High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/10555/2018allowed

Rohit @ Nawab v. State Of Haryana

2021-12-09Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma14 pages

! !

! "# $%$ &&&$!

()*+ ,,-- ./0 %/1 , 2 "# $$!33$!

40). 1)--0 ,,-- ./0 %/1 , 2 "# $$56$!

( ,,-- ./0 %/1 , 2 "7# $%$&& 3$!

8()% 0 ,,-- ./0 %/1 , 2

9 $ :;9% % :;9 % % << 9 . 9 / 9 ./0 % =(>27 2 9? */>27 /(,,-- $%$ &&&$!

' 9/ 8 4 ,2(11>27 /(,,-- $%$&& 3$!

' 9/ = (*/@->27 /(,,-- $$!33$!

9/ .(-(/>27 /(,,-- $$56$!

9/ 40/9->22- >/1 2 9/ %0/+(9=> >/1 /(/, 2 $% % << 9 . 9> (/2/*--2, $%$ &&&$!

'> $$ !33$!

> $$56$!

$%$&& 3$!

' ?? A0 -* 2 / 7-72 ( ,,- ( ,,-(7+ 2/2= (802=? 7 22 !' !

' 2/2/ 225 !

',2+1-/ 2 22 -% 02=> /4 0/>% , ! / 0--2 0 /? ( ,,/$+4 / ( ,,-- B02 ?-1 (> 40). 1> 8( ( )*+*/ /-/?? ,0 (+- 2/% 563$>535>5C6$>5C6>5C$>3>& 6 2!

$ ( 2 - 2> '6 /=/2 72 63 22 !

! !

C +1 ( % 0 /> - % %2/ % , ,/((,/0 >(?,- ((/

5 20=(/ 2 (/2 20=(/ - ( (0 9/(> !

6 2 * /=/2 - % %2/ % , = 02B,,-- ( ( ( (2 --2 2 4 *1 ?,- D 20=(/ *( (? 20=(/ * /7/2 5 ! !

6 +0 2 02 * //2 ,/ ?,- >

*2 ((24 *1(10 =/20=(/ ,/0/E '

! !

C 2(*/1 =/0(20=(/ *7/> 02 ((2?2--/?(?+- '5'

5'5 ' ( ?+- !&&!'3!652? 2 =/ ? 5-4(//- = ( 20=(/ /2 =-1> * /=/2> ( 02 */ //2 2(1*/(/=$(2 (,/0 (E? 2 * @$ @$! 2 ( 02 ,/ E? 2 (/ 2 * 5 / 2/ ((,/0 2 ?/(-- = ( 72 ( ,/0 - ( 2 * >(/- 0/ 72--(02,/ *(/ ,,-- +/ ( 0/ ( 0/ ,,- 72 802=? 7 22 !' !

' 2 72 /2/ 22 !

'(/202,/ (7+ */22 0 2/ $ ?( 7

B% /2 % "

# ?,2 /2 20- ,1? "

563$ /2 *(% !

$> 53 ?,/ ? /;

B$ =( ? ( 5C6$> ?,/ ? !

B$ =(

3 !

//? 2/ 0/-- ? ( 535> !

$> 53 *1/ $ $ 5C$> !

$ >53

71/

!&>

1/ & 6 (/1/

B$ (/ ? ( 3 *1/ $ $

563$ /2 *(% !

$> 53 ?,/ ? /-

B$ =( ? ( 5C6$> !

$ ?,/ ? //? 2/ 0/--

B$ =( ? ( 535> !

$> 53 *1/ $ $ 5C$> !

$ >53

71/ $ $ & 6 (/1/ 5>

B$ (/ ? ( 3 *1/ $ $

!"#

5C6 %7 1/

7 ? ( & 6 (/1/

B$ (/ ? ( $%

3 *1/ $ $

0/(/?/>(/-0/2/2(--( (-- /0 0// -1 *7/> ( ,/2 ?,/ ? -/21 2/= +1 ( 7 20/ = ( 7= 2/-( (--+= (0+ 7 0 2/% 3!' / ( /2 ?,0= 2 802=? 7 /0 2/(-- = (0/,,- 3 ;/ 2 0 - ,,/ = / ,,-- $ ( )*+0+?((,,-- (+ --1?,-2 ( ,/ ( --= = ( ,,-- / -1 *( /=/2% 5C6 2& 6( /$E? ( ,/0/E(2?2( (/(/2 1-/? /0/2

