High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/1057/2019dismissed

Sonia Dhawan v. State Of Haryana And Others

2020-06-19Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi38 pages

#$%& " &"'#%&'%

$ ( )**%& "

$+ ,,,,,

- .

& ./0 1

. 4

1 #

$ #. &"

#* * ..#.

$ + 5 .

% 3 . "* * # .* 6

7 !.

* & * * #

# & . - 4

$ & . 80

* &" # 3 .! 8

- 34 . 3

* &" # ".

$ 2

* &" # .

3!& .

< &

& . 3

#* &" # 2

# .."

#.* &" #* .

& .

$. "

! . % .

* !

. & . -

$# %3!

3 " .-

$8 +

! *3 ..

& . 3 3 = .

$8+

.. ! ..

3!*

# - *

. & . "

#. 2

= 3. #*. . 3* *.

. %;!

- &" # ..#.

$8+-

& . .

*. & .

! & . - 3 !

" . #.

.. 3 #

& . 1

# (&" # 3 & . % .

% & .

. !

. " & .

# # & . 3 * 2

* & . .

". " 2

. .

*% * % .% % ... ".*

"3.

& .

$ + " . " "

* # &% 8%)" .) >1

1 .

?&% +

2 .1 "

1" @A " . . * # @% @A$ . # 1 .

@A$1 " # 1 .

@ 2

- " .

$"4

%# * 3!& .

#* & . 12.

3 3 * &" # *& . -

3 1 #

* 3 # & . 8

* >.

$ . 3 "

#.%%

. % &*3.2 " %

#.%%

. %&*3. 3* &2&4 .

** .

9 %&2&4

$+ $ $#% #%&*3.1 %4

$8 =

# .

*. # * .

# ! ;*. #

&" #

>& . ?. - .

# . 9

# .

# ;!

* "

! ;*

&" # &*3.9 < *

#% . # ! ;*%#

&" #%

# .5

; ;!

* * .

# 1

#- "

# .

& . 9 7 ! ;* .

3!."

# *#

&" #

) .%&*3.1 -3"

* * " >

$8? .

$7?

* >

$+?-% * %&2&4 .4 ) .

# ; #

08%$ $#% '% &*3.1

45. )#*. #

0%$ $#% '%&*3.1 " # # 4 * - = .

* .

= * *3

. .

#&*3.. * 3 .

$ + # 1

$8+ ".

. . .

$ ! . * 34

# . * .

* .

3 # * 3. .

&% +> @ +&@? '

&% B> @ B&@? * 3.

* .

2 .

* %

$ "

. "

#." .1

3! .1 ** 3 #" *- & . . # * .* &3"

$. #

* &" # 2

- & .

.* .

# #

3 = .

* &" # *

$8 .#

** .

!* .

% * .

&" #

) .% &*3.1

$ .

% .

*3 ##

* .

$8+

# 3. . " * .

-* .

3 .! .

# ## *

- "

#." .

1 .!* .

3* * .

-% * 3

0 .

$ 8 + " ! * . . * 34

# . * .

* . 3 # * 3.

* ! . * .."* !

$8+" . .!* .

- " *

3 ". ##

*3 . B - . " B

..#

3* .

!.3

$ 34

# .

$ "

#3.

# *

& .

$ ! ..! . - .

# .

- *

$83 #.

# .

+33 #*.

#3 #..##

.!*

* .

$ 8

'&'

< #

& !

$ ! ... #%

.# #*3.

3 5 !

& .

.!* - * .

# B *!

$8+ #* .

& . (*

$( (&" # . "

#.. #

. 3!#

% *. * % . % !

** & . C ?

% *"3./ **"3.

** 2

#% *

. #

# !

# %

$( (&" # .

# "

. * " #

.. # (

*& . ."

$8C

& ?

:* .

**3 . "

$8*

$% .

3!#

/ % *

.** C

#% *

*. 3" % .

" B

$ .

- " B

. "

" .. # ( '()*+,-.*/0*)123-(.'"43565.+574/-875.+"6*/*38"9-31,.2:-(36 *.'356,'5.+,*/*))-77-'*+,-.,.(6+3*/,* - # *;!

