High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/8318/2019disposed of

Gurcharan Singh v. Sokhal Minirals Pvt Ltd And Others

2020-01-13Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh6 pages

!"#"$

%&!'

(")' *++ ,, - &#%# (.'

,/" & ,# 012 2' &# #+2 #

& # $3 /&(/"

,420!

4&' ++ ,,

5'"#+ ""4' + "" &!'

,, ) #' &2 &#'

, & 2 &"

, !%& 622"" , "0", %2) 6(& "04 ("&# 4 2 7

4859'"!', 0 2 2' #%""#"% 285' +& # + "" & "#' & #+2 #' & "62 2 #"' #%"'

#8 2' 2 2 #4' #%"8 ") ", 2%2 &' +&0"#"# ( !"7' 2 "0", &! 2%& 4

& 2!%# ,&' + "" &+"#' : 2 : :

2 " %, &2 &7' 4 8, ' ( #

84 &5 2 ":

, 2 #'4 ,#' " &&"&5< 4'

2") &' 2 ,'"49"'' # "2 %, & 2") #,,9#$3 =6' %&#'

,,4%+ "85' 2 2 4 )"0 , 0 & 22 2' #%"4%+ "2 0"#9'"!'2"#!,# #%!' !# # 9%,2 :

. " "!%:8 ' ',2 & +&0 !#"2 & "4&#%!'' & !# #' !%&:

52 :#%"!" #%++&' " 6 0 2 2:

58 )"0 %!2"" ,,54& #%8; !#%!' &:# #+ 5: "%&4)"0")# !%&"54& :")

33 2& !&2")"##% #&' &9"# 4 #' %&'".#" 6 ' +&0"#"#( !">' 2"

1":"

" !4

4#'

,, ++,5 "#%2 &#%83&%, 66")'%&" >77342>33 7?

' & & #%8:"#'

9"'' +&0"#"#( !"> ' 2"

1":"

"!4 @48 8, 5 "", 285 ' 2 2 # ."), 0 2 2' #%"4' & #+2 #32 2 # 9 & & A%"& 2", "%2 &( !">4"' 5#%)', 0 2 2' #%"4! #%!' "4# ."), 0 4'

28 ", 28 52 ' + &"2)"0 "' "! "##% 2 +"#' # "2"! "##% 285' , & 2&"

,!%&4 2 B 6!+5 C%& 34' & , 0 + &9'"!'& 2# ,,9#$3 =D' & #%&!'

(")''

#"#"% 2 #%" "#5% %2 & &2 &EEE-' 2 "0", &! 2%& 4

2" & #45% & ' & 85#%:: 2!

%# 2 ! 8 & 2 & 5%4 9"'" 2 5# &: ' # &0"! ' & 4 " 2 %, 9' & ' +, ""9",,8 ", 24 &' C+"& "' # "2+ &"2 2 5#48 " 2 !& & 5#%: C! 2")' #%:

2' #%:&!##4) ' &9"'#%!'" & #4" 54 ' %&:

5&2 & CCC CCC CCC?

'%##%8:"#'

,5 2 5#'

0")8 )& 2'

# 0 # ., 0 2 2' #%"49"'#%!'+ &"2 2 5# 8 !:+% 2&:' 2 # &0"! %+' :6' "! "##% 24

2' "", 285' :# ."), 0 2 28 ") 2 %,574 6!+5 C%& 34"9 #80%#,59 ,,8 52'

5#": )& 2 2' & & 49"'% "%2 &( !">

33 0")8 ", 24' , & 2&"

,!%&'

#9',,5 && 2"!2")'

2 , 5 2)& ")' :, 0 2 2' #%" D' '"#!

# '

2"""

,,5!: %+&'

&") % &5 4, & 2!%# ,'

2#%)'": !" ;%2): #%++&'"# ! "'

# + "%2 &( !">' 1":"

#& A%"& 28 ", 26 0 '%)'' & #+2 32 2 #4"' "&

"# ."), 0 2 2' #%"4'

2)"0 & ##&'

2 , 5 2 54' & ," #%+ ;%2): !&2" !''

,'"")'%&"# $%!&

'#%%()

!' 6 B 6"0",BB49' & ""9 #8# &0 2 #,,9#$3 = ' 8# ! "&!2 " 2 , 5& C+, "")' 2 , 5&"",")' , 0 2 2 "4 '"#!%&'

#+"8%2"#:"##' +& # " #'

0") 8 ", 28 52' + &"2+& #!&"8 2"' # % ?

0")!#"2 & 2' :

&4""## '

"' # "2!

8 & ' ,'"")'%&4"+ +' ""## 2 #,,9#$3 = %&' &4' #%8:"##":

2 85, & 2!%# ,&'

++&%"58 )"0 '":4", "& !2 "2 , 5!

