High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6388/2023dismissed

Bugha Mal Tirath Ram v. Narinder Mohindru And Others

2024-01-30Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh11 pages

!"## $%&' ()# '*

# # +% ,# '# % '

- .&%/0 .*# 1# 23 ." 4# '

+% 5'2." ! '- # #

,*# 6% *2." ! '" 7-

##(## #!#(/0- # # 7

! # & # ' #" # - /0 '

((2 1( ' ' :%&* ;

- /0 .--(( .% '# 021( '4'/0 '--(!#(/0 '- # # &# #" # '/ #*#

)'/#!!" ! '" ' - 4' (/ '!#(#" # &# - # # 2-

7*3 '%&'# - - 7 <#'#=(*3 '%&'# - 2 '&% ' '0 ( (! '*#-*#/# &%""# # ! '#& ! '>(# #*4'& '*#-*# - # # /% * '

?0/"5 .! '!>(# #*2! '! '

*(0 *5'%""'#* '# '2 '*#-*#4%""/0- )' !

4 2 7-* '

- %&' #" # !

- '!((4# &&%

#$%&' ( $

) *

, #" ! ' - # # 4 #% - # # # # !#( --# '% " " -# # %#" %( (024-"&# @-

42 ' 4" /0-

4'!#(:# -(0 5# &-(#*# 0/:" # 4# '& *# /#(# 0 - # # /# &/! :# ! "0- 0#

- !- # # ' '#" # #*(!#

*# # 4-( ' 4# &-

% -

9 4!% '-( ' 4# "!* 2 7 2 7-* '4 !

.-#( ? %- ?4 (0 -# 9 4 !% ' -( ' ' *# -*# # B%#/0 '( (! '#- (% ""%- #

)' ' ( (('# & ''-4'#"'4(# %

7.&&4() '0"%(% '#'-!-%-!

# & 4/%# 9 4 # ' *#-*#4%/( '

4# & - /0 - # # )' " %((0 - # # !#* 4 " # % ##(% # ;

AAA1&# ((! ' - '#- ' !#* 4 " # % ;

<%*/"*- # !#* 9 4!% '-( ' ' 4 !#*/0 *!- 7*3 9 4 !% ' -( ' ' *# -*# # B%# /0 ' ( ( '#!*#(0**/!%

&! 4/%# 9 4 !% '-( ' '#" # #!#(# -% -%

' - # # # " !* 2 7 2 7 - * '

0# & ! '* 2# 4-0 ' '#" # / #*# ?

- !#(:# '!#4#

-(0 )'!" -(# '4# -(04" &#"((0 # * ! ' 4#

'/#! '-(# &! '- #2 ' (( !*!((4# &#% ,

-./0 1 ,

-./0 1 %) %)

,2 ;

- '#"(#*2( (7- ,

'# %--# '4# /@> -%"# -( C@ . C@ .2"#- ?C@ .2-(0 ( C@ . "* @ % !- 7<#'#=(*3

C@ >7.2 * ! / 5 ""% C@ >7.2 * ! / ""% ! !# !#* C@ >7$2 "-0 ! ( C@ >72 '

" #!#" !<#'#=(C@ >72"-0! #"#%/0.# & .% '# 0C@ >72"-0!( 4# C@"# )@ # !!#"2 1( 'C@ >72"-#!( !*.# &.% '# 0C@ >7?

= (7- (@*# >+#"50$//23 # )@.# 2>3%'<%*2(5 >:

#'<%*2(5

' ''

2"% (--# & /'(!! '

@*# >5'<%* -(" " "#- C@ C@ 2- '#- C@ C@ ;2 #"C@ --(#" # C@ 2"-0!:%&* " C@ > 7. C@ >7$2"#- C@ >72(#" "# !% ! 7*3 C@ >7 2" #!#" !&# # % +.)." C@ >7C2(#" " C@ >7D2"#- C@ >762"-0!- '#- ;

C@ > 72 "-0 ! - '#- C@ >792 "-0 !

:" * --(#" # # (,# '# %+ 7.&&4() C@ >712"-0!4# * !#(# #:" * C@ > 7<2"-0! ;C@ >7=2"-0!#(% # A ;

C@ >7 "-0 ! - '#- ;

AA?C@ >7, )'

(@*# >.*'<%* .""%

>3%

023( !!#"2.@#$

/% (2 ( "% ( ! ' ( ( # # " "%* # "-0 ! :%&* ;

A - /0 .--(( .% '# 0C@ 2:%&* ?