A "

" . D #.

# * 2-2% !. 7 .

*. 3.

# #%

%& .

8B !

3* .

" *

" & . .. >

@&A@?8+(7>< *.

%0+%(%%/( * .

#*78**3!

.< 3.

# !

# " 3

* *. 3 (* .. " **

* .

;*.-

544 #2

" *. .. !

# *B*8*

$ 5&

% D #.

# % 2-2 .* - E % * %D #.

" .D

& . %1 (222 . *1 !2

D %

%& . % " .* . * #*

.*5

* #* & . * < #* 1

! * * 8*

+*8*

. * &A B !/&A+>

88%B%/(?

* .

#3 &A !/&A+>

. < *.

#A31 #

. * 3&A

% B%+>

+%B%/(?. " 3 * &A

! & . #3

+:536-(3)56-;,.)-75",;*.8"7-<5*0/5=,77-<*0/543-453+,56*.' 356,'5.+,*/*))-77-'*+,-.,..',* - 5 *F. ' % &*3.1

#$ . # %G !%*!".

+%%/(< *.

* .

+%/(

* *

. H0%A&%;!

% . # 3

*3 . *

* 3 !3.

+%+%/(< *.

& 5 !2

%( 7% !.

$ . * . '

1 %G ! "

#".*

+. - .

3 * 4 * .

# =

." + =%83 * % ! %.33 %83* % #*%

5 !3. 3&A%>

I!?.

" &A* #&A8B%BB+>

%%/(< * ?

. !"

&A8.>

+ ? "

#+#* #.

6 (8I< 1 & .

3-4-65' 6):--/,.2" +35*+75.+ 5+) -; +:5 '5+5.(5 *.' 4*3+,)(/*36 352*3',.2)(6+-'8*.')*35-;+:5'5+5.(5'(3,.2+:5,39-31,.2:-(36" ,;)(6+-'8,6:*.'5'-<53+-+:57 - " B .

# 8

..3. .%

..3 * * .

. !.

3* 7

- . " * .!

- .

! *- & . .

# *.# !% $:%& . 2 3 #"

* 2

- *

& .

3. # 3. .

& . 1 6

F3 %

% . "

#.*

# & . "!.

. * * '" * & . .

#.* - .

#&A 88!. # &A + * & . '" * - * .%.

& . '" * 3 #

#.*%

. "*3.. %" !

#% * 3. . & . '" * *. # !

# *B*8* < * . - "

*3.. . & .

$+- !

*%.% * %

... ".* .

< - #** & . 2

* .

;*.-

544 #.

" " .

J"4%

# * .

# ..!

4 !

" .

- . * .

**8* .*0* ..

! . # ** .

.! ** .

# *

$ " .."

# .

1 $ 3. .

% & . .

** .* & .

! "

3 .

* .

& . ..

# 4 * .

&*3.1 . #

* !

# .

**3 4 * .

. D 5DI% !.

%%/(

* %5

; : '" .%&*3.

B%/(* %$ !

& ! 5- 1* &" # .

) .%&*3.

. .

F* .

3 .

! "

3 %3 * " *

3 * .* 2

- . *

. "

* " .

" # .

* .

$ " " .

4 * * * .

- ! .

* 43%# * .. . "

- # " # * .

# #&A

88!*& . '" * - .

#&A 77!

3 !

#3"

3 . 3. .

7 2" . 1

# # ."

4 . . *

+ !"

#$%. 1

# * #

$!.

# 7

# & .

* # - 4

$ & .

80 - &" # 3

3# & .

# 1.

- . # *;!

$ 3.

- & . .

& . + 3 ..#..

# "

*- . B

#3- <

$ "

$8 .

$ .# .

3 3

..#..

*- .

$8+" .#. #

$8 .

# 30 %

+3!

3 .

..## # -

.! 3 *- 3 3 (.# .*

.#.# % .

- !

# # #%

%& . 3.

#&A8+(7* !