8 !! 2 2 '"## ) &' #":+, #'

' 2 2 9 #9 ,, & ' 8; !" . 85'

' &#"2 #,)8 !. 8%95 &# ) 25 # +#9 & . 85' &", "&!2 "2 , 5?

'%#4 # :"),54 ' & 9 # & #") )"0 " '

"' 2 2 ## ."), 0 2 2'

#%" ' +& # !

# 4""## '

"' "", 285'

3B3 & #+2 32 2 #4"'

#8 # 2"+ +'# 2B' & 4'

' #%::# "##% 2 85' &"

, !%& B 9 & # &0 2 + &# ,,5%+' :8% ! 2'&%)'' "&+ 4 2 '

' 5 9 & =8%#5 " !2%!") ' +&! 2")# ' "0", D&" "" @B ", 2 #=/<# ("- %& 0( &5 2 ' &#4+ 2")"' F8, ")'%& '

2") &'? '

#%&' &8 # 2'

' %!, ' 2 2 #'

C+"& 26# :"),5' %!, ' "& !&#' :+ 549"'" C 2'

' + '&%)'9':# &0"! '

28 ! 24B B

"# ,685+&! ## ##%8:" 2'"#!%&4'

22"#!,# 2'

! ' 2 2 #,5 7 4 2'

' & &' "'

8 ", 29"'" 2 5##%!'.9, 2) & 2!%# ,&' + "" &'9 0 &+"# C%&

3 "4#%8:"'

" !"9 # % 9'"##'9'

8 # &0 2' "! "##% 269"'#%!'# &0"! ' 0")8 ! 2 B B 4' # "2 % # 28 6"' & +&' # &0"! 4'

) &' !:+ 5 '%#4"' & +&")"#8 !! + 28 !&& !4"9 #

+ 8% :

) &' !:+ 59'9 ## &0 2' "! "##% 2 85' &"

,!%& 2' ! 4"9%,28 2""!%, !! +'

' / ) & 2"2"&:' "& !&' !:+ 54" & #+2 32 2 4 :

(.'

,4' !%:' "! '

0")8 & ! "0 2 #%8:"#'

9' ' &' + &# !! +")#%!'"! 9

3>3 / ) && + 4'

#8 0 ,. 2"85' &"

,!%&40"2 '

":+%) 2&2 & 0")!#"2 & 2' :

&4'%)'"' +""'"# !%&4 # + "%2 &( !">' 1":"

"!:

5 0 8 8#,% ,5 ! ## &5&' &"

,!%&2 !"2 9' ' && !2 ' 2 , 54 ! #: & #") 9 # )"0 " ' " # ."), 0 2 2' #%"4 0 '%)'' &9"# ,":" "9%,28

#%8# "0 &")' ", 8, ' + "" &3+, ""4'9 0 &4'

!%& ##",,& A%"& 2)"' )&%2#&2 , 54!#"2 &' : 2' + ## & # 2&2 & !! +")&& ; !")' # "2& ## # A% ,54""#!#"2 & 2 ++&+&"

' &"

,!%&8 2"& ! 2,."' & #"))"0 85' & #+2 32 2 #" &5") C+, "' 2 , 5" ++& !'")'

!%&0"2 ' "& " 2 7 7 6# .") , 0 2 2 ' #%"4 2 ' & & !#"2 &9' ' &' 2 , 5"# .")#%!', 0 2 # &0 #8 !2 2 &4 0 " &:# %, &2 &7' 6 : 2 2 0" 9' 80 4' ":+%) 2&2 &6 C%& 3>"##

#"2 0 9"'% "##%") "! ' & #+2 32 2 #4 8% 80"%#,59"',"8 &5' :+& # ' "&! # &!2 "2 , 8 & ' &"

,!%&" &:#9'

,& 258 # 285' :" ' "& "49"''

!%&' & &)"' :

&"2 ",4 9' ' &4"&#,54' + &##'98 # &0 29"'' "! "##% 29

+ & / ) &4 2' & &)' : &"#' & ##

3@3 )"0 2' 2 !"2 #9' ' &' 2 , 52 # &0 #8 !2 2& %& ,,54'")# 2' & " 80 9",,8 . 8 8# &0 "'"#!%&' : &"#' #%"4&& "# "' &+ &5 "' #%"49"' ,,8# &0 "#:

2 8 "),5"' ! C' !

!"0 & #")'

#8 )"0 85' &"

,!%&&!2") ' 2 , 54 &2% !#"2 & "' & ##)"0 85' & #+2 3 #"' "& "# ."), 0 , '"#+ ""# 2#2"#+# 2"' 80 &:#

0!) &) * + % %!!%)%$,)&%( -%) + % %!!%&!.% -%)