Union Of India And Others v. No 26135 T Wg Cdr Jaipal Singh Hooda (Retd) And Another
!" # $%& '
!$%$(%) # $%& *
& +,
- -- .
+, -
- - - ! "#$ % &'
()(& (&'&* +,& -( . % &+
!(* +,& % &/&0* +,& & % ( (&'&* +,& - -- .
/
(!(( &/ * ( ( 3 - &* &#-( !& -( & 45 7 * & & "# ( 0 & '
, "&0 ,, ( &- -(,&00 &( "&0 */( "#( ,0&'- 1 -( !&- &"0# /& &00/
0)1(02 0)34!$(%#
18 &, 49 4:
19:;
& ,'' 1< 4= 6444 & -' ( &&!( &!
- &&6:
!( , - ( *( , &"0#->)&# # * 0
0 ) ) )?76 ( '
- ,(&!
*( &"0#/&& &@4A-0-
@
&"0# ,0&'-( /& ,
"# ( )'
(#* ( ( ! (& ( & &"0# / ( &"&"0 "
! &!!&+& "# -'0&#
1 -0 - & &0 + 0 &
1:
4@ 6461*( )'
(# , &"0# ,0&'- &- * 1(& -
, & &0& ( , & &0(&&0"
,
&- * 1 -0 * "
- ( 0 & '
,
"&0,, */( "#( ,&&,(&00 !
( &- & , & * "
,&'
&00/ + &
&+ &-( & 7&, ( &-
&+ &-( & 7&, ( &-
!" # $
$
%
&
(") *")
+
$
"!"*,",!
$
- .!/0,"!,
1
# 2 3 $
!"%!,%,"!.
$
$
/ )
4
5 ;
0!&!! + -'( &- & & & & *"#( 0 & '
, "&0,, *(
3- &(&-0 &!&( &/ - () %5 ! %) $5 $(!1
=
?
- ,
!'&B & -- ,+ & 8 ,& / *& -0&&, - '!/( ( -&00'
- &# +3C3+ &# '
'"
- ( -
0*" ("
! 00 ( &'#* &( &0 &!
* ( "
,'! 0 * & & '
'"
- ( ,'"&&
- &"0('
*&( ( &'
'&! , *# ( & *( 0'
( !,&"0
( ,!
&0"
!,&"0 &!!&+& "
!
&"&"0 '0&# *(&,D *-'*( , 0 -(( 8 !'
E"0 7)*,& 0
&
*
+& &&!& (-( & + ,& 7&, ( &-
,
$ $
$
6
7
89 :
$ $
$
$
$
%
,")
$
&
$
$
; 3
<
!/,=
+%##
!>*9 89
$
#
$
&
$
$ ?3
0 3
!.89@ 89 A
%
$
83
9 8$9 #
$
$
$
$
$ ?3
!.89@ 8$9 #
$ B
$
$ B
$
$ ?!.89@ 8$9 #
$
+
$
$
$
D
&
?!.89@E 8$9 #
D
%##
=F
8C < 9
,"", =;
< =
> /
$ *"
&
$
$
<
,+ & ! -( &"+ 7&, , 0 * (!( 0# ,0& *(&/( & &"0#"
&0 &#'
'"
-( ,'"&& - &"0('
*& /(,( 7 - 64 A + * ( * (!( &# ,( &"0
'"
+&0 -'( '#*"# (
"
&! -- &"0# :
*( &!'
- &"0# &# '"
-( ,'"&& - &"0('
*/("
&0
/(& &"0#&D&'-64A' *"'
&+ 0# & ,0&& -' ( % ,&0 ?& * &( ,& 0# ,!(&( & && &"0#"
!&"&"0 ,'!&!!&+& "#'0&#
& ,0&&"
8 "#( ; 3
<
!/,=
+%##
!>*9 ( ' *(!( ( & ' &!
+3C3+( (#,&0& '
&0( &0(-&#'
'"
-(
- &"0('
,, * ,&00#/( &( &!
-( ,'! 00 *( , &"("
,'!"
/(&#
% + *(!(( ( &0&-( ' * (& /( &# & ( * ( ,, " D 0#* ( "# ( & (& ! - & !-&# *&( "
'
& D 0-( ! & & '
'"
- ( - &"0('
'
&+ 0#*( - +!( /'
D&"
- & +3C3+( ,, *" ( ' 0# *& ,& *( & '& 3 ,(&!
* ( * ( ,0&'& 0 , + &"0# % + *&00( -&, & ,,'&, & & ( - "# ( ,, *& ,0 0#,F *(- ,0&!/( (
-&# +3C3+( ,, *& D 0D& - '0&# & . ( &'
"
! &!!&+& "# "
!
&"&"0 '0&#
?
(&&'&#*( "
&0 -(&-( , 0 (&# ( ,&"
&0- &"0# ( ,, *"0# $ & ( '
-&,, &, -( ,, '0&# *'
!"
,'! , % ,&0 ?& +3&3+ ( "
! "
/( & /(,( (/ + *"
,,0 # !('
-"
0
# -( & ( -* '&# &0 " D 0#"
,,0 % ,&0?& * & -' - '0&# "
!
&"&"0 '0&# *&( ( &'
!& ,!
&0
( *-( '
,&0 (0 (&( ,0 (&+
, '
,&0 7&'&-( ,, !
'& *( ("
,'! 0 *( *( &'
/00"
(&+ & ! *# ( & & *( % ,&0?& & &- ,,0 !
