← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/33079/2019dismissed

Ramesh Goyal v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And ANR

2019-11-25Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal11 pages





       

 !"#!$%&%"'()**      !! "# #$%& &!'#  (  



#()!'  !! "# #$%& &!'# **** !&+"',!' &  -

 *+#,  !! "# &!'#-#$%& !'  (  -)

 )!)!'  !!



"# )-&   (  ( ./

* 0 101

   ./

* 00 2 0/ .

 + #(/*0-(!! !



 )#!1 2/*0-(!! ! 3

 ) )  !/*0-(!! !34

 )#+5!)!'1 %$/*0 -(!!! 

 15  /*0-( !34  

  ) /*0-(2

! 3  $0*/*0-( !



  

 6!!(--#(!!%!'2 

- /     !"!!#!!

$%&!!%&   2  - / !'

%#!() 

 !"!!#!! $%&!!%&  2  3-

/ *  !(       $%&  %+   !"  !  !#!!  !& $ !! !!%&  2 34- /  !(    &!&%+!#!!!%&  #--#/ (!!'!-& )#(!7#!! )0!  2 

- !(!!'

 #$%  )#(!  7#!!  )0!  *  (    0!   2  

8 9:"9 ;

/ 4 /((!!5!0!-!#(< (!#$%)#(!7#!!)0!! -#  - #$%)#(!7#!!)0!#/  9!#% !%  #-(!=(--55 0!   !#    !!

    (  -  !  #!  !

## %! )-#$% & /!# !00!(!!

-/-+- 0!/-%!'=- 5!(!!2  -

9  %!-/  (   !#   !-!! 2

8 9:"9 ;

 < !0!!'((!!-!#(

>0 ( 4- ' / - )#' / -

?+5' */ - ?+5' ?

-  > !  +  )!  -    ((!     &  )#(!7#!!)0!% 5 -!#!  !   4@-A# -  '!'!%*0- ?/% 5 - (!!0 = !!##B

 -& )#(!7#!!)0!#/

  -    C#/  C  6      -  #% !!  -   ((!!5-!= B < 95(0!!#

 (9- !-*0! D D   

   

  

 

           

       

  !"

# $ % ,-./,.01&((23..                 

    



      & %      

   ,-./,.01&((23.. '

    (      & %   

  

3   "

 )*+  , !% $  

     !"  $ %   %  

 

                  



 "

 )*+  , !%$  

    !"  $ %   %  $

       !%  $  

   

!" $ %   

 -(4!&%+%& % &%+&%!(5 &4&

    &   &!&  %+  !#!!6     

 ,-./,.01 &((  23..    .            

,-./,.01 

   - 6(!!/5!(!!'*0!E!! #+##% !!((!!- 5!5 %!'% !

5!! (-( 5#(((#!-# (!%!'  6 (!!#% !!# -!((!!- %#!(# !- # % !

(! ((!! - A#! 6 (-#! -((!!-  -5!'

(#%!!3

. -.

   "  

 

        

!"     &     /  0

 12  345 

 6*2,   +  6*4,*,  "  " 

 '   $    12     1%& )

 

 44  +6*4,*,   %

   

              544345

344345 $ %  

  

    % "       

       !"   & 12   345 

4 +6*4,*,

!" &  + 337      

      

 "   " 

           * ,         %   8  

   29 9 %  

       29 9    "  

 2    

    %    % "          $ 

               "  

 2           

  2        "   3:44345 )*+  ,- 9    (#%!  !/    !  -    !  5 ((!!- 5$/#0!#/5(#%!/! 5! -(!!!)!2 4/!- !'!

! ((!!    %  $  %#        (#  !  # % !

(!A#!  *''!0  '!    !  !  -    (/   ((!!%-!% (!!!

! %  !  5  0  -!  (  5!  (!!  5!    %!' !(-'% !

  #  -   (!!    0   '#     (0!!' (!!#% $!'

!((!!- /!-!! /-#!!((!! - #0%#0-(!'- 9!'/   0  !  #(  0!#  !!/    / %  %+  !

B & % & $&!(7% 444!"%!&%#!!%&   

!!&!

,*2  -  /!  /

&/ 9 !(!"(4)4$%''

% &"#&

4&!# 9 (!

((

!&&%'!(!4 9 )!!& !!'

!(!     ! !/  ,9 4/ ! ) '! !

  %%+ !!%&  /#:&:BB:

4  $ &!'  #  E?   !&#)     

 &!&   %(  ++4 4&'& :#:&:<4:

4 $&!'#E?

/#-(/#!' #  -  !'/  -!    --!0!   

4  5  %

E !#)!'/ )E ,!!'!/#$%& &!' #/!'/!5! -5!'0 . -4    

       "8   

  

       

       %   

 2 

-     -     %          %  "              

 

2  

             

  %

  

            %     ; 

   

               -.  -   

    $ 7*,

     - #  -    (  0    !  #(   !!    !      - 8!!  9!(*!   

