Balwant Singh v. Directorate Of Enforcement
!
"#$# %&' ( ) *+ ,-
.&/0.12 . 2 2
!" #$ % "
!" & !" '"% !"
$ ( ! ') 3 (, 45(6117 #$
'"
****** . 2 2 -1
# ! ++, -+. $/ +0+12 3/4 5.+ 6781 2 49 $29:
A)
!"#$!#!% & '#
( )#*! & , -
./ 0#'0!#!% #%#'!#!%
,120345.0'#0!#!!
6
(
#"
+
8
9
!'
:
:
:
B)
;
;
+
; 8 #<'#!#!% & '!
+
, -
+ #% +
+
8
= :
C)
-
+ , -
8
+9
+
+
+ , - :
D)
0
+
+
#<'#!#!% & '!
+
+
:
E)
0
+
+
+ 0, -
#<'#!#!% & '! F)
&
+
8
>
2&
1'1 ; < = < = > 6, +0602: !
= 9?
" $ 1- ) < = +5 +066 #@ $ 5,
< = # $ 7+ A +065 < =/:
!2/ !9
#$< =
3A< 42A<9 # B
= < =3?
- 4 !
" :+-67+:+06. #$ " " +5 0+ +0+0 $ # < =3?
- 4@
< # )" 2 )9 # D) /
&'+0++!006++.
+0++ 50, 507 5+0 5+6E 6+0:) 6.,02)
9 6126929 612+9 " ! 67.. 2" !! +06.92
!9 :
#" D) B #$ 2 9 6+0:E5+0 )
6126929 612+9
! 3( .> +2$9 =!" :! $ );(=FA;60;+0++ : +1 0- +0++
A05 +0+5 55 =!
08 (
%
<G
;< = ;<&D=;<=
1 $$6.
+0+5
B #
# # 06 +0+5
:# #+0 +0+5
1 < : # # "
::6+57-:+0+5 " $
!
1 A++ 0- +0+5 "# : :# # A +.
0- +0+5 H :# # : < " 6, 0.
+0+5 #$ : # 6
$ .. ) : # $ +0 0.
+0+5
1'
< +8 0.
+0+5 " 1072+9 15,2+9/ 08$
1''
0- +0+5 #$ $05 $ &
2 0 & 1'
= " # %
<G
: (
#$ H 67 =!
) $
! =! : $$ B
D : " # :# #
$#$ # ..
" 6, 0.
+0+5 #$ #$&I# " #
" +0 .
+0+5 # # H #$ #$ &" 6, 0.
+0+5J+0 0.
+0+5" #$ " $
$ $ #$ @ $## "
$ ) #$ #
05 +0+5 ) $ #
$ " J #" $ =$ #$ " @ $ #$ 1,+
J # $ " 1 ) G i.
$%&'() & !
* ii.
( +, - + ., / ! 0 12* iii.
#-3 4 ., / 1 0 4 * iv.
5#4 6 . 789 1:91 ;1!<!<18%<=>< v.
8,( # 6 . 78+< 91
; <!<18%<=>< vi.
< 4 '
# ?
1 0 @1 vii.
8-'4 6 . 1 0 !* viii.
$, 3' )
0 !
1*
ix.
$, 3' ) 4 ., / 0 :: x.
%/
/A
%/ 6 . 5&9&9!@!9 2<<* xi.
$ 3 $//)
78 < +<@B !:<1<=3* xii.
8)
5&9 &9!!@9 ;1<@<8%<=>< 02&
1'
= ! ' ) # $ 5, $ " #$< = # " D # #" " J "
!
# # H @ 56
1 D # 07 0, +0+1J 6.
+0+1J+- +0+1J+8 +0+1J06+ +0+1+7 +0+5 G " J
$ " $
! " ; :
"$
$ "
# "# " #
=$ # # ! G
"" 5.+ $ "
1 ) ! ' G :
i.
4<55 0 !@ 1
: * ii.
#-4'' &2!
!* iii.
& 5 C)
!2 @ :
iv.
& % 5 8 ( '!1!
1!* v.
%3 3 !!1
1 * vi.
E ., / 5 & *
0 !:1* vii.
< & :#
$ H " " 55 =! :
<0 % %? #
' @
+
& '*") !
'*"%
%
+
(
& 8 :
(
+
+
6 )
:
& 8
8
+
;
+
(
:
(
+ +
8
& '*") !
