← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/14313/2018disposed of

Managing Committee R.D.Khosla D.A.V. Model Senior Secondary School Etc. v. Managing Committee R.D.Khosla D.A.V. Model School Etc.

2025-05-22Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal18 pages



     



! "# $%&'

"%(%) $%&''

*%*+,%+--,..  /0!1*23 $ 14 %,"4 )%$*"5 4)01*%$.0 "!   .,.,% "! 2 "!(!

*%*+,%+--,..  /0!1*2 $ 14)01*%$.0 "!  6 !7%$ %.!  &  89

 42/   :9        



 

 !"  

#"   "$ 

  % &'

(((( 2/   :93        )& && *)&+,-./0     1 2      &+ )'

*)&/ ,- .30           1 ,   0 4    

    5 67   &  *        . &7)+ ,   8.90       :



      1" 

  -             $ *                 

           "   

-2-

 !   ;

 4 2  <    :



      !"!   5" .=        "    " ; " 

" 

"

  

 :       $ !"!    "    " ; "     

 :     <   :



"  

        :  "  "       :



  

% *',  !" ! 5" .=   0   :

"  ""            >   4    "  ?     ! @!   "  "$   > 4     "&7//+) ""     " !     "     :

  " """         &7+6+'    %  '+)   $ !   

 "   ""&+ "" "  " "  '

A  

 ""        5" .= !  "  ;, % 30    ""       ?          

        ! @! 5".= 

-3- !    !          $ !         B        "   ""                  ?" -      *))/          "" ?    $!  "  ; "

 "   

    D"        ""     !" !    5" .=   

       ""    $  !"!      

  

    

           

 



            

      !   "  #   $ 

     

  

  " % 

 

   

    & ' 



     (  ) &     &       &     '

 *

    ( &   *     +  

*  )&  & #      ,  &      



 -  &  

 & %        

    

  !  "      '&

 '&

     

&       & 

  .'&

 '/,

-4- #%        (+

          &      

   0  

& 1 -2 3"   *

 - !  4- 

       5  6 - ' "& *    !  " $     "* 47       

 

 &   &%     8

 8   &    $  )8

(  ( + 9 ((  (( ( (+  

   :&        (;;9-;<    6  2 = " 

%   9  & >;

88(      99   (    $  ()

() (<

( (()

(+ +(<

89 9 (+;

+ ()

) ( 8 9  )   +;

)   (<

(  ()

9 (<

+ () (+ )   

    !

 "    '&

  ?    &   ?            

        

  '&

                  0  

  &          7          &$   

'

   @     & 

 "$

 

  

   



 

 &

&

      1            (),&  &  &     2'

 "       



  /     '  

             

     

                    

-5-     (((

   &    

   &        

   

 '

&

    &     '

& 

 

 

 '

             &           $  '



                    '

  & 

    '

   '



     A        

 &   

        

       

         

     '

 

    '

 & B &     '



     

   1            (  ((   

   & 

&    

     

   '

& 

 

 

 '

   

   

         

  

  "  &

&

      

  & 

&   (((      '

 '

& 

    '

     

     

 &    1        :    

      

     '



 

  ' &      



   &   

  

'

  &  

             '              '

    

-6-   

 

         '

           

 

            

     &

  &

      

  &         



   &  '



       '

 

   $ '

     

  

    

     &

&

    &           

 &  & 1    



   C((  #

  &    2'

 "     



       &$ 

      $

  0      '       &    



            &  

 %     & /    

        &  &   &  

   A#'& 

  %    

? ' 

     

      

'

   '

 

 &'

    

              '   &  

   &    '

    

    D /     "

    

  5 67

  &  6 . ,- .*0          $

   

-7- ( !               :    

         

       '

  '  

 &

   



 &  

 

'

  &  

             '               '

      

    '

  

   

 

        

 &

&

    &   & 

&   

         & 

     



   &  '



         '

 

   $ '

          

    

     &

  &

      &    &    

    

  :

D + 

 ').        

( !           

 

 &'

      

'

 

   

 &       

   

$ 

'

       '  '&

 '&

              

 '

  

   $

    '   

' 

 

   $    0  $

 



 

             

  & &     5E&

 *     $



 



     '  '



-8-        

  :

D   

    :  5 "         % &  ' ,- .'0   "     % 3+ % **         """   "  

   &)

 

     $ 

"5').    &&      

  $    E9 5 

           

'

  

  '       



 &  

 

'

&  

        '                       

 

    

 &

&

                   



   &   '



      '  

 $'

    

    

   &

&

    &       

&  &  !   

