Haryana State Electricity Board v. Anil Kumar & ORS



"#$%$"&$'
#( ')*+$
, #$+"&
$

 

!   - 

+

 . / 0  $  3

  % 

2  *

1.     $ 1  &1

 1

4 .



51/6/  764 1

81/ 
/ . / 
0 $9*%
)'3#"%3'
,7#  $9*%
)'3#"%
' "

  

   

 

  

!"  #  $



%

&

&

% %   )" +,   -              .

(/ 0 %)"%     )       )1 

$   # 

 %       2  3-   

..( % !" 3  "*5%!"
%  + , 6



  7  -  *  -    3-  -      

  '0 %   ,
%  8

..(''

(/

..



"

$

% $#  
9% '0 % - #-  $1 2  3-   %#              3-    $       



 '0% )   4:7 2  3-  --

*3# ;3 



..<< <

..'

'0% 3- )"*#!
+, $ 

   

+
 8/(<

..<  5  764 1  5/  #8  $  3

  % 

2  *

1.  .

81/6 - % % -      2  3- %  

7  *3# ;3  '0  -)  =

+
 &448 ..< 5
:.13;8
.86

81/5/$ 3

% 

2*

1.

81/6 

-    %" -  )"

%)% 

$ )"* ) %  # 

 %    )    -       

" 3-  7  ;3#*31     )    "

  3- %  )  5- 6  '0%%% -  

<

% !% 

9 -'.

(8

..8 + %  )">9 -> 5 6     ;%  - 9-# %%    $2  3- %   %"2  3-  $#  
9 ) -

  $ )" - 2 - >9 -> 5 6% )" +,


 

,
 &48 ..8 !% 

9 -

'((0%  )" ,
*  - "  

-    

=  - -- "/8764 15/$ 3

% 

2*

1.

81/% )" -2 - + 

      9 -    4 (             >9 -> 5 6 $)" +, -  

,


/(&'(

5!"3  "* ;? 6%   )",
*

9 - .

3   , 5+65++

.4.'( <6-    + %  )" +  ( (8 <  , %   )"

% )" -2 -

9 - ''

( <  >9 ->  5 6 ;? 5 6 
  

 )"*#!
+,- 9 - ''

( <%   .

(/ 0%"

 )"% )  !%  )7 "

+  0/(/,
 &% )"*#!
+, -    .

(/ 0@"

-    +  >9 -> 5 6 

 "   2  3- %



(.

'((4            -  %      -  ")"% -   * 

(.

'((4% )" "  3- 

 =  !<< > 11

81/5/$ 1 &1

   1

  4 .  . 

81/       - % 3- % -  1 7  !%   -"

  A

* *#!
+,%   )   -  %  > " '%)

*% 

-7 )    )  "7 ) - "  7 %  )  = %    % - " )% 7 %  )  $A

*     #     '            )"+    >9 -> 

>

5 6  -"*#!
+,% %  "  2  3-  3-  #  ) -  )"*#!
+,-   - 2 -  - )     A

 *   
    5 6

  "% -   -%  -   $  % )" % )    8  &

& ? ;





1 6/ 1.1.

. 8 //6@41;.

8 .1

/  11 9/

//61 A. .. - A 61 81

/1B61.

@

C@2 8 /.1 

8 1.1 .

.<D61   8  1.3; )6.; 1

14/  8 1.1 .

.-  D61   //. 8 /

 $ - 

 @ )  )" 1 ) %) -  )"*#!
+, 

  *   
         5 6    9 -  >9 -> 5 6%  B   -2 -        # 

  %     %  )        9 -% 

  ) 

$ %  ) %-  C 

!

         

        -     +,          .

0  ) -         )"A

* 
  % ? 6/  11/ . / <

/

/

 1 11 6.   ;

A/ 4 @ :6.;4 / 1 //. 61  81/ . /A1



; 81 1;8 / /4 2@C 4.8

;6  8 1  / A/ 4 .#8 /:6.;4 /8 @

. 1

1. /D61/  A1/

 2 "  @ 

/ 8 @ 1  /

1./ /. #8 / 1.1

.

 14/

 8. / 

C >>8 8 /

. 1

1.  8/ >" 14/ 

. / A  1/8D1 /@.



/

1;8  8 / =84 C;

D1 /A:6.;4 /A //. 61 1/ . / <

 ./4 1 2/

.

811/ / @C 4. )" )   "%9 - >9 -> )"  -2 -,
*%   %  

>) -- C9 - >9 -> % % - 1 
8
/

"A

* 7  *#!
+,   %  -  "   # ; % # '%) 



  )  9  %  >9 ->   - "   )"

       '    )"         +, ?

8 @  /

;1 6/ .1

1 16 /8 1

81/   . 82 1--<46 8 1.

 1

/F.4..

/;--


:.13;8
.6 .

81/E =   -2 -  

%''

( <

 ) .

0 
 B % )      )"  A

  * ?=8 4 C; 

D1 /A:6.;4 /A //. 61 1/ . / <

 
 
 

  

     -  $    4

+  0/(/,
    '( &    ,
  .88    '( 0     )"   +,D 8/$ 9@ $;8 61 814 .. 8.1

/  //. 1 1=  !>> --< ./6@/B6   !> --./4//.. 1.1.

. A "                    )"    A

  *

, % - ) - )"  +,  -%%   - 
 A

*   "   )",
*

>9 ->  ;? 5 6 %  -  +               9             )        

+,   %7 " )"   +  ) ;%   -   A

*

 4

..<  )"

) % +
 &448 ..<

>9 -> %   )  

%  -  &

&   "

%% %  - )     8        D 8  ;

 

 

 1 6/  1.1  .

.

 8 //6@41;.

8 .1

/ 11 9/

//61 A. .. -  61 81

/1B61.

%         A

  *    )             >9   -  >  %     #   

'7 *#!
+, "  ) >9 ->    5 6     )-                )"  

*   %   )  9 -)" -2 -       % -"%)-

   =     " )   )"  8  "% %%)  0  &

&@ ?#8+/ * 8/ 

2

C



8   1 1  . /     8  

1/ 

  * 8  .

.

  D61  

A  1.1.    8 

/ 

-

:.13;8
.86

81//61  81 1

 2  8  .4/

  . /   .

.  >>   /

1 . 8 .1



8 /

112

1/8D1 /

/

1;8 /  8 //6@:

8

. 

   




       
 



  



!

 
 

  

  =%    "   &

&    -"  )   3'
,7# 
' " )'+&% )'+&% (/

  

  -#> E3# >) E3#