High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3043/2019dismissed

Mohan Vikram Singh v. Raj Singh And Another

2020-01-17Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

!"#$ "%&'&#() (* +, -. #/ (0&1+ 23&(4/ 55"!&!&#("+ 0"+'*' 63&(4/ (7 (#!/"+ 588"'9#(7"(!'

+"'"(!) +8: ;&+3&(4/. 7<#% !".$#+!/"9"!&!&#("+8

/"9"!&!&#("+= '!+&"7$#+%#22&!!&(4!/"#$$"(%"*(7"+ 3"%!&#( > #$ !/" "4#!& ?@" ('!+*2"(!' %!. >> $#+ '/#+! A!/"

%!B80&7"6*742"(! (7#+7"+7 !"7 88 >.!/"9"!&!&#("+= ' %#(<&%!"7#$!/"' &7#$$"(%" (7'"(!"(%"7!#*(7"+4#&29+&'#(2"(! $#+ 9"+&#7#$!=#," +' (7!#9 , ( 2#*(!#$'8 ..C&8"8 7#*?@" !/" 2#*(! #$ !/" %/"D*"' &( D*"'!&#( !# !/" %#29@ &( (!8

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

,!/" #*+!'?"@#=.!/"%#29@ &(!=#*@7/ <"?""(7&'2&''"78 ( '*99#+! #$ !/" $#+"' &7 ''"+!&#('. !/" @" +("7 %#*('"@$#+!/"9"!&!&#("+/ '9@ %"7+"@& (%"*9#(!/"6*742"(!'#$ !/" #(B?@" 3*9+"2" #*+! &( 8 3*(&!/ 0'8 3!

(+8. > 888 +&2&( @ (7 808 *+!/, 0'8 838 4 ? ' < (( . 888 +&2&( @ -E. "@/& &4/ #*+! 6*742"(! &( 0&+"(7"+ 3&(4/ 0'8 F H2& + &( (7 (#!/"+. - 888 +&2&( @ E-I J"+ @ &4/ #*+! 6*742"(! &( 8 (&"@ 0'8 3! !"#$J"+ @ (#!/"+.E 888 +&2&( @ EI 7+ '&4/ #*+! 6*742"(! &( 83&< +"6 0'8 F#4( (!/ (.

+&2"' (7 !/" #2? , &4/ #*+! 6*742"(! &( 3*?/ '/ 0'8 3 %/&( *+@&7/ + +1 '" (7#!/"+'. E #2888 +@8 G8 / <" /" +7 !/" @" +("7 %#*('"@ $#+ !/" 9"!&!&#("+ (7 / <" @'#4#("!/+#*4/!/"% '"$&@"8#="<"+.7#(#!$&(7 (,2"+&! &(!/" +4*2"(!'+ &'"78 /"$ %!*2#$?#++#=&(4!/" 2#*(!#$'8E..C?, !/" 9"!&!&#("+ $+#2 !/" %#29@ &( (! &' (#! 7&'9*!"78 /" ' &7 $ %!

'!##7 @'# 7*@, 9+#<"7 #( +"%#+78 /" $&(7&(4 +"%#+7"7 ?, !/" !+& @ #*+!&(!/&'+"4 +7.=#*@7+" 7 '*(7"+) K5<"(&$!/" +4*2"(!+ &'"7?,@" +("7%#*('"@$#+!/" %%*'"7 &' '&% %%"9!"7. '!&@@ @" +("7 %#*('"@ $#+ !/" %%*'"7 / ' $ &@"7 !# ' <" !/" %%*'"7 !# 9+#!"%! /&2 $+#2 /&' %#(<&%!&#( *(7"+ 3"%!&#( > #$ 88 %! &( !/" 9+"'"(!% '"?"% *'" '9"+7#%*2"(! H88 =/&%/&' %"+!&$&% !" 7 !"7 >8>8 - &''*"7 ?, *(6 ? "!&#( @

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

(7' 7*@, 9+#<"78 /" &''* (%" #$ %/"D*"' &' @'# (#!7&'9*!"78/*'.!/" 2#*(!! 1"(&'!#?"!+" !"7 ' 7"?!8# 7#*?!.!/" <"+2"(!'#$!/"%#29@ &( (! +"!/ !!/"' &7 2#*(!= ' ! 1"( ?, !/" %%*'"7 !# %#(!"' !/" "@"%!&#('. ,"! !/" $ %! +"2 &(' !/ !%#(!"'&(4#$"@"%!&#(&'(#! (*(@ =$*@9*+9#'"'# '!#?+&(4 !/"' 2"=&!/&(!/" 2?&!#$3"%!&#(#$!/"(7& (#(!+ %! %!8 "!$*+!/"+.&!= '(#!9+#<"7#(+"%#+7=/"!/"+#+(#!!/"9"!&!&#("+ / 7. &( $ %!. %#(!"'"7 !/" "@"%!&#('8 /&' $ %! ?+&(4' #(" !# !