!+!((!

 !!%& 





)#( #<4 -#?-!#!- ! (!"

!*!  

  !"94 4!() &# !(! ! )  6 4 B/ 

!% (!!%#!' !5 (!!!0! !- ! (((!!%!  0#-(!(# 5!!%!  6-!!(#/-/50- (0!!-0! -!#5!

0-# (!/%--!=((!!- / 5 ! !'% !0!'!('( 5F 2#%/0! 5!#-!#((- *!!E!!)!7#'!& )#(!7#!! )0!% 5 -5!= !!! -#B

 - #/ !% !0! /! 

5  -.          

 ,-./,.01     -6#/55!!G -! /    ((!!  #    %  ! (     /   ((!!#%-3*4*5!((!!5# %! ;0!-((!/((!! -  5    (!    !  5  '! !  !   %'!!'D4(!

!& %&+4!&%4!+((#"+%+(( & !(4!&%+%', %4%('"(+&"(!*6 9!#% ((!!5!#!'- ((!!! (%#!5!5  !'((!!- %#5(##(!-# %

< !

(!!-  !'# (!!- -  *!'(!!/!'#%(#%

((!!

-#% !!'((!!- /# % !

(!/5!- - /! ( - !

!!!!-!#0%# (!!%% (!

-#! - ((!! 9!'/'# -(  % +!5#% !/5!---!0!5%

  ) E  ,!!'!/  #$%    &   &!'  #     (#-'!'# (!-!5 000!!

(!!

-= !! *( --!0!/ !/5/ - ((!!  ! #% !   (/  ((  -  5!  = !!      ((  !  # % !

(!!(-90!'! 6!(#%00#!! '!(5((!= !!!  ( 5 !' ((!!- !#% ! 5!   (  -  -! ! %   (!'   # % !

(!      (  5    !'      ((  5 #  (5(#!# (! ((!!- !5!= !!((!(- 90!'!  -!!%=##'%!0 % = !% +!'((!(#!# %!

(! 5%!!'!'((!!- -/!! (

- !    '#  %  #  -    (!!  6  $#'  !

 #(% #-(!!!  !- 8 ! !&! #(!-(%#!!#5 '!'=(!-(-5!((!!5-! !%-#0!-0!5'!0!   '!  /    =#  0  %  ((  %   !'!0!'!-=(!'!% !

 9- ! !  #(-1&!'#/    !(!    #  %#       -  ! ((!!500--!!

!%+'#!5 !!(!C'!!C#% '!0  65$#'

!#(% (!!! -! )'!! #(/((! 5 #( CEC(!0!#'!% !5 #!  9 !/#'# (!5--!=%#!'#! (!%!>'!&!!5(( 9! %+'#/    $  &!'  #          # % !

(!%--!='5!('(A#! -!

(!! ( ## !(/ !#!!0%#!!/# (! %(((#(-# (!!## -!

(!% ! )!

! !- !&#) #(  5!  5    !'         -! #! % !5 E(/!5!-%! 5 5'

! %#!-!-) ) >#!?!!!'!-%!5(( 6 -!5$#'

% &C%$&!'#

 0-$#!!-(0

25  5  5!  -      !!  !  #(  %   (!- 8!!9!(*!  #(!5! &C%)#( #!##!!(0!! -  =!  !    0! /  !    %  (0!/  !'

% ((!!- 5!!# -!%+ %-!'!!-! !+!-!

(!"

!*!

#(/!(!!%-#5+!'(! !  -*! 3-!#!-9!'#  !0%'!0!

!- ! !+%# 0 %'!0  /%#!'# 5 (  *0!'%+--(+!'! !#-= !!5!!%!'#/5! ((!!0%!0!- !-!#(( -*!!E!!7#'/!!=(- #!/ 0! ((!!- -# %- #% !!'  9!#!+- ! )'!!

#(!&#) #(55 (!'-#! -

#(  CEC  (  !    !5   9  5             ! #!-!!-# %--!!'

((!!- 5A#!+( # - - %+ 9((!:(!!!! ((!!- #' :-#  0'!0  !##'A#! -(#!'!# (! ((!!- 5-!'!' !>'! &!!  % )# (-(%(



- !5((!-#! (- *!!  E!!  7#'    (!  5  5  0  -#   A#! -(#!'!# (!((!!-

5 ( - ! %#'(#(!0 = !5-!  %-!

(! 0! #0#! ((/(0!!((!!-  (!-!(/%!'!-!(#!# % !

(! +!'!-#!

!-!  (#!-# (!!-!- !'# % !

(!  2    (#!  #  0  %  +  %   (:= !!#!#!/((- (!!!50!'%( 05 !!!= !!50

! # (- !+!((!!- 0%$  6#/!0!5--!-!# /5 -! !!((!! %

! !#'5!#    101

 

  0 2 0/

)**   ($!!

0  8%  < = > 0   < = >