New Vasan Electric Co v. Union Of India And Others



   
    


 



 !"!

#$  % &'

( )*+  

,-.

 /. 0

,


/ ("1"

  

   .




,$ 20 ,.3 . . 

20 ,3 . , 0

  
 
 



 


 

 
 


 
 
  
  


 




 

.  00+ 3

!
" 
 


#




 



  






$
% 
  
"


&%"'
 
 
  
()(!*(*+
!,(**(*+
*-(-*(*+

(.(+*(*+
 



/


01
  


$  




 
 





,)
  



 
01

*(!2

 3



 
01

*(!2



 
 
3



*
" 
 
 
 



4 

 


  


 

 
56


,)7




 
01


*(!2
&

 


*(!2'
 #

##







 8

#

$

1
 9
%"


# 
1

  



#




   :;

<
" 
 
  



  
4 




3
#








 



    #
 




 

-
" 
 


#









 
   


 



  01

*(!2
&  
=
>0
9'

 3



 
01

*(!2
&  
=
>0
9'
 




()(!*(*+
!,(**(*+
*-(-*(*+

(.(+*(*+



?
*
 


#





 
 
3








 
@
/  
01


#
&@/'
 
$
/


01
  
&/0'

% 
  
"


&%"'






,)

A


*(!2



 

  #
 

%"
 

1 
7)
/







# 

  8
$

/0

1



/0
  



  

   


%"
/




#


  
 


 


 9
%"



#


/0



#






 
 




#
/0
 



 



#







" 
 




#



# 
B




 #


,)

*(!2


 


/0






#


1


%"
+
" 
 





 3 
C 



 

  
   !"#

D
C 
 

$  %&
'

'      

'

& %

 

  (  " )  *+"#
,

- 
'  
 '       .& .

' .

'    


 - '  "

*  *+*#

,  /

 /

- (    %

%  


 '0

(  "

** *) 
/


#


D
C 
 

,

- 
' 
 ,  /

 /

- (  

&

'

 



 

#

$ %&
'

' 1
 
&

'





"&'
? (!--.<A*(*+

(!22*<A*(*+
 


#


C9


#
 

!2(+*(*+

(.(2*(*+


" 
 



#


C 
 
 



(-!!*(*+

67*<)2+7*(*+


 


 
$


D
C 
 




$ %&
'

'

4"15( 6+ ,

- 
'   
 '     4"15( '
  ,  /

 /

- (  &

'   
 




# 
  
   



  

(-!!*(*+


67*<)2+7*(*+
&,-"

.78 & .1#9 ( .

(!5"

% ("1"

#!

#9!

#9

("'
/
 






 


 

)
" 
 






 





  






  
 


 
  

D  #A  

 # 


(-!!*(*+



:

  4,-"

.78 & .1#9 ( .

(!5"

% ("1"

#!

#9!

#9

("6



# 

2
6


 
 
 










,
/


#





  




  
0A0

*(!2

0
/  
?
&0/?
(<@%E)<2("!F"'
" 
 





 

 



%"
 

$

()(!*(*+
!,(**(*+
*-(-*(*+

(.(+*(*+
? 




  #

 

%"
 

1 
7)

.

  




 



(-!!*(*+


 

,-"

.78 & .1#9 ( .

(!5"
&

'
 
3

#
 3 
C 
 


 
 .

& ;;

8"+

D
C 
 


$ %&
'

' &

'< ,

- 
'  
 '  4"15( '
  ,  /

 /

- (  &

'

2  0  3

 %(      %

  "


%%4 


#! 0 
C 
 
 @#
C 
 

/5   

     ( .& %


0(  + *

"!)


  
C 
 

$  ,
(5 (  %

 / 


06%(-

(  
%%4

% "+""


C 
 

2 / .  '  
 7

(  *
%%4

**""
 

C 
 
   
  


- 
& -

5  
&



 % 0

(  "
%%4

+8+9
 

 



G
1


C 

 3 
D
@#


0 


 

 
 

(-!!*(*+


 7
5!<
/



 

 


 8
/0
  

  
 

3

 
 
 




  

 3 
C 
 


3

#


   

   1
 
&

'
 


#

/0
8

 

%"

0





  


%"


 
 
1  
 



,)7



*(!2


 
 

 3 
C 
 


 

  1
 
&

'


 7
5*,


,)


0

# 

##





 

8




 
  











  




1



 
  







 

 
0



 
 






1
  





 
  



  






,)7

$


  
/

 

 








# 




1
  



 
  








$




?
/




1
  






 

$
 
  






,)7



  

 









 
3



 
*.
B




   



,)&!'