& 1 80/1 (,,-- * (7 = 1*, *((? (/(/?-1??+/*/-, = (?(0 %((2 2?2( +21 /(/(0--(?(=* , 2/? 2 2(*7/1?0( 0(? ( --=2 2 -- ( 2 /0? (* ( =/2 % 5C6 2 & 6 ( / ?2 0 = ,,-- ( ;/ 2 0 - 0/(/ 0+? ( ( ,,-- ( 2 7/ ( ,/72 ( ( (2 -7 / *((,/0/E/(-/0 2*1/ 2+((? */ 2 ==?//2+0((/(,/0/E22 -4 (/ /- ( ,/0/E 02 -4 /A0 -1 *( ( ,,-- -,( 2 ( (2 - */ -7 -/ ( ,,-- 0((,,-- ((+ */ =-1?,-2 (,/ & ;/ 2 0 - / (/ ,,-- ?-1 (>

40). 1)-0> 8()% 00+?((,,-- (7 + */ =-1 72 2 /2/2 0 2/= ;/ 20 -0+?((,/0/E* =,/1 (*(7 =-7/*(02 ( ,/(? 1 @$& / 2( 90 8- *( ?2 -=--1 E? 2 ( ,/0/E*0-2/7-((/* E/ -?/4 80/1 / +-2 = * ,/ 7/ ( +21 ( ,/0/E ;/ 2 0 -0+?(- 7*(0-2(7+ 4 +1(/- 0/*(-*/2 = 02 ( 40). 1 )-0(1(7+ */22-?,/ ? //? 2/

0/--

6 6 / / -/ 2 % 0 - ( 0+?2 ( ( ,,-- (7 + /=(-1 72 2 2 +1 ( /- 0/ (/= 72 //2(*((,,-- */ ==2 ( ?? ( /2 ( ,/0 (E? 2? 1!* ,/7 / ,,/ ( 72 //2> ( /- 0/ ( /=(-1 72 2 2(,,-- B02 C @ (7 =7 0/ (0=(0- 2/ ( 0+? ?2 +1 -/ 2 0 - / ( ,,-- 2 = (/0=( ( ,,/$+4 @$C ( ?,- B(/ ( ,/0/E 2,2 ( '

! !

C *( (1 *4 0,> (1 0 2((20=(/ ,/0/E*? =/?((0 2,2 ( !

! !

C ( ?72 ?,- E @$CB = 02 ((,-/=/2 =? =(20=(/

0/(/ ( 2,2 ( 02 ( (2 E 22 (/ (? ,//? =,/0/E 2? 22 5-4(/ ? ? 1/?(? -,( +11 =(((242 ,,2( 20=(/ @$C -2,2( !5 ! !

C (20=(/ * /7/2/?(02102 ( 40 2( ? ( ,/E0/E * 4, 2 +1 ( 02 ,/ 56> 0 = /2 %/$&> % , 2 / = = //2 =? ,/0/E0 2/% 63( / 2(/?2-E? >(,-( 227/(021 ,/0/E ( ?,- @$C 0/(/ 2,2 ( ( ,/0/E-2(?( ( /7 = =(C$'

! !

C 02 (??2/,*((/*( (?2* (

C =/0 2-/((0/0/ 2/(02 ( 4042 ,,2(//?((0 '

/? ( ,/0- ( 72 //2 2 ( E? (,/0/E 2/2 (* +E>(* ( (0-21 ( =(?02 ( 40/ (( = /? - ,/1 +202 ,/0/E +1 2? / = ? E =0+ 24,(/ 2/721 ??2 = = /, 0, (/ (1 2? 22 5

- / ? ? 1 /? ( (/ ( ,/0/E -,( 2 (1/+-1 (2(/8*--/1 2/ 2(?4 * = 0--1 *-- ( 0( ,/,/1 * - 2 02 8( - 2( -1 / 2 ( - 8*--/1 ( 9 =- %0/ 9;4D*(((,0/(2/?02 (/0?

B$ 2(1,(2(?*(90( ;2 (0>(,/0 (20-1+-(2(=0-02 (>

40 8(/?? /2 ,/@$ !

;% /?-> 7= = /> 02 8( 0/2 2-0/ ? E @$&B 2 ,0/0 (/ = /7/2(8*--/1,/0/E/?90( ;2 @$5(4<0?/>9 =/90( ;2 -,/72 -/ ,-2= E @$5B *( ,,- / ,/ - - E @$5B ( ?02 8( -(0=(2?2 +1(,/0/E*--?,- ( +--8*--/1* =7 +1(?(,-+0@$C$?,- 20/ =(/$ E? 2,2((8*--/1*2 2+1(20=(/ (,/ @$!