A-/0 '#%

? C@ :%&* A-/0 E/(3%-*%

5 " #!#"-0!* !'% C@ ;

AC@

)' ((! &## & '%&' !%(" # # #(%/*## */0/ ' '- #24'#("## &#% '( ' '( ('!#( - '&% !%/( # & 42 ' (("##%, # !%! '( (4'#( '(# & ' '*#-*##B%#/0 '( (! '# - (% ""%- # !% ''( ' ' # / ! *# :# :# ! "0 - # B% (02 ' #" # - # # 4 ((4 /0 ' (( #

/# &&&#!#( --(&# '!# #" # -/0 ' (( '&% !- (

"# 0! '( ( )'.--(( .% '# 0(" # '#( " # !/ ' '- # #*# '--(# ;

)'- # # /# &# #!#'!#( '- ##

4'#"'#/# &# /0( (7- 4'!#( "

9'' '"% (! '- #

)'"% (! '- # # 4'#(#(# & '#*-%& -/0/ ' '% /(42' " ' '#

'# & '" - ' '*#-*##B%#/0 ' ( ( '#!*#(0 **/! '-%-!- (%

""%- # 4/%# 9 #!% '" ' -

, #'# &-* :/# 1) #((2'&44'#(- #45# &.""%

4# '#%-# !#* )' # '("* # " ' ! - , # *-(0 # .@# $ 1( '## !*'#--# * ( C@ >74'#"'4 -/0 '!!#"#(! '#/ 54' --# 4# /@> )'"% (! '- # # !% '%/*# ' # #4! '!# # "2 "%(#(0*5% ' '*#-*## B%# /0- 0! '#!*#(0**/! '-%-!

&/%# 9 #!% '" ' ''-# '* /%#(# &24 /0- 4& " # ;

AC@ -/0 '.--(( .% '# 0!% '!!#*/0 '#% # ?

AC@ )'"% (! '- # # ' !% '%/*# ' # " '# 0%"'- (B%#* !

2 '0"%(#(0 '# 4/%# # ' !#'-4'#"'4& " 4# ' '# # ! '% # "(!*!# ## % # '*/%#(# & #'# & *"**"#(- #( ' ! '*#-*# ?

)'"% (! '- # # '!% '%/*# ' # ' "2 '4 -"#!#"-(# & '- ! '- , ' '*#-*##B%#!%! '# )' - ' #(#4 /0 E/(3%-*% # #!*#-*## B%#/0 !'#%2 ' 'B%#* (#4 # 3" #

## / "! ' ." ' /# - # '*

; *

'( ' ' ! '( (' -(# '#" #

' 2 /'# ""%-0# &# '%/ " " ! ' -%-!'#/%# 0 '%"'/%#(# & ( '" *0/F "'' " %"'/%#(# & ( 4# '% %!!#"# "%! '"** "* ! ' ." # '%/ " " )'"% (! '- # # '!% '&% ' # ' - "2 ' %"'-(# &# '#" # '# (&% 2 '#" # /#*#

)' "% ( ! ' - # # ' !% ' " '

'!#( - ' ' "# 0-:" /0 '*#& %# / !# )' '# "#(/( '" %&& ' ' # ! - , # * !

"#!%( 4'#*#"( )' # %"'"#"%* "2 '#*-%& /# &#((&( / #

;

' ''

2"% (!- 4'#( %-- # & '#*-%& '%/*# ' '# #((&(# 0 -# 0 # ' - /0 / ' ' % /(4 9 # !% ' " ' '#*-(# "#(/( '" - '

4'# &-# :/2# '#-# /%# # '*#-*#4'#"'#'# &"**"#(- #( # % # "**"#( #%# /(!%

&! 0 0-!

/%# 9 #!% '%/*# ' # ( - ' !