.< 3. !

. # *.

"3 #

B*8*- #

* .

# * .

#&!

# .. !

(*2

* .

% * %* .8*

..!

(*2

* .

.."

# .2

* .

..! .. # *

..! *

# .3

* .

..#

<* . " !

$ ! .

** . " " 3

.# #*3.

* .

& . .

- (&" #

3 & . % .

% & .

. !

. " & . # # & . 3 * 2

& . .

". " 2

. .& +&

$%3 # .

# 3 3

$8+"

* ..#.

$+ .

" . "

* # &% 8

$+".

" . "

-)" .) >1

1 .

?&% +> @ +&@?-* .

3 3

K1 .

> 7?>? +&

@ @

>B? +&-* #3( * .

3 * *

3* #2

8>< ? +&F%

.@F* .

3 . @

8>"? +& *

3 . %

3 .# .* .

- 3 #3 .# .

. ..

3 .

$ . . ..-

$ .

" . "

2 .

1 "

1" % @A " . . *

# @%@A$. # 1 .

@A$1 "

# 1 .

@ 2

3 "! #

* .

# B&-% *

< 1

3 1

$+" ..

..#.

* 3

& . 2 #* %. 1

. . . 4 #*

" #$

%& '()*$ % +,-./ -0/1 -/#&0 ) ) +,-/-0/-/# 2' 3 +,-4/ -0/5-/#

6 ' +.-5/

-0/ 77 -8 !/

90 ( 3

' + ,-,7/ :5.-3 !/

. 1

# .

&% +'

&% B * 3. !

* .

1 * .

3 * 3.-% * 3 ! F* .

1&*3.I 1

$ + #

* .

..#

# -

#." .1

3!( * ** 3 #" .*-& . . # * .* & %

$ 2

. #

* -

* *

& . 1

* .

! 3.

"3 . # #

* .

- 3

. & .

* *

$8#

(** .

& .

$ .

< '&#

$8+ #

**3 )

F* .

. . " * .

$ . "

# )

F* .

& .

# . ".

)

F* .

3* .

* .

) .%&*3.1

. "

# # " *

# # -

. "

# . 1 . " .

* * .

# *. *

# #%

% & . & .!

% # # *. * .. *& . '" *

** .

& .

.. 3 3

. .

-% * 3

#* . 1

. . 4 #* ( ' +-/ -0/41-/#

)0 $ 9 -/+-./

-0/,5-/#2*

.7 5

.4,-*;!!/# <*=,4,=5 ->;6/

,5-*;!!/# <*=41=5->;6/

8 *

1,5-*;!!/#6 ( ( 6 +7-./ -0/ .-8 !) /#60$ !

& $ +1-.5/ -/, -6!) /

6@ : +- :

/.54-9 !) /

0 I 1

. 3* * 3

F* .

1 &*3. *

# = #

* 3

B $% .. . 3 3

* # #..

3,7,.*/445*/--;

>)3/?-#-;

+,+/5'*6:,+* *:(@6 +*+5-; *A*6+:*.*.'-+:536

@3.*13 "

(

! "

#! $%&'()*'+,,-./0 "

+ &0, !

*$"

&.2')*(+,,-3-

4 +

&.2'*)+,,6''

7, 1

8 $

%&> '()*$ % +,-./ -0/1? @3.*13 "

( '69

/ ;

/ / '(7

: + ,

7, / / /

8 "%< <

3 ..

..*.

* ..#.

3 *

. * .

".#. # !

+4 17+5 41+ . 45 3 " 3

* .

< 1 = 3.

< %

% %

. #3*.

.. < 4

= 2 3 " *. * * 3 .

#.#. *

*. ** . %3 %3 *

% <

4 .

%* * 3 . .

= "."

. .

.#. # % .

# %.. * . 2 .

% 3

3 ..#. C0(+,.

