Karambir Rathi And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others



 

 

    

    


 


 

















 



 


    
! "

!#$%& " '() 
& )(&)  

*(

!#$%& " '() 
& % %

$



 
 !

"#"$
#%
 &'" (
)
 
#
"$%


$
*%
" ""
+) 
,)")"%

*%
" ""
"


"")
"

%
*%
" ""
---- )(&)  

*(

+ ' . )
'$"/
/"



)
"
+


(
"

/" "/

/"


 
)
  
'' %
%

/
( )
$'
"
.01231.4
56
7.89
(
)
" "" *&/%
)
/"#
)

$" 

$"
(/ "':
")%

)
'/
7"$

&"$
( 

(
)
:
$'
 
3 )
$"
'$
"

"
(
)

)" ('($$
' %

$"#
/%

)
/" "
(

'
.1.

(
)
 )

"
,/ "
"
" "'
 ;"
':%
)"$"
"
$/
'%
31.8

 5)"(
(
)
(

"
)
<'
(
31.8<9
"
'"/ ' "

)
='
(
31.8<%
) )
" ""
'

3.
(
31.4%

&
+)(
"
6"'
)"(%
)"
)

$" 
" 7"$

&"$
(
)
$&"
$'
 
)(%
) )"
" 
)"
)

$" %
 '&
(
)
"$
$"')

"':
'  
 
)
;"
':
'%
.420 5)"(
(
)
'"$$
"
)
<'
(
.420<9
)
'/
($$ /" %
")
"
7"$

"
&"$
(


(
) $&"
$'
 %
)
)
"

"&"$"$
(
'/

$"
(/
"':

  

      
     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                    "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#  

  *  "

# 

"  "

 #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 8 )%
"
" 
)"

/"



)
+

( "'
(
'

)
  

' 
" ' 
)  "
"
.4..3133
56
7.09
0 )(%
)
$"
'$
"

"
(
)
 )"

$"#
)
/%

"&$
(
'
.1.

5 "9
"
+$$ "%

"')
(
'$"
>
(
)
$'
"
.01231.4
(
)
" ""

*&/%


)
"
/
'/
'/ $$

, ) %

)
("'
(
"
 '('
'
6

""

"

)
 3
(
)

 $ %

"(( "&%
"
()

)


)   
'' %
'
+)(
"
6"'
)"( ,- "  

'    #  "  #

   '  #  "

    

  $%#


  






+ ? 
"


(
)
"
'%

/"#
"

)'

/ '59%
)"
)

$" 
"
"/"#
(
)
"



$'
 
"
)
"
$@ %

"
$@"$%
"
%
" &"$
(
("'$"
)
"


$'
 
,:$ %
) '$
(
)

'"
" %
)"
)

$" 
" )
7"$

&"$
(
("'$"
)
"


$'

 

)
'"
+$$

"
" /
/ %

)
& (
'
.1.

(
)
<'
(
31.8<


&+
(
)
$'
"

.01231.4
,"$ %

&"$
/"
(
"$
$"')

"':
'  
 
)
<'
(
.420<%
) 

) %
(
" %
(
)

$" %

)
%
 '"$$ +)
)
& $
7&
)
$'
 %
)

") '/ $$
$"+($
)
"

)"
)
"&
 /


"&$
(
'
.1.

(
)
<'
(
31.8<

 %
$'
"

.01231.4%

'/ $$
'"

'
"
"$

"" 
)
" 
)"
)
"
  
)%
"

"

7 "$

&"$
(
)
 
$" %
)
(
("'$"
) "


$'
 %
")
"


 %

"&$
(
A'& '/ $"%
"
/"



)
")
'' %
"
'
) "&
A'&
)
'/ $"%


/"("&%
)"
)

 


$" 
"
"
 "$
'/ 
(
)
$" 
$"
$"
 )
'/ $
(
)
$&"
$'
 
)(%
)
$"

'$
(
)

)"
"$
$"#
)
"&
" /% )
/

)
&
(
'
.1.

(
)
<'
(
31.8< " B%
 %
$'
"
.01231.4 C
)/%
)
$ "$
' /
$"

) / " 
(
 ('"

)
"


"
'"

 <&"$ <

<7"$ <
(
)
"':
$" 
)"

$


"
A

/
/"



)
,

'"

$

"
<       



  

        

!

