High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/35743/2019dismissed

Yashpal v. Managing Director Haryana And Another

2024-02-19Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil15 pages

!"!#$!%&'((

#&'&)'*!%&' ((

+ ,-.( / ./ ..

- ****

!" #

$% #

$ #

(

) * #

& /0'%!!1&)%2345 ( +,- & ./ 01230 41541 04052 46,5778

&( ## 9 & ./ :

01230:46,5

+4-

: ( $ : *7 ; <*

< % 4663 (

44=& .

*77&

* 77

)

)% >

% ,4 1? 8 & & < ( & 7) 466=@466A

% )%

* ':"

< <*

* &7 ; * $ %

%B $ % 466A( * #

&% 8

)% C."< BD.

* 7) ,= ,546,A

- 2 - +0- " & 7 >&

$ ; <*

< % 4663 ,04!)

D C

' "

< <*

% 466A + > ,- &7 ; * $ %

% B $ + B

( 7

60 60 46,6 * ,, 6A 4665(

( )

& 7

* 8

) )% 7&7

E# 8

F )

* # )% C."< "

. ./ :3400:46,6+ )* * G -./ :,=,0=:4665 + !( G - ( ( ( .

,2 ,, 46,6 ,, 6A 46,6 + > 0 3

%- )% ) #

# %)

) * 8

)% . ./ :,361:4665

,0 6, 46,6 7 & (

& 7

)

) * (

07 +3- " : *7

. *

,2 ,, 46,6 '

$*7

6= ,, 46,4 (

D# 7

# & 8

) )%

+1-

& +.

- 01250:0125=@46,4( (

. #

- 3 -

60 ,, 46,2

! "# $ % &

C."<(

(

7 7

) (

(

& 7

466,:4661# * )$ " . &

(

# * )

)

+=- &

C."<BD.7)

,= ,4 46,A ,5 ,4 46,A C" !

&% >7

( B

% #

7 & > . $*7

+2-

41 64 46,5 ,5 60 46,5 + > 2- ) &

* <*

7:CC (

% * 7 7

& < ( & 7) 466=@466A

(

7 . $*7 +

& # * @)

(& #

@ # &

7 @ *

* ,= 63 46,5

& ( )%

& ./ ,4,A5&46,5( ( &#

- 4 -

65 61 46,5 (

41 64 46,5 +A- ( 7&

& & 7

* & *

* )

,4 1? 8 :

( $

,5 62 46,5 + > ,,- * 7

* &

@ *) &

. ./ :1=A0:46,5+

&% G - ./ :45=,5:46,A+$%!7 G

&% G - C

7* (7

6, ,, 46,A ./ :4A4,,:46,A(

( % * C."<(

& 466,:4661 &7 &

* 7

& . 7

(

+5- &

&;<@.

6, 6, 46,A

8 )

)

# %)

* $

#!7;<@.

(

&7 7 C & # # * &&

+# - & .

( & 7%

(

# * @)

) 7

+,6- )7

% & < )

( * $

# )

- 5 - 60 60 46,6 %

% & ;<@.

6, 6, 46,A

8 ( ,4 1? < *7 ) 8

)

# * &% 8

C."< +,,-

& 7

( ,6 ,4 46,5

: *7 &

7 %

,A 64 464, * ' B

% :CCC

+,4C % )7

7 % )7

* 7

( & 466=@466A . &'6!716 !6363&' &(8 &9 3' 3$34 11!04

&"(8:

8 &9 ";&< =)70# #"( >"( !13'%!# /3'2; ;!"3 #"( %

% )

( %)

&$*7 7)

)% ; B

)

& ;%4661 +,0- # . #

$*7

,= 60 46,= ./ :4,,24:46,0& )% !7

% * )%* *

&8 *8

& C<@'< "

( *

:,,,:46,2)%

:,=0=:

46,2 )% #

( (

)% '

- 6 -

65 6A 46,A %(((#)$* # *&

,%-&

') # * :

! " # !

$ %$

& '(& ) "! "# & $ ("

* !

+ ,-,.,,/#,, 0 , 1 2

$ "" 3 " $ "" 4 5,5,

6 7 '

, 1

* 2 , $ 1 * 6

* 2 " *

$ , $ ',6,5' 65,(,5' " ! #

,9,5( * $ , $ "

" + , +,3- & )7

)

7 )# *

(

(( % & (

(

:,1,1:

46,1

:,,,:46,2

* +,1- & )7

: *7 &

421:46,5(

(# * (

- 7 -

D F ) 7

((

( +,=-

)

& )%

./ :

41541:46,5

# 7 7 )% ) ) C # 7

36A:

365&466,5 && &7

( ( 7 #

7 (

> 7 &

(

+-% 7 &7 " & ) # I

& * " $

**J +,2Heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the record.

+,A7*

,5 62 46,5+ > ,,- )% : *7 )

(

7# )% !7

41 64 46,5 ( 7 ./ 1=A0 & 46,5 +

& % G - ./ 45=,5 & 46,A +$% !7 G

&% G -(

% (7 8 )

) 8 )% :

( 7

& 8

& <*

* )% *

60 6= 46,A

- 8 - +,5- . #

6, ,, 46,A ./ 4A4,, & 46,A & 7

&7 & ; <*

& <*

@) G&& ( % C ( ) :

*7(

) # &( : :1&

7 ; /

) < =) ") % & % & ! > ! - >

,(+

& ,? +46- ( ) & 7

./ 1=A0&46,5( ) ** (

./ 4A4,,&46,A ./ 45=,5&46,A( ) ** (

./ 443,,& 46,A ( ( &(8&98

063'%!#/3'2; #"(>"( /606! &9 )'?0@ #"( )

)% . (

./ 1=A0 & 46,5K ./ 45=,5 & 46,A ./ 443,,&46,A

+4,- 7

&(8 &9 8

063'%!# /3'2; #"(>"(/606!&9 )'?0@ #"( (

( ./ 1=A0& 46,5 +

& % G - ( ) ** )

)%.