%#(%@*'&#( !/ ! !/" 2#*(! '# ?#++#="7 2&4/! / <" ?""( *'"7 $#+ (,#!/"+9*+9#'"?,!/"9"!&!&#("+8

!!/&''! 4"&!=#*@7?"6*'! (7+"@"< (!!#"H!+ %!!/" +"@"< (!'! !*!#+,9+#<&'&#(') K3"%!&#( >#$!/""4#!& ?@"('!+*2"(!' %!8

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

!/"%/"D*"/ '?""(9+"'"(!"7!#!/"? (1=&!/&( 9"+&#7 #$ '&H 2#(!/' $+#2 !/" 7 !" #( =/&%/ &! &' 7+ =( #+ =&!/&( !/"9"+&#7#$ &!' < @&7&!,. =/&%/"<"+ &' " +@&"+I

? !/" 9 ,"" #+ !/" /#@7"+ &( 7*" %#*+'" #$ !/" %/"D*". ' !/" % '" 2 , ?". 2 1"' 7"2 (7 $#+ !/" 9 ,2"(!#$!/"' &7 2#*(!#$2#(",?,4&<&(4 (#!&%" &( =+&!&(4. !# !/" 7+ ="+ #$ !/" %/"D*". =&!/&( !/&+!, 7 ,'#$!/"+"%"&9!#$&($#+2 !&#(?,/&2$+#2!/"? (1 +"4 +7&(4!/"+"!*+(#$!/"%/"D*" '*(9 &7I (7

%!/"7+ ="+#$'*%/%/"D*"$ &@'!#2 1"!/"9 ,2"(! #$!/"' &7 2#*(!#$2#(",!#!/"9 ,""#+. '!/"% '" 2 , ?". !# !/" /#@7"+ &( 7*" %#*+'" #$ !/" %/"D*". =&!/&($&$!""(7 ,'#$!/"+"%"&9!#$!/"' &7(#!&%"8

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

&#(&'*(@ =$*@&'<#&78L @@*'!+ !&#(' !# 1HHHHHHL +#2!/" $#+"' &79+#<&'&#('.&!=#*@7?"%@" +!/ !!/" !=&( %#(7&!&#(. =/&%/ &' +"D*&+"7 !# ?" $*@$&@@"7. &' !/ ! !/" 7"?! '/#*@7?"@"4 @@,"($#+%" ?@"7"?! (7!/"9*+9#'"#$!/"' 2"2*'! (#!?"!/"#(".2"(!&#("7*(7"+3"%!&#(#$!/"#(!+ %! %!

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

&#(#$!/"#(!+ %! %! (7/"(%" !/"' 2"= '/"@7(#!!#?"@"4 @@,"($#+%" ?@"@& ?&@&!,8 ( (&"@B' % '" '*9+ . &! = ' /"@7 !/ ! !/" %/"D*" #$ '8G.C4&<"(?,!/" %%*'"7!#!/"%#29@ &( (!&(#+7"+!#4"! !/" #$$"(%" *(7"+ 3"%!

- %#('&7"+ !&#(.=/&%/= '*(@ =$*@8"(%".!/"' 2"= '/"@7(#!!# ?"@"4 @@,"($#+%" ?@"7"?!#+@& ?&@&!,8 (83&< +"6B'% '" '*9+ .&!= '/"@7!/ !%/"D*"&''*"7$#+ +"$*(7#$% 9&! !&#($""&(#+7"+!#4"! 72&''&#(.%#*@7(#!?"' &7 $#+ (*(@ =$*@9*+9#'"8 /*'. (#(" #$ !/" $#+"' &7 6*742"(!' &' #$ (, /"@9 !# !/" 9"!&!&#("+8 !/"+. !/" 6*742"(! &( 808 *+!/,B' % '" '*9+ '*99#+!'!/"<"+,% '"#$!/"%#29@ &( (!8 ( <&"= #$ !/" ?#<". !/"+" &' (# 2"+&! &( !/" 9+"'"(! 9"!&!&#(8/"' 2"&'/"+"?,7&'2&''"78 &

' ( (* +, -. 7' :/"!/"+39" 1&(4C" '#("7) "'C# :/"!/"+"9#+! ?@") "'C#