Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. v. Anita Devi And ORS



 !"!#!$% 
&$'()!%*  !)#%!



)+ , -

 . +/ 12+ 34,+ ,+ . 22//+  50  +)6+ ,. %2  



 


& - 777,.08,6+ .+22//+  .9+  +/9+8,6++ 1+ ,2:+08,6+ 2 + ,; 






.,.+//,2 


+9//+ 

/,32 + , 23 . 9+022/,/+  .+22//+   

12+ 3.+ /,.+22+/.+// < <+9+,,+,   2+,3, /+1+  0 +/877+<+8.+/ = 0 +/> . .<0 , 12 +9+,,./+1+   <?6      . . .+ , .+6  /, 3 . /+1+ ;@ < .+ 1 .12 +9+,, .13./+ , 0 +/ +0 ,+. . )2+@.+   . /+1+ 8 9. + 2+    . ,+,8 /, + 2 ,7 AA .5./@ <12 +0 



,+. . )2+@.+ ,,0 06, +16./ +,  9..@2/+    .,+, )2+@ .+ , 9+ 6/6,  9. .+/ <9.. 2// ,70 ,&+/9< < 15//+< 7+ +5//+<+<+ 13/+ <&( A #

BA +/92,+ , / , .+, (.   ,+, +1/3 0@. :01+ + , 0 / %+1 :++  9

//9 <.+613/+0

+189. .,+,, <. 13/8 +., + :+ ).++8 5//+< )8   (/ + < <+ &(  

9+2, <+./3+ /3  .13/ .,+,7+,(/9 9+,.9 <, +,+ , .1+ 18+ 3+

6++ <<+ !



+1 1.22, 1(+ 04+ ,+ ++63.<.2, ,6    + +. +  1+

 + , //,, 9. (/ )0  .<. 2,

6+8,60/,  /+ ,.+10@+<+  .13/ .,+,+0/. 8,+,)2+@.+ +/ < 9. 70 , &+/ // ,9  . +, + , 6, ++/  0 )2+@ .+ , ,,   . 28 9.+ 70 , &+/ 6, 0 0 . +,  @ 2/+ ,0  12  . 2+  ,6   . . 

< 6./ . ,+, 9+  + +0/ 
% A ,+,    9+ <, 0 , 7   B +

 & +<+ ,6  .. 6./+ &/7+  7.+ + 9+2/+,, .+.,+,+.1 .,+.9+A3+/,!9+9@ +9.2,, <+ <0 8+ <% 8

21 .

1 + 79 7.2 + , %

1 + < 0  12 9+.02+3,  4+ , 0 +/    ,+  . + + , 6, , ./, .+ . +,    D0  @ 2/+ ,0  . 12



 2    + , A; ,6   . 

< 6./  0.+// <.+ +, .+/ 12+ 3 . <+,4+/3+ ?,3. 0 +/+/ ,20, 4+ , 0 +/ /0,,.,+,A3+/,+. 1   . ,+. + , +, .  1 + %

 2 1 . E +  19+, 0022.+ +

,,),0

E 9+ 

, 9+, 2 +/ ?2  0/2/     9+ +22/, @2 69.+< .,+, .08+/,2 39++, + % 8

   ??   01   % 8

 9+ +9+,, 9+, /+  .08 . /+1+  9 ./,  /,  +/ 12 % 8BA8

+/ <9. FAE2+

01 1.,+ / < /+12 //+/+ 4+ .+22//+ ;

12+ 301.+ . /+ , 0 +/ .+ ,   +

, <  1  + . +  E  +0 00 228 9.+   69   . 0,<1  ! >/ 7021 0   + +/ 3 4, 5 &+ +3 7. + .8 C%%6/

B8.0/,+

,,+.+ C E 4+ ./+1+ ;0 +/, 3 .+ 00  1  + . +   C E +   +

,,  !8 .968 01.+ 1 .,+,+,3./+ , 0 +/9+ ./9,681+<12 .+ +9+,,0 ,.  6  +/.+,89.. , .+ ,+2.0,<1 ! >/70210 +<1+# +/ 12+ 34,5+ 0 %+1+/+.0.0%+1+ ,.8 6/22+/B  ,,, B ! 0.01.+ +.+  E AE .0/,+9+,,.02+3,.+  /,3./+1+  +//9,+ ,12 +9+,, .+ ,

C

.+6.+,/+ .2++ ,.+6< .0<. .,9..+/++  "6,  ,26.+)2+@.+ ,,,,0 0 6, 9..@2/+  ,0. 12  2    + , A; ,6   . 

< 6./ 4+ , 0  . /+1+ ;  / 02  . +1 &G #010@.7 <./+1.+.,+,9+9@ + 9 .28 + < % 8

 ,  <  <+<,   . 0   + <!968. 6,  , ,+.+1?2 .+/,+1 &G,.+/+1  &G #010@.7 <. + ,&G0@.:01+8. .,+,+ ,&G +)681. .,+, 1019+< + 0 @//,/+0 .7+ &0 + +.1 +, 9+%A

 . 8 1 .,+,.+  /3+,+%

 .,+,9+A3+/,+. 1 +,  69 .0,<1 ! >/.70210 +   &+ +3 7. + , . 02+8 C E  +,  E  +  1.++

,, +0 00220/2/ .+ <./3 +22/,),0 E.++/<./3 

, 69 . 0,<1  ! >/ . 7021 0   . +   +<1+ # +/

3 4, 02+8 %C

 +. .+   +

,,  . +22//+ 9+, /+/ 01!968./+1+ + ,, /, +01 % 8

+. / ++ +/?2  % 8

+9+,,9+,/+?2  22//+ +8.08 /,12 89.. 9@, +0 ,-

 



    

1

218 C8

2+

01  +/  1 +  +,,  + . +   C E   +0 00 22

C8

8A

 C8

?C E I8 8A



1 +  ,,0 E  +0 2 +/?2  8 8A

J

8 8A

; I

C +/ ,2 3 +  +22/3 < + 10/2/ 

 IB8BB8A

 4 +  8

A
0 +/?2   8

 4  01+22//+ F

%

C

? 
 8 B8A

.  1   . +<01  /+ , 0  . /+1+ ;.+ +.+  E.0/,+9+,, AE12  .+.++,1,/3 ,2,3.

3 9.  . 2, 2,   9 1 . 10 12 +/+,3+9+,,.+22//+ 8 ,/+38.+//+ ,,0, 1.+10 +/0/+,++622//+ .+// /, +.+  E2+

01 . +10  1.,+

/ < .2 //+/K+ G. . +6+, 1, +    . +9+, ,+,   8 ..+22+/+9//+ +,2, 




 

 .9+ G..2+@ <;+ ,- *; G..2+/- *;