+)%

)
$&"
""

"

)
)(%
""
+)(
" 6"'
)"(%
)
,
)"
6  %
)"
/
7 $@"
(
)
"':
$" 
")


$&"


)
$"
$ '' %

'$"/
)"
)
)
"
"':
$" 
"
) &"$
" B
"
7"$
(
()
)
:
$'

 
,"$ %
)
,
)"

)
)"(
6"'
$&"

""

"

)%
"
'"

)
& '
5 "9%
)"
"#
)
&+%
)"
) "'
(
)
"&
"
'"

%

)"%


"

$'"$
$

"

"
(& #"."


"
"
+)

"'' (
"
6"
/
(
'/ "
'/ /

) ,$$'
'' %
) %
)
"
6'):
'/

'/
+)
"

("'"$
 %
+) %

""$$ )
"
("'
(
&"$

7"$ %
:"
)

(
) "':
$" 
")
(
()
)
:
$'
 %
) +#
"
"
+$$
'"%
 
)
"':
")

''$ % )"
"
')
)
"':
$" %
"
"/"$
(
'/
$"
 6/ 
(/
"':%
&
)


'/

  ("'"$$
&"$
D>3 &%
)
,

"#$"!
$
"

%



&'(

 )  

"(



* ( + ,

-

 ./ 

  

0! ,

 1$!/"


)
)"(
6"'
&"!7 ,/
 $  0           $

'            $ %#"1 '  "#' $2

3  # 

  " 

 ", #

+, +  




40
5"

$  /04$2

3 "  

   $0
5#' '$2

3

 

     &     $  0
5    #  $  0       #6         '




5   

      

     "       #

 "

      $  %#"    "   

.#  6'

'


+ 34
-# # 

  '                     

'    

 "        #$0/04         

'          $ %#"1 '    

  ", #

+, +  



    #  '   

'#     



 

'6   "   '' '" 

  
5    # $0      #6           '   

     "'  , #

+  , +     

 

       




 5         

  # 

" #         "        $ %#"" .#  6'  '


37
    " .#   & # '#6 "       .#          !

        "    "6'       .# !  ## & # 6'#    ' "

 '    !  
 5    '    

 !#   6'  &"

              & #"6' .#"

   "'   ! "'   !             '    "    ' 

 
5"!"6' .# "

##"''"      ! "

#"  



         

  
 -      

     

    

" 6'





1 

 

"''

"

"

#




5#    &.

# &"    "

       

       ''  

      '     
8

   #        "         



-     

      

  
 -    !  

 #    "     " 

 !
32
-"6' #  

 " 

 #     '

 

  '



!  # 9 :#  ")  
 5             ''

"

"'



  

 #  " #   

 .



 #




5 ' #



 "

  " '

 #   


 33
;  "'

 *  #



 "  "   *  

 '  

  * 



  

 

      # ' 

 
%

' 



   


2

 34 5 0!67 11$$!<=

$

"     ( ,


4
-#"       

 2        #      $    "  

 "


 5     "'(     %#"    '            >-      

 

     

 

   # 

   




-



 

        

 



 "   

          



#':#)

   
-  & #

## 
?  ":#@

.

  '& ## 
# '""

 




A %#"

     '

 

  '  '''#






+   #$0#         $  %#"      "   * '

  "

'  , #   +,  + 

'

  




5 

   #      *!           '   "   " , #

+, +  




5 '



 !



  "6' !  !  







" #
-  # #



   #  ' #*
 5   #  

  

                     !   &"

! '"  !

  #            

    "

  * ' 

"

0
-    

# '    

"  ##  

 !  ' #        , #   +    ,  +  

   

&  & #

# !#".



& &# ""

"

"'  "            

"6'     #  .      

#


5"   " "     #    "#"'! #  ".   

  &     &#   "   "

" "'"      "6' # . 

#





5   #      '     "

    .'      '

"         ! !'"$ 0          /04    

         
0
/0
+ > &%

"
& '
 

)
<$
 6
, 
'"

../

001/ - ,

2  , $
" #13.4 $15 /1/

6171/ 8

4 )919 2 "1411491 1 !#%

)"
 6 $"

)
<$
 6
,%
)

)
$&"
""

"

) )(%
""
+)(

6"'
)"(%
)"
)
'"

"

/
$/
+)
+)')
)
")
"
6 '

$@
) "':
$" 
,
- #<'  

  &"  "  ""

& & .

  //2  '  

    "     * 



 
%



+ +

, 

 





 



  

!

8(9,( (

:

,;  ,9

, +

 



+ 

 

;

 

 ,

 

 9  <

 (9,( (

6, !