62 6, 4646

( ) % (

* * &$

& (

+44- (

063'%!#/3'2; #"(,"

0 @ C . &

- 9 - "

(

* #

& & &

() ' "

)

(

% 466, 4661)%(%&

7 C .

)

(

0 & ; 46,A ,4 & ; 46,A 7

)

7 ( %7 * & *7 &

*7 )

% " C."< &

323&4646#

(

$*7

4A 65 4644 7

+40C 7%

& % * ./ 4A4,,&46,A

(

& & % :& )

&7 & $*7 & .

./ 4A4,,&46,A+;

* G

& $) G -

) 3 ! < & 7

F ((

* * @

)

41 6, 46,A &

60 6= 46,A ,4 6= 46,A(

C."<BD.

* 7) ,= ,546,A +43- 8

& * @

& 7

)

* )%

(

; 46,A 7 ) 7

(

) 8 % 7) 46,A C ( &

- 10 -

) &(

% * @

& 8

@( %@ &

7) 46,A " &

& & 7

(

7* +41- .7 *) (

(

# 4663 ' "

< <*

% 466A&7 ;

% &7

& <*

( ,, 6A 4665( % *

) ( 7

* ' "

% # )% C."< "

(

% *

( 7)

,= ,4 46,A ,5 ,4 46,A "

7 ) : *7

7&7

+4=- &

# %

,5 65 4644 )% C."< (

)

8 *

&7* 7

*%7 *

# 7 * +42The Supreme Court, in MA Nos. 1795 -1796 of 2017 in Civil Appeal no. 17869-17870 of 2017 titled as Orissa Lift Irrigation Corp. Ltd. Vs Rabi Sankar Patro & others which was filed by those candidates who

- 11 - underwent independent selection undertaken by Union Public Service Commission and entered certain services as direct recruits and have presently either been engaged in the same service or have advanced in career on the basis of such selection by UPSC, while clarifying

"We, therefore, as a one-time relaxation in favour of those candidates who were enrolled during the academic years 2001-2005 and who, in terms of the judgment, are eligible to appear at the test to be conducted by AICTE, direct:- a] All such candidates, who wish to appear at the forthcoming test to be conducted by AICTE in May-June 2018 and who exercise option to appear at the test in terms of the judgment, can retain the degrees in question and all the advantages flowing therefrom till one month after the declaration of the result of such test or till 31.07.2018 whichever is earlier.

b] This facility is given as one-time exception so that those who have the ability and can pass the test in the first attempt itself, should not be put to inconvenience. If the candidates pass in such first attempt, they would be entitled to retain all the advantages. But if they fail or choose not to appear, the directions in the judgment shall apply, in that the degrees and all advantages shall stand suspended and withdrawn. At the cost of repetition, it is made clear that no more such chances or exceptions will be given or made. They will undoubtedly be entitled to appear on the second occasion in terms of the judgment but this exception shall not apply for such second attempt. c] We direct AICTE to conduct the test in May-June 2018 and declare the result well in time, in terms of our directions in the judgment and this Order. AICTE shall

- 12 - however extend the time to exercise the option to appear at the test suitably."

+4A-

) & )# %

& >. (( &

# * &( &7

7 &

(* E :

F% (# )

7 F

& % #

C %7

7 F ( ) E $ < &

E& FE

$ * F(

( 7 >

( ) * 7 C )

(& &

7 ( )

7& $*7 E)

* # * % &

7 F +45-

C."< * 7) ,= ,546,A

"!*&'% 066!7165

7 &

44 6, 46,A " &

( ( < <*

)% ;

$ %

$ "

)

)# :

7& $*7 ) >

( ) &4

7 +06- 8

) 7) 46,A )

)# (

- 13 -

7 ( ) * )

# * &

C >.

* *

( )

# % %

' & C#

)

% #

)% " >

)

* (

%( ) #

%()

# * 9 (&

44 6, 46,A ( 7 & "

( %

( # *

)%*

( :

(

7 >

(

) 8 % +0,- . * $.)/

0 # *0*

* 1'# )

# * ( >

(

%@; 46,A( )

G +04- / ** H & &

& ( %( $% * %& $*7

( )

% . * $.)/

* +- & &

- 14 -

( $*7 ( (

( & %

# * ( (

" .

(

)

(

( 7

& & $% *

& $*7 &

;*7 G

( %) * )

# ) (

() I

J (%) & )

( %( $% *

$*7 C

( + & %

# * $*7 +00C * & <*

)

C<@'<@' "

< <*

4A 64 4665&7

& <*

( C 7 &

(

) # "

* 7) 46,A 7 .

+- C %

& $*7 @

+- ()

@# * ( ) # )

(%&7

*& "

7) 46,A( #

& & 7

- 15 - +03-

)# (

& # * (

( ( $% * E

( ;*7 % G F ( C& 7

( *

( )

$% %( $*7 ( (#

. : *7 +01C #

( & & * * ) #

7 (

# &%7

7 ,5 64 4643 @,@

/0'%!!1&)%234

)%2!

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No