'

* '* @)E >821>2( 0983 (

*'*

#1-41 :0"139-#@

*'* " @

%$ @ .

*( .

4+9-0 1!)1> #

'2* :3 1%%F/ @ +, @

( , , , @ #2$0)-<1214

# '2*7 @:3 1%%F

. +, @ ( , (

. (

, / .

@ .

, (

6, EE( EE6

( E @.

, ((

* , .

, *(, (

F +, @

%03 ( ..#'2*

:3 1%%F/ .

(

, ((

, ( D

(

, *(, +,

28#-C011- 6>:11@ .'.*2

#189-'*0!#4438;! '* :3 1%%F . @ +, @ .

(

, ( ,,

( %"

(

, 3 (

, .

3 ( ,.

2 ( , , ,

. ., 2

(

( .

. , 2

(

- ( .

, .

. (.

(( , (>

, .

( , (

( .

(,,, .

+, ,

8. . ( 2 .

> .

; . ,

2 .

( .

, ( ,

7 > 22

(

G ,

; .

, ( ( ( + "!4!54 545

(

, , ,

(

B'/"5;

( . + * .

. , , ( . @ .

(

* . ,

, *(, /

-8"10!8214

'*'1+18*7:3 1%%F7 ., .#6-8 +1+11 611@15+@3-836D88 6888141 1681>A-1H >584-4 +1+>61 11388 81 1> 16814 8831 44- +11@1-21 ' *'*'1*

#@1 86115 1 1118>114-5C11+13 1 -66 C-4 1-1I)E$18- + % C 9- -6 J

.'* '1+18* @ 31158-, G11611183514-1>16814 414141@-121 ' *'* #@ 41+1@1-

11681 ->6+11K IC9-+$-)8J

*'*7 @138 , G+146-C-41$<J'-6*@ 1-1 611 -141 -5D 1'5*'* 21 ' *'*'1* #5 18>681+11611@3+@85> -88$1646

C-4@1-1

6111-85-- 1-@ 1 5 6814@ +1 414141+14--5D1'5* '*58<1@1611 1-@1

613 -88>35-141 -5D1'5* '*1 814+1561+ 8+11-@61153- 8>5-88 1868141

-5D1'5*'*1+11611K

, *(, /

2-10%188@

* '* 7.:3 1%%F 7 .7, .1-5->141 21 ' *'* '1* !-C5511#@ A-1 568

88A-161 13-61H1-6>145-18141 -5+-5-1814 31--

11- 1#1 1-5811148568-6 -88 $ #-1> 1 - 1 $< 0 211 2+1%+1@ //'

*'* -815 68-6C-4 ?582-6-1#2140 9-@:3 1%F7 @313181614 6 21 ' *'*'1* !-C5511 #@ @?582-6-83G 13 -K121 ' *'*'11*151814 -58-'5* '* 16+11+> -58-'5* '*A-188-85161 > 8 135-1-8+41+-661

>83<+4 -5D8- '*8>1 1583A-18 1 5-1:-8 8 !<0"31@ /'*/

@21C 0$8C214@ /.'

*'* 7@1 +1 68414D6814 > 141 21 ' *'*'1* 68 - 5C1 1 1 5 88 15-8@ 115C1>4@1184861

516-6611 83-11 -88$C-4 1-5>?582-6 -51-5+815>:-8 6D5-1@-5581+1- D6814 @31111 2-83>51 1@1 61 1(8+5C11 <1118411 18<> -5C11168>611 1+>16 1C6113 183>5<1+5@

168> 181)>@

7@6D1 1>-5C1

>141

21 ' *'*'11* #5685>88> 8>1@11-3+115 885 #6688#-1>@61 6145 3-5831614

188

1 115 1-@1681 5141414D6814 >141

585>1-12!<->0 93891)8@

*1+18-/./1 D6814 >141@ 831 8 6814+5158>1611@3 1161+183 161@31>5 1-111+18-161-88>3 18< 5C1 1 31 + 1 -5C 214 0 !214@

' *!:7 @1585> 1-3 18<>5C15-D 6814 >141 21 ' *'*'1* #@ >1-1 114@5C151415> 1+111+1 >1@181585 C

31885- 681+121C? '-6*@515>8-8 6D @1585>1-1111 14-883685<414D6814

>141 115 1-@3 -681<5 88#6688 #-1>1-81-690"4@ //'

* 7

@-0 4@ //:7 5 11@15811111 14 - 883 - 1 5 1 4

4-1+11611K % , ..

