Chamkur Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"
# $%&%!'
( (
)* ( + ,
!"
# $ % !"& $ '()
& * !" '+ ,
- ( .*/ $$ (, '! --
%./ $ ($ /$ * %
"$ 0 " 12 '(3 (4 5" -( "
$ 4- 4- 43 4, 43( (-)62 (,- 47
8 %
$ " 96 : " (3, $ " 6 6* #$ 5
" /$ $ $$ 12 * !%" $ "$
*
$
""
";
!$< *"
< !
* * %" $ 45" -( 5" -(* "! $" " =
) )+<
"
> 12 ) '4(4 -- " 8" "
*
" +-/ % -- *
(41
% -- (41
% -- *
+-
$ -- " $
"" !
) ( " (/ $% - + ? * ( / $% - $
$ *$$")""
!"$ !
(,'! -- 4 2"$$
" $
(,'! --* "
$ $
%
$$* %
$*
!
)( " $
$
/
)
$*
3/ % -(@! " *%
"
(, '!
--
$$
* $$
" $
* "
"
;
% "$ 4 -- * " *
*$$$% ! --
4 -- %
+- % " $ * 7
$
" 2* $$
, * "
( 1!$2 %!'
"!1 4 1&!'
5&$!'#%'6(7 9:2%
$ !9* !
" :
% **
% " ""$ $ "*
" ="
"
%
*
$" $
%%
"
9:<
$$
$$* A 9:9: $$
"$% "
$" * !
$$ * " "
$% B
9: $$ ="
* "
$%
"
$" "*
$$B 9: " % $$ = "
) B 9:
%$
"" %
$%*
$ $" * "
$%
9: *
%
"
* $%
% "$ 9:
)" 9: $$ ""$ ! !
"
" !" $ *
*
"% C9:?
)" 9(:
" ""
"
$
" +- +-4 +4 +3 +, + ++ +4 +7 + +3 +, + 4-- 4- 4+ 44 47 4-2 $ 947 (,-: " $
$"
%
% >
%
"
"$ " 9 :<
)" 9:9:$$
$% "$ %
)" 9:%
$%
)" 9:DE 3
, 2
$ "
"
" $
" <
" FF $
%*
" $$ """
* *
"
< $ ! "> " (34) $
* "%= % $* * $
$"
%
) (
, 2
$ "
"$$ " $
%
#
!
*
"> "
" ,94:
"
"<
"
" $$* % "
$ *$$ $ "> "
"
" $$*
"$% ,
! ,
!
$ ! **
" ""$ $* ="
"*
$ " $ F$%* " % <=
F $ F$%
F8 ''
!9 ''
,1%&8'
# :
;&( +
!"
&8 1 )- .</ + "
G(+ ======== <=
H $ H
"
2 " $ $
$" $ !
""
$%$$"< $$ " $
= " " "
" $! % " ===E (emphasis supplied) <
,9(:$
$" " 0$% "
$
*
*
$" <
$ $ +- %
"
,9:9 :
"
$$*
"
9:
2
"$% "
$" * !
$$*
$%
B 9:
<
= "
* !
$$*
$% $" " B 9":
%
$$ = "
<
(-
,9:9
:
"
%$
"" %
$%* "
$ $"*
$%
(( ? $$$
"
"
,9:9 :
$%" $ *
"
"
,9:9
:
" * "
(
,9+:
"
"
"
,9:9 : ""$ ! !
"
" !" $ * 2
% >
%* " $ "
"
" $ ,9:
"
0 I
" " ,94: (+ 1"
" (4 2
""
4 -- * --< *"$ 0 (, '! --
" +-%
%$*
"
$ %
"
! % (7 2!
*!
$$*2
(,'! -- > ( < $$"
<
$
=6=& - . '> ?
%'/ 41
=#6 Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No