High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/950/2019dismissed

Vishal Uppal v. Jaspreet Uppal And Another

2024-06-059 pages

# $%&%!' ()(

* +, * ( - -* ,

! "# $ % &' (& !""& " )*+,-./0-0. % (& !&% " )*+,-1/-00

233$ % &' (& !""& " )*+,-1/-00 % (& !&% " )*+,-./0-0. 44444 -* ,

( "% " '&55& 62%#5 33 %'"% 7& ! '"5"3 ""& !""&$ 8"# 258 )*+, ./0 &( 0.9 % )*+, 1/ &( 00$ ("3% #" '&55& &% !% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2$ 583$ %'"%"# '3"5 &( ""5 5"'$ " !""& ("3% 2% '"& / &( )&% &( )"5"3 &'%2 ;"# # &( 5"'

!" "

! 62%#5 8"# (% & ! " 2 " )*+, ./0 &( 0. & &"% : '&(2"& %2 & : & 3!!"# " 8&

!""&

8"( '

&&3&#: &( (' #" "# " & ("3"# &( 7& '"5"3 ""& !""& 8: !"

5"# 87 !""& % !&% & &&; !3' & 0<0100 &7 $ & '

"3% 7 8& &2 &( 7%3&'; &( !""& 7" !&% &

5"# 87 !""& % !&% & 7 " '&% 5"#$ !"& & " 5"# & 0<0100$ !""& % %2# (&5 " ! "&2 5"#9 % !&% & % %2# (&5 ! "&2 5"# <

3"& 87 !" % & 8'&5 "% "' 8#""# &( 5"#$ &7 $ !" 3" % &# 28% % 7"( (& !"&% &( 5& "# : % 233: !" #& !% (&5 '

& & 010=0=

33#"& % '&2-33#"& #%"# '23 % &'"&2 '&%2' 8: !" #" '

& &7 $ ! &( 33#"& 87 !" & 8"# #5 & %62%"'"& &( ! '"5"3 ""& !""&$ " )&2 (" (&5 #&"# "& '": % 2 (23 &( 5$ 3 "# " & 8 %'"%% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2$ !!&!" #$ ( ;"# "& ''&2 "%' & 8 3% 8:

1 ( #"# !% (&5 '

& $ !&% & *7"(, % !&% & * & (&5 ! "&2 5"#, ("3% !""& 2% '"& / &( ) ) #" !""& * 28%,$ " 3% +5"3: )&2 583$ ;"# # &( 5"' /

3% +5"3: )&2$ 583 "% " &% %% 0100.

3% !&% & 8"# & &( !&% & (&5 ! "&2 5"# " & "3% & '3"5 : 5"' (&5 !""& &7 $ 3% +5"3: )&2 #% ""5 5"' & !&% &$ & 8 !"% 8: !""& > 10$000- ! 5& (&5 % &( ("3"# &( !""&$ 8"# 3#33: 7%%% 7"( ? ) 33#"# "% &% %% 0100. !% 8:

3% +5"3: )&2$ !""& * 28%, ("3% )*+,-./0- 0. ;"# "# "% &( "% &% 7" 5 !&% & "3% & # &( : 5"' &7 $ !&% *7"( % & (&5 ! "&2 5"#, ("3% )*+,-1/-00 ;"# '5 &( ""5 '&5!"& 3%: #% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 @ % 3% '&23 (& !" % !2% '&% &( ' '(233: =

!""& '

33#% &% &( ""5 5"' !% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 7" 5 !&% & " A23&5 % #&""' 3%:

!""& ("3% 2% '"& / &( ) ) " #2$ '&""# 7&# % (3 ('

!&% & 3( '&5!: &( !""& 7" &2 : 2(("'" & "' !&% & (33 "& 8% 8"$ !""& "% & %"'"!3" "5$ 82 !&% & &2# !""& 7 '&3%"# "5 2'"3: % (& 3( '&5!: &( !""& #& '"5"3 ' #"% #" !""& &3"' "& 583 ) 2% '"& 1.=$ 10$ 10?$ << &( ) % "5 &( # &( !- 8"3 & !""& " "% ' 5&2 &( $@0$000- 7 !"% 8: !""& & " 285"% !&% & ("3% 7&# (("% " &( 8(& 3% +5"3: )&2$ 7"

&3%"# !&! "(&5"& 8&2 "'&5 % $ 5"&% 7&# "'&5 &( !""& " (("% " + & 2 &( ?$00$000- A2": % &'; " 5 & 2 &( 1$/0$000- " "'&5 B 7" "'&5 & 2 &( $00$000- (& : 0?-@ % 0@-= . " 285"% !""& " %&"# !" 6&8 7" 3: &( =/$000- ! 5& $ % " 5& 3: B!%"2 " =$?00- &3% #% ! % :&2# %2# & 3&&;

($ 7 & (233: %!% 2!& "5

3% +5"3: )&2 7&#3: '&2% 3: &( !""& & 8 $?$.- (& 5& &( : C $ 5-&(-('$ !""& #& :3: 8&2 (&5 " 5!3&: " 5& &( :$ 0. "

#& "% 5&2$ & 7"$ " 3: " 3

!&% &$ 8"# ;"33% % %2'% 3%:$ " '!83 & 5""

3($ 7" A23"("'"& &( D % %

& '%" 0 '&:$ !&% " " ! '"5"3 ""& !""& !:% (& 5&%"("'"& &( &% !% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2$ ;"# '5 &( 5"' 5&2 & 2 &( $00$000- ! 5& " 285"% 3% +5"3: )&2 % " %""3"# !&% & (&5 ;"# : 5"' (&5 !""& !&% & 7 %&!% 8: !""& & % !&% & 3& '&"%% !""& " (