2 /

-62140C1214$1@

* '*7/@:3 1%%F /

.@ .

., (

(

+ "%" ),(

(, ,3 " ).

,( ,

, @ + %45 9( @

+ !45 .

+ "%

* + %45!45

"% " )

/ H21 '* L8141- 1-1L@ > 4--3@68@-@A-@68 "1$-D 31141-6+11 211411 #@ .7 '8#MM .7 *1581-> -18->68 3165>3+@1 >588@31141 11581- >-H L8141-61L@>83- 41-8-8D41-8-86-6@>5-18146 5-1814584148141-1-118-@

4@ 4- -D-@ 1 >@ 66114-5-18146 5-1814H

> 114

1N-5-18146 5-1814 5 118C> H !453@51488@84@ 5> 11881 188@8 4 1 31 1 58 1 1@@35 1 #@518-6>8-8141-61H

$ "-111,D - 88 + C-111 1 >-1 6141 6 +11 >6311--1-61 > 8141-61 +> 6>58 --5D1'

* 1746>58--5D 1'

* 138141-1-1 --5D1'* 1.>61 -@4 K

%0 /

. ,

"1!< >8'-65 (..

2 /

. .

+ "% " )@ .

" ).

( (

( .

, (

(

B .

+ "! @.

, ( " ).

H7$331 @>14 1- 1C-111@>14 1545># .@381 1 # .

!-C5 5 11 # 5 1 31 88-8815>6614#-1>-#

.@15 1 88 11

/ 14<1 +118>-#14 ->1856@ 15-8>--1O -6#8@136113 18@31 61 > # .@ 8836 8>C-1 18>1 18146115 88 .61@1 88@-853883-8518 6--55 885 #-1> 1--# .+8> -8 61141+14-61 146-5 6-1>-# 36--14>8>5 88 #-111--11#21

-8+6136113 181+13 > 61 #@5-+1 816114 +-5-5A-8>+@188>- #18 1688>316- # 18 1>6+1131 5 614 <5 8821

8> 5

61441--1O-6 >8141-61 111 L61--1O-61L5 161 !-C5511#@31 --1O-641 8>->6+11 !-C55 11## .-@1>+13@5 1 8 # -8 5 1811+ 5 1 88 41 --1O -661 84181414>61+184 681 C-58>5> 14--1O-6-# .

-8#-61 C-111 65>#-111-- !-C5511#1@ @-68K %) .

F .

A0 "" '

(

,* @

D ..D

/ '$8+ 214 0 2 2 % 25 *@ %%$!%$"0 /

/ H6@1+111-4 +1-4-31+18588818-14-5D 814 5 1 A-1 5 4188> +61A-116 51445-181431 1

64- 86- 1 - -511#6 @18161 818568-@881<14 +11+1-4- 311<+11- / # 5 1 31 -58 8141- 11-1 +11 --1O -6 8141-61 1118- / # 21 #88<5-63+ --1O8>-61>8141-61@35 #-58@1+1 88@84@31-611 8141-11-1!154-21

- 3-8 + C-111 1 > -1 614 1 6 +11 > 6 3 1 1 --1O-61 +> 316>58-217 8+- 4--5D1'7* "1!< >8?'-6*@131 16+11 5 1 11-11 88 1 1 14 ->@C-111 -11- # -85-5-88>@15+1@+11 3@-@-684-15> - 5-21

@-113-8+ C-1113CK %

" ).

5C214 02 !-C5'-6*3 .

*(, .

. ,

!$ (, .

, . 8. ( .

(, . , !" @ ( ( *(,

3 .*(,

( '',

" )

( .

, ( (

*(,

$8+ 214'-6*

"1!< >8'-6*

(

, . *(, +, @ .

. , !% (, ,

,3 . , . ,

( " )

@ ( 4

B'/!5 ( .

2 F

, . ( ,

(

!! *(,

( (

(

!& @ .

5 ,

( ,

' ( 5

( '09#)#

#=#:* "%

!- . /

I 2 (<

J < I J <