+:5)*65-;6():*93,+6(5'-(+;-3+:5'5+5.+,-.-;*):,/'"+:5/*9,6 )-.)53.5'.-+6-7():9,+:+:5,//52*/,+8-;+:5'5+5.+,-.*69,+:+:5 95/;*35-;+:5):,/' 8 &0 ) ) =5-1/ -0/ ,5 @3. * 1 3 "

+4 17+5 41+ 2 .45

.#. 2

.. 3" 7 AB 9%6 069%;>-,5/ $ @3.*13 "

( (9

8 + ():,*A--@6 *.A55<*A-- >#? >,<,/?

?-.B0/5 (43575-(3+-0653<5'*6(.'53 C>

: / ,

8 :

% + & .

3 & +&% .#

* @

.. * @ ><.

4 * .

? % 3

* # .

*%*F 3

.# % .

8> ? +& . *

* 3 % .* ..3*

8>? +& . ..3 . #

" "

.. ##

* # * #

% #

.. 3.* 0 B &* 1*! #

0> ? B&"

# . ## * %1 ..% 34"

%3#

. * 34%

* 3.* 0>?

B& .

# ..3. * %1 .."# #% <

. # * %

* % %

% %

< # " .

# * 0>8? B&*

* .

# * .. # %1*

+& .# * .

. #. *

0(+ ,.7*++536)-.)53.,.2+:5)(6+-'8-;*7,.-3):,/'"+:54*3*7-(.+ )-.6,'53*+,-.,6+:595/;*35-;+:57,.-3*.'.-++:5/52*/3,2:+-;* 4*3+,)(/*34*3+8 +&

".* .

> 55 (3,.'53!*(3 *.':(> 7+?@6*30*C ,.2: *.':(">&$?# %&"/,D*05+:,.6:*9>36?@63<*.',.6:*9">&? $*.':*.'3*1*/*5.-.>36?@6@,4,.5.-.>*4+?"#>?

>3,7,.*/? >#? %?- .

*. ( 3 " M3. *1 -68*)-0@6*)-0:*13*7*11*/">#? &$2 .% .*

12 .*

* . *

> *3*69*+:,0*, :3,4*'@6 :3,4*'@*6*.A, $-70*8#?; # *

. .

% .

* . "> -<53':*. */@6*A5.'3*!(7*3" *A$&?1

3 * % . "

N* N-* * .*

* .

* 3 3 * ." "

. " >!*3,-<,.'*.@6 *A*3*7" #*'#? B 2 *.

* " .

* 2 )3*+:">&#?:$#" ,.'/58"

93 "

(

# & N

N * .

%)$G.

1 */153@6*/153E*33,6-.

>&?59F5 5)5.+ *9O%> 5 I1**

% :!

#$% ?

7 /

@ /

A 8 &0 ) ) +5-1/ -0/ ,5 @3.*13 "

( -.C ,

# #

@ & */ ,

/ /

-6 @

@ + '6 "

8 6' 3 35-./ -0/,.7 +-5/,1.7 @

+ , =B 3.

: /

/ @

/ /

A 8 *3 .

& .81

. .. #

#1 < 4

& .1

% @3.*1 . =

3 * .

% 3

*" * #

3#2

* 3 *" @3.*1 ! " #1* "!<

* ".

! # *

. .

" #

* .

. .

- 1 * * .

*/ * " 3 *" C @3. * 1 3 @ *<, :*.'3*. @6 .,-. -; .',*" > ?

>$? >,<,/?%

:,/4*22*39*/@6<,3*/,++*/*.'

*.-+:53> ?>? >,<,/?# >? *3,+* :*37*@6 (6:,/ :*37*

>? >,<,/?#% >?# $ 88 ,+:8*.*.' *2:*<*.@6 +*+5-;-;5/:,"> ?

>#? >,<,/?& >&? $$ @3.*1

( -

" .

3# 2

% 1 2

** = >3? .3 = =

2 ** = %1* * .

*/ *" .

3*. .

%" * ** = %

1 .

. .

*/ *" "( < # .

# 12

.3 = %1 3. # <* * *

. .

! (< # # 1 .

* 2 % .= 3

*" ?

# .

@ .- 3 3 # *

L 87 * # 1 . "

% * .