0


*(!2

 

 



   


,)


1 


##







  

#
&


$





##

 '
H 





1 
 
 
 
 



 
'
  




1





 
  


 
'
0
##







  

#



 





  








 
'
0
 


 

    <(
/
 


  
 
 


 





$


,)
I 




,)





7
'
D 

#

 
  




 





-.


#






# 
'
 
  




# 
4 


# 
#








  <!


,)
&!'

0


*(!2

  




  
0
   
 



 
4   




 

$

 


0

  
 


 4 

 


,)

$  <*
/





 

    





,)
 


 





$





 

 4 



#
17 


 <<
B
 # 
 

 

$


,)
 

  




1





 
  


 
H  


  


#



&

 

 




  '


  <-
 

 
 
&'
  




1





 
  




&'


  

  


 


   


,)


$  <+
H  


,)











#$

 


 
  





  
0

# 










   

#

 
  






#  
#




 
/
 


 
 
# 





 

#


# 

 #
 





1
  
  
 #
 
  


  
&
2<

2-

0
'


 
 






  



,)


1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 -!
/

   
 







# 
4 






 
 


 4 

 

  

 
 



 

  





 


$


 
 

  




1




 
  



 

 4 





 #




 
 





1
  

#

 
  


 

  
#  







  


 
   
C



#



  


4 
# 



  
  
C 



1 



  


 
  


  -*


#
 
  


   
#






  



  




 

 
 



,)




 









/
 


,)




#





 #
0
 #

 






2<


2-


 
#



 

  
  
# 
H  

 #





 
#

 

  
&






 

'


*.

0

H  # 

 #

 




 


$
 
 

1



,<

0


-<
 






   
  



  










$


,) --
0


  

#

 
  



 1 #
 

 
0

  









  
 #




1
  
  





2<

2-
 0


# 





 
# 
 
 

# 
   
/






,)

$


 


 


8



#




# 
 




   



  




  1  
  
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 111111

5-.
0



 


 
#

   





#
 


 




 


 #












,)


 #

1  
 
 



  

#




$ 

 ;

!(
G
1


C 

 3 
D
0 
 @#




 






 


#











,)

*(!2




 
 









J

 

/0


#   
#






#



  
 



,)

*(!2

 


 





##



 
/0

%"

 


 











 
 
 
#

# 

 





&



?'


4  
  
C 


#
#
 


  


%"
 


> 
$ 9
/

 


  

  

  
#



 

# 
6



1
  


  





 #

# 
  

 #

2<

2-

0A0

!!
 

 








 

#

C 
 
 


     


 
 

,-"

.78 & .1#9 ( .

(!5"
&

'
  7
5!,
/




   

 






#




 3 
C 
 

C 
 D

0 

1




  



     
6
 







 




 
1



C 

 


  
  

#
$   ,
(5 2  /  .   '   

- 
& - 

5 1 
&

'



  









D
C 
 

,

-
' 
 , /

/

- ( 1

&

'






 
C9



#
 


!.
6




# 




#


   





 
!2(+*(*+
 (.(2*(*+

C9



#
 

3

#


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1
 &

'





 
   

 

 

#


 



$


C 

 


  
  
0

#






3



 
# 1
*(
6




# 




#


 
 





 
!2(+*(*+

(.(2*(*+

C9



#
 


#


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1

&

'





 
   


 
 

#


 



$


C 

 


  
  
0

#






3




 
# 1

*!
/




   

#

 A 





 







1




#



%"

 & '

1

/0

 


#


A$  & ';

!*
E





  


 






#
 #
67*<)2+7*(*+
&,-"

.78 & .1#9 (

.

(!5"

% ("1"

#!

#9!

#9

("'


(-!!*(*+
!<


 

 

 $

  

# & '


 

 



!-


# 

& '


 & '

 

. 



4, 06

 % &'

( )*+  



6

$ A   
K A?

6
  
K A?