High Court of Punjab and HaryanaIOIN/40200/2017allowed

Lachman Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-10-01Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal6 pages

! !! "

# "$%$

!! %&'! "

$( !$ )*+,-./0 12.)/-2 .+)3)1 " # $"%&'"$()*)"(+ " $" ,

* "&)% ,- $"*". /()*"(0+& )/-2 .+)3)14/ ) ( + &/

(,%/0 +

-2( &.

%/) "3 %") ("+%"* 4(((+ "4 *"+"42"

% ".

67 ( (+ "4 % + -2( %"* ""8

("")*"" )(+

4 0 % +

(+ "4 "" %%" /(+ 2(+ (0 0)(+ "

& ++& $5

8"/" +"0

0+% ( ) ( ( ""* 0+"0 4( ( 0+& 9

:%"7;

" /&2) * "" !) ( +" 4" "++"-"("& %"6&&<%$/ ")"/ /("

0 ""= (/ %

(0+"0 0+&

(")"+" (%&$/ ") ("+%"> !)(

- "*)4(" )( - ((0+"0 ""* / % )*&% "2)4(% 2" "% % &% (""0 + //

(0 (%&00)-,* /&&/& 0 " &( & & ?4 "<%" &2

%"(++&

(*/(4(((",% +"(""/(+"+"2)"/( & &-"2 (""/( %"(0-2(&/& 0(*& +% "( & -4 4+" )(* /&

"*" "(

&"") &("0 2"( 2 %( - &%"0 /* (+" &(" +% -20+"0 )%"

) 0 / 4( " &/&

<% 4&& 4*") ( "0 & +%

"&2" "(0 &* &24+" ( +% "0 (" +)

<% ("0 &

<% * %+ ( 2&"/ ("") ( &4 +" "- +% (0 ) *" +% (0 ( :"0+% (0 ) &% /(+ &2""0 & 4*" 0" ( ( *& +% " "7 & 4+" "

"0 (0 &* "0 & +("") (&/& 0+&2 0+"" &*( &-4 4+" = 4(( 3

%" /((*"

0+ +%<% 2 &"/ 0 0'% &&(" " &*( &-4

4 -2+% /" ("")* ("0 &&4 "<%" /*%"/"(4 ( (+" +% / ' /(

+" +& &2)( &/&.2 0& +"* ""/ ' /( 4 "0 & +%. "

:+"

+"* ( "/" ( &2 +"* "

> 0+% /%" /("&)-%+"0 0+% /* ++&&"

"* & /4*"-2 *"2 %" +). "

-( &"+ "2= 4(" ("/ 0+"0 (*=

"&2=- ( "&

&2( +" "-% "( & (""& 0" +" "-% * ( : ( 40

" "00 0) 03 / (: -&/("" " / * 40& +" "- /"/ *4( &/&* 0 (

"<%" ( "&3 /-2 . " "/ (0+"0 +%%0 (

2(+"%"+" "-""0 &"&=("& %"

-+"0"*&-2 ( ++" "-% "(+"%" ( " *3 /. 5! " -2(/( %" %) - "*-*)(4 ( &2+" ("0 & +%4%& &42 - % "0 "0 &"& *4 (+ )& " %-&=(" %4%&(*&<%(

2&"/(""( 00-2+"

*&*

/*"

"0 " "<%" /&+4""4(&:" +4"

-+"0-0+"0 ?34 )* ( *&* / &2 4 +"* +"

) -% "& / +"*2 (""" *&* /% &&

&"% & &

+"+"2-2: /00 ("&

- +"0-0+"0 :+(-*0 /"* ) (" *"2 " ( && (" (%& - +"0 - -2( %". (+" -"( %") / 4%& *&*( %(+" +%)(""(

%" +"0( 0-0+"0 ( 4%& +&2"3 %+ ( %"

%"(<%&% -2

%-*" /(0 " "0 &,% *" ( 0 " "0 &,% "(' &"

+("3 / -+&2%+ %" %-*"(,%

0 . 4%&&42 - ( ,% &=(( "/ ' (' "0 0" 00(

& ( 00 " ,% ) & )<%( )4((( 2 +"0- @-&(.%+"0 %"( 0+&2&"(&/&+

"/ ' /0+"0 ( 5 #$ !! %&'

! "4

" 674 ( - "* % "#7 AB8(+ (0"/ "0(-* %

%00" (% #(+4"(/( %" <% ( / & +" / " " 0+& :"

(" ,%" " "0(+4"

/* "0 &%""0+% /( % "

. ( (" +4" 4+& % 4( %"2&0 -%( -:" " 4((/%& /" %(+4"*'=9; %"( ,% "9;+"* -% (+"

%" 4( +4"<% (("0 /"

0+& " 02-:" 4("( " *0(* &(" +%4%&+ ( "%0 ( /"2 -+" "- 4*")-":" %(+4")(/( %"0%

(*%"/"( %" /"*2("0 %

"% 0 &+"*2" &30%"") "+)2)

- /&2<% (* (%/(( *0 " *0@ 0&2 ( " (* & ( +%.%( " +"* %" (* "%

0+ 2 .0&"&2) 2 0+"0 -4 ( *0 " "& ( % " +&

% &3 "* ""%+ " (

00-2+%-& "* 4(&4"3 (+2=

+"*" 2- "<% ( /"0

*&* / %( % ( "0 & (* *"4(&0 /&2 +"0 /&2 *& &*%"

" /"(+%"+ <% ( /)+"%&"&2( " /"000"&) &)0" &)*&) +" "

(+" %(&3"

"( " /% 0"0 2"& / 4"2) " (0&2 +%

4("(4" - &&2+"*"+"

& %" (+" (*" &*(" " +% ( /"2 )/( %"02<% ("0 *4) -% (0+"0 ( " *0)( +

-&2 * "0 -&3 % & 4%& +% % /" ++"

+",% :"0 ,% 4%&-% (0-2 <% ( /("0 +%&& 0+& &0 0+"0 4((*0 ("4" )(/( %" 0%

"4(("4%&-% "" ""2( ,% %4(("0 /"

% ("0 /4%& 0% -% +"

&4 + &0 0+"0 (*0 4" /" 4((" %"( ,% ) ++"+"("0 +%

(

4"(-*<% ; "0*) (/( %" (&&-4&&4( ,%" <% (( /D ( +" && 2 ( :+

* /-* ) *4("+" (%&$/ ") ("+%") > ! 0 +%"

% ( ""

-2( %")( %"& ( % %&+%"+ 4%& - "*-23+ /(+" &*4&&- ( ,% ) ( &0 "(-4 + " /&2)(+"0

0+% ( /" ( +" + &&4 ( 0+%/ ,%/0 +

-2&"

%/) "3 %") ("+%")4("-2(++&(+ "/

* 4

,%/0 6"" 5

1 ( &"

$) ("+%"*4(((+ "4 * ""% "/ "/"% 0+" 0 "42"

67 %& % "/0+" 0 "+"B2 =% ". 5 "

)/-2 .+)3)1 /085.

9 &!

E((" +3 /6" # E((" +"-&#