, 9  '

'  

 , 



  

 =( ,

    < 

 ,;

    %

  3,( 

  , 

+ ,



 =( ,

 

+"

'(  

+



('

  9

  

( (

!,

(,5

 

;

 9 5 (  ,  

( ,



 



 4 ) %
"$
&
(
)
"':
$" 
/"
7 $@
(
"
$ "
(
/%


/"
7$@ % ) 
"$

)"
"$

'$"

)
& '
/"



)
, 
./ ) .# 1 : 01;%
)"
)
"/'
(
)
$'
 
" &
')" 
"
)
'"


"
')" 
(/
)
$'
 %
" )

)
('"
(
"':%
")

/
)
$'

 
$"$
"
')
)
("'/
(
)
$"


7 $@
'"
&
"
$&"



)
'$
(
)

 '
)"
)
"
&"$

7"$
(
()
) :
$'
 

)
'"
" 
)"
)
)

$"

(/
"': 2
&%

"
"


(
""

8
(
)
 $
()


)
+

%


&"$
)"
A'
 
'
?7
( )
<'
(
.420<
+
($

)

"
"(
' 
) "/%
)
;"
':
,$$'
)"
&
)"
)
'
 )
 "
)"


"#

)
*&/

,//
+" '

)
*&
'/ 
(

,//%
E)"AA"%


&
"

"%
E)"AA"%
'
+
$"%
E)"AA"
"

'
&
(('%
E)"AA"
)
,//
"(
' 
) A'
($

)

)"

A'
)
"/
' 
) ("'
)"
)
A'
$" 
"
:
(
)
$'
 
 ''
(

"
"
")"

 ")
"
(
' "$
 

 .1
)"(%
)

($
,F7>4?4731..
( )
,
')"$$ 
)
"':
('"59
)
"  '"/
/

)
,
& 
 
"
.31>31.8
56 7.19
)

"

"
)
"(
"
 
()
($ ; 5,&$9

8.188731.8
(
)
<$
 6
,
+&%
&  
"
.?123133
56
7..9%
)
" ;
'"/

/

)
<$
 6
,%
) 
)

(
)

<
$"
")
(
()
)
$'
 
'"/
 )$  $"$
) 
"$
)


($

)

 "

)
' $
(
''&
.


..
)%


 '"

)
 $

"(( "&%
()


)
+

)"

(
)
"':
$" 
)"
 "/

)
" 
"/
& 
"

"

>.0
"
/"


?.123
"$
'"/


)
&
' 
.3
&%
)
"$
"/
(
"
'/ "
:"

)
"':
$"
(
)

"$
'/
  %

)



# /59
)(%
$"


)
"/
 '/


)
;"
':
,$$'
+)
)
(' ,%
(
) 

'/
"&"$"$
(
'/
$"

) $"
$
'' 
)(%
"$
)
"':
'  
)"& 
'/
($$
"
$"+($$
''$  .8

"

%
)
"

$'"
($

)

#

$"
(
)
"':
$" 

/
(
'
.1.7
(
)
<'
( 31.8<
"$
'"/
A'
& 
 
.>183138
56
7C9
)
' "$
'" %
" 
)

')"$$
)
"

 
56
7C9

+"
(
($
,F7C1.173138
"
)
"


'"/
/

)
,
& 
 
"
.>1>3138

 ) 
"$
)
($
(
)
"


"

)
' $ (
''&
.

 .0
)/%
)
$"
(
)

:"
)
$"+($$ " 
&
)
A'
$" %

"
/7( $"%
"% )
'' "
(
)
%
&
)
A'
$" 
")

"  "
)&
"
)

"
:


$"+($$ &'
)(/

)
"&
'/
 "#
(/
)
("'/
)" 
"'
(
"
('"
 
'
0
(
)
<'
(
.420<%
) $"
+59
'"/
&
(
"
 )%
$


&
) "':
$" %
+)"%
'/ $
&/
(
 )%
$
"
 &
)
"':
$" %
")
'"/
)
'( %
 %
) "':
")  <.1/ ! 2 94.
 9 .?

"(/")%
)
,
( 

/

)
+
% " %
+)
)
"&
&"%
)
"/

/ 
)
/  

('"59%
"
':
)
"+"
"
/""
"

"((/ 

.C


 
"

'

.>

'
)
/"
'"
$(
)"

' %
)%
"$$
)

 
"

$'"59%
(
" %
"$
" 59
 
(

:)(&)  

*(;

'(&

:% %

$

 ;

 

'(& #"&
 )


494 013.6=1  >= 494 0915/  >=