** =

.3 = #

#.* .

- #1*

= ..# F* .

1/' 1-# .#.3

# = #1 !

# 3

3 * *% #1* 33 * .* % 33 4 # F* .

1/' 1 3

8+ 3@ *<,:*.'3*.@6 .,-.-;.',*> ?>$?

>,<,/?% .

.3 =

%3" .

)-.6,'53+:5

% 95/;*35*.':*44,.566-;+:5):,/'*6+:54*3*7-(.+)-.6,'53*+,-.*.' 2-,.+-*//35/5<*.+*645)+6-;95/;*35-;):,/',.)/(',.26+*0,/,+8*.' 65)(3,+8" /-<,.2 *.' (.'536+*.',.2 )*35 *.' 2(,'*.)5 *.' ;(// '5<5/-475.+-;+:5):,/'B6):*3*)+53"4536-.*/,+8*.'+*/5.+6 8 -=

* .

% 3 "

@3.*1 *:*3, *1:*7(3,@6 -0:*.!-'*/, > ?&& >? #% .

1 3 . 4 ..

(

& 3 " @3.*1 @,<51 ,.2:@6 -7*., ,.2: >? >,<,/?%#"

% .

* 3 .

3*% 3* % * % . *

3# " $ 3%*

. .

"% * " .

# * 66.

3* . # . #*

3. . 80 * #

$!. 7 - 4

& . 80 &" # 3 & .

&" #

# 8

3. .%$:%& .

3* 7

$. # * ;!

- & .

$ & . + 3

- . B

.& &

$ " *

$8 #

$ . * 3*

& . 2 "

& . 6

3* . # 3. F3 . "

$ *

$ . "

# 4

F* .

&*3.

. 2

F* .

* A

$ .

. #. *

3 + &

".* .

* .

3 3# "

= .* .

- #

* .

& . 3 3

#* .

..#..

* .

$83 ..# "

* .

..3

$- .

( .

*" 2

- & . 3

* .

# * .

& * .

. "

# & . - ..#

& "

# ." .

* ** 3 #" .* # * .* 3 & .

. 2 ..#

> ? #

7 ..# .

* .. *

> ?

# **

3 # * : * .D*# * 3 . . 3 .

! . .

" 3

. 3 * - .

# ** . * 33 # "

2 "

$ "

# .. .

. "

# * . " . (

# " ** 8/8 5 % !$: +

% & . .

.** .1 &..#

<* . "3 " B - *

..#

*.* 3

*. * 3

3*". .

. " .

* 3

= 4 3

. = 3

8B %

$ . " #

# .3!#

% *. * % *%

. **

*"3./ **"3.

*. *

" . " 2 "

*. 3.

# #%

% & .

#&A8+(7>< *.

%0+%( %%/(?* "% * . B 3

: .. *F * !

# F * 5 * & . - # "

. *. *

* . *. * 2

" 3* . *

+%/(*

+%+%/(33"

* 3 3 * . "

& . . #2 " 1"

(

= .!

% *

# 3#3 * # *. *

. * #"% *#* . . 1

# . 1

$ . *

* " "

( # *. * .. *& . '" * - . * 3 # % . "

# *

" !

# & . "!.

* *'" * & . .

#.*

. "*3.

-= . * .

= 4 3

* 3 = * "

3 * #" .

. 3 .

. * 8 - * " B

. " * #3

* .

;*.-

544 #.

" " .

* J"4%

# * .

#& !

#*78**3 !

# .< 3. * *.

# B*8*- . * .

* *8* .0* .. !

. # ** .

# * ...! ** .

% ".

# *2 "*

< > ?(* . B &

<(+ "

**. : .. *F * !

# B*( 8*

(

# .< 3.

3. 3 # *7* .8*

> ?( * . 0 &

<( " *544 #

# * .

#** !

# 0 %

# * . * &" #

#%* .8*

* .. * !*

3 & . ...!

# *

* .

.!&" # " .3. "% " !

# % ..

(*2

* .

# .

#% *!