 

 +;          &



      & +;&

    

      

 &    <<C#(%   #*%&





        

  

    '

 && 

 '

 

& 0 

-9-       !  &:

        '

$ 

   

    

     &$  &   

&

 $

   +;  

'

              '

 &

 



&

  

      

    

 !     &

      

  :

    

                      



     '

  &

   $  5 

       +< 

(

C*F* 

 &    +;>(;+  &

 

   &'

   & '         

 &        );   

 C *F* +;>(;+ 

&   F &* ?  

             12   <> !     

 

    0 &

  &              

     6



           

     '

                   &     

  

'

&  

          '                 

 &

&

   &    



 &  '

      '              

     ' '

       '    

-10- &                '

      '           '

 

    '   &

  &

        5 

     

        +;  

 '

           5 '

   3  

  &  & $  G  

&  

  D ?              &6 @     &'

?             $ 

 ?  "   $   @   

        "       $"  ?  "    " "           $ @   ""    4*& &* *)&+  "           "    -        &3

      !

        B"  "  ?   "     

     "  

-11-

   "$ @

   "

   "   "    &C ?  "  "      &/ 4     "            "      -"  "  $"    "          "

    $    "   "   "  -" $"  

    "  

     $" -"           $   ?   "  $"     

                   "        "

   "  "  " ?  "1 = $"      

   B  $"   -" "

 

 &+   "     : "  "        "= "

 "

              1 5

   1" 5

            $"  

  -   $ 

-12-  =    $"    "

    -"   &7

   "     $        =   "   -                    $          $          "         "    ? -"   $& *$ 5  & *$ (;(C#(% * #*' %8)?     

              $     ?      -        $ "          "

 $ 

 " ?                 ?                 B       " ?     "      

 $                  $ ? $    B "

    " ?      "   $   " ?             $  -  $  "   "   $     =             $  

-13-   "

 =     $    " ?  "  

  $ 

   "  *) ?  "

& !

'F   '

. F '  3      H

 4   4    3  (;()#)% *  #*' %    1  4     "   ? -"    "$     "             " $          "    ?    14$"   

  7    $ #<<)%)**((C  E3       ,0 "   ,0     ,0     "

     "          $       B 

  "$  "  #      "    

 "    "              $   $    "   <  "    "        >                  "        

 " -        

      ?                "   - "$ "         $         

-14- 

 7'   $ #<<)%)**((C

"

E6C    - $  - "               -  $ ,0   "     

G ,0        -  $    $         G ,0         "   



  "

  "= "

         G ,0        

  B   ""    "    - $G ,0-   

  -  $   "     "=  

 , 0 - $  "  " ,0 2    = "                  F *&

                     "            -  "     "  9      

   

        

&   .   '

: 

-15- 

'

     '

    A-  !

    &

 $  & 

  



              &    ( 

(*F*   

    

 &  

&

 &  ( !  

 

    &

    & 

   

    &

& &  '3 

 $      & 

   

      ?   $

           

         

         ' 

$

 ?    ?     

   +!  

 &

  &

  



      &

   ?

$

 

   

   

  

  )! 

 &

  &

  



                           5 

         

          '

      

  &      C !              

     '          & 

  '

 

     '           

      &



  '

&

      D

-16-  ** ?                  -            

"                



  

 

     $  $  4      -" "" $

  *6 ?  "   "                 $ *'

  4           "*& &* *)&+    1

    1)     5  '  



 &      1)        :  (>;+(;<    

     

           

    

  #   @ @%5 '

   

   

&    

  '   

    F:& *'  '

 #40

'

 "  %   &    '

     & $   &        & 

 *  2     

  '

  

$ 

 &           $    

  

  &$

  

 *  2    

    .  

 

-17-

   

    -   

 & 

  '

&

* 2         &       

 *  2      

 ! !  * 

  0    

   F    

     3  *  &

?   :   D   *3              " -     

       " *C            

   "      " ""     ?                  

 :   "     :



"     

             :



                  A 

   

   :              :



    ,6)0 # > " 

  "    

        "     D  "  "  "

     4   

-18- */ #    " "            *& &* *)&+          !        = *)&6   -        "           "        

     "     -" "    =         

:        "  ""        

    

                  "

  .

, 0       



2/   :9   

"%(%) $%&''

= < =:  

H :%  < 

H :%