'*"%
( ,B
C 8
+ ;
8
+
+ 8
+
+
8 8
+
!> 1 ) 552692#92 9 #$ +0+5 08 B #$ 6.
+0+5 1 D 66 + 8 $ # " :
''!"
C
(
8
8
( #*#D!#!) '$#*!#!) !<'#!#!) !"''!#!)
#<'!!#!)
(
18
.
0 <# &/4 8 8
8 =
8
+
(
8
B 8 6
+
&.>
, :
,;
4$
1
8
+
+
E +
6
+
0 ) "#
% &/4 !##!
'
" +
8 8
+
$< &/4 !##!
+
+
8
.
+
9
> 1 ) B # #;:# # : " G # #$ " 6, 0.
+0+5 #" :
D 1
9 ( 1
9
8 1
0
8
. 8+ +
8 6 B
+ " C
8
( F (
= (
+
,-
6
8
1
8
9
+
+
8 (
$$ &
0
B $ +
0
( F (
= (
2'
+
6
$$ &
+
+
+
B *
0
2'
+
6
'< + &
> '
) # ; $# #$ $#$ +0 0.
+0+5 :
C
6 +
8
0
( :
F (
= (
0+
'D#$!#!%
-
+
1
0
( :
F (
= ( 8
+
;
B 8 8
1
8 ( 6 1
7
/
8
B &
> ''1 ) # ; $# 6, 0.
+0+5 #$ $ '
#" " +8 0.
+0+5 3
4 08$
1G
( 8 8
8
(
8
8
( #*#D!#!) '$#*!#!) !<'#!#!) !"''!#!) #<'!!#!)
!*#'!#!%
(
18
.
0 <# &/4 8 8
8 =
8
;
(
+
8
8
+ +
(
8
B 8 6
+
&.> ' 1 ! #"H" # " # # B $ -0 =!;
3
8
4;
5526929 H K2 92 9 < #" $ 3
4 $3
8
4
'
1 " $ 3
8
4 H 2 92 9 J $ " # #$ # '81 <
0- +0+5 $ # #" #" J$29 ; # 05$
'91 A $ $ B $ ! +6
'1 !#" " "" B 29JH " 55 =!; 107 & #" B ( A 29 "# =! ; H
) #$ B $ @ & # #$
$ G $ # $G '1 A0- +0+5 $05$ # 07 +0+56+ ) 07 +0+5 A " 6+ 00 $ # ( $ L $ 07 +0+5 ( $ H J G $J $ 60 +0+5 "
$ - $
'1 !
60 +0+5 # $ G G $ #$ +1 +0+5
) @ +1 +0+5 G $ 65$ 0, +0+5 0, +0+5 G $ +0 +0+5 # 29 "# #$
'1
# : B # " 107 :
F1@<8)##' # /9' 1 8+
; +
+
+
8 B
= +
+ +
& 8
; +
)"D )"D )"D 7
)"D7 )"D )"D- )"D- )"D-7 1
&
%< '$D#
; +
! 1
+
8
=
+
; +
+
=
6
+
?;
& 8 /
+
B +
& 8
=
B B
& 8
=
+
& 8
=
;
+ B
+
+:
+
= :
+
+
+ B B +
6
6
B
B
+ G# !<9. , %% # ?, ## - ? , ?% % %? % < ,B
!
=
+
+
> 1072+9H 62 9 " # $ #G :
" B 2 9 $J2 9 " # # $ " $ " $## #$ &" #" # 0- +0+5 $J " # #$
$: 67 =! #$ $
!
# " # # " :
:#" $ #$
) / 60 #"G &I#
$
" " " $ #$$
! #$ # C $ $$ @ "
" 67
=!
!$ 29 ;
B J $
" G #$ #
$ :: :
i.
;
" # < 8
+ 8
(
,- + ii.
#-4''" #
8 8 :
8 +
iii.
1 5 & *4<55*& % 5 8 * %3 5 C)" #
=
1
+
+
:
=
)" #" : :#" 0- +0+5 #@ G $ "#
#$ G J #
@ $ ;; < != 0- +0+5#$ " #$ G $ #$@ :
91
# G $
1 ) # :#; $#$ #$ " # $
1 ! $ : $ $G
1 2
9 @ 0- +0+5 #$ # # @
/ $ #" #" # H #
J $
29 $
6. /"# +0+5 3. 2 2 7 / (
( ,$>
?#%5@,
$ % !& $@ (
( , > ,
+;
& $@