( -2,2((8*--/1*

' (* ( ,/ 7? (0> ,/ ,/0 /1> ( 8*--/1*20-12 2+1(,/0/E E,- ( + =7 +102 8( (? //220 2/% 55( / /=/2 =(/7/1(/28*--/1 2(((( -?2(8*--/1(* ,/7 ((,/0 = (? (/ , ( ,/ ( ,/ ,/0 /1> 02 ( 40 (2 42 ,,2 ( ,/0/E 71 0/ = //= 02 ( 0/2 2-0/ ? E @$&B 2 = 2?/2 ( ,-0// 72??E @$B*(/02 40 0/2 2-0/ ? E @$&B 2 = 2?/2 ( ,- 0// 72 ??

E @$B 02 40 ,0/0 ( 2-0/ ? - = /7/2 2 7 1 2 - 2 -/ 2 /, - 72 ??E @$&B 2(-=/7/2 ,/=-2// = ( ,/0/E /? 90( ;2 72 /7/1 ??

/?(A0 7 2(,/0 > +-(2 //2(02 (> 40 8((7 /=(-1+ 0 2+ 7-72 (?? ( /+0 = (?//0 0/(1(7+ 0 (7??22+- 2( 0 42 ,, =>= = /, = ( *( ( ,/0/E 2 0 2/ /? - ?2 +1 (/ = ( ,/0/E 2 4 = / / ? ? 1 /? (/ (/ E @&B$ 9;

( ,/0/E -/-1

(* ( ,+-1 E0- 0-

+ /0-2 0 (

/0 ( 02 ,/ = ( ,/0/E /0? 2 2+- 7* ( -1 /0? ( 2 +7> 0,-2 *( ( / /? 2> ( 0/ - ( -02 ( ( -/ 2 /- 0/ ( ??2 /// -*>*(- , = ( ?,0= 2 802=? 7 A0 02 (> 40

8( , --=-1/,/7/1(+ , 20+1( -/ 2 0 - / ( ,,-- > *(( / // ( ? ( /0? > * / ( 2/2 , ( ( 02 (> 40 8( (7 /=(-1+ 72 % / */2 - ?,/ ? / /? 2/ 0/--0, 02 ( 40 / 2> (-=-, *(/=/2(,*/(/- 0/*/2 *((/2/(+ ?2E,- ( 0 ( 802=? ( %0,/? 0/

,/ 5 &> ( --* =*/2 $ G 5 ( ,/> ? 0( *(/ 2( , -1 / - ?,/ ? ( ,0 (? ?,2 +1(/- 0/ 2 /?2+1(7 ( ( =( 0/> ( / 2 7 *-- = ,,/0 1 = 0( 7/2 2 +1 - = 0/(/ ,,-+1*1%,-;7( 0/ 1*1 +0 2 0 2 ,/ ( ,//+2 -* ( 2 2 ( /? - 80/,/02 > * / (

/ ( - 2 = =0- 0( ,2 =/7 2(?, , -1(/2(/- ?,/ ? *( ? 0 2/ ( /0 1 ( 7 ( ( =( 0/> -1 ( =( 0/ *(( 2/7 ( ,*/ 0 2/ ( - 2> *((,//+(,- 2-/ ,0 (? > -/(2,0 (? *( (//( /1 ( 7:-// 1,,/2?/( 31/>1!

>5 / 2, 2 =0, (=/71 ( /? ??2 2 ( E/ 802- + = 0( 0 2 ,/72 (7 + ??2 3 @>(//>//(>(,*/2/72/? ( - 2/ 1?22,0 (? *( ( ,0 (? ,/722 / ( - 2 / 0( ,2 -1 + E/2 +1 ( =( 0/ 2 ( 7 0/(/ ,,- -1 +1 ( %0,/? 0/ +1 1(/ 0/ (0 /1 ,0 2/ -1> ( ,*/ ?, ?22 ,0 (? ,/72 = / 1 , /? // / -- ( 2 ( 7: - -/ 2( , -1> + E/2 -1 +1 ( =( 0/ 2(%0,/? 0/ +1 1(/ // 0/ & .*2 (/,>*((/-2 2* %*?1%(/22 2H"!

'#5% C6CI( ,- =/1 J 2 (J / /? E2 = 3 1/ 2 ,0 ( =/1 +1 ,,- /? *--0 22 2* */ ( 2 A0 ( /?7 @ /> (//>

=/? *( ( , E,/2 +1 ( 0/ % =/ 2 (/7 %/1 >!

5 "!#% 3&!((2,/7-/? ,*/( ,,/,/7/ ? +1*/2 = !