# .

. F%

# !

% # !

# * .

.# #.

./ .# #% #!

# % .."."* .

* .

" .3 . * %

! P

3 . /" 3 . #* .

34 " *3 # 3

.* = # 4 3

3 # 7

$ %

$ # .

* 1 $ 3. .

%& . * %

$ ...

33. .!* .

# !

# "

... #"%=

$ 3 #

.. 3 *

"3 3

# ." "

. = 2* 33 "

$8 #

+ . .

* .

3 3. # **3 4

* .

$3.

. 2

* .

D" #

$8 # 30 3 " 3 #*

*4 .* #3 . .!

!* .

D" #

$8 (

" *3

$ ..3.#..

! *!* = * ' ..

#% * 3 #34 3. . *

#. . "

../: . *

. . .

< '&#

$8 * " %

* .

$8 **3)

F* .

$ 3 3 ..

..#. "% =

.#.*

3 .

'&'

$8 3 # 3

. .

= 4 * 3

93 "

' +.-5/ -0/ 77&. . 1

. ? 3

# "

## !

* . 3.

. # 7 $ 3% &" #% # %

3# & . 3 " 3

3 "3 *" * ".

# ". ## ! %"3

" * . *

* &" #%

# 8

3. . $:%& . % * "3 *

) .%&*3.1 %2

* .

&" #

& . &" #

3 " 3 *..

&" #

3 "3 34 #

*& . *

3 3

.# .

3 &" #&" # 3 #"

* & .

* " * .* .*

&" # 2

&" #

" # ** .* 2 # % 1 &" #% . " #

(*2 !,3+,1(7*3 *:56:*.1*3-6:,@6 3*',41(7*3!*3(.*6:*.153-6:,"#>?

>3,7,.*/? >?# #% .

7B& 21*.*

* . . .!

# * " ..

#$ <

# @3.*1

.. # #

..(3 #

* %

* .

2 * %&" # 3 ## 3

3 3..

3.*!

..#

* .

3! "%= 3

.# 3 3

." "

3 78 -=

. 1

. "

# * . " .

# " . *

C:'& #

$ "

$8 .#..

3./".

# ..

*. .!

* " 1"

# *

* * .

C #* 3* 3 *.

(** .

.!/ .

.. # #

..(3 #

* 3 *

..3

3 .

. .

3 .. . " )

F* .

" "

)

F* .

3 1 3

# "

= 4 3 F* .

1/' 1 &*3. 3

. = 3

- . 1

. F* .

1/' 1 2

.#..

3. 3 = *". 2

3 # * .

#&*3. 3.

. %" 3 .

# 93 "

90 (

'+,-,7/ :5. >. .

. ? = 4

1 4

. # # . * #4

" . 3 . 77 $

%&> '()*$ % +,-./ -0/1? @3.*13 "

( ' /

7 #

9 "

: D

9 "/ '(2

: : /

8 7+ *3,+* :*37*@6 (6:,/ :*37*>? >,<,/?

#% >?# $%

* .

#% 3 *

-F* .

1A& .

# "#"

# :

*.2

% # 13 .

#3 - #1 *

9 . % @3. *13 " #1%

.. #3

% .

# = .

3* 7 * 3

* . .

# "

$ . 3 1

= *

3.*

&" #% # 3 %2*

1 < <

&" #& . 3

.* .

$83.. "

34 F* .

1/'

1&*3.%* .

F* .

1/'

1&*3. 4 = *

& . 70 5 # % * .

3 * "

# .

# 7B

@3.*1

3 "

( '(

'" /

: /

/ /

.. GH 1I/G, I

E 3B'2

8 7 " 3"

F* .

1/' 1 &*3. 4 = *

& . 2 " *%F* .

1/' 1&*3.

. %< .

< * - ..

$+ .. .!1 .

# . :

&%!

% " -

**..

# 3

& . % ..3*

*+*

..+*

+ $ # ..3 <

* 3

. F* .

1/'

1&*3. 4 %

. >

% ;"

# : !

#/ J /$ :3. J /$