%&'25 &( !&% & "$ % )%$ '

&&3 %5""& +&5$ '

&&3 "# )"("' ' 8 5 &( !""& ( 2'

$ !&% & &2# & 8 #% 5"' 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 !&% & 8"# %2'% 3%: " "3% & # &( 5"' '&552 7"

3% +5"3: )&2$ 7 "3 !"# "5!2#% &% 7&#3: % 3: &( !""& & 3&7 "%$ 7 $ " "# 5& 3' ! 5&

3% +5"3: )&2 ( 38&3: %3"# 7"

285""& 5% & 8 3( &( 8& !" %3 7" !' &( 5 &( "'&5 &( !" & 8" &( (("% " &( % 3"8"3"" ("3% 8: 5 733 & 3 %&'25 " ! &( ''&2 5$ '&5

2$ ' 23 &( "5!2#% &% &7 3% "3 )&2 2%; !";"# B'" " 32"# "'&5 &( !" ( #&"# &2# "'&5 B 2 &( !""& (& : 0?-@$ 0@-= % 0=-.$ 3% +5"3: )&2 3% " #& &3 "'&5 " $$0$1- % B !:83 " .1$=1=-

B5!% "'&5 " //00- 5"# 8: 23 "'&5 &( !""& " 0$$@@?- " !!&B"53: =1$</- ! 5&

#25 % '% & 8 3( &( !""& 3% +5"3: )&2 5"'3'23%

" "'&5 8: ;"# "& '&"%"& " 3: (& 5& &(

:$ 0. " 7 &33: "33 (&2%% 23 &( "5!2#% &% 5; " '3 :$ 0. 3: &( !""& " & 8" &( '3'23"& &( " 5& 3: 3: 8: 3% +5"3:

)&2 $ 3% +5"3: )&2 % 5& 3:

3: &( !""& & 8" &( 7 &3&5 5"3 "383 & '&% &( ' " 5& 3: 3: % 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 " !!&B"53: =1</- 7 "3 !!'""#

:$ 0. 3: &( !""&$ 7 " " " 33#% '" % " 23 8&2$ 3% +5"3: )&2 &3:

3% 5 & 8 &5 '5 &( " 3:

" ("%"# &( 3% +5"3: )&2 '& 8 (23% 23 8&2 % 8: !""& '"3: (&5 ! &( " 3: &3: & %&28$ 3% +5"3: )&2 " "5!2#% &% 3% !&% & & 8" &( 5"3

%%2'% 8: !""& & '&% &( ' " & '&5!33:

7" &2 &2' % & %"'3&% ("'"3 3

2 (233:$ &7 $ " 7 3% "33 " & !&% &( &2' 7 "'

7&23% 8 2(("'" (& 2'

+ &( ?$00$000- " 5 &( !&% & % " % 2!& " "7 &( !'23" (' &( ' '& 8 5% 2(("'" 5&2 (& !&% & & 5"" 3( ! 7" %% &( !""&

("%"# 2% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 ' # &( %'"%"# ""5 5"'$ 8"# 23 &( &5 35 &( "5"&$ 3& '& 8 (23%$ "35 &( !&% & '" 5"' '& 8 8% 2!& B' " 5"'3 '3'23"& 2'

# #& 7" &2 :"# &% #"# ""5 5"' " 286' & ("3 %62%"'"& & 5" !""& % ""5 5"' #% %2"# !%': &( !&'%"# " &3: !& ""&3 5"' 286' & ("3 %5""& & 8 5% & '&'32"& &( !&'%"# < )&5"# & !' &( '

33# 5% & ! &( "5!2#% &% !% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2 &3%"# !&% & " & "3% & '3"5 5"' (&5 !""&$ !&% & '3"5% !&% & " %&!% 8: !""& &7 $ & %&'25 "%'"# %&!"& &( !&% & 8: !""& 8 !3'% & '&% &( '

% )%$ '

&&3 %5""& +&5$ %

&&3 "# )"("' &( !&% &$ 8: "2 &( 8"# 5 &( !""& ( &( !&% & '& 8 5% !&&( &( 3"% %&!"& &( !&% & 8: !""&

5 5% " '"5"3 ""& !""& A2 %&!"& &( !&% &$ 8( &( : %"3 &($ " 8: : '&# 5"3 & !3%"# 8(& 3% +5"3: )&2 '& 8 5% 8" (& # &( 5"' & !&% & 8: !""&

%$ "5 % !3' &( 33#% %&!"&$ 5 &( "% %&!"& % '5&"$ "( :$ !(&5% %2"# %&!"& '&!"'2&23: 5""# " ' 2'

3% +5"3: )&2 '&'3: 3"% 2!& 62%#5 !% 8: &E83 F26 "# )&2 " ' &(

" 7 " " 7 3% 2% - G

$ %! & '

$ %! &

' (

(

$ %!

& )

(

* + H 1 "7 &( 5: 8& ("%"# " 5$ & (23 & 3#3 "("5": " (&2% " "5!2#% &%$ %% 0100.

!% 8: 3% +5"3: )&2$ 583 % 2'

5 " 2!

3% D& 8& -5"&% '"5"3 ""& !""& ("3% #" "% &% ''&%"#3: %"5"% / %3 & " &8 "& 5%

"8& 33 & 8 '&2% &!""& & 5" &( ' ?

%"# !!3"'"&*,$ "( :$ 33 3& % %"!&% &((

-* ,

2 0/$ 01 *

!;"#&% I& !&83 I&