% + *&0 ,0& &*(&'& &# -( % ,&0?& -00/( ! 0 0& /)(& 3
-( G % ,&0%0&#
*6446HG0 $ &0 , 0 G
1@
- *(&"
/ ' /( '- &"+ , 0 */( &( '
- 0'
-( ( '#*(&- & 0'&#'
,&0 7&'& !'& +3&3+(( &0(*(& ,&'
, &" '
!('& ./( '
,&'
&
(&( & /&& '&&!
% + *&0 ' *-'( -&,&(& */( ( & ,&&0 7 3 -( *& .( ! -*( *( ( 00'
-( &B! 0&, * +3&3+ ( &,+ "# (' - '0&# */( "#*()'&#,,0 (&( -( "&( /&& D 0-( ! ( '#& &,(/&&"&"0 "
,&'
&!!&+& "#( !'0&#
& *&0 !&( -'( , */( ( % ,&0?& * &00# ,
'&B &
&0 ,+ & ,
&0,( ,B* &,0&0#& &!( & + -( *(!( ' 0#'
- & -'
,&0 ,(D * ( + 0! ( "0,B ,(& !
, , ,* /( -'*&( ( ,&'
,
% + *-( &
' 0#'
-&0 0&0#*( "#'&#"
,,0 D&
( -*(" D ( & 0'
&B!
0&, *&( /&,!
&0"/ ! -
'0&# "
!&"&"0 "
,'!&!!&+&
"# -'&, -'0&#
)&0#*-( & ' 0#
,(D &( &!
-& 0'
&B! 0&, *("#( % ,&0?& ,, *0 & &,,0*(&( & &( '&, -&# *"# ( & '& ("!( 0'
-&# 0( &'#*&+#& -,
0&0#*( " D &,+ ,.
( -* !( , - -'0&# *"/0 &&00# & &/ 00,,0"#( % ,&0?& *(&&,+ " "
,&'
, -' & -- ,+ ,&&0 !
, , , /( "#( /0 "
&0- &"0# 1;
/ + */( & &+*()
"
7&,!( , -( *&"
,&'
, '
,&0"& *( & 7&, ( &- $3 -!
$
7 0872717 11!78(1082 1$ !"7)
44!0"01 # !"7)
, -
. ,(& - & 1<( 0# 6464 ( (& -'
&# '0&# 15 &# - &"0# /& /B! - & &..) ,& '& -&, -&00 /( ( &'" - + .
7, &0 &'&* '&0 (#,&0&*&'
&&5<&
-%644:
&
--/ , :--,
-- -
;
1=
& !-( , + &0(&&( '
-( & 0'
&B! 0&, &( ,&'
'& '- , 0 & ,0& E"0 7),& 0
&
!" "#( % ,&0?& * (&'
/(,((/ + * -" ( * "
0 ( '#* '&B 0'&# ! -
#
*( ,0&&-0&/8 !'
& (&( "#( & ' (&( ,!-( & /&& D 0- - * -&+&"0# / +3&3+( (!(( & ' "&"0 "( & + "( & ' "
,&'
,& (
/ + *( & ,& + & ,! ,(&!! +3&3+ ( * &( - ,!
0# "! ( & ' *"&&00#&0 ,&& #&0 ( % ,&0?& * !&!
0-( &+- &(!*(!(
' 0#'
-( & -"0,B,(&!
,,&&0, , ,(D */( "#'&#"
,&'
&+ (&( !- ( &'# 0*"
,&'
, -'& ,
&0 !
,-&'0#(# % + *( "#/&&0 & ( '
,&0 *(&( "-&/ 00-'
&&( /&&,!
&0 & "
,&'
( &!!&+&
"#"
,&'
&"&"0 '0&#
1<
/ + *& & !- & * ,0 (&(&
, & # -'& &(&+
,
( 7 &
& 0#* , + " ( ' & (&"
0 *( "#*() ,& !+ / !(&!
( -( '
,&0"& * & 7&, &
) ,0#* ( "# ,
,& "
&! ( &00-'
&*"
( "#( !
-( ,&"
& "
& D 0-& ,
&0!
, -&'0#(# )&0#* ,0& & -'
-'0&#
& * ,0& &"&"0 "
,'!&!!&+& "# -'0&# "#( 1:
( *, '-( 8 !'
7)*,& 0 &$ % & ' B
() * + /( *& ,0&&'& ( 7 * (&( -- !--*&( (&"
/ ( ,,
0&0#&0( & - &"0 !("
,&'
+ ( - (
B! D& ( & !--"
!'& (-&+ + ( / , ,0&&-0&/'& + , & '&B ( & ,0&&"
& 7 0&-0&/ '* "#*( 7 0&-0&/ '*&'& + , &
&0'&B ( ,- -+3&3+( -
0,, **
*&0 0 ,, *( &&#'
B( !&!-( /'
&'& * & (&*( -00 ,' 0 *& 0( *"
,+ -( "&*-&#*- 0&#& 0&,(
- * ( !&! - ( "
- - ( & !--* '-( + , & "&0 ,, *&0 -- -'� !&0#& (
7%02
!# !
$5 $(!1
&- '&(*()- '
( / & /(" +&&"+ *( &'
'
' ! *& & 0 & "&0 ,, *'&& & &--'
6@
-&0!/(&00 !& 0,& *-&#
-- . - - * '&('& I( &B!. & $ J . I( &"0 $ J .