High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25937/2025dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Ms 17991p Major Abhay Garg Retd And Another

2025-09-02Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri5 pages

!"#$# %& '

(& )*( ' + +( ++ )*( ' +,-++

"#$ %%& $%'%& () ***** +( ++ .'/ *0 + ) &),)$%%-)"

- $./.+0.0123!+4 $56 0!", 5$%& -$% ,)& ')$-$) 2)$( ( $ 7 5$%84&569),)& +)$5$%%9)5(( $5%6 56-(()$5%6%"("/.:;.: (%(&)-)$)$" < 0 ) %6 $-" $ 56 ) %$ ,% ( )

5" )$ ) -$ ( 5( ( $5%6 +56) 5$%<$./.+0.0123! +456 %$,-%$, )=-"( "'($

. 1+ %2#%+.

,, / >)$<)$%$,%() $)$<

-)-)),$(%9))$5%$$, 1 ,,($,)$$)"9) +9$ %<("<,/++.0.0.)-($5%6&9),) $5%69$$5$5%)"%$6<,56),$%$5 ($)5(($5%6 56)%-)$ $5%69$$5$5%)"%$6<,&9),)$,()

$9$"$5=,"$5() 5$% ; )% %(%$9%56 '($

& 1+ %2#% + & $6 ((, <- ) " ,& 9) )$ -)",$%3$"$$)"()A)%,$9$ ((&5B%6 ((-$$5%6&%)5( ($5%6 56-(()$"$) "

9%5 )$)$5%6(($5$5%)%$6<, %<$

$$()=-"

,$2 $4$$ !

C1 6) ($

$%)$

%%$24 $)B&9))&$<$%&9) )$$$-)$-( $$ ,"

%()(-$-"&(( 5 ((- (" " $5%6 9),) $5$5%$--$<$56)"%$6<,& %5-$)5((-!((( $5%6 ) $

%%$24 ) 9% , )$& ) 5$ ( ',%$ +204A?@A2!'456)6((,&

<"($&$/+.+0..+&)$($ 5("$$<$%$5%%6$", %9)<$%$(<,&$ $6 ) ,$-6 ( " , %

2/4 ")$5< ; >)$<)$%$,%() $ )% D > $6 ) " - =-"24$24$)($%%)$

$% 9),) $),, (-!((() $5%6 $"&9)$ , @ )"$%()"$9%%5$E (56) -)'$9%%$56) 5$% -$-$

$%() 5( )"&($6&9)$--$%) $5%6 F D )&$ ),=-"() '($

)$")$5,$-$$)$ 5)%)$ <-)$$5%6$5"%$6<, "

%6$ (,$%$,$5$,, ,$%%6 9)$5%69$,$)"(6<,&%<$

$$$$ #$%

" # $ !

" #$ !

(

)

) (

/ @ G$,%() )$5$5% )$ (%$9)$<-5%56) '($

,$2 $4$9%%$

,$ 2 $4 H # -<9)% %(%$9%

,$2 $4$

,$2 $4$9%%$)($, $ ,,"$, ( ) ,$ )$ $ ) " ( %,& +9$",$%%63$"$9$(($%% , $9$%6$( +<,(.;6$9))

2;4

!&)9$(5((-(") $), ),

6"I"$%')$-$$5%69$(5$5$5% "%$6<,56),$%$5<,)$55-) ,)9)')$)$5%6$5$5%"%$6 <,& ,$%%69)),$%$()<9)$$5%6 ((56 +$5$5%"%$6<, )$5-& )$$5%6)$5$5)"%$6<,$) ( ,$%$$) () <",$$E$9$6) -)( +,%$")5(($5%6 ? )$-")$5$ +.

,&)$5,($6 <65- ) "

-$./.+0.0123!+4))5$() ($, ) % % ( %$9&

++ ,,-%6&)9 " +0 -$

%,$24&($6&$ ( / +( ++0 /,-++

0 +3 456 . >)) $E-A$

>)) $5%