!&1//*(0 1/? ,/?+-

*( ( -* 2 * ,--1 7//0-(? K ! (0>/(802=? ( 0 (( %0,/? 0/

"0,/#> , 0/ // ( =( 0/ 2 %0,/? 0/> *(- */2 = -?,/ ? 0 2/( 2 - 20/(/ ,/72 / 1 , /? // / -- ( 2 7: -> / 2/ ( (/ (-- + /? > -/ (2(, -1 (,*/7-+- -1*(( =( 0/ 2(%0,/? 0/ A0 -1>(/- 0/> (,/ >*(-*/2 =(,,-- ( 40>( /=/0?,/ ? //? 2/ 0/--0-2

(7222(/2/((0-2+/(/(/ 0/- - 5

0/(/?/> 2/ =(/2=02 =,/ ,- 2(?= = 2,0-/ 2/0? (,/ > ( 0/ ( 2/2 , ( ?,/ ? / /? 2/ 0/--*/22,,-- ( 40) . 1)--00 2/% 5C6$>!

$( ?22 (E ((/? ,,-- ( 40). 1 ) --0 (-- + / - ?,/ ? /2 =-1> ( /2/ 22 5 !

' ,2 +1 ( 22- % 02=> /4 0/> % , ?22 ( /2 E ( 7 2 */22 ( 40 ) . 1 ) --0>+(0 2/% 563$/B*% !

$L53>535/B*

! !

$L53>5C$/B*!

$L53>& 6 23(

8(0 2/% 3( //2*( 3 7* ( +7 2 0+8 /2 ?2 */220 2/% 5C6$ !

$ ( ( 40> ( ,,- "

$$56$ !

> $$!33$!

$%$&& 3$!

'# -2 +1 (>

40 8(>/,7-1(-- 22?2 & % / ,,-- ( $%$ &&&$!

' / 2> ( ? //2( ( * ??+/ ( 42 ,,/ 2B/(,/ *(??2= =/, (* (7 =-7/*((,/0/E/(-+0*1/ (1*/ 2 ==?//2+0(?,- B(/( ,/0/E 22 -4 (/ /- ( ,/0/E 02 -4 /A0 -1*((,,-- 7/-,( 2((2-*/ -7-/(? (-? //2(,/0/E* ?8/ 2*+7(='1/(? 2 ( -/21 ?//2 *? ( ,/0/E( =/--1 2?2 (//$E? (02 (22 =7 1 + =(/(?/,*((/ 2(

--*((/

((2,0(( 2 (/?0((??? /,*((/ (,/0/E0/(/2?2((22 0/ 1 80/120/ =(?? /, 2(22 /??+/ *((/ 1+-2*M =/ (? (?/- /0 (*(7-0 /1/- (,+* ,/0/E (

+ 2 2 0/(/?/> @$& / 2(90 8-

5 *(- ,,/ = ( * +E =/--1 2,2 ( E? > E/ -?/4 80/1(+ 7/(/+21> 7/+/ 2= - ;BE/ -= --+?8/ /?-> -+? / /?-> 80/1?/4*,/ +-2 =

2(/=*,/ B.* =/ /2-1 20/0

/?-MB;/ -/ 80/1 2+-2 =*/,/

0/(/?/>(,,-- $ ((0 2/= &1/ 0C 1/ 2/ =--(?/- //2 (0( / 22? / 80>*/ ( 2/2 , ( ( ,/0 ( -2 ,/7 ( = ,,-- $ (+1 2/ +-20+ (//> +1=7 =+ 20+>02B,,-- (A02( (/=/?2= (? 6 7* ( +7> /? - ,,- + = $%$ &&&$!

' -2 +1 ,,-- ( ) *+ --*2 2 ( ?,0= 2 802=? 7 2 /2/ A0 02B,,-- ()*+2 A0 -1>0+8 /2?2 */22 (

40>(,,-"

$$56$!

> $$!33$!

$ %$&& 3$!

'#-2+1 (> 40). 1)--0 8() % 0 /2?2 2 = ,,- "#> 1> ( ,,- (-- 22,2/2 =-1 -/2/,,-- ( )*+(?/(-/21+ 0272,//2/ ,221+1( 0/ *7/>( 8()% 0 * 0, 22 +1 ( /- 0/ 5 !

' 2 (// ( ?*E 22+1( 0/ ' ! !

'20/ =(, 2 1

3 (,,- A0 0, (2?-(,,-> 8() % 0 2/2 0// 2/ +/ ( /- 0/ ?,- ( /? = /2 =-1 "% << 9 . 9# "

! !

! <