← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CR/179/2017dismissed

Aadish Aggarwal & ANR v. Brijeshwar Swaroop & ANR

2018-05-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga16 pages







   

 

  "

 # $

 $  

   





    

 

!!!!

"

#     $



 %%&'

() %     

( )' () .  *

 

/

  *   *            



   *

  / 

"(#





 

+ *  "0# 

 1 %

 * 2

&

$$   

*

3



 4  , +  * * 5+/

 6 , ,7 * ,  . * *

   



 * * /  *

, *  * 5.

   , */

 7 * /  *  



"4#

 / 

,  3*/  



 (

  

*

  



 

 * 

 

 * /  

"&#

  

 (

, * 

3

 



 /

 



+ 

 ,  / / * +  *   

( )' ()   *

*/

*

"%# 9   *



   

  

   

  

"   #   $%



!  &

()

  ! * +  *   ,

"

-  .

/  # )

"   0

    " 1

$ "  

#

(2 ' +%"



 * 4"5 -   

14'

#

!!% '

  * 

6   8

5    #

&  

+

 4 +

&&2 )

"   (0

98 '  " 

 5   

"  

2

98 

5 

3



3

 $  

&&2

"  

 '% 5  ,  5    # ) 14'

(#

"%

 8$ +" 5 

 5 

)

"  

98 :"" 5 :"  "  )

1'

0(

"% 8$ %"%

8 %"

+

    

"  

+%$    

"  

2#

+%$  ' :"

.

;" '     )

"  

!!% '  '" 

!

  #

(

< 

 " 



     )

"  

0#

!!%

'

'



45  <!!

3 "5 1'

 

)

(2



 

    /    +   :  



 

    /    +  

/ 



+ ; 

 1 %

$$   

 $  1

 < 

+/ 3   ,/  .

 /

   

 / 

''' /

 $ . $  $ =>  ())( 

+  /?/ * /

 * *   *   * 





+ 

  

         /    +     

 9  

   <= <

  5 > 5 < !!



1



<= 1 ' 

&

/'

(2

<!! '$

<= ?"" +"

! @  8"

5 * $    )

&#

'"

+"

! 3!

$ $     

"-# 9    



*



   ; 

 *





*

    1 %

$$ 

,  8

*   / 



 + /  1+   

 *

    $  /

* * /

, 

      3*/

 /

   *

*/

*  / /

* *

  , 



       /    +  

/

* 

+ ; 

"@# 9     



 / 1 4-

$$

 ; *

 .  

      * : / +

* *

 /  9    

"5 1'

  



  

)() !  

<$

   )

0 4 "    "5

 

 !!

 "%!



1 /'

( (2( !  A!* $ +

* A!* 8$ 1

 

# ( " "   (#



/   +, * * +  / * 

/

*

/    / + *

"'# . * /  3   

 /   + 

3   / * 3   * < ! '!

3





"5 1'

   # 1 8!

98 2)&

<   

/ 

  



+

, 

*

 3   / " " 

 < 5 &

#& -  +! % 



       

2) +! 5  < 5  ( )

 +

+

 +

   

#

+ 



  

 ,

 

A

+ /  ,  *

;   B



/      ,

    * + , 

  

  

  C  3 *





   * < 

 *  /

*

/  

    //        /  /

/    

   ,



"

)# 8 ,

*



 *

 ,  / , +*    +/ /    ,   

 

 /

/

*/  /  ,

"

# 

 ,



 ;,

/ 



< /  / 

 +* 





 

$$ /  $ +    



*

  ,

   /  

   

"

(# 

+   /  

* 

 

 

*  , 3 



*

+ / , ;   



* + /

/

    



 <= A !! '"%%

3 A 



1 

)(

 /  +   

3 *



 + 

*



    



 / 8



 



*/ 

* *  ,   / ,

  

"

0# 8  +

*  ,  * 

 , / , +*

+   

1  * /   ,     * 3,    1 ,     *       +   +      

/   *  + ,



   /   /



 *

/  / / 2,     , 

  

,   

 /  *  / / D / /  /

 */ 

; 3   

D

/ 

  

  E + D



E

    

 , * 



;    D 

/



 E 

  

     

 +     /





,  

<  8

, 

 <

  3

   

  

/ 

  

*

 

/ /



 

*/  /

.        /// / ,  , 8 $ *

* , + * /  .

*, <  1 %

$$   *

/ 

 <  /, '"

+"

! 3!

$ 

  * 

" 6F+ < //

  * ,

"

4# %"!

' 

<

'"!"

  

6F+ <  *

*

* / <

, / / 

 +  

*/

 / 6*  *

+  +  

*

 < /  / 





 

  + 





  / /     4%

''' * 

/    (( ())( *



 

 

     / 

   +     <  

+ 

*

, / 8



    

*   /  

 +   + 

 ,   /  +*        , *

*

*

<

, / /  *  6F+ <

"!



:"

<    

&)

"

&#

/ ,  +   8 +  3/

  

8     

    





6F+ < < $ :   

  <$

-  8% % 3"  )

&(#      

 

 

"

%#

6*  ; ,  

+  

   8  , , 

*

/

   /   

 E  

, *



*

+    1 %

$$

+ 

,  $%



! 

&

() 6F+ < * ,/  +! 5

< 5 ( )

 ! 

"



# 02

'  " 55!

 

< (

#

/'

(

(0



  6*



*

+ 

         / 

   +  

  <   /  , ,   /  +     

+ / <

 .  

 

 /   </ *

 



*

  

 , +  ! * +  *  

-  .

/  # )

#)

+ /  , +   /

+ /

*   

 /

  , / , +* 6F+ < "  "

< 5B *  "    1 %

$$

    $

*

 





 



  3/

/ 

  



 +  ,

;   ,      +,     , 6F+ < 

  * ,/  + 

 !!$



 !!$

 )

(# " " "

-# + 

 ,  

*



 *  ,  , +*  /    '*  <

3 , % , !

3 



(

)

'  " 55!

 

< /'

(

(0

"

@# /  ,  / 

*  / /  *



*



/, 

 (' () @

%&'(# )(*  

&+,)- D  3/ 

G

D  + G