4'#(# &:/# -# / 5#(# '# 4/%# 9 #!% '" ' '( (#/ :%& !'#4 B%#* '

# #" '#* *

&%#'#* '4 # 4' *

2''%(%'#-*# )' "% (!- '!% '" ' ---(# & 4*# ' - 'B%#* !(4 )'"% (! 4'#(!# & ':%&* -/0 ' E/( 3%-*% #

!"#$%&$' %-4'#"''/ (#%- /0 '"% (! '- # # 2'%/*# ' '#:%&* #

! 0'(- '- # # !% ' '#% #'# &(#*# :%##" # # '@"#!# ## (-4% ' ." !4# ' '" "% !# # &!!" "/0/ ' '% /(4

9 ' " # ' %/*## * /0 "% ( ! ' - #

$! # & '%/*## */0"% (! ' - #2# #---# #" '* */0-

B%- ( "# 0-%"/0 ' ((# -

!# :%&* 24'#"'!((4 G34

0 5

( *67( /

, ( $

)

("0

7 3)

+ ' 2( ((-( ' '0 4 # ""%- # ! 0 '-- 0# 1( ' ' & " 0-- 04# '% 0%!!#"# # " ' " * ! ' ."

.-(# # &! '!#-(# &2*5# # '

'-# B% # ':# &'-4'#"' ' #*!!#(# &!

4""%-#/0 7.&&4()2B%#/0- , '# ! # & 4/%# D* '-%(!

C@ C@ 2 # # # ' ' :# & '- 4 /0 ""%-#/0 7.&&4()24(

& " 4# ' '# # ! '% # 4- /0 42# '"* '"/040!

# " ' '#'-4'#"'4(## -# ! 7.&&4( ) '*#'-B%#/0- '# !*#(0**/! # & '## - /%# $ ' ''- # % '&% !( '# &"**"#(- #( 9 '&#

"#"%* "2 # "

/ # ' - , 4#((!%((0 %--" # * #(!" !* '% ' #*!!#(# &! '

)'%2 '- # # '!#( - ' '4" "(* !

" # # (!" '- !- 24'#(!#(# & ' #" # &# - # # - 4# '& -" !- ( "# 0 9 #4(( ((&(-# # ' '( (# '/ :%&!

'#/%# B%#* # ' '

'% "

%/ # % # -# # !4#* '( ( #" *# '#& ' ( ( , %/ 2 ' '- :# & *# '- # ( #(/(4# '- 42 '"!-

!* '0/&#

&# ' / '*#'- ':# & '-4'#"'4(#""%-#/0 7.&&4()B%#/0 ! '-%-!%

& # - /%# !

'#!*#(0 3 '-( 5 /0 '- # # ' ( #""** #

'-4'#"'4(#""%-#/0 7.&&4()##(/( 4# '- '#/%# # /( D% '2 ' -( 5 /0"% (! '- # # ' - (0 -""%-# !- #45# &# / 54'#( ' "'#( # %0# &2 # %!!#"# & ' -( ! ' / !# B%#* #/0- C 2 '-( 5 /0"% ( ! '- # # ' '-(# &*/0 '( (4# '& '# - ( "# 0# '#" # # " !*# 04# ' ' B%#* !3" # # / "! ' ." #( *#-(" )'"% (! '- # # %# &&%* !#( '4 %"'!(4# '-(# &2# '#" @ "%(/! ( '"!

9 # ((4 ' 4' :" * #!#( ' &% !/ !#- ( "# 02 '% #B%# -" '-*# ' *#-*##B%#/0( (!'# / !#- (% ""%- # '4# 9 #( ( -# # !(4 ' / !#B%#* * ' B%#* *% / & %# ' # 4# ' 0%( #* # # *#4#'

42# '- "2 '"% (! ' '!#( /%&' ' #"! '#% 0!" 4'#"'

4%( '4%/ '/ !#B%#* ! '( ( D% '2 - ( "# 0!( (#B% # !!" '%( /

*((0# !# ##

D% '*2 '--(( % # !&%2 ' #&' !

2#&' (0/ ' # "*#'-# % /0- ! " # ! '*/0 '

2 '0 "

& /"5 '#-# '*#'---## !

3" # ! ' ."

(#&' ! '/2 '#% #! '#4 ' ' !# # &" /0 '( % /(4 / ""

--"# # !-(# & # " -%!# # &!!" 2 4'#"'#**% !*"'(( &# '- ## 2% ( '# 0#((&(# 0-# 0# '#*-%& :%&* /0 / ' ' % /(4 9 ' # "2 ' "% ( ! ' '!#( /# & ' #"! '#% # 0*

'#*-%& :%&* %!!!* 0#((&(# 0# !#*# 0 ?

D '!&# & 29 !# 0*# # '

.""# &(02 '*##*#

())*+)+,

: -"'"'.$/'&0 !1.'&$2 '34 '$12 -"'"'..'/2.&56'4 '$12